I very much loved the story of this book, but the execution was a little lacking for me. I loved the point of the story but it wasn't smooth. I felt like parts of the story moved too slowly for my taste, but I stuck with it because I wanted to see how it ended.

Our Infinite Fates was an interesting read for me. When I initially added this to my TBR, I thought I was going to get a story centered around reincarnation with a touch of rage romance thrown in. That wasn't quite the prose. I was hooked on the premise of Evelyn trying to outlive her death date while figuring out why she has an expiration date in the first place. However, after a while, my interests began to decline.

The way Steven wrote the story was extremely romanticized. I thought we would get some sleuthing and mystery in the mix. OIF almost resulted in a DNF because I was so bored. The pacing and repetitiveness did not help. What saved me was that we did get a glimpse of her previous lives and how she died, as well as the plot twist! That twist was...different. I can usually guess what's going to happen in a book before I get there, but this one threw me for a loop. The unexpected outcome altered my perception of how this book was structured.

I rated this book 2.5-stars. I was expecting more from the story. It took too long to reach its intended destination, and it felt hollow at times. I didn't feel a connection with the characters or their plights, which made it even harder for me to focus.

I love everything romantasy and reincarnation so this audiobook completely drew me in from the start. It was amazing well written by Laura Steven. I loved the changing timelines as we go back into the character's past lives together. I felt the jumps were well defined and natural to follow. Absolutely an immediate recommendation from me and I've been telling everyone about this amazing book! Thank you so much for this ARC!

Overall: 3.5/5
Characters: 3.5/5
Plotline: 4/5
Writing: 3.5/5
Tropes: MF Romance; Fated Lovers; Forbidden; Multiple Lives; Demons

Themes: 4/5
Romance: 3.5/5
Spice Factor: .5
Enjoyment Factor: 4/5

Audiobook: 4/5
Review: I love this concept of multiple lives and continually finding each other. With this book, I could tell that this was a debut, but I will be watching this author. I think they have an excellent POV and have good storytelling skills. I believe that the biggest issue with this is that both of the MCs should have been adults as they were almost too teenager-y for beings who have lived and died 1000 lives. I love the flashbacks, as they added a lot of depth to the story, and it was fun to travel to different times with the characters. I wish we got more from the present-day plot line, as the only thing pushing us forward wasn't different from the past lives.
I received an ARC of this title from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.

Our Infinite Fates struggled to hold my attention. I frequently found myself setting it down, with little motivation to pick it back up. Even the audiobook couldn’t keep me engaged, the narrator’s delivery just didn’t draw me in. The flashbacks felt unnecessary and often disrupted the flow of the story, making it harder to follow. While the premise sounded promising, the execution fell flat. Readers who enjoyed The Invisible Life of Addie LaRue may find something to appreciate here, even if it didn’t quite work for me.

Thank you NetGalley, Wednesday Books for an ARC, and Macmillan Young Listeners for an Advanced Listening Copy

This book was fine. It was very different from what I expected, which I think hindered my enjoyment of it a little bit. I was expecting more of a fantasy, and while there are obviously fantastical elements, to me it had more of a magical realism feel than pure fantasy, and I'm not as big a fan of magical realism. There were some more interesting and fantastical elements towards the end, but I wish some of that stuff and some of the big reveals would have shown up sooner, so there could have been more time with them. A lot of time is taken up with flashbacks of several different past lives, which I ended up not liking because they didn't really add anything to the story. Most of them didn't move the plot forward at all, didn't reveal anything super important, and would have made no difference to the story if they were there or not. Overall, this book feels like a commentary on love and humanity and touches on these themes in a thoughtful way, but it isn't very plot driven if that's something you're looking for. It focuses more on the characters and the romance which is enough for some people, but these characters just didn't draw me in the way I wanted them to. It's a good read if you have the right expectations.

-- finished back in April.

