Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Black Odyssey Media and NetGalley provided an eARC of this book in exchange for an honest review. Opinions expressed here are solely my own.

This was a super cute Black holiday romance story with:
✅ Hot cinnamon roll MMC
✅ Small town setting
✅ Forced proximity
✅ Spicy scenes

The third act made me roll my eyes a little bit, but that’s pretty standard for holiday romances.

Still an enjoyable story that I could totally see as a made for TV movie.

#ANovelChristmas #NetGalley

Was this review helpful?

I love Christmas books with a hallmark feel good feeling and this book gave me all the good hallmark vibes. It was well written and fast pace. Character development was great and I enjoyed every bit of the love story from beginning to end

Was this review helpful?

I am a sucker for Hallmark Christmas movies and this book felt exactly like that, only spicy. It was engaging and well-paced with fun and endearing characters. I enjoyed the setting, Saint Nicholas and I loved that in that small town they had built such an amazing community. All of this was portrayed well on the page, so much so that I had a running film in my head. Dorian was the perfect, imperfect man and I loved him together with Saira. Their chemistry was palpable in the story, you could feel it as you read, which is always amazing. This was a new author to me, but I know I will look for more from her, as I enjoyed the storytelling. I received this ARC from Netgalley for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

"A Novel Christmas" was a truly enjoyable read with just the right mix of romance and heartfelt emotion. The concept of a romance author like Saira finding her muse in a place as festive as Santa Claus, Indiana, and stumbling into her own love story is both charming and engaging. Dorian, known as Mr. December, is a character with depth, and his past scars add layers to the budding relationship. I was cheering for Saira and Dorian as their connection unfolded, despite the whirlwind timeline. The book's portrayal of Dorian's grief is touching yet not overwhelming, striking a good balance that adds to the story's depth. If you're in the mood for a sweet holiday romance that warms your heart this is a good pick!

Was this review helpful?

I just finished "A Novel Christmas" by Charity Shane', and let me tell you, it's the perfect feel-good holiday escape.

The story follows Dorian and Saira, two strangers whose paths cross during the most magical time of year. Can true love really blossom in just a week? This book had me completely invested in their whirlwind romance, rooting for their happily ever after the entire time.

Dorian's journey resonated deeply. Charity Shane' beautifully portrays his internal struggle with grief, making his emotional growth all the more satisfying. Plus, the Christmassy small-town setting practically leaped off the page. I could practically smell the gingerbread and hear the carols while I was reading.

If you're looking for a heartwarming instalove story with the perfect pace to keep you engaged, "A Novel Christmas" is definitely for you. It left me with a warm, fuzzy feeling and a renewed belief in the magic of the season.

Was this review helpful?

***below review was posted on StoryGraph and private Facebook bookclub group****

This book was the perfect combination of sweetness and depth. The way Dorian’s grief was written was relatable without being heart shattering. I rooted for the couple with every page. I love the relationship with Dorian and Crystal. I sometimes shy away from books that are very descriptive however this one was just right. I felt like I was watching a movie. This was my 1st book by this author and I look forward to reading more of their work.

Thank you to the author and NetGalley for this Advance Readers Copy ebook in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

I liked this a lot! Though I don't know how realistic it is to fall in a week, the book was well-written and detailed. I really liked Dorian (Mr. December) and Saira. I loved how their relationship developed. Both of them had some scars- Dorian, more than Saira- but they were able to make it work. I liked the storyline being that Saira was a Black romance author who had lost her spark and needed inspiration. She found it in Santa Claus, Indiana and she got a whole lot more! Getting her own love story was the best inspiration! (P.S. I wouldn't mind a little follow-up story for Crystal and Mike.)

Was this review helpful?

If you're in need of something festive for the upcoming holiday season, A Novel Christmas is the book for you. This was a fast paced holiday romance with a cute plot that felt reminiscent of some Hallmark movies. I also loved the banter between the characters.

Was this review helpful?

This holiday romance by Charity Shane is perfect for a cozy read by the fireplace with a cup of cocoa! The story moves quickly and offers plenty of festive vibes, making it a great pick for the holiday season. The characters are well-developed, and the plot is engaging, although there's room for improvement. While some readers may find the pacing a bit fast, Dorian's charm adds an irresistible allure to the story. With its satisfying length, this book is ideal for reaching your reading goals and getting into the Christmas spirit. Grab it in late November or early December for maximum holiday magic! Thank you for the ARC!

Was this review helpful?

Very fast paced romance - but super cute for the holidays with a cup of cocoa! The characters were complex and the plot was great. Could have been a little better - 3 stars

Was this review helpful?

If you are looking for a great holiday romance, A Novel Christmas by Charity Shane should definitely be on your list! This is a slow burn with some killer Christmas vibes. I loved this book & will read it again closer to the holidays.

Thank you NetGalley & Black Odyssey Media for an ARC copy of this book.

Was this review helpful?

This marks my inaugural dive into holiday romance, and the festive atmosphere truly swept me away. The characters boasted depth, and the storyline was captivating.

Yet, as an aficionado of slow-burning romances, I found the pacing a tad brisk for my taste. While the writing style didn't quite align with my preferences, Dorian's charm managed to overshadow any reservations.

Clocking in at a satisfying length, this book is ideal for padding your reading goal and serves as a delightful prelude to the holiday season. Consider picking it up in late November or early December to bask in its Christmas magic.

Was this review helpful?

This is the first holiday romance I’ve ever read and the Christmas vibes were amazing. The characters were complex and the plot was great.

However I love a slow burn so this book moved way too fast for me. The writing style wasn’t my cup of tea but for Dorian, I overlooked it :)

This book is a great length to bump up your read goal and would be great to read late November/early December to get you into the Christmas spirit.

Read Time ⏱️ 2.5 hours

Was this review helpful?

Thanks so much to Black Odyssey and NetGalley for this ARC.

I absolutely loved this story. The setting was the perfect backdrop for this holiday romance. Saira and Dorian’s meet and fall for each other was beautiful to witness. Their banter and interactions were so sensual yet cute. I loved it.

This was a great read!

Was this review helpful?

Saira es escritora, tiene que entregar inmediatamente un libro con la tematica navideña, pero no está inspirada, entonces decide ir a un pueblo navideño y ahí conoce a Dorian e inmediatamente se siente atraída por él.

Dorian es bombero, viudo, se mudó al pueblo Santa Claus porque ahí creció su ex esposa, no cree que se pueda volver a enamorar porque sigue amando a su esposa, pero cuando conoce a Saira le hace dudar se su convicción.



Thanks to NetGalley, the publisher and the author for the ARC in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

So excited for this beautiful Christmas novel. It’s so nice to see someone not Christmas/Holiday crazy find her holiday spirit. I also love the element of the handsome firefighter and funding love again after the loss of his wife.

Was this review helpful?