Cawpile: 8.43/10

This new series is sure to entice readers with its rich lore and unique magic system. The world felt well developed with different nations of people that have different relationships with magic. There were a few different types of magic including elemental and more abstract magic.

The story follows three main characters - each from different nations as they journey across the lands. I grew to love the characters and felt like they were well developed and dimensional. There is Aiz who is trying to save her people with the help of her god, the prince who doesn’t want the crown and the bounty hunter who is exiled from her people. The characters coming from different parts of the world made for interesting contrasts between POVs.

The book switches points of view each chapter and made many references to the authors first series. I haven’t read the first series yet but could see how it may make the story feel richer in depth and didn’t have any issues following the current story.

I enjoyed seeing the character growth and how the plot thickens and develops. The intrigue was built subtly and did sneak up on me. There were a few good twists here and there and a lot of good hints to things. I thought the ending was great and I am excited for the next book.

I would recommend this to anyone looking for a lighter high fantasy read (mostly 3 POVs) who is looking for a book with magic but where magic isn’t the main focus us of the book.

I would like to thank NetGalley and Penguin Young Readers Group for providing me with an eARC of the book. All opinions are my own.

Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher of this book for this eARC.

I never finished the Ember ion the Ashes quartet, so there were a few context clues missing for me, otherwise, Sabaa is an amazing writer.

4.5 stars

Told between three interwoven perspectives, Heir is an epic fantasy dealing with themes of sacrifice, power, betrayal, and love. There wasn't a single POV I didn't enjoy reading - Aiz, Sirsha, and Quil were all distinct perspectives and I had a great time with all three of them. The first 40% of the book was entertaining, slowly building out the world and our characters, but right around that 40% mark is when the puzzle pieces start clicking into place and I was hooked. I am super looking forward to the sequel!

Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for providing an ARC in exchange for an honest review!

Yes, this is a stand alone book, but as someone who did not read the Ember in the Ashes series, I felt like I was playing catch up for the first half of the book. I would have appreciated knowing that going in. It is fast moving action for the majority of the book. That said, it took me about 40% of the book to really care about what was happening. I enjoyed the second half of the book much more than the first. I was not happy with the ending. For grades 9 & up.

Heir is the first in a duology that interconnects with the Ember in the Ashes series. While it is POSSIBLE to read this as a standalone - I would highly recommend reading if after finishing the other series first. I went into this book without doing so and the world building was very difficult to get into. I believe the first half of the book would have been much more enjoyable if I had the background.

That being said, the first 50-60% of the book was very difficult for me to get engaged in. The multi-POV also contributed to this as it felt like it took a really long time to get any momentum built up. Once the character's intertwined stories started to become clear, it got better.

The last 30% of the book was fantastic. The ending had me on the edge of my seat and cursing. For that reason alone, I am willing to read the next installment. My hope is that the complex world building in this book will help lay the ground work for the next one.

I didn’t realize that you had to read her other four books. I read from other people that people should read those four books to understand this book. I wish I would have known that before I picked this book out. I do want to thank u for the arc.

This was my first book by Sabaa Tahir and it definitely won’t be my last. Love the world building and the banter. Have added An Ember in the Ashes series to my tbr!

IMPORTANT: If you have ANY plans to read An Ember in the Ashes or you haven't finished the quartet yet, do not pick up Heir until you have done so. There's a ton of spoilers.

Can you read Heir without having read AEITA first? Sure. I think it works well enough on its own. SHOULD you? Heck no. Not if you want that full emotional ride, baby~ (no seriously the way my heart weeped at every little cameo/hint.. T.T)

Heir picks up about 20 years after AEITA concludes. The story follows none other than baby Zacharius Marcus Livius Aquillas Farrar, heir (hehe) to Empress Helene Aquillas. Obviously he's not a baby any more, and calling him by his full name or even first name in any given sentence is way too long so he goes by Quill now. Plus all that baggage, oof.

We're introduced to a smattering of new characters, some with connections to old. And while I don't think Heir quite lives up to the amazingness of AEITA (first book, not series), I still loved every second of it. Heir feels faster paced and I'm not sure we get to spend as much time getting to know the characters as much as we'd like. I also felt like the big reveal was revealed way too soon and while it did make me curious as to how events turned out it did not emotionally scar me as much as possible.

All in all though, I loved this book and cannot wait to pick up the sequel. I'm also insanely sad I missed out on my local Sabaa Tahir event because I was sick T.T so I could not tell her in person how much I loved it. Ugh, dumb cold.

4.5 stars.

Thank you NetGalley and Penguin for the ARC. All thoughts and opinions are my own.

WOW WOW WOW. She did it again. I am in awe how you can write an series like "An Ember in the Ashes" and then follow it up years later (in real life and in their fictional world) and still give you that same feeling and connection.
And if you don't read the OG series, you are 10000% reading this wrong. DO NOT start with Heir, whatever you do. You need to know everyone, the back stories, the history, the heartache and love. It is essential.
And "Heir" put you back in that perfectly imperfect world and ripped my heart out again. I love how Sabaa Tahir knows how to make you feel so connected to her characters, you read from their perspective and feel what they feel, and in some ways, it is a horrible way to feel. No spoilers here, but I love how Tahir is not afraid to give you real life and real struggles rather than fluffy romance and a happy ending. Not to say there isn't happy endings here, just more realistic ones. And now thinking that I have potentially years to go until I can get some closure on the ending of "Heir"!! I am UNWELL.

