Skip to main content

Member Reviews

While this was well-written and engaging, I couldn't connect with it. It seemed to be everything I would love in a book, but I just wanted more interaction between the main characters leading up to a romance. It seemed disjointed in a lot of ways.

Was this review helpful?

This story was so cute. I loved the banter and the plot. It didn't feel predictable. I really liked the characters.

Was this review helpful?

This book is everything you want in a Christmas read. The characters were so easy to fall in love with, it was charming, it had just enough spice. I was hooked from the jump and I didn’t want it to end. I look forward to Emily Stone’s Holiday read’s every year. She does not disappoint!

Was this review helpful?

I have been a big fan of Emily Stone’s previous books and was excited to read her latest!

This book is very cute and I enjoyed the plot- I thought the travel company in it sounded like an amazing idea and I liked hearing about the travel. I also felt that it did a good job of working through Lexie’s feelings towards her dad which I understood as someone who had a complicated relationship with my dad.

I just found the book a bit repetitive and slow at times. I also felt like there was a lack of chemistry between the two MC and I never really felt behind their romance.

Overall it was cute, but probably my least fave of the author’s books. I will continue to try her books in the future.

Thank you NetGalley and the publisher for the arc!

Was this review helpful?

There’s something magical about a holiday book that feels both cozy and bittersweet, and A Winter Wish delivers just that. Emily Stone’s storytelling shines with her ability to weave heartwarming moments with themes of grief, love, and the rediscovery of joy. She makes you feel as though you are part of the story and the warmest welcome.

Was this review helpful?

Lexie has many conflicting emotions when learning about her estranged father’s death. Especially when she inherits part of his travel company. The catch is Lexie must help the company turn a profit within a year. Now Lexie must learn to work with her father’s business partner Theo who seems to hold a lot of resentment towards her. As Lexie travels on tours and comes up with ideas of her own for the company, Theo’s attitude towards her begins to thaw. Both begin to open up and examine their relation with Lexie’s father and each other. But will the company succeed or fail? Will Lexie move on when year is over?

As usual, Emily Stone gives us all the feels in the comfort of a holiday romance.

Was this review helpful?

There’s something magical about a holiday book that feels both cozy and bittersweet, and A Winter Wish delivers just that. Emily Stone’s storytelling shines with her ability to weave heartwarming moments with themes of grief, love, and the rediscovery of joy.

The novel follows Evie as she navigates life after loss, bringing her signature warmth to the tradition of granting Christmas wishes. The premise tugged at my heartstrings immediately, but what really hooked me was how Stone balances Evie’s journey of healing with the charm of the holiday season. The settings are vibrant and atmospheric—snowy markets, twinkling lights, and cozy firesides that feel like stepping into a Hallmark scene but with richer emotional layers.

Stone’s characters feel achingly real. Evie’s vulnerability is relatable, and the romance unfolds with a slow-burn tenderness that’s both sweet and deeply satisfying. It's not without its moments of frustration—miscommunications and emotional hesitation can feel drawn out—but it fits the narrative arc of growth and second chances.

While the plot is a little predictable in parts, that’s part of the appeal with holiday reads. It’s less about the twists and more about the emotional journey, and A Winter Wish wraps you in a story full of love, hope, and the power of connection.

If you’re in the mood for a holiday story with heart, Emily Stone delivers once again. It’s the perfect book to curl up with on a snowy evening, hot chocolate in hand.

Was this review helpful?

It’s the holiday season, and Lexie seems to be a nanny on vacation helping two young charges decorate a tree at a ski resort where she’s had enough time to hook up. Out at the bar and off duty she gets a call that her father has passed. The funeral is attended by his other daughter., Rachel, who seems genuinely distraught—Lexie cannot relate, as Richard may have been a father but was never a dad. And then the novel takes an abrupt left when we learn Lexie and Theo—her dad’s employee—have been willed his travel company and have to commit to a year of working together to inherit. Rachel gets the house.

At 10% through, I put this one down. I’m not sure if the writing style is a mismatch or it’s just poor writing—lots of exposition that doesn’t even tell very much. The very vague beginning, too many characters to keep straight, and lack of warm, cheery, holiday appeal made this a DNF for me.

Was this review helpful?

I have come to look forward to Emily Stone's winter/holiday books and this was another lovely read for the season!

This book combines travel and celebrations and it was really just perfect for the Christmas season but it could easily be read any time of the year.

If you're looking for a book that's more than just a fluffy Hallmark-y book that's still seasonal this would be a perfect book, especially if you like learning about other areas/cultures and their celebrations.

Thank you to NetGalley and Ballantine for the eARC copy of this novel in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Here it is - my last holiday read of the season. I didn't love this one, but I didn't dislike it either. It just wasn't her strongest book.

I did really enjoy the sweet reveal as the story unravels that leads our MC to understand her father more after many years of a broken relationship. Outside of that, I just never felt all that connected to our main characters. Their romance just didn't make a ton of sense to me, and I wanted to see more chemistry from each of them.

Emily Stone usually gives us tear-jerker holiday reads, and this one strayed from her typical formula. It may have been that wish to have a happier ending and less drama that led this one a bit astray.

Bottom line: Try Always, in December or Love, Holly by this author for a stronger holiday tale.

Was this review helpful?

This is a wonderful read for travel lovers.

Lexie inherits her father's travel company, but has to share it along Theo for a least a year. After a year the two can decide to sell the company.

The characters were likable throughout the story. Each adding something to the story. I enjoyed the writing and the story overall.

