Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Heir by Sabaa Tahir follows three young people, Aiz, Sirsha, and Qwil, as they navigate the dangers of their world. Their stories are intricately woven together, brutally colliding as the tale unfolds.

Aiz grew up in the slums. Her past is full of loss and anger. She seeks vengeance, no matter the cost...

Sirsha was banished from her people at a young age. Forced to fend for herself, she grows up strong and cold. Bound by magical code, she seeks a killer. If she can not follow through, a desolate future awaits her.

Crowned Prince, Qwil, caught between his troubling lineage and a future he did not choose sets out to protect his people. He needs to be the ruler his people deserve.

This book is told by multiple perspectives, which definitely adds to the depth of the story. The characters and world building are great!

Thank you, NetGalley, and PENGUIN GROUP Penguin Young Reader's Group for an advanced readers copy of Heir in exchange for an honest review. Can't wait for the next one!

Was this review helpful?

I absolutely devoured this book from the first chapter. It had such an intriguing introduction and drew me in immediately. Heir was a brilliant addition to the ‘Ember in the Ashes’ world and left me desperate for the next book in the series. The characters were intricate and flawed, with so much description they came alive on the page.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley and publishers for providing me with this eBook!

I have to be honest right off the bat: I did not finish The Ember in The Ashes series by the same author. I read the first two, they were good, but wasn't really interested in more.

HOWEVER, this one makes me want to go back and read those books. Maybe I'll still not finish the series, but I liked Tahir's writing so much in this book that I can't not go back and try again. The characters in Heir felt new to me with a lot of their moral grey-ness, and the pacing kept the story moving, even with all the world- and character-building that needed to be included.

There were some parts that were predictable, some very much were not, so overall felt like a good, solid, fantasy story with a lot more story to tell. I'm not a huge fan of "big battle" fantasy books and while this technically has some of those happening in the background, it doesn't get bogged down by scenes about planning or strategy or big long battle scenes. Much more focused on characters and action and even some mystery!

If you liked City of Brass by S.A. Chakraborty, The Wrath and the Dawn by Renee Ahdieh, or the Thorn or Sunbolt series by Intisar Khanani, or either of the Grisha series by Leigh Bardugo, you'll probably like this book!

Was this review helpful?

Told from multiple perspectives over two different timelines, this well written YA romantasy, has fully developed characters and was fully engaging throughout. This is the first book in a new duology and as such ends on a cliff hanger. Apparently this series is a continuation of the stories from the Ember in Ashes series but reads well as a standalone. I haven’t read the earlier series and did not feel lost. Highly recommended.

Thanks to NetGalley and G.P. Putnam's Sons Books for an advanced reader copy

Was this review helpful?

When I finished A Sky Beyond the Storm in 2020, I thought to myself, “Surely Sabaa Tahir won’t be able to consume me with another fantasy series any more than this one, right?” Now, I wish I could go back and tell my naive self how wrong she was. 🥲

Heir is the first in a new fantasy duology set 20 years after the events of An Ember in the Ashes. The story follows three characters thrust into a tumultuous journey. We have Aiz, an orphan from the slums of Kegari, who is fueled by vengeance and the love of her people; Sirsha, an outcast from her home, who now uses magic to work as a tracker-for-hire; and Quil, the crown prince of the Empire who is reluctant to take the throne when his aunt (👀) steps down. It was so interesting seeing how Sabaa interweaves these three characters’ storylines into a tale of power, betrayal, friendship, found family, and love.

I loved being able to explore the Southern continents outside of the Empire in Heir. The new politics were gripping, and I found myself in shock at the impossible odds that are stacked against the undefeatable Empire that we are so familiar with. The twists and turns of this book had me reeling and gasping out loud on FaceTime with @pawneepubliclibrary_, @azantareads, @rams.reading, and @luu_reads. Sabaa definitely does not hold back with the utter devastation that our characters (both new and old) experience due to the power and greed of societies willing to sacrifice innocent lives for their agenda. Each chapter packed punch after punch and I’m hoping our faves make it out all right in Book 2.

I also have to shout out the delightful romance that’s included. The scenes in this book had me grinning and squealing all in one. Not to mention how hilarious the dialogue is?? I tabbed so many scenes with our favorite romance tropes and funny one-liners. The references to South Asian and Islamic culture were also so fun to read! I’m so happy to be back in this world and among these characters, and I need everyone read Heir on (and AEITA before) Oct. 1. Thank you so much to @PenguinTeen for providing me with an ARC and these gorgeous new AEITA paperbacks!

