Skip to main content

Member Reviews

All the Water in the World by Eiren Caffall is a captivating and tense novel that is rich with resonance. The detailed emotive descriptions, nail-biting adventure, and vivid setting make this book truly incandescent.

Was this review helpful?

“All the Water in the World” initially grabbed my interest with a unique post-apocalyptic vibe, but fell flat throughout. Slow to medium pace with nothing big to drive the plot in any exciting direction to earn its “thriller” tag.

The MFC was quirky and endearing, and supporting characters had the makings of something better, but needed to be fleshed out a bit more. Writing itself is strong, just needed more oomph to the plot.

Overall, 3.5 stars. Interesting and unique, but could have been stronger. If you like post-apocalyptic stories, “All the Water in the World” brings a creative voice, just without some of the thrill and tension its rival’s provide.

Thank you St. Martin’s Press for this advanced digital copy.

Was this review helpful?

Wow, this book explored so many great topics including climate change and human connection. It will leave you thinking! If you like Emily St. John Mandel, you should definitely check this book out.

Was this review helpful?

Nonie and her family have made a refuge on the top of the American Museum of National History in New York City after the vast majority of the world is now underwater. The glaciers have melted, creating a new survivalist world full of turbulent storms. When a superstorm hits, Nonie and her family must take to the river to try and make it to a family farm, where they think they will be safe.

This book reminded me of The Road by Cormac McCarthy in some ways as a parent is trying to save a child in the dystopian world. The book is told from Nonie’s POV, and she is very loveable in that she is so tenacious. This book was very cinematic, I can totally see it becoming a movie. I loved the cast of characters and the world that Caffall created. The ending was not my favourite, but it still left me satisfied. The first page takes off running and it was very hard to put down!

Was this review helpful?

Poetic and haunting, this novel brings us into a world ravaged by climate change, and the people trying to survive amidst it.

Caffall doesn’t hold back on the imagery through the eyes of Nonie. Deadly storms, extinct icebergs, massive flooding, cities nonexistent, and necessities scarce. Nonie gives us memories from before, and the reality of living in The World As It is.

As we take this journey with Nonie, her sister, her father, and family friend, Keller, we are taken through a journey of longing, sadness, pain, but determination. They are leaving the only home Nonie has ever known-Amen-and heading for a farm up north that may or may not be there. Their path leads them through dangerous waters, and something even more so-people. But along the way, they fight and refuse to give up-despite death nipping at their heels.

A word of advice-don’t go into this novel thinking you’ll be reading a fast-paced story of danger and adventure. It’s quite the opposite. It’s more of a slow walk, full of detours, but beautifully painted for us. You get to know the characters, their back story, and walk along this new world with them. It is also a cautionary tale of what could happen if we do not change course to save our planet. I enjoyed this novel, and if you like slower dystopian, you will, too.

Was this review helpful?

This book was an emotional rollercoaster from start to finish. The depth of loss was overwhelming, yet the bond within the family—how they supported and cared for each other—was incredibly moving. Their unwavering commitment to preserving human history amidst such devastation was truly inspiring. The impact of the rising waters from the melting glaciers was heart-wrenching, and I can’t even imagine the pain they endured. The occasional flashbacks to happier times brought moments of joy and contrast, offering some light amid the darkness. Overall, I found the book to be deeply affecting, blending themes of loss, survival, and hope in a unique post-apocalyptic setting that explores the consequences of global warming in a fresh way.

Thank you to NetGalley, St. Martin’s Press, and Eiren Caffall for the e-ARC.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you NetGalley and St. Martin's Press for allowing me to read this book early.Very dystopian and a future "what if" scenario.

Was this review helpful?

This novel was so transportive. You are so engulfed (pun intended) in this new world that it feels real. Raise your hand if you started preparing for the end of the world after reading this. The situation may be extreme, but Caffall fully captures the breadth of humanity and the ways in which we cope with loss, power, and dreams. Highly recommend!

Was this review helpful?

This book made me CRY not once, but twice, and that is no easy feat. All The Water In The World is a heartbreaking story of loss, grief, and the will to survive.

Nonie and her family have made the American Museum of Natural History their home after the climate crisis floods NYC and leaves watery destruction behind. What an absolutely cool setting for a book, with several characters being scientists and experts in their fields. I loved the little tidbits about bugs from Keller and the conversations on preserving history for future survivors.

