This was one of my most anticipated books of 2025, and it did not disappoint. The cover of this book is the stuff of dreams! Often, I am drawn in by a cover, only to find myself dragging through the book that does not interest me, and eventually sending it to the DNF graveyard. The Otherwhere Post was every bit as magical and mesmerizing as the artwork that introduces it to the world.

After the hardest 7 years of her life, Maeve Abenthy is still struggling to survive. Maeve—not that anyone knows her by that name anymore—never stays in one place too long, never gets emotionally attached, and NEVER EVER gives her real name to anyone. Time has shown Maeve that she has to keep on the move, and keep her head down. The slightest slip of complacency could cost her the very life she is trying to protect. Her identity must remain hidden. One day, Maeve receives a letter. A letter addressed to her with her actual first name on the envelope. A letter that says, "Your father is innocent."

I fell in love with Maeve from the beginning, and wanted so desperately for her character to find a path to peace and love, with people she could rely on...a family all her own. When Tristan came into the story, he easily became my favorite character. You could feel the brokenness in his character, but for different reasons that Maeve. There were times in the book when I worried that he might not be the person Maeve thought he was, and those times were heartbreaking to me. Each time Maeve felt the smallest hint of friendship, I shuddered. I was constantly wondering who would be the next to betray her. At times, I felt that way with Tristan, Nan and Shea...but I hoped beyond hope that I would be wrong.

The plot twists in this one definitely kept me turning the pages. Just when I thought I had things figured out...whether they were for the good or bad...I was surprised when the truth was eventually revealed. The second half of the book was so charged with deception, corruption, and lies that I could not put it down. I was desperate for Maeve to have a life outside of the courier program.

I would definitely recommend this book to anyone who is a fan of dark academia, fantasy, and unique magic systems.

Thank you to NetGalley and Penguin Group for an advance reader copy of this book.

Tropes: Dark Academia | Frenemies to YA Lovers | Slow Burn | Gas Lamps | Cobblestone Streets | Enchanted Letters | Magical Worlds | Unique Magic System | Deception and Corruption

You might need to grab this one if you like YA Mystery & intrigue, dark academia, unique writing based magic, enchanted letters, slow burn romance, yearning, Edwardian-inspired multiverses

I was intrigued by The Otherwhere Post when I first read the synopsis of it back a few months ago, and I expected to like it, but honestly I didn’t expect for it to be such a comfort read, that kept me grinning the entire time I read it. I loved the storyline, and characters, but there was also just a vibe to the overall book that made it feel like the perfect book to get a cup of hot chocolate and cozy up with the rain falling outside and the world slipping away around me.

The relationship between the FMC and the MMC was filled with the kind of yearning I just wanted to scream at them for and it made the book, and their slow burn all the more delicious. The Otherwhere Post was a unique magically journey that I am so glad I had the opportunity to travel on.

Maeve lives with the shadow of her father's treachery hanging over her head. She never stays in one place for long and always gives a false name so no one knows she's the daughter of the man who destroyed one of the three worlds that used to be linked by doors made of writing - and caused the death of hundreds of people.

But then Maeve receives a letter telling her that her father is innocent. Driven to find out if there is a way to clear her father's name, she lies her way into the College of Scriptomantic Arts, now called the Otherwhere Post so she can learn magic writing that will enable her to travel between the two remaining worlds and find out who sent her the letter. But this mystery is anything but simple. And while she attempts to untangle it, the last thing she wants or expects is to make friends with her roommate, Nan - or to be found out by Tristan, the head postmaster's son and a scriptomancing prodigy, who just happens to be infuriatingly handsome as well. Can Maeve exhonerate her father, or will the person who seems to want her secrets to die with her succeed?

This book...there aren't enough words for how much I loved it. First of all, I love an alternate universe where all you need is a special kind of ink and the very act of writing can become magic. The construction of the worlds, how they are joined together, and the lore of scriptomancy all form a universe that puts me very much in mind of Stephanie Garber's "Caraval" series - as if the two could exist in the same universe, just maybe in separate dimensions.

