When I read the description for this book I knew it was one that I would have to read. I had so many questions: What did Rose see? Why can’t/won’t she talk about it? Was the nanny suicidal? Was she pushed/killed? Who did it and why? Nothing like a good who done it. Highly recommended!!

Thank you to the author and NetGalley for gifting me this book in exchange for my honest review

I switched between Audio and E on this and I really enjoyed both. I loved the dynamic between the characters. I found it difficult to trust them all and did not like what they had to say (or did not have to say) through most of the book. There were creepy and chilling scenes that definitely had me on the edge of my seat. I figured out the ending pretty quickly, but it did not stop me from enjoying how the book played out. I liked the story line - a nanny falls (or is pushed) from a window and dies. The child she is watching becomes mute from the trauma. A lawyer is assigned to figure out which parent should have custody in their divorce. The Grandma was with the child when the Nanny died. The lawyer has her own traumatic past, which adds to the drama of the book. Overall, this was really well done and enjoyable.

Thank you Netgalley for my advanced reader copies.

This story focuses on Rose Barclay, a nine-year-old child who has witnessed the murder of her nanny Tina. Tina is found on the ground outside of the Barclay home after being pushed out of a glass window of the house. We soon discover that Tina was pregnant and was having an affair with Rose's father Ian Barclay. Meanwhile Ian Barclay and his wife Beth Barclay are going through a divorce, and they both want custody of their daughter Rose.
Stelly Hudson, a family court attorney is requested by the court to help the court decide which parent should receive full custody of nine-year-old Rose. Stella soon discovers that Rose has not spoken since the murder of her nanny Tina. She has gone mute, and she seems to have a number of secrets she is trying to keep hidden. Stella who is a survivor of trauma, and who has also experienced not speaking for months after the death of her mother at a young age. While helping Rose and trying to get her to open up to her Stella begins to revisit her own trauma. There's a lot going on in this book, but the main objective is to figure out the mystery of who pushed the nanny out of the glass window. Who did it?
Since the murder, Beth Barclay has ordered that all the glass has be removed from the house, and the house has become plastic. Glass windows are replaced with plastic, and all glass items are replaced. As Stella gets closer to figuring out who may have pushed the nanny out of the window, she must also keep the murderer from killing her too.
If you like a good mystery thriller where you look for clues to see who killed the nanny in the Barclay house.
I want to thank Net Galley, Macmillian audio and St. Martin's press for the opportunity to listen to the audio. I highly recommend this thriller.

Sarah Pekkanen continues to deliver in a manner that solidifies her place on my list of “must read” authors. She’s earned another gold medal in ‘House of Glass’ with this 4.5 star read I’m bumping up to 5 stars.

Enthralling, thrilling, and smart I was immediately invested in the story of a young girl, Rose, who tragically witnessed the death of her nanny who fell through a window in the family home, landing on the backyard patio in front of her. Due to this life changing event, Rose is experiencing trauma based mutism. To make things even more challenging, Rose’s parents are going through a divorce in light of the news that Rose’s father had an affair with the nanny. With both parents fighting custody, outside mediation is needed.

Stella Hudson is brought on as a BIA, Best Interest Attorney, to determine what is best for the child. In order to make this determination, she needs to speak with and spend time with the entire family, including Rose, who currently isn’t speaking. Stella’s mentor, Charles, is the one who brought the case to Stella and suggested she take it due to what she experienced as a young girl, causing trauma based mutism in her as well.

The more time Stella spends with the family, the more she questions what really happened to the nanny; people don’t usually just fall through windows on the upper level of a house. If Rose’s mom or dad was involved in the death, it would greatly impact Stella’s decision of who should be granted custody of Rose.

But when Stella sees Rose picking up a shard of glass to put in her pocket, she begins to think the unthinkable. Maybe Rose grew angry with her nanny sleeping with her father, resulting in the final straw in her parents already strained marriage, leading to their divorce. Then Stella realizes all of the glass in the house, including family photos and mugs in the kitchen, have all been replaced with plastic. What has this family done? Who is guilty? And is the family protecting Rose or are they afraid of her?

Again, this was brilliantly told from start to finish! I always look forward to a thriller from Sarah Pekkanen and recommend this to all thriller lovers! This released August 6th so make sure to secure your copy!