Holy shit. Just yesterday I was like not even 100 pages into this story, but I sat down, turned my phone off, and just read and read—I didn’t stop reading until I finally told myself it was time for bed.
Our Infinite Fates by Laura Stevens completely pulled me in. This book was everything to me. The writing, the tension, the way the characters unfolded like real people—I felt all of it. I’m still carrying them with me. I’ll always think about these characters, the choices they made, the world they moved through. It was raw, beautiful, and so deeply human.

If you’re even thinking about picking this up, just do it. Let yourself fall into it. I did, and I’m still reeling in the best way.

I tore through this in one sitting, partly because I’m a sucker for “we’ve loved and killed each other a thousand times” vibes, but mostly because Evelyn is a total badass. She remembers every lifetime where Arden offed her before she could blow out 18 candles, and now she’s gotta figure out why while saving her kid sister. Talk about pressure.

The whole reincarnation curse setup feels like The Invisible Life of Addie LaRue crashed into This Is How You Lose the Time War’s love‑hate party, and I am here for it. Evelyn’s voice is funny and weary in the same breath: she’s been through centuries of murder but still cares enough about her sister to try one more round. Arden’s equal parts devilish and tragic, so their push‑pull romance lands as both thrilling and gut‑punching.

Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for this advanced reader copy in exchange for my honest review.

At its core is a fierce, complex heroine whose journey is both empowering and emotionally resonant. With strong themes of fate, identity, and resistance, this is a standout YA fantasy that will appeal to fans of romantasy with real depth. A fresh and thrilling start to a new series.

Our Infinite Fates by Laura Steven is a book that immediately intrigued me with its high-concept premise, and while there were certainly moments of brilliance, I walked away feeling a little underwhelmed by the ultimate explanation. The story contains some truly beautiful, memorable lines that will stay with me, and the writing style as a whole was strong; enough that I’d definitely pick up more by Laura Steven in the future.

That said, it took me a while to finish. There was something in the resolution that left me unsatisfied, despite the emotional highs and creative ambition. Overall, I liked the book, but didn’t love it.

Thank you to NetGalley and Wednesday Books for the ARC!

I absolutely LOVED this book. I think about it daily since reading and have collected almost every edition (in English).

Unfortunately, this one felt overhyped and did not deliver in the way I wanted it to. Sadly, “Our Infinite Fates” is a DNF for me.

Thank you, St. Martin's Press | Wednesday Books and NetGalley for the chance to read this book in exchange of an honest review.

Evelyn is able to remember all her past lives and she knows she will be killed before her eighteen birthday by a supernatural entity bound to her soul. But she loves the life she has now and she wants to stay with her little sister and protect her. So she will have to find the devil responsible for her death, who hunts her in every life before she's found first. She will have to find a way to survive and not to fall in love...again.

In this heartbreaking, heart-wrenching, heart...all, book, Our infinite fates, Laura Steven writes about a love story that defies death, about to souls that reincarnate through centuries and centuries, loving each other and killing each other in every lifetime.
The invisible life of Addie LaRue meets This how you lose the time war, so it's advertised and being in love with Addie LaRue I couldn't not read this book and it wrecked me. I was a crying mess every time, every word and page.
It's romantic, brutal, so well written and it will break and heal your heart every time and then break it again and again. It's so recommended it!

Laura Steven's OUR INFINITE FATES is gorgeously written. The prose swept me away straight from the beginning. The story is lush and romantic, interweaving Evelyn and Arden's past and current lives (love how their names are kind of a play on Adam and Eve). Some decent research clearly went into their past lives, but the plot development felt uneven because the past lives didn't always move the plot forward. I was also underwhelmed by the ending. Things could have been fleshed out more and the explanation could have been more compelling. That being said, I really enjoyed that Evelyn and Arden did not always reincarnate in the same gender, and yet they still always love each other. OUR INFINITE FATES is often comped with V.E. Schwab's THE INVISIBLE LIFE OF ADDIE LARUE, but I feel like Lauren Kate's 2009 FALLEN is a much better comp.