Dates read: 07/17/2024 - 07/27/2024

Set 20 years after the events of A Sky Beyond the Storm, Heir tells the gradually converging stories of Quil, Empress Helene’s nephew and reluctant crown prince of the Empire, Aiz, an impoverished Kegari attempting to fulfill her cleric’s holy order, and Sirsha, a banished Jaduna tracker who’s just trying to survive, through their connection to a mysterious killer.

I loved the Ember Quartet, and I had so much fun diving back into its universe. The characters were well developed and intriguing, and I was eager to learn more of their backstory as I read. The story was relatively fast paced with some slow scenes here and there but I was never truly bored of the story. There was a good amount of romantic scenes throughout the books, and I loved every second of it! The story was told in an interesting way, and it kept me turning the page to see how everything would line up. Only life responsibilities prevented me from binging this book in one go. I think it would’ve been nice if there was a prologue or chapter that summarizes the events of the original series because I’m sure I’m not the only one who hasn’t read it in a while and may have forgotten certain scenes or information; however, it's definitely not necessary to have read the original series before reading Heir!

This was an amazing read, and I am so grateful to be able to experience this universe again. I’m really excited for the final book of this duology and I can’t wait to see the storyline of each character unfolds as the story continues.

Thank you to NetGalley and Penguin Random House for the ARC.

Thank you, NetGalley for this ARC!

I LOVED being back in the world of the Ember in the Ashes series. Sabaa Tahir is easily one of my favorite fantasy authors and for good reason. She has created a world that is easy to follow but has so many more secrets left to be found.

Heir is set in the same world as the Ember in the Ashes series but truly, you don't need to read that series in order to understand what's going on in Heir. It certainly adds more depth to the story (like the Empress' backstory) but can be foregone. Heir follows many points of view and the journey you go one with each of them is something I haven't seen in other fantasy series, especially in the YA category. There is a romantic subplot for all your fantasy romance readers out there, but it is a YA novel so keep that in mind!

Sabaa Tahir does a wonderful job of creating this world and its characters, and I could not get enough. I loved the story, it was full of action, adventure, romance, and plenty of shocking moments. I loved the characters and their relationships with each other, especially Sirsha and Quil, and loved getting several povs. I cannot wait for the next book in this duology!

Overall, I loved this book and highly recommend!

Sabaa Tahir writes fantasy like no one else. I had to sit and savor this book for a while. The expert weaving of the storylines, of new and old characters, and all of the different voices make this book phenomenal.

Thank you to Penguin Teen for the ARC of Heir by Sabaa Tahir. All opinions are my own.

After recently reading the whole Ember in the Ashes series, I had some expectations going into this book. I had heard great things from early reviewers, so I was excited to see what this author had in store.

The first half of this book was great and immediately hooked me back into this world. I liked the different character points of views and how they eventually tied together. It was also fun to see characters from the Ember in the Ashes series.

However, the second half of the book made me pretty angry. I couldn’t stand Aiz or the type of person she became as the story progressed. The other characters were okay, but I didn’t love them.

In a similar way to books three and four of the Ember in the Ashes series, Heir really seemed like evil triumphs over good, which is just really hard to read about after a while since there is very little hope in that kind of storyline. I kept hoping to see some good things happen to any of the characters, but it was just one awful thing after another.

Overall, I would only recommend you read this book if you’ve read the whole Ember in the Ashes series and loved it. Otherwise, you will miss out on a lot of connections to that series, and you probably won’t enjoy this book if you didn’t enjoy the last couple books of that series.

Sabaa Tahir’s main job is not simply “author”–it’s breaker of readers’ hearts, in the most gut-wrenching yet beautiful way possible.

An Ember in the Ashes is arguably my favorite series of all time, so I was absolutely overjoyed that Sabaa decided to return to the Ember world. Despite this being marketed as being an entry-point into the world, I cannot stress that those new to the Ember world should first read AEITA. Heir spoils basically every aspect of the original series, and the reading experience is 100x more emotional and satisfying knowing the incredible backstory of the world and (side) characters.

Okay with the disclaimers out of the way, I will now attempt to write a coherent review lol.

Sabaa’s strengths are manyfold, and yet she has somehow improved every aspect of her storycraft with Heir. The characters are infinitely complex yet relatable, the worldbuilding (while intricate) is nuanced and effortlessly diverse, the prose beautiful and evocative without being unnecessarily descriptive and flowery (as is the unfortunate trend recently), and the story will emotionally touch and resonate with readers of all backgrounds. I spent the entire book swooning, gasping, and generally freaking out from all the tension. Sabaa’s plotting is just *so* tidy–she hooks you on every perspective and entices you before dropping a mini-cliffhanger and switching perspectives, yet it never feels disruptive or unnecessary. Despite so many story arcs and chronologies, I was deeply invested in all of them, even as I grew to despise a certain POV (spoiler: Aiz) more and more. Perhaps Sabaa’s biggest strength is the way she can make readers invested in and empathize with every single character, for even when the villains commit atrocities, they are condemned in clearest terms but never painted as inherently evil. I rarely see such incredible nuance in books, regardless of genre and target age group.