Maeve is a delightful if stubborn and sometimes frustrating heroine, but because of her father's reputation, I could easily understand her reasons for doing things, even if I didn't always think she made the best choices. And she's left-handed, like me. A redheaded, slightly Irish heroine named Maeve who is left-handed? Say less!

As for Tristan - a gorgeous, dark-haired glasses-wearing hero who is a prodigy at writing magic. There is nothing not to like about him, right down to his stubborn loyalty to Maeve even when she puts him through all sorts of things. I could not love him more if he was plucked out of my own brain.

So to wrap up, I thoroughly enjoyed this book and I think those who like fantasy worlds based closely on ours but just a little strange - like "Caraval" - will love it. As will writers, people who are left-handed, and basically anyone who enjoys a well-thought world, a nice sweet romance, and a dash of magic. Five stars. Thank you so much to Netgalley, Penguin Young Reader's Group, G.P. Putnam's Sons Books for Young Readers, and Emily J. Taylor for the advanced reader's copy. This is a voluntary review, all thoughts and opinions are my own.

The Otherwhere Post is a young adult fantasy about a teenage orphan who joins a magical school in hopes of clearing her father’s name.

When her world was destroyed seven years earlier, Maeve barely made it out alive, and her talented scriptomancer father was blamed for the magical blight. After years of living under assumed names, a letter finally reaches her, declaring her father’s innocence. Determined to uncover the true culprit, Maeve enrolls in her father’s former magical academy, hoping to clear his name.

This is an enjoyable read with a unique magic system. I liked Maeve’s bold character and the chemistry between her and her mentor, Tristan. There are also plenty of close calls and dangers to keep the pages turning.

Overall, this is an engaging young adult novel with a creative magical system, and I look forward to reading more from this author.

Thank you so much to NetGalley and Emily J. Taylor for providing me with a complimentary digital of The Otherwhere Post. The honest opinions expressed in this review are my own.

This is the first book I’ve read by this author. I haven’t finished Hotel Magnifique yet. This was supposed to be dark academia, but it didn’t really feel like it to me. I was expecting a little more of that. I thought the plot and the set up was interesting. I just don’t think I fully enjoyed the execution of the plot. The characters didn’t really do it for me. I thought some things felt rushed, and it was hard to get on board. I would check out other books by this author.

After the Hotel Magnifique I was so excited to read this. While it wasn't seemingly connected to the Hotel, I seriously enjoyed this read. While it took a little building the story was engaging and kept you questioning what would happen next.

Maeve Abenthy lost everything. The loss includes her world her father and even her name. Wanting to escape and forget her father’s crimes, she decides to live under a fake name. She never stays in one place very long as she doesn’t want anyone to know who she is. Yet one day, she receives a “Your father was innocent,” The signature is “an old friend” but it has arrived seven years late. She wants to find this .”friend” to find out what she can about her father’s supposed crime. Yet when she finds a courier she receives little hope for finding that person. She decides to try she finds the paragraph in yesterday’s newspaper stating that there is a listing for a courier apprenticeship. The person applying must have a completed writing program certificate to one of the testing locations. What will Maeve do? Will she get to take the test?

This is a dark fantasy tale of love, justice, the delicate magic of finding connection, and the complex art of scribing. The prose moves quickly. The main characters by the author shows their pain and humanity on par with their abilities. In this young adult fantasy, mystery and romance I saw the talent of the author in her complex world-building of three realms, a magical system, dark academia and romance. It’s a wonderful novel to read!

What initially drew me to The Otherwhere Post was its marketing as Divine Rivals meets A Darker Shade of Magic. That pitch was irresistible. The story follows Maeve, a novice courier with the Otherwhere Post, a service that uses Written Doors to transport letters and packages across dimensions. Maeve is eager to prove herself, but her job quickly becomes more dangerous than expected. Mysterious disappearances, cryptic messages, and the growing threat of the ominous Aldervine plague pull her into a conspiracy that could destabilize the entire network. As she navigates this treacherous world, she finds herself increasingly drawn to the enigmatic and charming Tristan, a seasoned courier with his own secrets.