Was this review helpful?

“Grief is a strange beast. Some battle it, their souls scarred from its abuse. Some bury it, and live life waiting for it to reemerge. And some tread water, the grief a weight about their necks. Every reminder makes the weight heavier.”

Aiz, an orphan under a tyrant that does nothing but use and abuse those under his control. She’s desperate to save her people, but to what end.

Quil, heir to the Martial empire, facing his imminent rise to the throne. Loyalty to the end is the expectation, but below that is the fear he’ll be just like his father.

Sirsha (S’rsha), a disgraced and exiled Jaduna tracker. She’s been hired to find a child killer that has been sweeping the continent and leaving piles of bones in its path.

“When you sacrifice other people’s children on the altar of your ambition, it’s only a matter of time before you’ll be willing to sacrifice your own. That’s how evil works…”

I was left shocked and wanting more with this cliffhanger ending. I cannot wait for book two!

Heir is full of twists and turns and crossed paths. Some felt expected, and some totally left me surprised. This multi-POV and multi-timeline young adult book took me a second to get into. After getting about 20% into the book, I couldn’t put it down. All the connections were starting to click and make sense and I was immersed in the world. This was my first Sabaa Tahir book and it did not disappoint. I didn’t know this was a spin off of the An Ember in the Ashes series, but now I’m totally ready to dig into that series. I think had I read it before reading Heir, some things would have made more sense more quickly, but could totally be read as a standalone. The world Sabaa created felt totally unique and original. I’ve read so many fantasy books where the same types of creatures are used over and over.

Thank you NetGalley, Penguin Group, and Sabaa Tahir for allowing me to read an advanced complimentary copy of the book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.

Was this review helpful?

Omg I loved it! I received this arc from NetGalley and was hooked from the beginning. There are 3 main povs (with a few others sprinkled in) and each character is so different and their stories are captivating. The different magic systems were really interesting and the way it all came together was really cool. The world building was perfect; not too complicated to follow, but intricate enough. Hopefully there will be a map in the finished product. I could picture everything so vividly. Honestly, I really enjoyed this book a lot.

AND THAT ENDING… it’s cool. I’m fine. I’ll be fine.

Thank you NetGalley and Penguin Teen for affording me the opportunity to read this arc in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

NO SPOILERS Arc review!

The Ember in the Ashes Quartet is my child. That series made me cry, smile, hope, and love reading. The stories of Helene, Elias, and Laia were crafted to perfection and it's my go-to fantasy recommendation. I strongly believed that A Sky Beyond the Storm was the perfect cap to the story and that my imagination could craft the futures of our beloved characters. Yet Sabaa wrote Heir - and I foolishly picked it up.

Sabaa Tahir, I love you. But it is inevitable that I will compare this book with the masterpiece that is the Ember series. And it simply does not compare.

Despite being the same age as the main characters in Ember, our three protagonists feel distinctly younger and more naive. Additionally, they felt almost too similar to the original trio, Quil especially. Grab a snippet of his POV and a snippet of Elias' and I swear I would not be able to differentiate them.

My biggest gripe with Heir is the plot's timeline. I understand the "twist" Sabaa was aiming for but it was written so confusingly that half the time I was texting my friend that I was extremely lost. My attention was not hooked the way it was with Ember, and I was nearly dragging my feet towards the finish line.

The most prevalent thought in my mind while reading was "why was this book even written?!" Again, I loved A Sky Beyond the Storm. I truly don't think Heir was necessary. Sabaa, WHY CAN'T ANY OF THESE CHARACTERS KNOW PEACE?! Every character from Ember went through so, so, so much. Just let them rest, live in peace, and be happy - I beg you. It's inevitable that this book will change my perspective of book 4, and a small part of my heart is saddened by that.

Those are my two cents. My hope is that this review is not TOO harsh or discouraging, as it was fun to see characters old and new, but I do aspire that this review conveys two things: First that I stand firmly against spin-off series. And second, that I love An Ember in the Ashes so very much (so go read it!).

Thank you sincerely to the incredible Sabaa Tahir, the publishing company, and the NetGalley team!

Was this review helpful?

Nobody can write like Sabaa Tahir. Her writing is rich and her characters are well thought out and the plot is extraordinary. I'm looking forward to November when I can purchase a copy and read it again.

Was this review helpful?

