Skip to main content

Member Reviews

3.5 stars.
Sixteen-year-old Jun has one dream: to win the elite Guardian's Tournament so that he can become the new Guardian, or protector, of the Eastern part of Longhan. Jun wants this not just for himself, but also so that his father's name and honour can be restored. A mistake by Jun's father many years earlier, cost the family: he had been training his twin boys in martial arts, something the non-breathmarked are not allowed to learn. Breathmarked individuals have a patch of dragon scales on them, as well as powerful abilities. Jun's identical twin Sai is breathmarked, and when a pair of Aspects (elite government servants) arrive one day at the family home, they take Sai, and the boys' mother, away with them so that Sai may train and hone his abilities. Jun and his father lose not only half their family, but their father is censured, and now works at an opera house as a labourer and performing in bit parts, after he and Jun were forcibly sent to the West.

Jun is determined to change his and his father's fortunes, and has joined the Iron Core school of martial arts, working tremendously hard to qualify as the House’s representative in the upcoming competition for the new Guardian. There is one boy who is a little better than he is, Yin Yue, who will be entering the upcoming Guardian competition. Ever determined, Jun hides on the wagon of the flautist Chang and his actor adopted daughter Ren, who have worked at the opera house, and are headed for the city set for the competition. Along the way, he comes to learn there is much more to Chang, and Ren.

Once at the competition, everyone is caught unaware when the head General of the East has decided to change the rules, endangering all the contestants. The General wants to take war to the West, and hopes to use the new Guardian in his plans, which, the more Jun thinks on things, he comes to realize just how conflicted he is about his loyalties, and how against war he is.

The plot moves along well, with many instances of well-conceived depictions hand-to-hand combat. I expected no less from these two authors, considering their knowledge of martial arts, and Fonda Lee's Green Bone Saga. What was actually more interesting in this story was Jun's evolution from totally self-absorbed, selfish young person, to someone who, through the multiple setbacks and betrayals, comes to realize that there are more important things than winning a competition. Bigotry-fueled war is on the horizon, with much suffering. Jun matures to the point that he begins to appreciate others, and thinking of their welfare. He also finally makes friends with people who previous saw solely as rivals, another positive development for the very talented martial artist.

I mostly listened to this book, and liked voice actor Eric Yang's work. Jun's arrogance was apparent, while Chang's humour comes through nicely. I liked his interpretations of Yin Yue and Ren, Jun's friends.

I am interested to see where Jun and his allies go next, and how they tackle the seemingly insurmountable odds against them.

Thank you to Netgalley, St. Martin's Press and Macmillan Audio for these ARCs in exchange for my review.

Was this review helpful?

“The abilities that matter the most don’t come from Dragon’s blood. They’re gained day by day, through sweat and tears.”

3.5 out of 5 stars (3.5 / 5) When young, Jun and his twin are separated and each given to one parent. All Jun wants is to be reunited with his brother and mother that are now on opposing sides of the country. The only joy he finds is warrior training but his father forbids it as that was the reason they were split. His brother is also breathmarked which means a small spot of dragon scales are on the skin of these chosen ones and they are given special abilities.

A competition happens every six years where people fight for the right to be Guardian and in charge of sacred scrolls. Even without being breathmarked, Jun runs away and enters but learns quickly he is in over his head. What he once thought was most important isn’t even relevant in hindsight.

While the story and characters were interesting, the lack of connection to them made me feel detached. The fighting scenes dominated the pages which was interesting, but became less so as the story moved on. I did love the fighting, how can you not when Bruce Lee helps to write them? And I think many will agree. The world building was unique and found so many aspects I liked but I believe more POV and possibly more info on the brother and mom would have kept me interested more.

This is a great story if you love Asian Literature with striving warriors and lots of fight scenes!

Thank you to Wednesday Books for the copy!

The book releases January 7, 2025.

Was this review helpful?

First, I'd like to say thank you to the authors, publisher, and Net Galley for the review copy of this book.

I think the book had great promise, and it is a pretty solid YA book. Younger readers and readers not familiar with some classic fantasy tropes will love this.

Ultimately though, this book was not for me. I found it predictable from the start. Every single event and plot point seemed like they were there to just check off a list, if that makes sense. Not a single thing surprised me. I also really strongly feel that the book should have ended several chapters sooner than it did. Those last several chapters seemed to drag on a good bit, and while necessary to the story, I think they would have been better suited at the beginning of book 2, instead of the ending of book 1. (For the sake of pacing)

Again though, I think it had great promise, and that younger readers not familiar with classic fantasy tropes might really enjoy this.

