Skip to main content

Member Reviews

I look forward to Stone’s holiday books every year - they are a great mix of heartbreak mixed with unexpected romance. I appreciated Lexi’s grief journey after losing her father, all while working through so many other changes. I loved the concept of his travel company and her role in that. I think there was just a bit too much happening and I was missing the typical charm of her books, especially in the romance department.

BUT, still a great holiday book that veers away from the typical hallmark style plot ❤️ Give it a try!

3.5⭐️

Was this review helpful?

Emily Stone is the crowned queen of Christmas romances with complex emotions. As someone who is no contact with a parent, I felt so seen in the complex emotions had about how Lexie feels about her estrangement from her father. However, I do almost wish that this one had focused solely on Lexie and her journey. The romance portion felt forced and like it lacked a good bit of chemistry. That said, I really enjoyed following their travels.

Was this review helpful?

This was a cute one but I felt like it lacked emotional depth. I did enjoy the relationship that slowly developed with Lexi and Theo and how they went from not standing eachother to more but I wanted it to go deeper, it felt very surface level. Still enjoyed it though!

Was this review helpful?

This was a enemies to lovers story line. I love Emily Stone books for the holidays, this one isn't my favorite. Still a good quick read!

Was this review helpful?

Lexie’s father, Richard, has passed away. They have a tumultuous relationship, but he leaves her and his partner, Theo, a shared portion of his traveling business. A great Christmas read. This is a enemies to lovers trope set in Great Britain and Ireland at Christmas time. A great story! Thanks to NetGalley for the advanced copy.

Was this review helpful?

I requested this book purely because of the author,Emily Stone . I have read some of her previous stories and enjoyed them very much. This book was no different. I adore her holiday-themed novels. A Winter Wish didn’t disappoint—it might even be my new favorite from her. The story explores themes of grief, enemies-to-lovers romance, and estranged family dynamics. Having lost my dad in 2020, I deeply connected with Lexie, and Emily Stone did a remarkable job capturing the complexities and challenges of such relationships. Despite the themes of loss and grief, this book is a quick read with plenty of heart. Thank you NetGalley for an advanced copy of this book!

Was this review helpful?

The perfect book to kick off the holiday season! Emily Stone writes the most fun, cozy holiday reads. This did not disappoint. The characters had substance, the plot was plotting. Overall, enjoyed the read!

Was this review helpful?

I absolutely loved this book! It was a cute, heartwarming and cliche but cute christmas book and I loveeeeed the main characters and flow of the writing.

Was this review helpful?

I really liked the idea of this book - it would have been a super cute “enemies” to lovers romance, but it was missing some key aspects for me that unfortunately has the romance side of the story fall super flat.

I really loved the idea of the travel company, i think there was such a special opportunity to build chemistry and romance between the two characters, but I didn’t feel that at all.

There was 0 tension built and the build up, in my opinion, wasn’t super entertaining. Due to that i didn’t find my self rooting for them, i got to the point where i really didn’t care if they got together or not.

I felt that for a holiday romance, it lacked a lot of holiday aspects / that cozy feeling you get when reading a holiday romance..

It had potential and i loved the FMCs growth, but overall it wasn’t my favorite.

Was this review helpful?

An emotional, fun, read. Lexie hasn’t seen or spoken to her father in many years. He was an amazing connected parent until the day he walked out the door for a new life and new family. She went no contact after years of chronic disappointment. It wasn’t difficult as she figured he barely noticed. After 10 years of nothing, she ignores his calls because why set ones self up for more heartbreak? So to say she is shocked when she learns of his death and what he has left her. A wonderful opportunity that will bring up every emotion she has tamped down and a business partner who is more angry bear than human initially. When she learns of the stipulations she has choices to make. Can she make it work with all of the emotional baggage she is carrying? Does she even want to? Why Theo, who seemingly was like a son to her father while he all, but abandoned her? And why does Theo seem to hate her on sight and is she willing to give up the life she has created for herself? So much to unpack and the author has created an emotional journey for us to join Lexie on. I enjoyed the read and the ending was exactly what I read this genre for.
Uprated to 4 from what would have been a 3.5 rating.

Was this review helpful?

Lexie learns her father passed; they have not spoken in 10 years. Lexie is shocked to learn that her father left her half of his holiday travel company! The other half is owned by Theo. The two of them must learn how to run the company together. Lexie wants to leave after the year is over; however, she learns how this work is fulfilling. Plus, Lexie and Theo go to Spain, where they feel sizzles!

Was this review helpful?

• when she receives half the ownership of her deceased estranged father’s travel company, vagabond lexie is forced to work for the business for one year before selling. and to make matters worse, she has to work alongside a young exec, theo.
• i love a workplace romance, and the travel element of this story worked well for me. even the third act breakup didn’t ruin my enjoyment of the story.
• lexie & theo’s chemistry was really well done, and believable!