Thank you to NetGalley, Sarah Pekkanen, St. Martin’s Press, and Macmillan Audio for the opportunity to both read then listen to this in exchange for honest feedback. The audiobook narrator did a marvelous job bringing the story and characters to life!

I couldn't put this one down! It kept me guessing until the end. The narrator is fantastic. I will be definitely recommend this to fans of Ruth Ware and Lucy Foley. As a long time NW DC and MD resident, it was fun to see how well the author placed her setting and I definitely recognized some places.

I liked this book but didn't love it. It just didn't WOW me like her other books have. But it was still good. I did find it easy to figure out. I was spot on correct in who did what and why... But it was still very good. This author always delivers good books.

The narrator of this one was not as good as I had hoped. She did good but some words she just dragged out a bit to much. Still she did ok and I enjoyed listening.

This is a story about a little girl. In a way it's about two little girls.

Rose who lives in a big house with everything she wants. Possibly not everything she needs though. Her parents are getting a divorce. Her grandma is crippled in a way. Walks with a cane and seems to be crazy about Rose. There is a dead nanny and Rose saw her fall. Rose can't talk, she is mute due to the trauma. She actually loved her nanny.

Stella who is working with the the lawyers to determine who Rose should live with. Stella found her own mother dead when she was just a child and also became mute after. She feels a connection to Rose. She wants more than anything to save her. To protect her. But she is also a bit afraid of Rose.

The house Rose lives in has absolutely no glass anywhere in it. Not the windows, cabinets, no mirrors. Nowhere. Not even the picture frames. Seems Rose might like to collect broken shards of glass.

This story is very good. Very well written and will keep you guessing. Mostly. I did figure out who did what and why. In two parts I figured out the motives. That didn't really take away from the story though. The characters were fairly likable. After you get to know them that is. What took away from this story for me was feelings. I just had no feelings when reading it. No tears, laughter, happiness. Nothing. But again I did like it.

Thank you #NetGalley, #SarahPekkanen, #StMartinsPress, for this ARC. This is my own true thoughts about this book.

4/5 stars.

What happened to Tina, the nanny? We have the cheating husband Ian, sus mother Beth, also sus grandmother Harriet who has a seemingly tight relationship with our young, smart, sneaky, trauma induced mute 9 year child Rose. Stella who has her past traumas as well, is tasked to assess Rose on her future wellbeing.

this mystery thriller has me guessing from the beginning, thinking I knew the who from the beginning, but that wasn’t the case in the end. I always say there’s something about thrillers with creepy little kids, and Rose was just that. I’ve read one other book by SP and she knows how to bring the creepy, suspenseful, twisty mystery thrillers! I’ll just say don’t focus on one thing because those twists will catch you off guard!

The audiobook was also amazing! New to me narrator Laura Benanti brought the thrill factor throughout the story with each character as well. She was a great narrator! She definitely left me wanting to continue to listening nonstop!

As a best interest attorney, Stella is accustomed to working with teenage clients. But her beloved mentor has asked her to take on the case of nine year old Rose Barclay because he believes Stella's own past trauma makes her the best advocate Rose could hope for. Rose's nanny recently died under suspicious circumstances, and Rose has been unable to speak since. Stella suffered from traumatic mutism as a child as well.

But as Stella begins to spend time with Rose and her family at their beautiful mansion, she begins to feel like perhaps she has more in common with the deceased nanny, Tina, than with Rose. Just like Tina experienced strange goings-on at the house, Stella is likewise having uncomfortable encounters. Encounters that make her wonder whether Rose is a victim or the perpetrator.

Pekkanen masterfully weaves a tale of suspense, skillfully manipulating tropes and reader expectations to create a labyrinth of red herrings. The isolated, imposing mansion with its absence of any glass items serves as a chilling backdrop for Stella's investigation. Perhaps a few too many extraneous characters were introduced, but overall I thought the author did a good job balancing Stella's professional and personal investigations.

The narrator's performance was exceptional, bringing the characters to life with distinct voices. While one accent might have been overemphasized, it didn't detract significantly from the overall listening experience.

If you're looking for one last beach read mystery/thriller too end the summer on, House of Glass is a great pick for your beach bag.

This review will be posted to Goodreads on August 3, 2024 and to Instagram (@goodquietkitty) on August 5, 2024.