What I enjoyed most were the travel scenes. The characters discussing trips and experiences in various countries. I love to travel and have been lucky enough to visit some of the places mentioned. For me it added to the story.

I was expecting this to be more of a winter/Christmas read, but it wasn't. The story takes place over a year and for me the winter vibes were not present like I was expecting.

Thank you NetGalley for the opportunity to read this book.

Was this review helpful?

When Lexi’s estranged father dies, she is shocked to find he has left her half of his travel company with a slight complication. She and his co-worker Theo must agree to run the business together for a year before they can consider selling. Lexie wants nothing to do with the business and plans to be a silent partner for the year. But a trip to Spain leaves her feeling more connected to both the company’s mission and to Theo.
I think this was the first Emily Stone holiday book that didn’t make me cry. Yes, it was still heavy and deep with grief as a central theme, but it wasn’t quite the shock to the system I’ve had from her previous books (and that was a welcome surprise). I love Emily Stone’s writing and how she manages to tackle deep themes within her romances. At its heart, this is a beautiful story about dealing with grief, self-acceptance, and dealing with challenging parent-child relationships. This paired with the travel and the slow-burn romance made for a beautiful story.
Thank you to Random House Publishing and NetGalley for the advance copy.

Was this review helpful?

Enjoyable, and I’ll keep picking up Emily Stone! A nice medium touch on grief (it’s a main plot point, but not overly sad/emotional). But there were a few skimmed over scenes I would have liked (Dublin, Irish Country Inn, Vienna). Now where do I meet a travel agent boy??

Was this review helpful?

Emily Stone does heartfelt and emotional centered around Christmas so well! I very much enjoy light hearted Christmas reads, but I also love these deeply emotional stories that Emily Stone weaves and I will read anything she writes. She delves into wishes made that don't come true, expectations not met, and relationships fraught with disappointment, but having strength in times of struggle, and that love that conquer all - whether that is romantic love, familial love, or friendship love. So well done!

Was this review helpful?

This is a DNf for me. I just could not get into. Nothing about the story really pulled me in to get my attention.

Was this review helpful?

A lovely heartwarming read, perfect for cozying up at Christmas! Our main female character is dealing with a lot; her father dying, a new potential career/company, change of location, and a man who she can’t seem to resist. This book has all the ingredients for a cozy romance, with a little spice added in. I enjoyed the development of the characters and their romance. I would have loved a bit more depth but I enjoyed what there was.

Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for an advance copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are mine alone.

Was this review helpful?

This was the perfect holiday romance. It pulled at the heartstrings and was such an enjoyable story.

Was this review helpful?

I never read the synopsis for Emily Stone winter/holiday novels, and it's honestly a good thing that I didn't. The scenario Lexie experienced with her dad hit extremely close to home and made this a very emotional read for me. I don't know that I would have been brave enough to start it if I had known in advance, but I'm very glad that I did, as it was really enjoyable. Lexie and Theo's antics were awesome, Ange is who I want to be when I grow up, and the extended family is just so perfect for the novel. An excellent if tear jerking holiday story.

Was this review helpful?

A Winter Wish is the story of Lexie, who has inherited half of her father’s holiday travel company, despite them not speaking for the last 10 years. Additionally, he leaves the other half of the company has been left to Theo -her father’s young executive. The two of them have to work together and run the company together for a year before deciding whether or not to sell... which of course, he wants to keep it and she wants to sell.

Overall, I liked the storyline of the travel company which aided both Lexie and Theo's personal growth. But then when you add in grief, Christmas AND complex family dynamics, making the story a romance additionally was too much in my opinion. Lexie was not my favorite FMC but I did enjoy her getting her to connect with her half sister.

This is the first book I have read by Emily Stone, but I am interested to check out her others!

**Thank you to NetGalley and Random House Publishing(Ballantine, Dell) for the ARC and the chance to read and review. All opinions expressed are my own**

Was this review helpful?

🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤
5/5 ♾️

This story will stick with me forever. I just absolutely fell in love with these characters and this story. This is my second Emily Stone book and my goodness, did she serve us a beautifully written holiday book.

First off all, by looking at this cover you wouldn’t know…but the romance & spice in this is SO good. I could feel all the feelings of falling in love. And Theo was such an amazing MMC. I also pictured him as Andrew Garfield, so that also added to my falling in love with this character. With that being said…this book also has a strong storyline. So, I was here for the romance & stayed for the story! Or vice versa. But I LOVE when a book has both. And this really did that for me. The only other author that I feel really delivers in that way is Sarah Adler. So, if you’re a fan of her (I know a lot of my booksta friends & followers like her!), I highly recommend this one to you!!

Things I loved…

🫙 the wish jar was such a magical element. I honestly might take this idea & start a new Christmas tradition with it.

🎄 the different holiday traditions in other parts of the world was such an interesting & marvelous factor!

🇮🇪 I really enjoyed the parts that took place in Ireland

🛏️ ^especially the one bed part (because obviously)

✨ the chemistry between Lexie & Theo was intense right from the start & was depicted so well

🫠 every time Theo called Lexie “Lex”

🪩 the references to Step Up & Save the Last Dance

🍻 the dancing scene at the pub in Ireland

🎶 the song that kept coming up in my mind for this book was….The Bolter. I feel like this is a very Lexie song. And I love that about her….along with everything else. She was an amazing FMC.

❄️ A Winter Wish is out now & I would highly recommend adding it to your winter TBR! While it has Christmas themes in it, this book could be read at any time.

Was this review helpful?