Skip to main content

Member Reviews

If you are looking for some fall witchy vibes that seem cozy, but also have some real evil stakes, A Dark and Secret Magic will be for you. Hecate was told her whole like she would be a hedgewitch, even though most of the witches in her village were allowed to choose. As she approaches her 31 birthday, Hecate feel pretty unfulfilled and aimless and has some deep resentment directed towards her deceased mothers. As Hecate gets closer to her birthday, and the ritual of containing her magic that all witches go through at this time, she starts to have questions and new faces arrive in the town. This book is a cute story of finding yourself mixed with a quest to resolve some generational trauma, mixed with a fun romance and a very very bad King of the underworld.

Was this review helpful?

A Dark and Secret Magic has such an incredible cover that I was drawn to it straight away and I knew I had to read it because it sounded so interesting.
Taking place in the days leading up to Halloween this is the perfect seasonal read.
Filled with all the Halloween and Fall vibes you want including our main character a hedge witch. She lives in a cozy cottage filled with herbs and her cat's name is Merlin.
Hecate, our protagonist is always baking, cooking and making a special recipe hot chocolate, I swear I could smell the cinnamon as I read.
This is my first fantasy read and I was captivated by it. Witchy, Halloweeny vibes, black cats, cozy cottage, small town charm, a pumpkin contest I'm all in. Marvelous and I'll be looking for more like this soon.

I was given a complimentary copy of this book.
All opinions expressed are my own.

Was this review helpful?

This book was fall perfection. Witches, spells, love, a little bit of suspense/drama, and just ALL things Halloween and Autumn. The characters were wonderful, and I especially enjoyed the 3 sisters and their relationship. I loved this one, and if you’re looking for something seasonal, this will absolutely get you in the spirit. ✨🪄🎃

Was this review helpful?

Set in the days leading up to Halloween, this atmospheric and magical tale of witches is an absolute must-read.

From the moment you start reading, Kinney’s writing style draws you in. The book is well-edited, and the plot is engaging from start to finish. The romance in the story is sweet and heartwarming, without being overly spicy.

One of the standout features of this book is its atmosphere. Kinney masterfully describes a cozy cottage, complete with mouth-watering autumnal dishes prepared by Hecate, the protagonist. You can almost taste and smell the delicious meals as you read. The small town setting, bustling with Halloween preparations and a charming pumpkin carving contest, adds to the enchanting vibe of the story.

In summary, “A Dark and Secret Magic” is a delightful read that perfectly captures the essence of the Halloween season. It’s a book that you simply must read before Halloween. I absolutely loved it.

Was this review helpful?

A cozy, riveting read! The food descriptions inspired me to bake, cook, and make delicious fall tea to go along with the vibes. This is the perfect way to start your fall! The characters were realistic and felt like your friends.

Was this review helpful?

This wasn't bad at all and in fact, I really enjoyed how this encompassed Halloween and the season, but I was less intrigued by 60% because I felt like it was dragging a bit toooo long and now I'm done and it was just okay.

Was this review helpful?

What a lovely book for the spooky time of year. This book has a coherent magic system with enough complexity to keep fantasy readers engaged and a steamy enough romance to keep those romance readers turning the pages. Fans of Practical Magic will find much to love.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you NetGalley and Alcove Press for this ARC.

This book definitely was a cozy, fall book with all the Halloween themes. I really loved the witchy vibes and the fantasy elements. It felt very reminiscent of a 90s era movie like Hocus Pocus or Practical Magic. I absolutely loved the nostalgia of that.

My only complaint was the romance. It felt exceptionally rushed and not well explained. However again that gave in to the 90s nostalgia as love at first sight is a common theme there.

Overall though I really did love this for the Halloween season and was a good break from the norm of horror for the month. I wish more books like this existed for my favorite holiday.

Was this review helpful?

A Dark and Secret Magic by Wallis Kinney is the perfect read for the fall/ Halloween season. This a perfect witchy book and the romance was adorable. I enjoyed the plot, the secrets, and especially the characters. Overall, it was a fun read and I can’t wait to read more books written by Wallis Kinney. Thank you NetGalley and publisher for giving me this opportunity. I can’t wait to purchase a physical copy because the cover is absolutely stunning.