Because so much of Heir’s plot is a spoiler for and/or relies on the events of AEITA, the only thing I can say is that it’s all incredible. The themes are rich and expand upon the commentary of the original quartet, especially when it comes to really tough topics like militarism, colonialism, and religion (including religious fanaticism). The subtext is wonderfully nuanced and woven so carefully into the story that it never imposes the entertainment factor.

And of course, it wouldn’t be a Sabaa Tahir book without a little torture for all my favorite characters. Sabaa’s reveals are some of the best in the YA space, and while I predicted the midpoint twist, the three consecutive reveals at the end sent me reeling. If I wasn’t reading on my expensive iPad, I’d be tempted to throw the book at the wall because what the hell, Sabaa. You insane woman, I need the next book ASAP.

4.75/5 stars

4.5/5. Rounding up! I am a HUGE ember quartet fan! And leave it to Sabaa not to disappoint one bit! This book is extremely relevant to current times cough cough palestine. The commentary about religious ethnonationalism and extremist was SO WELL DONE and believable! SO wonderfully executed!
This was stellar and a uniquely plotted book. She did an excellent job weaving together all of the POVs to make this a ground breaking YA! It’s honestly leagues above most YA’s! Aiz I want to shake and throttle her but Sabaa did a good job with the commentary and delusion Aiz underwent.
I think I just need more time with the characters because this was such a fast paced books and I needed some more fleshing to feel attached to them. the romance was my one and only critique about this book. It felt very forced and rushed but I do love Sirsha, and Quill is my fav in the book hands down! I just know when the sequel comes out I’m gonna be obsessed!

this was so good! i really wish i read an ember in the ashes series before though. i think having background info and context from the series would’ve made this a 5 star read 😭

the book focuses mainly on 3 povs, i think sabaa tahir does a really good job of switching b/w the povs without breaking the flow of the story. i really enjoyed all the povs but sirsha is my favorite! this book felt long (this could also be bc i’m in a reading slump though 😓) but the pacing was good imo and i was never bored while reading! the world also feels really fleshed out. can’t wait for the next book!

Thank you to the publishing company and NetGalley for this early copy in exchange for my honest review.

Let me start by apologizing to Laia and Elias. After how much Sabaa tortured Helene in the Ember In The Ashes series, I honestly felt like out of the protagonists from that series, Laia and Elias didn’t get tortured enough. And I’m so sorry I thought that because she hurt them in the worst possible way in this book. In all those writing workshops that talk about how to torture your main characters, Sabaa should be the keynote speaker at all of them!

When I first found out that she was releasing another book to follow the series from a number in the ashes, my first thought was “Yay, she’s releasing another book” immediately followed by “Oh no, she’s going to torture her characters and us along with them.” in this story we get to follow. Quill, the baby we were introduced to in the last series, now grown up. We also follow Aiz and Sirsha, one an orphan desperate to free her people and one outcast from her own group of people. These three voices and stories eventually merge to create an adventure, full of heartbreak, loss, and at the root of it, finding love in an unexpected place. Sabaa has created a beautiful story with a surprise twist ending that I know the follow up story will have our hearts torn out by the end of it.

First, I went into this without having read the An Ember in the Ashes series first, which was probably a mistake. While it is a separate story, I feel like there was a lot that I didn’t understand, or missed because I didn’t have that background and world-building. Anyway, I spent most of the book a little bit confused. There were multiple storylines happening, and it was difficult to figure out how they linked together for quite a while. I thought the characters were all really interesting, and I was completely shocked by the ending. I also loved the writing style which was beautiful and descriptive.

Many thanks to Penguin Young Readers and NetGalley for the ARC.

Aiz is a gifted orphan, determined to help her peers get out of the slums and into power. Sirsha is the haughty exiled daughter of a powerful matriarchal nation of magic users. Quil is the heir to an empire, hiding both his ambivalence about taking the throne and mystical powers of his own. Together, the three of them team up to take on an evil pretender, bent on twisting holy purpose to his own nefarious ends and destroying any chance their nations have at finding peace.

Sabaa Tahir’s Heir is familiar fun—the first installment in an epic YA fantasy duology full of big battles, exciting magics, and enough love triangles to teach a geometry lesson with. It’s even set in the same universe as Tahir’s previous series, An Ember in the Ashes. It shares the same setting, styled vaguely after the late Roman Empire, and has the same immensely detailed worldbuilding, although Heir is set some years after Ember, with an (almost) entirely new cast of characters and a slightly darker edge. You don’t need to read the previous series to get into Heir—it’s written well enough to stand on its own, although the glimpses we get of people and places from the past are probably much more satisfying when you get the references.