I really enjoyed the world-building, especially the Written Doors—magical portals that allow couriers to travel between distant locations in an instant. The concept reminded me of similar portal fantasy elements from Howl’s Moving Castle, The Ten Thousand Doors of January, and especially, A Darker Shade of Magic, where different worlds house different versions of the same places. However, with this book and as with other books with a dark academia setting, I’m learning that dark academia just ain’t my cup of tea.

Tristan was easily my favorite character. Every time he appeared on the page, the narrative seemed to sharpen (more wit, extra clever)—I realize that in some characters this could come off as cloying, but with him, it just works. It’s his armor hiding his softer underbelly.

His banter with Maeve was delightful—playful, sardonic, and layered with juuuust the right amount of tension.

One of my favorite scenes was when Tristan finds Maeve shivering from the cold:
“Tristan took her heel.”
"What are you doing?"
“He ignored her and tugged off her left shoe, then slid down her wet stocking... He put them on her, sliding them over her calves, to just below her knees. She sat frozen for the entire affair.”
“Your skirt is wet as well.”
"Don’t you dare."

God, I love me the microtrope of a man holding a woman’s heel (blame Cinderella, I think). Later, when Tristan asks if he can have his sock back and Maeve cheekily replies, “It’s my sock now,” I started kicking my feet.

The romance between Maeve and Tristan has a lovely, slow progression that feels organic and believable (so grateful for this because I’ve been reading too many insta-love stories—a trope I really dislike). Their growing connection adds warmth to the otherwise cold and shadowy setting. However, about halfway through, I’m sorry to say the slow-budding romance takes a backseat as the Aldervine mystery takes over. While the intrigue and stakes of the plot kept me engaged, I did miss the spark of Maeve and Tristan’s interactions during this stretch.

I throughly enjoyed The Otherwhere Post! Maeve changed her name since her father was blamed for a terrible crime. She gets an anonymous letter stating that her father was innocent. This causes Maeve to enroll as an apprentice at the Otherworld Post to track down the sender of the letter.

Maeve and Tristan have great banter from the start. The sarcasm level is appreciated and an enjoyed both these characters the most. The stakes for Maeve’s motivations make sense and aren’t too dramatic so some of the risks she takes for the most part feel logical. I never got bored and loved the way everything gets resolved and ends.

First thank you to NetGalley and Penguin Young Readers Group for an eARC in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own.

I wanted to like this, the premise is incredible, but I just didn’t connect with it. The writing felt pretty juvenile, world building too shallow, and the stakes were so low that I found it hard to stay engaged. This is definitely aimed at a younger YA audience, but then would get overly graphic with some gruesome details. It felt like the author couldn't make up her mind on what she really wanted this to be.

Overall, this was a dud for me. I was wishing for so much more.

“If you could reverse the worst thing that’s ever happened to you, wouldn’t you risk everything to try?”

Seven years ago, Inverly, one of the three identical connected known worlds was destroyed in a matter of minutes by Aldervine. In order to save the other worlds (Barrow and Leyland) from the same fate, the Written Doors, which connected the worlds and made travel between the three possible, were burned and destroyed. People were stranded wherever they were when the doors burned, thus separating families.

During all the chaos, scriptomancer Jonathan Abenthy perished. It was also believed that his twelve-year-old daughter, Maeve perished. When in fact, a stranger found her and pushed her through the Written Door to Leyland, where Maeve found herself in an orphanage. An investigation determined that Jonathan was solely responsible for the release of the Aldervine. At the orphanage, Maeve was bullied, abused, and told to never tell anyone who she was. After a short stay, she ran away and managed to obtain a fake name and paperwork.