This book was 👩🏽‍🍳💋everything I want in a thriller and more❤️ Very psychologically thrilling and had me shocked multiple times!!! The similarities/mirrors between Stella’s past and Rose’s present were done impeccably and I loved the tie in!!

Here are the vibes:
✨A wealthy multi-generational family living under one roof
✨An affair with the nanny
✨Suspicious death of said nanny
✨Divorce with a child custody battle
✨A Best Interest Lawyer with a past
✨A now mute (possibly homicidal) creepy child
✨…AND MUCH MUCH MORE

This was soooo fun to read and super exciting that I can only imagine how cool and thrilling the audiobook would be!

Definitely look out for this one when it comes out!!!

⭐️HOUSE OF GLASS, comes out AUGUST 6TH⭐️

5.0⭐️

Special thanks to NetGalley and St. Martin’s Press for a review copy of this book in exchange for my honest review❤️

I LOVED this book so much! I was so sad when it ended. Sarah Pekkanen is a master of suspense and thrills! The characters are so well written and established in the story. I found myself changing loyalty to each character as they were explored as potential perpetrators of the nanny's death. Rose in particular drew my interest. She is so complex even in her mutism. Stella is so thorough in her investigation. I couldn't believe the twists and turns that I went on through this book. I will defiinitely be reading more from Pekkanen!

Laura Benanti is by far one of my favorite narrators. I have listened to several of her audiobooks, and this one is one of the best! I felt immersed in the story as she told it from Stella's point of view. I was trying to guess, along with Stella, what the heck was going on in the Barclay house. The parts of the story where she read the emails and reports being written got a little choppy, but I think an expected translation from print to audiobook. This is a great story and Laura did not disappoint!

House of Glass is a dark and twisty psychological thriller that centers around the mysterious death of a nanny and the impact of this death on Rose, the young child she was caring for.

The story is told from the perspective of Stella Hudson, an attorney who has been assigned to Rose’s case. Rose’s parents are getting divorced and it’s Stella’s job to determine what the custody arrangement should be. Rose has been mute since the nanny’s death, which makes the case all the more challenging, and Stella realizes just how unusual this case is when she observes Rose picking up a dagger-like shard of glass off the sidewalk and hiding it in her pocket. Stella can’t fathom why Rose would want such a thing and it really kicks her investigation up a notch as she tries to figure out what is going on in Rose’s home life. Since the nanny’s murder remains unsolved, Stella feels like it’s her job to make sure she isn’t potentially assigning custody of this child over to a murderer. The more Stella observes this family and digs into what really happened to the nanny, the more disturbing and downright chilling the story gets.

I love a good psychological thriller especially when there’s family drama as well. I was hooked from the moment Rose reached for the shard of glass and when Stella goes to Rose’s house and sees that there is no glass whatsoever in the entire house. 😱

Pekkanen’s writing is fantastic, with vivid descriptions that deliver the creepiest of vibes at times. There are also plenty of twists and turns that kept me guessing what really happened all the way to the end and Stella is battling some personal demons of her own that really help to flesh out her character and add additional layers to the story.

I also thoroughly enjoyed listening to the audiobook, which was narrated by Laura Benanti. I’ve always loved Benanti on Broadway but didn’t realize she also narrated audiobooks so that was a real treat.

Unfortunately, after making it to 50%, I have no desire to continue. I usually love Sarah's books, but this one just isn't working for me at all. I was fully invested in the beginning, but now I am dreading picking it up. The narrator did a fantastic job with what I listened to.

I do have several friends that I think will like this, so I won't hesitate to recommend it. It just didn't work for me.

Ghoul Von Horror's Reviews > House of Glass

House of Glass
by 

Sarah Pekkanen (Goodreads Author)


Ghoul Von Horror's review

Aug 02, 2024  ·  edit


did not like it

bookshelves: 1-star-hated-it, audio-book, forgettable, gay, netgalley, not-worth-the-hype, read-books-2023, started-great-ended-meh, thriller-s


TW/CW: Language, divorce, gory scenes, death of parent, drug addiction, alcoholism, toxic parent relationship, drug overdose, cheating, anxiety, depression, grieving, drunk driving

*****SPOILERS*****
About the book:
Rose Barclay is a nine-year-old girl who witnessed the possible murder of her nanny - in the midst of her parent's bitter divorce - and immediately stopped speaking. Stella Hudson is a best interest attorney, appointed to serve as counsel for children in custody cases. She never accepts clients under thirteen due to her own traumatic childhood, but Stella's mentor, a revered judge, believes Stella is the only one who can help.