It’s no secret that I am a big fan of eco and climate fiction, and listening to this one on audio shortly after finishing Private Rites by Julia Armfield lent for some really neat comparisons and contrasts. Shoutout to Eunice Wong for the excellent narration which followed me through a couple of rainy commutes.

Definitely check this one out if you loved Station Eleven and enjoy climate fiction, dystopian societies, and survival stories!

**Thank you to NetGalley and St. Martin’s Press for the eARC of this ~soggy~ title!**

Was this review helpful?

What a book!!!
Thank you St Martin’s Press @stmartinspress , Netgalley @netgalley ,and Eiren Caffall @eirencaffall for this free ebook!
“All the Water in the World” by Eiren Caffall ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️Genre: Dystopian Climate Change fiction. Location: New York City, NY, USA and north up the Hudson River. Time: Near future, in the years after the glaciers melt.

Climate change ruined New York City-it’s almost deserted. Nonie (13), sister Bix (16), their parents, and their researcher friends have lived on the American Museum of Natural History (“AMEN”) roof on the Upper West Side of Manhattan for 8 years, hunting and growing food in Central Park, protecting exhibits as they can. In November, a hypercane (super hurricane) destroys what’s left of the city, including AMEN, and they escape north on the Hudson River. They bring the museum logbook (records of the lost collections), and Nonie brings her water book for the future. They meet communities that adapt in different, sometimes frightening ways to the new reality. They’re determined to find a way to make a new world honoring what they've saved.

Author Caffall uses neurodivergent Nonie (“I was a blur of closed heart and quiet voice…”) as narrator in a tale of violent climate change, love, community, and what we leave behind. Her writing style makes climate change scarily real: (“…the pressure sinking so fast my teeth itched”), (“It was 3 days before the river tried to kill us.”), and uses evocative dystopian descriptions: (“The city made noise as it died.”), (“People didn’t make it who wanted too much.”) She alternates chapters of their journey north with chapters about life at AMEN in the World As It Is, and life before in the World As It Was. Caffall was inspired by Iraq and Leningrad curators protecting their collections from war. If you enjoyed Station Eleven or Parable of the Sower, you will love this book! There are storms, danger, a fight for survival, great characters, powerful themes, and it’s 5 water-filled stars from me🌵📚💁🏼‍♀️#SMPGEarlyReaders #SMPinfluencers #eirencaffallauthor #allthewaterintheworldbook

Was this review helpful?

I will start by saying that I am a huge dystopian novel fan! It’s my favorite genre and this one did not disappoint. I loved the characters and the entire plot. It was both terrifying and intriguing. I thought the book was really well written and the author’s writing style was great for me.

Was this review helpful?

this book really blew me away and made me think about the world in a different way. so well written!!! 5/5 stars!!!!

Was this review helpful?

Eiren Caffall's "All The Water in the World" is a captivating sci-fi novel that defies expectations from the very start. The cover alone is a work of art, drawing readers in with its intriguing imagery and promising a unique literary experience.

Caffall's prose is nothing short of mesmerizing. The narrative's almost lyrical flow keeps pages turning, creating an immersive reading experience that belies the book's dystopian themes. This stylistic choice elevates the story, making it stand out.

The world-building in this novel is extraordinarily vivid. It presents a future where humanity grapples not with the typical post-apocalyptic tropes, but with the raw, uncontrollable force of nature itself. Storms and hurricanes become central characters, their fury matched only by the desperation of human nature when pushed to its limits.

At the heart of this environmental maelstrom is Nonie and her family. Their fight for survival is visceral and heart-wrenching, with Nonie's journey through loss and resilience forming the narrative's emotional core. Caffall masterfully weaves past and present, providing crucial context while maintaining nail-biting tension in pivotal moments.

"All The Water in the World" is more than a survival story; it reflects global concerns, diversity, and the concept of found family. The author's ability to blend these themes with pulse-pounding action and deeply human moments is commendable.

This novel is a prime candidate for cinematic adaptation, with its vivid imagery and gripping narrative practically leaping off the page. Caffall has created a world that is at once familiar and terrifyingly alien, making "All The Water in the World" a must-read for fans of thoughtful, beautifully crafted science fiction.

Thank you, St. Martin’s Press and NetGalley, for my free book for review.

Was this review helpful?

Nonie can feel the storms coming—and in their dystopian world, that’s an invaluable skill. Yet even her unique gift hasn’t protected her from heartbreak and loss. Set in a waterlogged New York City, where survival is rare, we follow Nonie, her older sister Bix, and their group as they are forced from their rooftop sanctuary in search of higher ground. Along the way, they encounter both natural and human-made dangers that test their strength and resilience.

