LOVE! This story was excellent. Kind of two different storylines going on for our FMC but both were done well and everything blended beautifully. I was hooked from the beginning with the mystery of what happened to her husband-that’s all I’ll say without spoiling it! A very fun, cozy mystery.

All’s Fair in Love & Treachery by Celeste Connally had so many elements I love- friendship, romance, mystery, and enough suspense to keep me guessing until the end. I thoroughly enjoyed this book & I think you will too.


Thank you NetGalley & St. Martin’s Press|Minotaur Books for an ARC copy of this book in exchange for my honest review.

Those who try to solve the mystery before the characters will be thoroughly stymied by this one. Good luck! This was a delightfully complex mystery and a worthy second book in the Lady Petra series by Celeste Connally.

The first book ended with a cliffhanger and this second installment picks up exactly where things left off. The first two chapters are pretty stunning as Petra processes what she has learned about her late fiancé’s death and her childhood friend/current lover’s involvement. She doesn’t get much time, as she’s called to meet the Queen about an investigation…

There are actually two investigations in this book. First, Queen Charlotte asks Petra to investigate the murder of the matron at an orphanage where illegitimate children of the wealthy are trained to go into service. The suspects are the under-matron, an orphan who believes her father left her an inheritance, or outsiders. At the same time, Duncan seems to be involved with a group of reformists who are resorting to violence to overthrow the monarchy. For a time, Petra is unsure about Duncan’s beliefs - is he working with the revolutionaries or trying to undermine them?

I loved the deeper insight into Petra’s late fiancé, Emerson and his family. The secondary characters still shine, as do the dogs. There was a great hint at a future storyline involving Petra’s best friend. I can’t wait for that!

Though I read an early version via NetGalley, I’ll be rereading when my physical copy arrives in November!

All’s Fair in Love and Treachery is a romp of a novel that has all the elements of a regency romance including a detective element that readers will enjoy. I do think All’s Fair in Love and Treachery could have been edited down a bit, starting the novel with Lady Petra in full swing of the investigation. There's a little too much exposition in the opening chapters, where the pacing is stagnant instead of pressing and urgent as Lady Petra is summoned by the Queen to receive a lengthy explanation of the case she wants Petra to investigate.

It wasn’t until further into the novel, where Petra was in full swing of trying to find the killer, that I felt completely immersed in the novel. Where every chapter brought us closer to identifying the killer and if Lady Petra and the handsome Mr. Shawcross make it out alive, and more importantly, together and happy.

If you enjoy a cozy mystery set in the regency-era with a splash of romance, make sure to add All’s Fair in Love and Treachery to your reading list.

Celeste Connally's All's Fair in Love and Treachery is a historical novel and worthy successor to the first in the series. In fact, I was delighted to find that I liked this book even more.

We are back in London in 1815, where the beautiful and wealthy Lady Petra has just learned that her friend since childhood, the dashing Duncan Shawcross, may have been responsible for the death of her beloved fiancé three years earlier. Petra and Duncan have been carrying on a romantic liaison, and she can't bear to think Duncan might have betrayed her. At the same time and at the behest of the royal family, Petra is investigating the death of the matron at an orphanage, where one orphan is complaining that the inheritance she expected when she reached age 15 is nowhere to be found.

But there is a much more deadly plot that may affect Petra, Duncan, and others in her life. A cadre of those who believe the monarchy and Parliament are running the country into the ground and taking away the rights of citizens has turned dangerous, believing that only by violence will anything change. They have something planned in the aftermath of Napoleon's defeat that promises to be devastating and is so intricately planned that Petra and her cohorts are racing to figure it all out before tragedy strikes.

The book really picks up steam later in the book, with clever plot twists and an increase in exciting scenes of action and intrigue. I found Lady Petra to be a more relatable character in this series entry. I also enjoyed supporting characters such as a street urchin who has proven to be so much more, Petra's close female friends--including a dog trainer, an extraordinary archer, and an apothecary--and Duncan himself and his previously estranged half-brother. I look forward to the next book in the series.

My thanks to St. Martin's Press/Minotaur Books and NetGalley for the opportunity to read and provide an honest review of this book.

Usually I love historical romance with a modern twist but for some reason this story felt disconnected and I felt like I was missing something.
A very mundane read for me.

Friendship, love, dogs, cryptic messages, clues, murder & mystery in Regency era London!

I loved the first book - it was so FUN! This book is more serious, following Petra as she's tasked with solving a murder. There's another murder in her not so distant past, that of her finace, which she doesnt know the whole truth about.

Her new love, Duncan, is dreamy yet mysterious and he's an integral part of this book.

Had me guessing until the last chapter when everything was pulled together.

I so badly wanted to like this book. I really enjoyed the first one and the cover is fantastic! Unfortunately, it was really not for me.

The first 30% dragged so badly that I had to tell myself I couldn't do anything until I read at least one chapter a day. Finally, it picked up a little bit, so I thought everything would be fine. It was not.