From the moment Stella passes through the iron security gate and steps into the gilded, historic DC home of the Barclays, she realizes the case is even more twisted, and the Barclay family far more troubled, than she feared. And there's something eerie about the house itself: It's a plastic house, with not a single bit of glass to be found.

As Stella comes closer to uncovering the secrets the Barclays are desperate to hide, danger wraps around her like a shroud, and her past and present are set on a collision course in ways she never expected. Everyone is a suspect in the nanny's murder. The mother, the father, the grandmother, the nanny's boyfriend. Even Rose. Is the person Stella's supposed to protect the one she may need protection from?
Release Date: August 6th, 2024
Genre: Thriller
Pages: 352
Rating: ⭐

What I Liked:
1. Always enjoy this writers writing style

What I Didn't Like:
1. Repetitive
2. Book feels like it lost focus
3. Too many plotlines
4. Ridiculous story

Overall Thoughts:
{{Disclaimer: I write my review as I read}}

I love the relationship between her and her ex. So cordial and polite during the divorce.

I really thought the briefcase was going to go differently, like she stole the briefcase and there was money in it.

Stella's mom dies in the usual way that thrillers kill off their drug addiction parents. This is the 3rd book I've read that it's happened like that.

Gosh I hope this isn't like one of those things where Rose is the one that killed Tina and the grandma is protecting her.

Do I understand the situation right that Stella took Rose to go look at these baby squirrels and then her friend calls her to tell her a box cutter is missing, but Stella doesn't go back to the house to see if Rose has the box cutter. I mean wouldn't Stella be the one responsible since she took her out of the house that she got a box cutter. I don't know dude why wouldn't you go back and make sure that she didn't have it she's only 9 years old it would be weird for her to steal one. Stella hears the news that the box cutter is missing and she dismisses it and we move on.

Typical woman in a thriller - - living on a few cookies and a half beer. I love that all women in thrillers barely eat anything but men are never mentioned about how little they eat.

There's no way it's not Harriet. Harriet mentions that her husband had cheated on her many times and then Ian had mentioned that his father had died but after Harriet mentions that women know what a man stepping out and women aren't going to put up with it anymore says "I've been there. Trust me we women don't get fooled twice" so I'm wondering if she murdered her husband because he was cheating. I think she killed Tina because she overheard her on the phone talking about being pregnant and she didn't want the family to break up since she loves Beth so much

Another mention to Stella not being hungry when she puts bread in the toaster. Why?

Okay so now Lucinda's squirrels have been killed. Stella is approached by her and decides to call the phone number but it's blocked so I'm just like why can't you start 69 it and see what happens. Like yeah your phone number is blocked but the other number won't be blocked cuz it's a private number. Or you could call back from Lucinda's number. Also Stella says that Rose is the only one that knows about Lucinda and that's not even true because she had to let Rose's parents know where she was taking her so three people know (Ian, Beth, and Harriet).

By page 280 suddenly Stella is starting an attraction to the Detective Garcia. Why? Where is this book going? It's so all over the place. Ah.

Charles was Stella's mother's lawyer and and they used to use together because he used to do heroin too but he didn't get addicted. She called him the day that she was feeling down which is the day that she died and as he was comforting her he tried to kiss her but her mother said no because she missed her husband too much. In the end of all this Stella's mother ended up dying of a drug overdose like it was rolled. No mystery! This was completely unnecessary! I am so glad that we broke from the mystery of the little girls a killer or not to jump into did Stella's mother die of some other cause. Oh and Charles was the one to take care of her financially.

Honest to God I am so confused by what's happening in this book. For almost all the book Stella was convinced that Rose was like dangerous and killing people and everything suddenly it changes after she gets a phone call from Harriet saying that they're going to cancel the divorce and they're just going to live separately but on the same property and Rose is just going to stay with them and she's going to home school her. Now Rose is this victim she has to go rescue from these villainous people try to drug her. Can't build up that Rose is this like murderous child who killed her babysitter to now she's this innocent child who's being drugged up and she's the victim.