Now eighteen, Maeve is barely surviving and still living under an assumed name. She doesn’t live in one place for long or allow herself to get close to anyone, lest they figure out who she really is. Maeve’s life once again changes when she receives a lost anonymous letter via an Otherwhere courier. The letter, from seven years ago, states that it’s from a friend of her father, who says her father was innocent and wants to meet. Maeve sets out on a quest to find the anonymous letter writer and prove her father’s innocence.

Emily J. Taylor’s The Otherwhere Post puts letter writing, or more specifically scribing, front and center. This young adult story combines a little romance with magic, mystery, suspense, and a few thriller-like moments. Maeve has built a wall around herself and doesn’t trust easily. Lying for her is second nature. But she has a good heart. The banter between her and Tristan, the boy appointed to be her mentor, provides a little break from some of the heaviness of the book. The Otherwhere Post focuses on the themes of friendship, found family, betrayal, greed, and absolute power. This was an intriguing, thought-provoking page-turner, with no dull moments.

~ Favorite Quotes ~

“When you discover what it is you love, you must clutch on to it with your whole heart and never let it go.”

“You’ll never get over your fears unless you face them.”

This was a dnf for me - I gave it to 30% and just was not clicking with the story or the characters

Thank you for the opportunity to read early

Maeve Abernathy had to go into hiding after her father was accused of terrible crimes. When she received a letter saying Your father was innocent, she plans to uncover the truth. She poses as an apprentice for the Otherwhere Post to be trained in scriptomancy, the dangerous magic allowing people to enchant letters and deliver them to various worlds. Searching for the truth is drawing too much attention, and her mentor knows she's lying about her identity. She's being threatened, and being told to stop her investigation or else.

Three worlds were linked together by Written Doors allowing travel and trade between them. Other worlds were infected with Aldervine, a plant that sank into people and put them to sleep as it consumed them. Maeve’s father was reviled as the man who brought it to Inverley, which devastated the world and killed everyone in it before it was sealed and the Written Doors destroyed. The people who were trapped in the other two worlds remain there, and only the people trained in scriptomancy and are able to use the traveling scripts can become couriers. Once thinking she could run away, Maeve decides to steal the identity of a potential student to discover the truth about her father. Her mentor has secrets and heartbreak of his own, and someone is using scriptomancy to send Maeve subtle threats and scares in the school.

The world details are really fun to read about. The quality of quills, ink, paper and how to stop the magic from bleeding through the paper are discussed, as well as the rigid rules required to be a courier. The couriers are the only ones able to move between the two remaining worlds due to the time and energy to hone the magic talents involved. While Maeve only wanted to discover the truth about her father, she learns about scribing, and even makes friends in spite of herself. The threats she faced are really inventive, and the showdown in the final quarter of the book was tense and drew me in. I really enjoyed the world here, and the characters portrayed in it.

I've been on somewhat of a dark academia kick lately, so I was thrilled to receive an ARC of The Otherwhere Post, a YA dark academia billed as A Darker Shade of Magic meets Divine Rivals. I'd say that it fulfills both of those promises fairly well - the worldbuilding was on par with V. E. Schwab's and it has the Divine Rivals-esque romance to please romantasy readers. I personally enjoyed both comps better than The Otherwhere Post - for a number of reasons I'll go into here - but I still felt this book was a good read.

The Otherwhere Post centers around a mystery. Maeve Abenthy is the daughter of a man her realm (and Maeve herself) believes is a mass murderer - many years ago, Jonathan Abenthy released the Aldervine, a deadly magical vine, into their world, sealing off the doors between realms for good. As Jonathan's daughter, Maeve lives her life on the run, but a mysterious letter has her sprinting towards her father's old scriptomancy school. In order to find the recipient of the mysterious letter, who claims her father is innocent, Maeve must learn the art of scriptomancy: magic writing that lets the user travel between worlds, imbue letters with vivid memories, and bring ink on the page to life, among other uses. On the quest to find the letter writer and prove her father's innocence, Maeve's life becomes increasingly endangered and her fate entwined with that of a charismatic young courier, Tristan.