Was this review helpful?

A Dark and Secret Magic is a cozy fantasy following a hedge witch after her forbidden magic practicing ex shows up at her door and she finds an item of dark magic. This novel takes place during the week leading up to Halloween, and I enjoyed the fall atmosphere of the setting. I loved that the witches had different types of magic. Overall I enjoyed the book, but I felt a little disconnected from the romance and disliked a few of the witches.

I received an ARC and ALC from Alcove Press and Dreamscape Media via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Inside and out, this book is a wonderful addition to any fall TBR! Witchy, cozy and wonderfully written, definitely add this to your list!
Arc via netgalley

Was this review helpful?

My heart is so ridiculously happy and full after reading this book. Obviously the cover and the premise are what initially drew me in but then I started reading and I was captivated, which is not something I've said about a book before. I immediately fell in love with Kate's character and her entire personality. She was such a wholesome, heart-warming witch and I strive to be like her. The romance was fantastic, really no spice and lots of fade to black which I appreciated a lot because I wanted a story more focused on the witchcraft, which is exactly what this was. This book broke my heart a couple of times while reading but the ending brought everything together and mended me. This is a perfect warm, fall, witchy book for October.

Many thanks to Alcove Press for the gifted copy for my honest review!

Was this review helpful?

Full of cozy fall vibes, this witchy tale will sweep you away and into a story of magic, mystery, and romance.

Overall, I loved the autumnal nature of the book! Its charm just made me so giddy and reminded me why I love this time of the year so much. I also really enjoyed seeing our main character grow and develop throughout this read. I loved her little cottage too, and her cat. (How cute is the name Merlin?!)

I also LOVE the recipes at the end and will definitely have to try a few out this season!

3.25/5

*Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for sending me an ARC in exchange for an honest review.*

Was this review helpful?

A cozy and mysterious book about witches, family, and love.

I very much enjoyed this book - I finished it in one sitting. Hecate (aka Kate) is a lovely character. I found her so relatable while also wanting to be a bit more like her. The magic that is in this book is......well, magical, and I loved the setting. Any book that is set in a small town I'm interested in. Ipswich is actually one of my favorite towns to vacation in - it's so cute and it's close to both Boston and Salem. Being familiar with Ipswich made this feel so familiar. Matthew is the perfect book boyfriend and seeing the friendship (and romantic relationship) evolve between him and Kate throughout the book was something that made me so eager to keep reading.

The family ties in this book and the mysteries that surrounded Kate's mother was interesting. There are some themes that I think a lot of people who have lost a loved one can relate to. Learning more about the coven and Kate being named a Hedge Witch had me wanting to learn all of the secrets as quickly as possible. There are some spooky and exciting scenes throughout the book with the ending really amping up the excitement and had me on the edge of my seat.

While this story is cozy, it's also exciting with the best Halloween vibes. This is a perfect book to read in the fall, especially if you love witches.

Was this review helpful?

the author really whipped up the perfect witchy halloween concoction in her cauldron, filled with sprinkles of forbidden magic, a shadow daddy love interest, a loyal black cat named merlin, a fall festival, warty pumpkins, and a dark and evil twist. only complaint is she threw in some insta-love on accident.

✧ 4 stars

thank you to Alcove Press for the arc in exchange for an honest review

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to the publisher for a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.

A Dark and Secret Magic is a very sweet and cozy fall read. It. This story has everything cozy you could want for an autumn read. This story fits squarely in the cozy fantasy genre and knows it's audience. There were times were i wanted the story to go a little deeper and say more but I don't think that is what the author intended for this to be. This is a vibe story, read it in October and feel all the feels.

Was this review helpful?

OMG, this was the *ultimate* fall, witchy read! Picture this: cozying up with a blanket, crisp autumn air outside, and diving into a world brimming with magic, curses, and witches. It’s everything you crave for those perfect Fall vibes. This book had it *all*— covens, curses, forbidden magic, and even a slow-burn romance that had me *swooning*! HIGHLY RECOMMEND!! Seriously, it’s made my favorites list for 2024 already!