Harriet has a bad knee and difficulty walking, but threatens Stella with a taser gun saying if she shoots her she'll pee herself or Harriet will have to drag her into the elevator after she's collapsed. I'd love to see that. If my options were that peeing myself or collapsing, I'd take the option of being shot over willingly riding an elevator upstairs to my death. How ridiculous. Like Harriet can drag a person into the elevator.

Weirdly enough though Rose does have the phone - the phone that was Tina's that disappeared the night she died.

Omg omg it's just a taser! I seriously don't know why she's scared of a taser and a woman that's almost 30 years older than her. She was just faking her leg being hurt.

Like It isn't enough to learn more and more about this book but the last few pages we now find out that Charles was the one that that caused Stella's dad's death. Any normal person would question how this person was around when two people died. Ludicrous.

So I guess Stella is now dating Garcia. So completely out of left field.

No Garcia Stella is not a puzzle. She is the most generic person to ever breathe.

Final Thoughts:
This book feels very disjointed. On one hand we have the story of this murder of Tina, the housemaid and maybe a girl who murdered her. Randomly 60% into the book we jump into now we're trying to solve what happened to Stella's mother even having flashbacks to when she was a little girl. I don't understand why. It seems all over the place. Can we just solve one thing before we jump into another mystery? I swear this is my problem with most modern thrillers is that we can't keep focus on what the book is about. Why do we have to have eight different story lines in one 300 page book?

No joke though if I wouldn't have finished this book then I wouldn't have been mad or felt like I missed anything. It was so mid and basic. I spent too many times rolling my eyes when reading.

IG | Blog

Thanks to Netgalley, St Martin's Press, and Macmillan Audio for this advanced copy of the book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.

Childhood trauma is inevitable, though its impact varies for each individual. Stella Hudson's trauma, stemming from losing her mother to drug addiction, has led her to a career as an attorney specializing in child advocacy. Her latest case involves nine-year-old Rose Barclay. Rose's parents, Ian and Beth, are in the midst of a divorce, and Stella has been called in to determine Rose's final custody. Both parents have agreed to abide by Stella's decision as a neutral third party. During her investigation, Stella gets to know the parents, Ian's mother, Harriet, who lives with the family, and, of course, young Rose.

Divorce isn't the only dark shadow over the Barclay family. Rose's young nanny, Tina, recently met a tragic end, falling from the third-story window of the family home and plummeting to her death. Rose witnessed this event and has been so traumatized that she hasn't spoken a word since. Beth was equally impacted, developing a phobia of glass that has led the family to replace all the windows with plexiglass. Ian was affected in a more personal way. Before Tina's death, he had been involved in a passionate affair with her. The investigation into Tina's fall found no obvious sign of foul play, but the question lingers: was the young nanny pushed? If so, who was responsible? Was it the father, Ian, or the scorned mother, Beth? Or, most disturbingly, could the quiet young Rose be the one responsible for the tragedy?

Sarah Pekkanen has a knack for crafting page-turning thrillers centered on compelling family dramas, and her latest book, House of Glass, is no exception. After enjoying her previous standalone thriller, Gone Tonight, I was eager to dive into her newest release and was thrilled to receive both a physical and audio copy from her publisher. Pekkanen skillfully plays with genre conventions, using familiar tropes to present tantalizing red herrings. I'll admit, I thought I had the plot figured out, only to be surprised by an unexpected twist at the end.

House of Glass hooked me from the start, drawing me into the mystery of a mute child whose perspective may hold the key to the truth. This irresistible puzzle kept me reading non-stop. I had noted some uneven pacing in Pekkanen's previous novel, but House of Glass showed no such inconsistencies. It's sheer fun, popcorn reading at its finest—slightly over the top but thoroughly enjoyable.

House of Glass by Sarah Pekkanen is a riveting psychological thriller that delves into the dark secrets of a seemingly perfect family. The story centers around Rose Barclay, a nine-year-old girl who stopped speaking after witnessing the possible murder of her nanny during her parents' acrimonious divorce. Enter Stella Hudson, a best interest attorney specializing in child custody cases, reluctantly taking on Rose's case due to the insistence of her mentor, a respected judge.

From the moment Stella enters the Barclay family's opulent and eerily plastic home, she senses something deeply wrong. The family's facade of perfection quickly unravels as Stella delves into their lives, uncovering a web of lies and hidden traumas. Each family member, including Rose, becomes a suspect in the nanny’s mysterious death.