Was this review helpful?

Solid YA perfect for younger readers who love martial arts and a tournament setting. Filled with found family.
the worldbuilding is easily the strongest aspect of this book - it's a fully realized world,
if you enjoy Fonda Lee's work or are interested in a new martial arts fantasy series, this is a good option

Was this review helpful?

Book review: 3.75/5 ⭐️
Genre: YA fiction
Themes: martial arts, chi, government control
📖 Read if you like: The Legendary Mo Seto

Born to a land ripped into two, Jun is separated from his other half in a tragic event of childish showmanship. In the East, only those breathmarked by the dragon with scales of power can practice martial arts. Sai is one such child and was taken for it. In the West, anyone may study, but this utopia is riddled with corruption and fear. It is here Jun and his father are abandoned to after that fateful day.

In the shadow of his gifted twin Sai, 16-year old Jun is determined to enter and win the Guardian’s tournament and finally prove his worth. Disobeying his loving father, he hides away in the cart of a travelling blind man and his performing daughter Ren. Yet this blind man is himself a skillful fighter with the ability to harness and use breath. Taking the long way to the capitol, Jun discovers that Ren and Sifu Chang have abilities and perhaps motives beyond performing.

As Jun finally makes it to the tournament, he begins to realize he is fighting for more than just the honours of becoming Guardian of the Scroll of Heaven. With the East and West on the brink of war and a vengeful general at the helm, tensions in the city are running high. When some last minute changes are made to the tournament, it turns into a savage bloodbath where more than pride can be lost. Add in a rebel group advocating for peaceful reunification and things finally boil over.

A story of finding purpose, strength and honour in the face of adversity, it reminded me of classic anime. Jun may be a braggart and overly brash, but his heart is in the right place and he shows up when it matters most. Forced into early maturity, he truly learns what it means to be a Guardian when all hope it lost. An eventful coming of age story amidst a brewing civil war with magic, martial arts, and politics. It definitely reads YA with a youthful perspective, but I enjoyed this high octane tournament of skills and intrigue.

Will be keeping my eyes peeled for part two of this duology! Thank you to NetGalley and Wednesday Books for an advanced copy of this book.

Was this review helpful?

I requested this book for Fonda Lee and just as expected, it was great!
This world is divided in two, the East and West. The West thrives on martial arts while the East bans it for its normal citizens. There are people who are born with “Dragon’s Breath”, a mark from their Dragon that gives them a talent or power. When a family in the East with twins doesn’t register the children to the government, the child who has a mark is taken while the other child is banned to the West because he participates in martial arts. The twin in the west, Jun, wishes to participate in a tournament that makes the champion the Guardian of the Dragon Scroll. The story goes from there.
I really like the characters in this book, the magic is very interesting as well as the politics. I feel my only gripe is the pacing. Some places it dragged, some were too short. I do like how the ending sets up the next book, I hope it continues strong.

Was this review helpful?

Although, I did not feel Bruce Lee in this story. But I did love it in its entirety. The story of a boy who knows he is the one, destine to be better, to be something, yet loosing everything in a process and humbling him big time. The story had something form hero's journey and I think, at the end, this is what made this so good. Delivery was a little clunky at times - I didn't like change of language at the last part of the book. It was quite jarring to see how vulgarisms were introduced pout of nowhere. The consistency with this was broken. Yet, at the same time, I had grand time and I'll recommend this book to anyone who likes the vibe of martial arts, Dragon Ball, and Naruto all in one.

Was this review helpful?

Li Jun dreams of entering the prestigious Guardian’s Tournament, which is held once every six years to choose a new Guardian to protect the magical Scroll of Earth. Though only sixteen, Jun is eager to prove himself against the best fighters in the kingdom and restore his family’s honour, correcting a mistake that caused him and his father to be banished from their home, separated from his mother and brother. But his father forbids him to participate – as he is not breathmarked like his twin and blessed with any special ability, there would be no use in him training to be a warrior. Jun is determined nonetheless and runs away to compete, but this year’s Tournament is more deadly than ever and there is much more at stake than he realizes.

First review of 2025! Breath of the Dragon wasn’t on my radar initially, but I looked it up when I was offered the arc and I knew I had to read it. I had never read a martial arts based fantasy novel before and this sounded absolutely fascinating.

