Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Thank you, Netgalley and publisher, for this ARC!

It was really exciting to dive back into this world and follow a different storyline with different characters, but it was also fun to see characters from the last book. (Peeping Elias and Laia 🥰)

At first, I thought I was following the same timeline while I read each characters chapters until they started to meet up with each other later in the book. That was a fun surprise when it finally made sense. The chapters aren't titled with dates or anything, so I wasn't expecting that.


I did like the chemistry between Quil and Sirsha, so I really hope the next book resolves our little issue at the end of this book. (Don't want to spoil anything).

Overall, it was a fun book and I can't wait for the next. I'd recommend to anyone who likes fantasy.

Was this review helpful?

Gosh, this book! It has every single thing I love about fantasy. Romance, politics, emotion and action. I loved this continuation of the Ember series and honestly every time Helene, Elias, and Laia were mentioned I SCREAMED.

And those TWISTS!!!

Book two, I need you now

Was this review helpful?

THE ENDING!!!!!!! SABAA please. I need the second book right now. I loved every minute of Heir. I can't say much without spoiling the story, but it was so much fun to along with the POVs of Sirsha, Quil, and Aiz., and it was so great to see Ember characters pop up again.

Mark your calendars for October 1, 2024 immediately.

Thank you to NetGalley, PENGUIN GROUP Penguin Young Readers Group and Sabaa Tahir for the complementary digital copy in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley and Putnam/Penguin Random House for the opportunity to read Heir by Sabaa Tahir in exchange for my honest review.

Heir is a high fantasy set in a familiar world but offers an entirely new story and characters, with a few cameos from Tahir’s Ember in the Ashes (EITA) series. The book's narrative structure, featuring one point of view set in the past and two in the present, can be challenging to follow, sometimes making it difficult to keep track of the timeline and character arcs.

For those unfamiliar with the EITA series, the intricate world-building in Heir might be daunting. The story takes place 20 years after the events of the previous series, and while the world-building, magic system, and character motivations are exceptionally well-done, new readers might struggle to grasp the full depth of Tahir’s creation.

However, Heir stands out in a genre that often feels saturated with generic tales. The novel’s world-building is immersive, the magic system is fascinating, and the characters' motivations are compelling.

If you're a fan of YA fantasy looking for something that breaks the mold, I’d recommend Heir, however I’d probably suggest starting with EITA. Tahir is an expert at exploring the dark side of life.

Was this review helpful?

EXCUSE ME I NEED 5-7 BUSINESS DAYS TO PROCESS WHAT JUST HAPPENED BC HELLO?!?
Sabaa Tahir really knows how to build a world and introduce it to new readers. I have not gotten around to reading Ember in the Ashes series yet but I heard this was a spinoff series (but can still be read as a standalone). I had no issues jumping into the world and getting a grasp of the magic system and political set up. I would say it starts quite slow in the beginning but starts to pick up quickly after and BOYYY DOES IT GET GOOD. The author truly knows how to keep you on your toes with banter, tension, high stakes and crazy twists! I am so so excited for the second book that concludes this duology because I care so much about these characters and i need to know HOW IT ENDS FOR THEM 🥹 otherwise this is a fantastic read for fantasy readers who love romance and adventure!


Tysm Penguin Teen for the early copy for an exchange of my honest thoughts and review ~

Was this review helpful?

The way I screamed when I was approved for this @netgalley eARC was so loud it startled Astor cat 😅

Truly we do not deserve the glorious writing & creative mind of @sabaatahir but I am so so so glad that she graces us with these books. Heir is book one in a new duology that takes place in the same universe as the An Ember in the Ashes series. Per usual with the books in this universe, all the stars. You’ll want to make sure to read those first (& it’s required reading in general by yours truly!) since you’ll be reunited with many familiar characters. I love these upper YA books with all of my heart. If you have various theories (as I did) while reading or need to scream your reactions always feel free to DM me!

You won’t want to miss Heir when it’s published 10.1.2024 💙

Was this review helpful?

Oh man this was a wild ride.