The mystery element is very well done and kept me guessing throughout. Taylor introduces enough twists and turns to keep the story engaging, while also building in downtime to discover the characters and explore the romance. I thoroughly enjoyed how the mystery element took us on a journey through the various different realms - the worldbuilding is a particular highlight. Like A Darker Shade of Magic, there are several realms layered atop each other here, which only special magical people can travel through, and one of the realms is infected and dangerous. I think Taylor explains that complex concept very well, and the worldbuilding remained accessible throughout. Although scriptomancy is a magic I haven't seen done before in fantasy, Taylor never info dumps or leaves the reader confused; there was just the right amount of explanation at just the right time. I thoroughly enjoyed my time spent in the world Taylor crafted, and I think others will too.

I also really liked the romance. Tristan is fantastic - a well-dressed and shy academic, who hides his magical gifts due to a secret dark past. He's so sweet and so good to Maeve, while also not being one note. I would take a thousand Tristans, please - can we make "secretly a golden retriever" a more well-used romantasy trope? I love that Maeve was the morally gray one here, and I love the way that their relationship unfolded throughout the novel.

But what I didn't love was Maeve herself, or, rather, the way that Taylor treats Maeve. Maeve makes a number of horrible decisions that, were she a real person, would not work out nearly so well. I felt there was a good amount of luck on Maeve's side, or at least a good amount of "don't kill your darlings" going on. I also didn't love how nearly everyone seems to like Maeve, despite her rather standoffish behavior. I don't mind an unlikeable or morally gray protagonist, but I do mind whenever everyone falls all over them. From Maeve's too-nice (and kinda nosy, tbh) roommate Nan, to the random secondary characters that let Maeve do what Maeve wants to do, the characters supporting Maeve's bad decisions are the only wheel that kept this plot turning. And THAT really detracted from my overall enjoyment. Well, that and the random conveniences of everyone turning up whenever Maeve needs them most.

And then the other thing is that, while the worldbuilding and the twisting plot felt sparkling and full of life, the characters and writing did not. Outside of Maeve and Tristan, the other characters felt like background or like plot devices to drop clues. The villain is exactly who you think the villain will be, because everyone else is so unambiguously nice or forgettable. I think part of this is due to the writing. I read an ARC, so this could be corrected, but it was so flat and there were lots of typos. Forgotten filler words like "a" and "the" mostly, but enough that I questioned if it was written in a hurry, or if it had gotten a final editorial pass. And once I noticed all of these things - plot conveniences, typos, and lack of character growth - I couldn't stop seeing it, and then I no longer cared if Maeve ever solved the mystery. I just kept reading because the magic carried this book.

But as always with YA, take my reviews with a grain of salt - I'm a midtwenties bookworm who's read far too much for her own good. If you gave this to me ten years ago, I'd have devoured it, and, after all, that's the intended audience. This is a solid, middle of the road YA dark academia that has plenty of mass appeal and enough twists and turns to satisfy clever teen readers. The romance is sweet and age appropriate, and the language and subject matter makes it a good gateway YA book for middle grade readers seeking something more challenging.

Many thanks to NetGalley, G.P. Putnam's Sons Books for Young Readers (Penguin Young Readers Group), and Emily J. Taylor for gifting me this e-ARC in exchange for my honest review! 3.5 stars rounded up.

Thank you NetGalley and Penguin Teen for providing me with an ARC!

I read Emily J. Taylor’s debut novel, Hotel Magnifique, a few years ago after receiving it in an Owlcrate box and I really enjoyed that one, so I was super excited to get a copy of The Otherwhere Post!! This book completely exceeded my expectations, I loved everything about it.

The book follows Maeve as she tries to prove her father innocent for crimes he committed several years ago. She uses a fake identity to get her into the prestigious scriptomancy school so she can learn more about his past and also the skill in general. I really liked the worldbuilding and magic system a lot! It reminded me of two of my favorite books of all time with the different versions of the same cities in different worlds (A Darker Shade of Magic) and the magical letter writing (Divine Rivals). Usually I don’t like when there are obvious comparisons to other books but this was still different enough and I still enjoyed this book a lot!