I was immediately drawn to this book for its dystopian theme. Stories of survival in radically altered worlds have always fascinated me, and this book absolutely delivers. The premise of a flooded world felt vivid and believable—I could easily imagine this scenario unfolding. I especially appreciated Nonie’s strength and the bond she shares with her group, which added a heartfelt layer to the story.

This isn’t a quick, breezy read. The narrative moves back and forth between the “world that was” and the “world that is,” which, while slowing the pacing at times, ultimately deepens the characters and their struggles. It explores profound themes: how people behave under immense pressure, how nature can dismantle humanity’s grandest plans, and how, even in ruin, we fight to preserve what makes us human—love, art, and history. These reflections on survival, tenacity, and connection resonated deeply with me.

I recommend giving this book a try. Though it took me time to fully digest, it has left a lasting impression. Thank you to NetGalley and St. Martin’s Press for the ARC in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

To me this was a mash up of a Sci-fi series I watched during Covid and the movie Water World. I tried many times to get through this book but kept falling asleep.

It is a coming-of-age story set in post-apocalyptic New York. Unfortunately, it seemed repetitive throughout the story.

I did not connect with the book’s characters or the environmental destruction caused by man’s bad behavior over many generations.

Netgalley graciously allowed me to read this book and I’m sorry but I didn’t really like it.

Was this review helpful?

Much thanks to the author, the publisher and NetGalley for providing me this eARC in exchange for an honest review. I always gauge my enjoyment of a novel by how quickly it grabs my attention and how quickly I finish it. All the Waters of the World is all that and more. I don't want to give away the plot but it is apocalyptic but with a sweet hopeful sweet nature that is not usually found in this subgenre. I feel like there are more stories to tell in this world the author has built. Highly highly recommended!

Was this review helpful?

Nonie's parents were researchers with the American Museum of Natural History (Amen), and as the ocean rose and New York City gradually went under, they stayed behind to preserve the holdings as long as possible, and record them in logbooks for future generations. When the flood suppression efforts finally break, bringing the sea through the streets, the last survivors launch a canoe from the collection and journey toward a family farm in northern New York. The story flashes back an forth from the times before the disaster to the journey forward, filling in the heartbreak and horror and love that preceded the journey and learning more about the characters as we follow them into the unknown. The love for each other, and respect and love for their work radiates off the page, and how differently each age sees events based on how much of the Before they remember. It is both sad and hopeful, and deeply emotional. There is adventure and excitement and tragedy in all the complexity of constant struggle and conflict. The characters are all wonderful and will follow you away from the pages. The emotions are real and deeply moving. And the setting so logical and organic, the plotting seems to flow without effort. It is often compared to Station Eleven, but I found it resonated with me more like The Light Pirate, the same sense of deep sadness mixed with hope. I absolutely loved it and can not recommend it enough.

Was this review helpful?

All the Water in the World was a scary look at a future in which global warming finally takes its anger out on the world. It had the potential to be a wonderful and expansive journey. It meandered instead of ran. There was no sense of anxiety or danger in the situations the characters continued to find themselves in. It read more like a textbook than a novel in several places. I did not find the characters to be interesting or even realistic. Often they were almost robotic. I enjoyed how the author described the world of the future but didn't connect with the book.

Was this review helpful?

Despite the slower plot, I still read this in a single day. It’s very well written and deals with its topics very smoothly. There’s some jumping in time that also is handled well and is never confusing. We see a world where climate change caused massive flooding, and much of New York is now underwater. Having grown up in the museum, Nonie and her family are forced to eventually flee and work to find a new home. If you want something dealing with an apocalyptic event that isn’t very rushed or action focused, this is a very good choice.

Note: ARC provided by the publisher via Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

All the Water in the World's is marketed as a gripping narrative of survival and adaptation in a flooded New York City. We follow our main character Nonie and her family as they are trying to navigate a flooding world.

This is a story that should be right up my ally, but the pacing of this story really did not work for me. I read to almost 40% and the info dumping is just continuing in a way that pulls me out of the story. There are also time jumps in the form of recollections of thing that have happened in the past and while some can do this well I personally did not enjoy it in this book. I feel like the concept for this book is so interesting but for me the execution just didn't work.

I appreciate NetGalley and St. Martin's Press for allowing me the chance to read this as an ARC.

Was this review helpful?