Pekkanen masterfully builds tension, intertwining Stella’s investigation with her own troubled past. The narrative is filled with well-timed twists and a haunting atmosphere that keeps readers on edge. The character of Stella is particularly compelling, as her personal history and emotional struggles add depth to her role as an investigator and protector.

House of Glass explores themes of truth, deception, and the psychological scars left by trauma. The Barclay family's dynamic is complex and disturbing, making the unraveling of their secrets both thrilling and chilling.

Sarah Pekkanen’s sharp writing and intricate plotting make House of Glass a standout in the psychological thriller genre. It’s a gripping, suspenseful read that will keep you guessing until the very end, questioning who can be trusted and who is hiding behind a perfect lie.

Stella comes into the Barclay home to assess the situation for the daughter, Rose. Their nanny fell to her death out of a window in the home, the parents are getting divorced, and now Rose suffers from traumatic mutism. Stella has come to find out what is best for Rose, and as someone who herself suffered from traumatic mutism as a child, she can understand Rose at a deeper level. But she notices something, the house no longer contains anything made of glass, why would that be, who are they trying to keep safe?

I really enjoyed this story and as an audiobook it kept me entertained. Stella may only be there to assess what is best for Rose, but she’s also curious about what happened to the nanny. The police have no leads, and in a family who would lie to save one another anyone could be a suspect. Passing the suspicion around, you think Stella has figured it all out until she hasn’t.

Stella has a complex past and we learned a lot about it and there was a lot of story of her life progressing. Felt like a first of a series, and 8 hope we get to see more of Stella down the road.

I always love Pekkanen's books and House of Glass was definitely intriguing and held my interest. There were a few different storylines going on in this novel and mostly I enjoyed that. At times, I wanted less about Stella's past and more about her current case, but it did all work together nicely.

I had inklings about what really happened to Tina, but Pekkanen was fantastic at constantly throwing me off and making me question everything. I loved the strange and aloof characters, the interesting dynamics between Stella and the family, Stella's career, and the descriptions of the eerie home. At times, it almost felt like there might be horror elements woven through and I thought that added a nice element to the story as well.

I listened to this novel on audio and felt it was well done. I liked the narrator and appreciated the sense of drama she brought to the story. She helped me visualize the setting and I think it would translate really well to the big screen.

Overall, I enjoyed this book but think it may ultimately be a bit forgettable for me.

Thank you to St. Martin's Press and MacMillan Audio for the copy.

This was a rarity for me: a five star review for a thriller. I do like them but they are usually palate cleansers and I accept that about them. They typically earn four stars from me unless I find them dull because they often lack something that makes them more meaningful for me. Sometimes it is character development; at other times it is believability.
House of Glass, however, had all of that. I really liked Stella, the protagonist. She had a backstory that drove her to do her best to find out what was going on. She is a lawyer who needs to make a custody recommendation in a divorce where there was a murder of the little girls nanny. I was as invested in Stella's story as I was in Rose, the little girl's. I was with Stella as she got to know the family and all the secrets its members kept. I really hope that there is another book with Stella, as I really enjoyed learning about her as she solved the mystery.
The narrator was good, reading the text with inflection, keeping me engaged when I was listening to the audio.
Thanks to NetGalley and St. Martin's Press and MacMillan Audio for providing me with this advance reading copy/audio in exchange for my honest opinion.

This was such a fun book! It really kept me on my toes and I really could not figure out what was going on until the end. I really loved the main character, Stella and her growth through the novel.

I was able to listen to this on audio and I think Laura Benanti as the narrator did an amazing job setting the tone!

Thank you to NetGalley and Macmillan Audio for the ARC!

Big thanks to both NetGalley & Macmillan audio for the ALC copy of this great thriller!!
This one is out Aug 6!!!

This started off super great with a quick, fast pace that I really loved. I was very ibntrigued with the story & how the MC & subject were connected on some levels. The middle did get a tad slow for me, but by the end it picked back up & was ready for all the action!!

I think Pekkanen did a fantastic job painting all the characters as potential villains to disguise the real cuplrit. The twists were definitely fun throughout this book.

I really enjoyed the way this wrapped up & thought Macmillan audio did a fantastic job with the narrations!!
Recommend this one!