If you love the mix of Hades and Persephone mythology, **Practical Magic** charm, and just a sprinkle of **Charmed** (because let's be real, Matthew gives major Cole vibes), you *need* to read this.

Hecate Goodwin (Kate) is a hedge witch living in a cozy cottage, spending her days collecting herbs. But, just a week before Halloween—aka her 31st birthday—her sister drops a bomb: Kate’s hosting the coven’s New Year event, a special containment ritual where she’ll give up some of her magic. And if that wasn’t enough to stress her out, a man from her past, Matthew, suddenly shows up seeking sanctuary. It’s been over 10 years since she last saw him, and let’s just say there’s some *serious* tension. Oh, and by the way, Matthew practices *forbidden* shadow magic! 😲

Things get even more mysterious when Kate stumbles upon a spellbound, cursed tome, written in handwriting that suspiciously resembles her late mother’s. With Matthew’s help, she starts unraveling secrets about her magic, her past, and her family that she was never told.

Now, let me just *scream* about the chemistry between Kate and Matthew! The tension, the longing, the sparks flying between them—it’s *electric*! I need more of their story ASAP. This world was so immersive, I could live in it forever. The side characters, especially Kate’s two sisters, were just as fascinating and added so much depth to the story.

It’s fast-paced, with no slow moments to drag you down. The writing? Absolutely gorgeous. I savored *every* word. And don’t even get me started on the food descriptions—there were so many cozy, magical recipes mentioned that I’m convinced we need a cookbook inspired by this story!

Plus, learning about the hedge witch lineage from Hecate’s ancestors was such a cool touch. Overall, this book was pure autumn magic, and I’m already craving more from this world!

Absolute 5 star read! Pick this up before Halloween!

I received a complimentary copy of this book. The opinions expressed in this review are entirely my own. Thank you to the publisher, Netgalley, and the author for the opportunity to read this novel.

Was this review helpful?

This isn’t fully a cozy fantasy because of all the action, but it is cozy ish. I still enjoyed the world where she’s able to make magical food and heal people while living in her little cottage.

I like that the ending feels full of hope and that the future will be better.

Was this review helpful?

There is something magical about this book that makes it feel like a safe place to call home.

This is definitely a cozy fall read that is full of references to everything fall from the late 90's to early 00's. The original title of this book This Book Is For October tells you everything you need to know about what you'll find inside. And not only are there sly mentions of references to all of our Halloween favorites, this book is also full of some of our time-honored holiday traditions.

Crafting, pumpkin carving, making caramel apples, decorating, and celebrating the festivities with friends. The food. THE FOOD. Our MC Kate's mother's magic was in her food and she taught her recipes to her Hedge witch daughter. Throughout the book we are given descriptions of the delicious foods as well as watching Kate make them for those she loves most. The back of the book also has a section for recipes and excerpts from Kate's spell book that we can try ourselves!

Add to that a very sweet closed door romance that will have you at baited breath waiting to see how our favorite couple make it through the darkest Samhain of their lives. I love these characters and just the absolute vibe of their world. This book is just one giant fall hug that always sets me right in the middle of my favorite season.

And we can never forget Kate's cat Merlin. He is by far the absolute best cat on the planet. We love him.

Was this review helpful?

This should be on your October TBR list - it has witches, magic, mystery and evolves around Halloween time.

The book itself gives you a cozy feeling to start with. It lures you into the chaos of a coven, with unique magic (hello, a BOOK WITCH?!) and keeps you there until you realize you're in too deep to look back - and ironically just like the main character herself.

There's a lot of emotion in the later part of the book, and I can see where the Persephone and Hades story takes place; and though I am glad it's not another retelling, I do wish to see a short story of their time together after the book.

I thoroughly enjoyed the ride this book was. This 100% will be a reread for me next fall, and I strong recommend others to read it.

Enjoy the little things in life, y'know?

Was this review helpful?