Give this all the stars. One of the best books I’ve read this year. Fantasy with different POVs. Tons of adventure and lots of twists and turns that’ll keep you on your toes. Super sweet romance with two of the POVs. Ends in a big cliff hanger and I’m dying to know when the second book will come out.

I received an arc from NetGalley and the publisher.

Was this review helpful?

May Sabaa Tahir go down in history as one of the best storytellers of all time. Since I loved her Ember quartet so much, I had to read Heir, and getting an eARC was one of the most exciting things I’ve experienced.

Heir takes place almost 2 decades after the events of A Sky Beyond the Storm. And while there are some familiar faces, the focus is on the next generation of warriors and magic wielders. After a deadly invasion, Quil and his friends Sufiyan and Arelia must find safety, and a way to save the Empire. Along the way they meet Sirsha, a tracker hunting something dangerous. We also meet Aiz, a mysterious orphan from the slums of an impoverished nation.

When all their worlds collide, these young men and women question each other and themselves. Heir is a sweeping story of adventure, magic, and all kinds of love. The pacing was incredible and I thought about the book even when I wasn’t reading it. I can’t wait to read the next in the series and see where Sabaa takes us. Five stars, EASY.

Was this review helpful?

Returning to the world of "An Ember in the Ashes" with Sabaa Tahir’s new book, Heir, was both thrilling and nostalgic. As a devoted fan of the original series, I was eagerly anticipating this continuation, and I must say, it did not disappoint.

The story follows three main characters—Aiz, Sirsha, and Quil—each with their own distinct and captivating storylines. Aiz's arc was, for me, the standout. Her journey, marked by vengeance, magic, and resilience, was mesmerizing. The twists and turns in her narrative left me speechless, and I found myself wanting more of her perspective. Aiz's story alone is worth the read, showcasing Tahir’s skill in crafting complex, unforgettable characters.

Sirsha, a fierce and witty tracker with magical abilities, quickly became another favorite. Her chapters were a joy to read, and I found myself staying up late, unable to put the book down until I’d finished her sections. Sirsha’s development throughout the book was beautifully done, making her a character I could follow endlessly.

Quil, the reluctant heir to the Martial Empire, brings a unique blend of qualities reminiscent of both Helene and Elias from the original series. His internal struggles and his interactions, particularly the romantic ones, added depth to his character. The fact that Sabaa Tahir solidifies a romance early on in the series was a refreshing change from the slow-burn approach we often see in fantasy.

What really impressed me, though, was the seamless world-building. The 20-year gap since An Ember in the Ashes is felt throughout the book, as the world has evolved, and so have the characters we once knew. The cameos of Elias, Laia, and Helene were handled masterfully, showing just enough of their growth without overshadowing the new leads. Their appearances were like a bridge between the past and present, making the world feel richer and more expansive.

While Heir can be read as a standalone, I strongly recommend revisiting the original series before diving in. The lore and intricate details are so intertwined that having a fresh memory of the past events enhances the reading experience tremendously.

In conclusion, Heir exceeded my expectations. Sabaa Tahir has once again proven her prowess in fantasy storytelling. The character development, pacing, and world-building were spot on. I’m eagerly awaiting the sequel and highly recommend this book to all fans of the genre. Thank you to Penguin Teen for the ARC, and here's to the agonizing wait for the next installment!

Was this review helpful?

This is from the same world of Ember in the Ashes, so maybe read those first???? Having not have read those, I wish I would have, but this book was really good!

Was this review helpful?

What a masterpiece! 🙌👏 Sabaa Tahir never disappoints!
I did a re-read of "An Ember in the Ashes" series before starting this. I'm so glad I did! This can be a stand-alone, but NOT my recommendation as this story takes place in the same world, but 20 years in the future with different characters POV. 😊 In my personal opinion, you would miss a lot of important background information. I enjoyed everyone's POV. (Only 3). The plot is engaging and well-written. So much adventure and action-packed. I can't wait for the next one!
Thank you to NetGalley, PENGUIN GROUP Penguin Young Readers Group, & Sabaa Tahir for this ARC.
*All thoughts and opinions are my own.*
#SabaaTahir #Heir #NetGalley
Also posted on my goodreads

Was this review helpful?