This book combined so many genres together and it did all of them perfectly. There were the fantasy elements with the magic and the fictional world, the romance between the apprentice and her mentor, and the mystery plotline. Every single element was balanced perfectly with each other.

I highly recommend this book and I look forward to Emily J. Taylor’s next novel !!!

I'm not always a fan of dark academia, but this novel is definitely an exception. The idea of a school where scholars learn to enchant letters to allow them to travel between overlaid worlds is so intriguing that I was happy to pick it up, and I'm glad I did. Maeve, our main character, has been running and hiding for the past seven years to escape association with her father's horrible deeds. She's planning to run again until she receives a mysterious letter claiming that her father was innocent, and she can't let it go. But finding answers might cost her everything.

If you're not a huge fan of novels set in academies, don't turn your nose at this one. Although there is an academic setting, the focus is not on classes or petty gossip or quarrels between students, so it doesn't feel like your typical dark academia story. Instead, we have a young women who infiltrates the scriptomancy academy in order to search for answers about her deceased father. It's set in an interesting world where special forms of writing hold powers. While some of these are described in detail, I do think there is room for more exploration here and am intrigued to know whether there might be a sequel to this book in the future.

I appreciated the interplay between our two main characters and was certainly rooting for them to get together. They both had secrets and struggles to overcome, and it kind of worked. This book was really about the plot though and about introducing the reader to some wildly fascinating ideas about the world in which it was set. I enjoyed it a lot, but would caution that if you're not interested in a slightly disjointed, not to character driven experience, this one might not be right for you. Having said that, the writing is well-done, the world is fascinating, the characters are likable, and there is room to expand to a series if the author so chooses. I would recommend this.

Maeve was so easy to connect with! Not the picture perfect heroine but more of a loner who cares about her goals and not much else. Shes driven to find out answers and doesn’t care what rules she needs to break to reach them.

Tristan was a fun character. And such a great counterpart for her. He’s very secretive, stubborn and has a whole haunted vibe to him.

The magic system was so unique! I loved how refreshing it was to not read another story that has the same things as the next fantasy book!

This book was fantastic in every detail, from the unique magic system and world-building to the slow burn romance and yearning with an added level of mystery, dangerous scribings and newfound friendships.

If you are a fan of a darker academic setting, hidden pasts and the journey to discover what lies beneath layers of buried history, magic that feels fresh, Edwardian inspired setting, *almost kisses* and characters that stick to you long after you close the book!

Finding solid good young adult fantasy in this age is so hard. I stumbled upon this and just from the description of Tristan, I knew I would like this, I'm not even going to lie and say it was the intricate magic system that beguiled me! Not to say it wasn't a crucial, perfectly thought-out and executed part of the book. Scriptomancy was a unique take on magic and writing power. It did confuse me for a bit but that only solidfies it as strong world-building in my books. If it's too easy to digest, it's lacking something.

Tristan did not disappoint. He was the exact surly, sarcastic guy I had in mind. New fave hero alert! On that note, Maeve did not let me down either. I love heroines who can lie with their whole chest, and do. She was an expert liar with a slight conscience, of course, but not enough to turn her into self-pitying, sorry-state main character who refuses to lie and steal. She was grounded and fun while being serious. She was the highlight of the book.

Emily J. Taylor is a new author to me, one who I will be keeping an eye on for future releases, and so should you.

There's nothing inherently wrong with this book, it just completely failed to interest me at any point. Maybe because I never got to know anything about the characters? I know Maeve has rust-red hair and Tristan has dark hair (I think?) and glasses. I don't know what Nan looks like, or Shae, or anyone else in the book. We learn nothing about their likes, dislikes, etcetera except that Maeve doesn't get along with horses and Tristan likes music. At once it feels very hasty and at the same time like nothing's happening. Maybe I'm just the wrong audience?