There is so much happening, and the author did a fantastic job of piecing everything together beautifully at the end. There is a real art in designing plots like this one. Every action causes a reaction. It’s beautiful.

The characters are sound, and everyone I read about was interesting enough that I wanted to continue to know more. No one felt bland. I enjoyed reading the side characters with or without the main characters. Everyone had good balance.

I love multiple POVS. They make my heart sing because I’m nosey, I want to be in the know for every little thing happening.

The slow burn this had was just glorious. I rooted for them the entire time I was reading and only wanted to see them thrive. The banter they had was impeccable. The romance is not the main focus of this story, for me, it worked. I was so interested in everything else that was happening as well that not having full blown romance every page was perfect. It had just enough to satisfy. Also, I loved the way the umm “love” scenes were written. I’m a spicy girly but sometimes it’s nice to have stories that leave things to the imagination.

Overall, I really enjoyed this book. It was my first time reading Sabaa Tahirs work and I cannot wait to see more from this author.

Thank you NetGalley, and Sabaa Tahir for early access to this work in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

As someone who was not crazy about An Ember in the Ashes, I was really curious to see what Sabaa Tahir’s next work would be. This fantasy novel follows three young people: Aiz, who has powers she cannot control; Sirsha, a tracker, and Quil, the heir to the empire. I unfortunately didn’t find these characters very interesting or original, and the writing struck me as somewhat bland. Tahir also fell into one of the traps set for authors of another bestselling series when they write something new: providing enough exposition for new readers when the book is set in the same universe as the other series. This attempt failed on two levels. I’ve only read the first book in her other series a long time ago, and I certainly did not feel that this book gave me enough information to understand what was happening between all the different groups in the story. Tahir also did a lot of Remember the Characters from that Other Series and Also How Great Those Books Were while providing exposition, which was not enjoyable.

Was this review helpful?

I absolutely loved this book! I had a feeling I would, as I also loved Ember in the Ashes. Sabaa Tahir’s writing draws you and has you invested in no time. You absolutely don’t have to read the Ember in the Ashes series to read this, BUT if you did enjoy them, you are bound to love these, too! At first I was a bit overwhelmed with multiple point of views, but it didn’t take me long to get a handle on it. There were some clever surprises throughout that had me marveling at Sabaa Tahir’s creativity. I cannot wait for the second installment in this duology!

Was this review helpful?

I'm obsessed with this expansion of the world built from the Ember series! This book had me gasping. so loud in the last half of the book with all the twists and turns! truly such a crazy experience! I loved seeing old and familiar characters mixed with the new characters. At first it took a while for me to really understand what was going on, especially with the multi POV. However, once things started to click together, I couldn't put the book down! The new characters and the romance... THE ROMANCE was just absolutely impeccable I just loved it from start to finish and I'm so so terrified of what's to come I just know Sabaa will hurt me once again

Was this review helpful?

This story was so immersive and fast paced. I really enjoyed the aspect of having the different POVs of Quil, Aiz, and Sirsha and overall plot of the story.

Was this review helpful?

Wow what an absolute ride! Such a fantastic read. I haven’t read something this good in months. I could not put it down!

Was this review helpful?

He caught her wrist. "Behave," he whispered. "I never have," she said, her lips a breath away from his. "Why would I start now?"

3.5 stars. whew! what a page turner!

✨THINGS AND STUFF✨
-multiple pov
-elemental magic
-political intrigue: abdication & regicide
-freedom from tyranny
-a place of unending death
-ope! fake engagement
-chapter cliff hangers!!!
-oh no! you’re wounded (hurt/comfort)
-found family
-the spirit world
-touch her & die
-sacrifice & betrayal
-#IsThisAKissingBook: ftb. “His dimple flashed as he brought her wrist to his lips in a swift kiss”

thank you penguin teen for an advanced copy!

Was this review helpful?