SABAA CANNOT BE STOPPED!!!!
She has done it again & will hopefully do it again & again.
I love her writing. There’s always high stakes & fantastic characters to root for.
It was lovely to return to this universe. The way Sabaa writes 3 POV’s and weaves them all together is what draws me in. The character development, word building, & magic system kept me turning each page.
I highly recommend reading AEITA series, but this can be read as a standalone. If you want more depth, definitely consider reading the previous series.
I am so happy to have received an ARC. Thank you to NetGalley, the author & the publisher!

Was this review helpful?

Heir is a fantasy novel focused on the lives and adventures of Aiz, Sirsha, and Quil.

The complex characters and their stories made for an interesting read. However, being a mood reader, I felt I was not able to get into the book and therefore was not able to finish reading it completely. Apart from this, I felt that the story was engaging and the world-building was detailed.

Thank you to Penguin Group and NetGalley for this ARC!

Was this review helpful?

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

“There is beauty in the dark, and strength.”

Heir is the first book in a new duology by Sabaa Tahir that takes place in the same universe as Ember in the Ashes, however this can be read as a stand-alone. I have not read Ember in the Ashes yet but it’s been on my TBR for a while.

The book follows 3 POVs that are all interconnected in different parts of the same story. While this is YA there is a great romance subplot to this book that has angst, longing, and sacrifice that comes with being duty bound to something else.

Overall, I really loved the story. There are a lot of plot, twists and intense things going on. Sabaa has created a world of dark and intricate magic that is fascinating to follow along with very complex relationships and friendships. I will definitely be continuing the series and preorder the special edition from BN.

My only reason for 4⭐️ is that at times I found one of the main plot twists a bit difficult to follow at first and thought I somehow missed a major piece of information. It was more of a “trust the process” moment and all worked out in the end but I did have to go back to make sure I didn’t miss anything.

Thank you to NetGalley and Penguin Teen for the arc. All opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

A vengeful orphan. A determined outcast. A shadowed prince. And a killer who will bring an empire to its knees.

What a joy to read another Sabaa book in the world of An Ember in the Ashes, one of my favorite series of all time.

Some 20 years after the concluding events of A Sky Beyond the Storm, a new cast of characters takes center stage as the Empire is under threat of attack. There are three primary POVs in Heir: Aiz, an orphan from the Dafra slum of Kegar on the southern continent (a place we barely saw in Ember). Sirsha, a Jaduna sorceress cast out from her people and in search of a killer, and Quil, heir to the Martial Empire and nephew of mommy Empress Helene Aquilla. All of these characters have unique motivations, personalities, abilities, and arcs. The magic of the world takes center-stage maybe more than ever before. The sexual tension does too. Boy, are these teenagers horny. And, in true Sabaa fashion, hearts are broken and, quite literally, ripped out of chests and devoured for pleasure, our hearts included.

I love this take on expanding an established universe. Sabaa takes us to a different time and a lot of different places with a lot of different characters. We, of course, get some cameos from our beloved favorites out of Ember, but they aren't the focus of this story. We also spend a lot of time on an entirely different continent, with different people and cultures that we didn't even know existed until now. Sabaa excelled with telling a fresh story in an established world, and I wish more authors would attempt something like this.

If I had to offer any criticism, I would point out two things: The first is Sabaa's handling of Aiz. This character's arc is something that I imagine is incredibly challenging to do right. And, don't get me wrong, Sabaa does an excellent job with the character, but Aiz's behaviors and conclusions didn't always feel right in the moment. She's a complex character, for sure. And that came out. Some things just felt a little disjointed at times. The second bit of criticism would have to do with the pacing. I felt that some important events were just zoomed through. There were epic battles that were over in a page. There were major moments that were simply summarized. And then there was the climactic events near the end of the book that just seemed a bit garbled and maybe even "easily" solved.

While it's not mandatory that you read Ember before Heir, I would strongly suggest you do. Not only will it clue you in to all the cameos and Easter Eggs and rich lore and history, they are great reads and will only serve to increase your enjoyment of Heir when you get to it.

The ending of Heir is clearly not the ending. Sabaa has some big things planned for the second half of the story and I'm certainly here for it. She continues to be one of my favorite worldbuilders and storytellers and I can't wait to read more.

Was this review helpful?

Wow! I have missed this world so much and have been so excited to return. It introduced new characters, while seeing the return of a few old ones. This book follows Sirsha, Quil, and Aiz all with their own reasons and motivations to be in the Empire. Sabaa expands the world into other territories, introducing their own unique magic, and governments. The pacing for the book is perfect for the events that are taking place in the book. It gives you enough details that you don’t feel you are missing anything or creating plot holes. Heir, I feel can stand on its own without the original AEITA series (although, I still think it’s a must read) It gives enough details to understand that the Empire has a dark history. (That being said, does poor Helene ever catch a break?). Heir is the perfect follow up to the original series.