I really hate to say this, but the only parts that held my attention were the parts with Duncan. I like Petra and her friends, but it was just kind of drawn out and boring when Duncan wasn't around. How many different ways can I read about Petra going to have tea with a friend while trying to solve a mystery?

Because I was so uninterested, it took me longer than usual to read the book. I don't know if it's because I don't have the best memory or if it's because my brain really didn't care, but I couldn't remember who the characters were. The conclusion to the mystery was kind of lost on me because I couldn't remember who was who.

I really liked the first book in this series, but this one just didn't work for me.

The 2nd in a newer series starts just where the first ended with Petra being confronted with the possibility of her former fiancee’s death being a murder! And worse her new love, Duncan, was involved somehow. Before she can confront him, he disappears into the night leaving behind a cryptic message. Petra is then called upon by the Queen and her godmother to look into the death of a Matron at a local orphanage. Her investigation brings her to suspect friends, question motives, and track down the man she loves but doesn’t trust. Every clue she turns up only leads to more questions and danger is lurking in the form of republicans bent on violence who are connected to her former fiance and Duncan. Bringing some levity to the story are Petra’s assortment of friends with varying unique skills including archery and flower bombs. The mysteries and crimes weave together and are not completely undone until the last few pages of the story.

If you are a fan of Regency mysteries, you’ll love Alls Fair in Love and Treachery. I really enjoyed this book and am going to have to read more by Celeste Connolly.

Lady Petra finds out her childhood, best friend and current lover could've been responsible for her fiancé's death. The death of her Viscount makes Duncan flee the scene and she has no choice but to investigate, also helping the queen with a murder case.

This is a swell sequel to the first book! I will admit, I did not realize that this was the second book in the series. So I did go check out the first book out of my library, just to have a little skim through. I will say the description is made me want to pick it up.

“Bridgerton meets Agatha Christie and dazzling new installment (didn't catch that when I requested the book) in a captivating, regency-era mystery, feminist spin.

That being said this book was just OK. I was not in love with it. It's kind of forgettable. I don't remember much from it. On a brighter note, it was very fast pace, and this did make me want to read more to find out what's going on.

If you're interested in historical mystery/lady detective books, I would recommend this, even though I didn't enjoy it that much. If you're a fan of the genre, I really do think that you would enjoy it.

Thank you to St. Martin’s Press and NetGalley for the opportunity to read an advance copy in exchange for an honest review.

I didn’t realize this was the second book in a series when I started it, so my opinion comes only from this book. I found it very poorly written. There was an entire scene toward the beginning where one character would say a bunch of exposition, and another character would agree by repeating it in almost the same words. They went back and forth like this. I already didn’t feel invested in the story, but that really solidified my early suspicion that this book wasn’t going to be very good.

Worse than that, this claims to be a mystery, but I knew who the culprits were before I even hit the 20% mark. I was certain that I was right, so I skipped to the last few chapters to confirm, and yep. It was exactly who it seemed to be. I stopped reading the book at that point.

A compelling, fast-paced sequel! Petra is stunned to find out her childhood best friend and current lover may have been responsible for her fiancé’s death. Duncan has fled the scene so Petra has no choice but to investigate while also helping the Queen with a murder case.

This was great - a very high energy mystery with a captivating romance between Petra and Duncan.

Thank you to St. Martin’s Press and NetGalley for the opportunity to read an advance copy.

Good book, interesting twists and turns! Fast paced and leaves you wanting more. Duncan makes for a good mmc and leaves one wanting a relationship like theirs!

Huge thanks to NetGalley for the eARC.

Readers of All's Fair in Love and Treachery should be prepared for ANGST with a capital A.N.G.S.T, courtesy of this newest installment in the series. Not to give too much away but when you suspect your " half-Scottish secret paramour" of murdering your beloved "viscount fiancé" a girl's allowed to wallow in misery. Luckily for us, Lady Petra Forsyth, not being able to confront Duncan Shawcross, delves into "royal assignment instead", thereby taking the reader on a wild ride of a mystery.

I've been really enjoying the recent influx of historical mystery/lady detective books being published and a highly recommend this series by Celeste Connally if you are a fan of the genre.

This is a great sequel to the first book! Lady Petra is shocked to find her lover was the murderer of her viscount years ago and she now goes on the hunt for him. She feels betrayed and her trust has been shattered. The plot of this book is not always clear cut, but I still loved the book and rated it five stars.

Kindle Copy for Review from NetGalley, Minotaur and St. Martin Press.

I received a free, advance copy of this book and this is my unbiased and voluntary review.

Lady Petra finds out the death of her viscount three years ago was a case of murder and the murderer is her Scottish lover who been consoling her. Shea cannot let things go as she will hunt down her missing lover and get the truth as she feels betrayed. Love and treachery goes hand –to-hand as trust is a fleeting emotion. And things are not always clear cut.