I received this acr several weeks before I read it. Why did I wait? I was scared. The Ember in the Ashes series is still absolute perfection in my mind. I should not have worried. Heir takes place two decades later. Elias, Laia, and Helene are secondary characters. Quil, Aiz, and Sirsha are our main characters. I loved this book as much as the previous quarter. I felt all the things, love, hate, disgust , humor, horror. A certain characters choices made me so angry but through Tahir’s writing, I actually felt bad for this character at the same time. Knowing I have to wait for the conclusion is just about killing me. Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for the opportunity to read and review this fabulous book.

Was this review helpful?

I was incredibly excited about this ARC, though it took me awhile to get into it. I really didn't like Aiz and her POV at first, but once her path crossed with the others, I could not put this book down! I felt like the character development was really well done and I ended up loving all of the characters. I liked getting to see more of the surrounding countries and people, and I appreciated the glimpses into the future of the characters from the Ember Quartet. They weren't the main focus though, and you can absolutely understand Heir without reading Ember first. However, there are obviously major spoilers about how the Ember Quartet ends, so I would still recommend reading Heir after. I can't wait for the next book!

P. S. Without giving too much away, there is a fake engagement trope for those of you who like that!

Was this review helpful?

I was extremely happy to dive back into the "An Ember in the Ashes" universe and it did not disappoint!

The story picks up after a time lapse from where "AEITA" left off. We meet the main characters: Aiz, Sirsha, and Quil. I enjoyed most of the new characters, but one of the POVs was a bit challenging for me. I appreciated what Sabaa was trying to achieve with that character arc, which is something we don’t often see but should have more of.

I was quite invested in the other POVs and eagerly anticipated their storylines. Quil and Sirsha were amazing characters to follow, and their interactions with others were engaging. I particularly enjoyed Sirsha's POV and how she evolved throughout the book.

The ending, as expected from Sabaa, left me wondering what on earth will happen next. Can’t wait for the next one!

Was this review helpful?

Sabaa Tahir has done it again. I came into this book as a huge fan of Ember in the Ashes so I had high expectations, and Tahir delivered. I wasn’t expecting Heir to be so closely attached to the Ember series, so I was surprised that all of the characters reappeared and had important roles in the story. This is definitely a book that should be read after having read Ember because so much of the world building is done in that series. This allowed us to jump into action pretty quickly without having too much backstory to the realms - though Tahir did a good job of adding in refreshers for people like me with memories like a sieve.
Without spoiling anything, Tahir does something in this book that I didn’t see coming at all and just as it started to unfold is when I realized what was happening and my jaw was on the floor. Truly excellent storytelling and a wonderful first book in a new series. I was connected to each character, even the most complicated ones, and appreciated the nuance that went into showcasing war, conflict, and power.
My only complaint is that I know have to wait more than a year for the next book.

Was this review helpful?

sabaa tahir is a genius. she manages to create immersive worlds with complex and loveable characters that simultaneously deal with similar problems as our world while still being magical and transportive. I loved seeing laia and elias and their children, although honestly I could have done with less suffering for them, especially after the original ember quartet. I did see the twist coming at like the 30% mark, but I still really enjoyed seeing the story unfold. thank you to netgalley and the publishers for this e-arc in exchange for an honest review!

Was this review helpful?

This was a book that once I finished I couldn’t wait for the next in the series, and since it’s an ARC this book hasn’t even come out yet (Oct 2024), I’m all out of sorts! I NEED to know where we go from here.

An orphan, a crown prince and a castaway witch all share their different POVs making up this book. They each are on their own missions that make up this story set in an epic fantasy world. I became hooked very quickly and while I wasn’t a huge fan of one character (I won’t share who), all of the stories came together in such a beautiful and surprising way.

I have not read the authors other books, but apparently this story is an extension of that world, so I would definitely consider going back to read that. It’s been 2.5 years since her last book and the wait is definitely worth it!! Thank you to NetGalley for this ARC in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley for the ARC.

As someone who never read An Ember in the Ashes, this book wasn’t nearly as confusing as others would lead you to believe. I didn’t find myself wanting for more information by any means. That said, I’m sure you should read the original series first if it’s on your list. This book had its slow moments, but I enjoyed the action sequences when they did occur. I never really connected with any of the characters however, even though this is quite a long book.

Was this review helpful?