Was this review helpful?

I’ve read Emily Stone’s past holiday books and while not favorites, I enjoyed them. For whatever reason, I could not get into A Winter Wish. The characters were not particularly compelling and even when I was 75% in, I still didn’t feel an attachment to them or a curiosity about where their stories were going. This one just wasn’t for me.

Was this review helpful?

While rom coms are my go-to holiday reads, I also love a more emotional holiday-themed story that makes me reflect on family, love, and loss. Emily Stone is my absolute favorite author when it comes to those kinds of reads and her latest novel, A Winter Wish, did not disappoint!

Lexie and her father had been estranged for years, so she doesn’t know how to feel when she learns he has passed away. Her feelings become even more conflicted when she learns he has left her half of his holiday travel agency, a successful niche business that specializes in trips that explore holiday traditions from different cultures around the world. Not only that but he left the other half of the company to Theo, a handsome young executive who worked with her dad for years.

Lexie is not a fan of Theo’s at all, but the terms of the will stipulate that the two of them must run the company together for a year before they can do anything else with it.

As Lexie settles in and starts to learn more about the company and its mission, she realizes that she actually enjoys being a part of it. Not only that, but she realizes that Theo isn’t as bad as she originally thought either. In fact, she actually quite likes him.

As I mentioned, Emily Stone’s books are always on the emotional side so there is a lot of Lexie exploring those conflicting feelings about her dad and trying to make peace with them. Lexie’s emotional journey is beautifully written and made me cry a few times.

I recommend A Winter Wish to anyone who enjoys an emotional, heartwarming holiday story with just a hint of romance.

Was this review helpful?

I love the idea of a wish jar and I love to travel so when I saw the synopsis of this book, I thought I would love it. Lexie inherits half of her estranged father's holiday travel company and throughout the year she gets to go test drive some of the trips? That's my dream!

Although the theme of the book was something I was extremely interested in, I do feel like this fell a little short for me. The timeline jumped around to tell the story over the span of the year and I felt like the parts I was most enjoying or engaged in, were cut short or glanced over and more time was spent in the in-between.

The story was entertaining and I did find myself wanting to see how it ends.

I would definitely recommend to those who love holiday romance!

Was this review helpful?

This was cute! I love the idea of the travel agency- especially one focused on Christmas.

It had more romance than some of Stone’s previous work, which was fun. And I love how she’s able to write about grief- but this wasn’t a huge stand out for me.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Ballantine for the advance reader copy and to Random House Audio for the complimentary audiobook. These opinions are my own.

A Winter Wish features a travel company that organizes trips to learn about culture through holidays and festivals. Does this actually exist? It sounds like my dream travel. And I especially want to start with the described trip to Iceland for Christmas. (who else is planning to celebrate Christmas Eve with Jolabokaflod this year?)

On to the story...
Though this novel starts with the death of a parent, I did not find it a heavy book. Lexie did not have a close relationship with her father, so her journey is one of processing and growth, more than one of grief. She and Theo meet when the both jointly inherit her father's company, and they must make a profit from it.

I found all of the trips and destinations fascinating. In that way, this book was just the transporting escape I have been seeking.

I wasn't as keen on the romance but didn't really feel it was missing. It just didn't feel especially notable to me in light of the more interesting stories of travel and character growth.

Meg Travers narrated the 10 hour audiobook quite well with a variety of accents the covered all the characters.

CW: death of a parent, parental neglect

Was this review helpful?

Charming story of two people who get pushed together due to the circumstances of a will left by Lexie's father. Lexie's relationship with her father was distant since he left the family and then started a new one. Feeling abandoned Lexie's relationship with him and his new family hasn't been exactly warm and fuzzy over the years. When she is summoned to see what is going on with her father's travel company after he passes she discovers Theo has been running the company since he passed. Theo and Lexie need to work together to keep the company afloat for one year or else neither gets what they want. What could go wrong?

I give this 3.75 stars. It was cute with the travel planning aspect, just a little slow to get going.

Was this review helpful?

Your family splits when you are young, and your dad has been fairly absent from your life. You discover that he has died and has left you to run his company - with a few stipulations. What follows is a discovery of self and healing in the most beautiful of ways. While there were portions that were slow developing, the overall story is a hit! Thanks to NetGalley for the read!

Was this review helpful?

to say this book took me by surprise is an understatement.

it was a slow start and i thought the premise felt a little farfetched to start but the things i was skeptical of weren’t the focus of the story as a whole and the story focused so much more on the grief and growth fmc Lexie worked through.

this book was set in europe and follows Lexie who loses her estranged father and inherits his travel company. this book takes you all over europe through Lexie’s experiences.

there was some romance and you grow to love the MMC, there is a touch of christmas but subtle enough that this could be read any time of year.

i just loved Lexie and i think that grief was represented well in this story <3

Was this review helpful?