Books set around competitions or tournaments is a trope I’m really coming to enjoy as it has a way of making the plot way more engaging and focused. I loved that this was set against a more complex backdrop politics and war – it added another layer to the plot and made things less straightforward for the protagonist.

I know literally nothing about martial arts of any kind, but I still found this to be such an intriguing read, especially the training and fighting scenes. It was written in a way that I could make some sense of it despite having no background knowledge.

I did have to suspend disbelief a little to let myself enjoy this book – it was hard to believe that a sixteen year old boy was better than all the seasoned fighters in the country, but I guess since he was the protagonist of the story it had to work out this way.

I found the pacing to be a little uneven. The first half of the book dragged a lot in my opinion and there was too much time spent on explaining Jun’s life in Cheon and then his journey to the capital (and all the training montages within). A couple of chapters really would have been sufficient to cover all this, allowing more time for the tournament itself. Once the tournament began, the pacing was perfect and it was a thoroughly engaging read.

The other thing I noticed about this narrative is while the target audience would seem to be YA based on the writing style and characters, other aspects felt more fitting to an older audience – particularly the tournament matches which featured a level of violence I’ve rarely come across in YA before.

Jun was a typical teen protagonist, impulsive, self centered, and quite naive on top of it all – but his character arc was really well done, and that made him likeable. As the plot progressed, he learned to stop and think about the consequences of his actions, and take in what was happening around him.

The secondary characters of Ren, Yin Yue and Sifu Chang were excellent. Despite them not having POV chapters, we got to hear a lot of their backstories and motivations which made their characters memorable.

I was wondering if Jun’s brother would make an appearance in this book at all, and he didn’t, but it does seem like he will in the sequel. It’ll be fun if a second POV is added for him.

Maybe I’m just getting too accustomed to YA writing, because though that ending was a shocking one, I wasn’t personally that surprised at all. The twist was something I was waiting for – though the last minute reveal of some characters was definitely unexpected. That said, the authors did a wonderful job of building up the tension throughout the tournament and through the plot twist, setting the stage for what should be a very interesting sequel.

Overall, this was a fun read with a unique concept. I really enjoyed Breath of the Dragon, and I would recommend it to YA fans. Myself, I’m not 100% sure if I’ll be picking up the sequel – it was a great read, but some parts just read like younger YA and a little predictable at times too, so I’ll probably wait to look at reviews whenever it’s out.

Was this review helpful?

Breath of the Dragon is a fantastic start to the duology by Fonda Lee and Shannon Lee. For me, the world-building in this story was the highlight. Although I don't know much about martial arts or have a great desire to learn more, I still found the storyline fascinating and can’t wait to read the second book.

Jun is exiled with his father after the Aspects come to recruit his twin brother, Sai, because he is breathmarked, which makes him special. During the Aspects' visit, Jun makes a terrible mistake, resulting in both him and his father being exiled from the country. At 16, he aspires to compete in the Guardian's Tournament to become the best martial artist in the country. Defying his father’s wishes, he sets out for the tournament with Mr. Chang and Ren. He soon discovers that this tournament is about more than just achieving martial arts excellence. Can he win it all and help avert the impending war?

I enjoyed the tournament aspect of the book, even though some matches felt rushed and were quite graphic. My favorite part of the story was definitely the theme of found family, and I can’t wait to read more about them.

Was this review helpful?

I wanted to like this more than I did cause the concept was interesting and the world-building was very well thought out. I just didn’t connect to the characters and I think this was a case of the right book wrong time for me personally.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley, St. Martin’s Press/Wednesday Books, and Shannon Lee and Fonda Lee for an e-arc of Breath of the Dragon in exchange for an honest review. All thoughts and opinions are my own.

This was so much fun. The world building was so well executed and one thing you can always count on is a fantastic action scene from Fonda Lee. A lot of times, with fighting that relies heavily on martial arts, it’s hard to follow what’s supposed to be happening. But with Breath of the Dragon, it felt like I was right there watching them play out.

I love the collaboration between these two and I cannot wait to see where the story goes.

Was this review helpful?

"Marked or not, every one of us has Breath enough to will our own destiny into being.” - dang, this line hit.