Sirsha, I absolutely enjoyed reading from her perspective. After, being approached for a dangerous job that could put her life at risk, she embarks on a journey that intersects with others, leading to friendship, love, and loyalty—even when her life is in jeopardy. Her growth throughout her journey was my favorite part to read. Sirsha’s loyalty was always present, she just didn’t have anyone to be loyal to until she found this family.

Quil, battles with becoming the king of the Empire and his past, including his family history. Afraid to end up like his father, who once ruled the Empire in a cruel and unjust way. He loves hard, and cares deeply for his family and friends. Battling with the events of the past year and struggling to come to terms of his soon to be king ship, he discovers new unexpected battles. The Empire in jeopardy once again, Quil takes it head on especially because it will save the ones he loves. Quil is such a strong character, and it was wonderful to see him come terms being the crown prince, duty, and love. His feelings towards Sirsha were so pure and heartfelt.

Aiz is a character that will catch you off guard, and you won’t realize it till it’s too late. Her changes throughout the book are subtle but come together at the end. Aiz’s character reflected the environment she grew up in, with her dreams and desires being amplified by certain being whispering in her ear. I found Aiz as character I found to be the most complex character in the storyline, embodying the transformation of rightful anger into unjust actions.

Overall, Heir is a strong start in this duology and furthermore a strong book to add to the AEITA universe. Expanding the world and its magic beyond what was discussed in the predecessors. I’ve been waiting for a book to scratch my fantasy it and this was just it! I am beyond excited to see where this story goes in the next book.

Was this review helpful?

There are those stories that sink into your heart and stay with you long after you've put down the book.
Another masterpiece by a master storyteller. Left me destroyed, in awe, heartbroken, raging and wanting more.
Heir by Saba Tahir is one of those books for me. The whole Ember series really. In Heir we are taken twenty years after the events of Ember. Quil is about to inherit the empire his aunt ruled until he came of age. Sirsha is a tracker exiled from her people and recently hired for her most dangerous job yet. Aiz is an orphan used to suffering, but fueled by revenge. Their lives will interweave in heartbreaking ways as they navigate corrupting power, love, friendship, grief, and violence.
Tahir weaves a tale so masterfully that I'm left in awe. Each character is infused with life. Quil was an endearing reluctant heir. Frightened by the ghosts of his father's legacy. With his knowledge of his father's brutal reign and the corrupting influence of power Quil has a lot to come to terms with. Can he be a good leader and escape his father's shadow? I think I love him as much as Elias! He was strong, capable, and full of love for his family.
Being inside Sirsha's head was so great! She's funny, but she's also dealing with the loss of her family and her home. Her relationship with her sister was so heartbreaking, but refreshing to see. We don't always get along with our biological family. It was nice to see this compliment family dynamic. I think I also love her as much as Laia. Her journey as she hunted down a killer that had murdered children throughout the empire was exhilarating.
Aiz was I think the most tragic character to read. Her life has been filled with violence. A violence derived from hunger, poverty, and oppression. Her love for her people was vast which made her character so interesting. You can compare and contrast her with Helene for a fun thought experiment.
I always think about an interview I read once where Sabaa Tahir speaks on her inspiration for Ember. She speaks about her work as a journalist and how she started to think about the children that lived under bombardment. (I'm paraphrasing.) I think about it as I read her novels with Heir it was even more apparent how much she has to say about war and its effects on the young. Her focus on the youth it affects is what makes her writing so brilliant. Through it all though the characters or at least for the most part keep their humanity. It's a struggle to keep hate from their hearts, but they try. Seeing the enemies humanity leads them to better deal with the threat.
How Tahir creates multidimensional villains will always be another thing I absolutely admire about her. Evil is never simple in her books. It's always so tragic. Here she poses the question of how far will someone go to save their people? Will that heroic journey turn into the ends justify the means?
Love is very much a theme woven in the story. There's familial love, a chosen family, and of course romantic love. The romance was sizzling!! It was so satisfying with a dash of tension to make it worth the payoff.
If you've never picked up a Sabaa Tahir book pick this one up! If you like fantasy read it. I definitely recommend putting this one in your tbr. It comes out in October.

Was this review helpful?