I was so excited for this book because I am obsessed with The Green Bone Saga and I mean who doesn't love a tournament? However this story fell a little short for me. The pace was too slow for my liking and I found myself having to push through to finish the first half of the book. Once we got to the 50% mark of the story, it started picking up. We get to see the development of our characters and that was probably my favorite part of the story. I'm not sure if I'd pick up the second book immediately as I felt like I've read many books quite similar to this one.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you so much to Netgalley and the publisher for letting me read and review this book! All I needed to read was "The first novel in a sweeping YA fantasy duology based on characters and teachings created by Bruce Lee!" to know that I wanted to pick this up. I haven't read any books by Fonda or Shannon Lee before, but I am glad I did. I can't wait to read more by them soon, especially by Fonda Lee.

This was a fun ya fantasy book that has good fighting scenes, characters, and political intrigue. Breath of the Dragon is definitely a love to Asian action films. If you enjoy fantasy books and Asian action films, and Bruce Lee, you should definitely pick this up. Also, the cover and the writing style is stunning. I am excited for the next book and hope it comes out in the next couple years. However, I want to learn more about the characters more, and their relationships in the next book. That was the only thing in this book that was lacking a little bit.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to netgalley and the publisher for this e-ARC in exchange for an honest review!
4 stars

I honestly really enjoyed this book. The writing could be a bit distant and on-the-nose/telly at spots, but it wasn't bad. It made for an easy read that just kept moving.

Overall, this book is such a love letter to Asian action flicks while being a very solid YA High Fantasy book. The fight scenes were very clean and concise with a clear show of martial arts knowledge, and the magic system shows a lot of influence from both martial arts practices and Asian culture. Also, anyone who wants to claim books aren't political should avoid this book, because there's definitely a lot of fantasy politics that are woven in nicely while still leaning into the martial arts aspect.

I'm super excited for the next book. There were so many sprinklings in this book that I want to see come full circle (primarily Jun and his family), and I want to see how Jun continues to develop, especially considering the environment he's going to be in after the end of this book.

If you like high fantasy and you like Asian action movies, or even action anime, I highly recommend this book. Even if the writing wasn't always for me, the plot and world itself was just *chef's kiss* Right up my alley, truly.

Was this review helpful?

I wanted to love this book but it fell flat. It was hard to really visualize the world, and the main character just wasn't that memorable. Overall it felt very tedious to get through

Was this review helpful?

Another fantastic fantasy novel from Fonda Lee—this time with Shannon Lee—based on characters created by Shannon Lee’s father, Bruce Lee. The world-building and magic in this book were top-notch. Even in such a short span, they crafted a world that felt rich, immersive, and complex.

As expected from Fonda Lee, the fight scenes were expertly done. I usually struggle to visualize action sequences and tend to check out, but with her writing, I can see every move so clearly, and I’m completely invested in the fight itself.

The plot follows a familiar YA fantasy structure, so it doesn’t break new ground, but it was still engaging. My only real gripe—and the reason this didn’t get a full five stars—is that I wanted more depth in the character relationships. Most of them felt a bit straightforward (mentor/mentee, school rivals, crush), and a little extra complexity would have taken this book to the next level.

Was this review helpful?

This was a fun journey. It's the exactly the type of story I'm looking for when I think of YA. The plot being based around honor amd the martial arts aspects kept reminding me of avatar the last air bender and I loved it so much. It took be back to my childhood.

Was this review helpful?

I am so obsessed with Fonda Lee's writing and storytelling and this book left me captivated from beginning to end. Gorgeous world building, compelling action scenes and excellent characters!

Was this review helpful?

Unfortunately I think this one wasn't for me because of the main character. I just found it very difficult to get into his head and understand him but that was probably a personal issue. The writing was beautiful which I loved and I liked the plotline.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for providing this eARC.

The first installment in the Breathmarked duology, Breath of the Dragon follows teen Jun who enters a tournament to prove his skills, restore his father's honor, and hopefully reunite him with his mother and twin brother.

This was such a fun read! I love a good tournament, and it was interesting and honestly refreshing to see a story unfold almost entirely at a tournament. While I wouldn't argue that this reinvented the genre, I did adore the attention to detail in the fight scenes, and found the world and our lead character to be remarkably interesting and compelling. The pacing was also impeccable, at least for me. I never felt rushed, but things were never slow enough for me to become disinterested. Sure, this was a pretty teen read, but YA should feel teen, and there's a lot set up that I think will be a lot of fun to read in the sequel. I'll certainly be reaching for it as soon as it hits shelves!

Was this review helpful?