This book is an ambitious, genre-blending ride - part speculative thriller, part queer love story, and part multiversal chaos. Steven’s writing is sharp and emotionally grounded, even when the narrative veers into high-concept territory.

What really works here is the character voice: witty, raw, and real. Despite the scope of the plot, the emotional stakes never get lost. The pacing is brisk, and while the sci-fi elements are fun, it’s the character dynamics that carry the weight - especially the portrayal of grief, identity, and moral complexity.

That said, the multiverse mechanics might feel slightly underexplored for readers coming in with heavier sci-fi expectations. The narrative leans more into emotional arcs than scientific explanation, which works thematically, but may leave a few questions hanging.

Overall, it’s a smart, inventive novel that balances heart with ambition. A great pick for readers who love their speculative fiction messy, meaningful, and unapologetically queer.

In this fascinating new fantasy novel, readers follow Evelyn and Arden, two people connected by fate and unable to escape the cycle -- Arden murders Evelyn before her eighteenth birthday in every lifetime. This time around, Evelyn desperately wants to stay alive because her little sister needs Evelyn for the medical treatment which would save her life. To stay alive and save her sister, Evelyn must find Arden and convince him to not kill her, figure out why he has to kill her, and avoid falling in love with Arden (again). With its unique take on soulmates and romance, this enemies and lovers novel will pull readers in through the characters’ relationships and their complex interactions over millennia. Evelyn is a relatable and deeply human protagonist focused on her relationships with other characters, and these relationships really flesh out her character arc and personality. The world-building is interesting and unique, and the modern setting with the layers of Evelyn and Arden’s relationship is fascinating because of these added complexities that readers discover over the course of the book. A great fantasy read for fans of similar titles, readers will be invested in Evelyn and Arden’s relationship and the eternal questions of free will versus fate that the novel focuses on.

Laura Steven’s Our Infinite Fates is an emotionally ambitious and lyrically written novel about soulmates cursed to die before turning 18—again and again. Told across multiple lifetimes and identities, this reincarnation love story explores the tension between destiny and choice, memory and identity, gender and love.

The prose is stunning—dreamy, melancholic, and rich with emotion. Steven captures grief and longing with real resonance, and her commitment to gender-fluid representation and queer love gives this book a refreshing and meaningful core. Evelyn and Arden’s dynamic is complex and timeless, and the book’s core message—love transcends gender, time, and even death—feels powerful and necessary.

That said, the novel’s structure may not work for everyone. The frequent flashbacks across various eras (WWI, 1980s Russia, colonial Algeria) are atmospheric but can feel repetitive, slowing the plot’s momentum. While I appreciated the high concept, I found myself wishing for more present-day grounding and a clearer emotional arc in Evelyn and Arden’s current timeline. The romance, while heartfelt in idea, sometimes leans more on telling than showing—especially when it comes to rebuilding their connection in this lifetime.

This book felt like falling in love with words. It’s such a beautiful tribute to romance…like the author poured their soul into every sentence. The writing is dreamy and emotional, almost like reading a love song or a long, aching poem. It’s the kind of book that makes your heart hurt in the best way. If you love romance that feels deep, poetic, and unforgettable, this one’s for you.

Our Infinite Fates is a sharp, genre-blending read that pulls you into a world where fate and free will collide in unexpected ways. Laura Steven’s writing is vivid and fast-paced, with a voice that's equal parts witty and heartfelt. The book’s strength lies in its layered characters and a plot that juggles humor, high stakes, and emotional depth without feeling overloaded.

While it takes a few chapters to fully hit its stride, once it does, the narrative's momentum keeps you hooked. A few threads felt a little too neat or familiar, which kept it just shy of five stars for me. Overall, this is a compelling, creative story that lingers after the final page! Thank you, NetGalley!

You know, sometimes I rate books 5 stars because of how invested I was in the story or the characters. And it continued to be a book I thought of outside of just while I read it. So because all of those things happened while I read this book, I had to give this one 5 stars.

This has similar vibes to The Invisible Life of Addie Larue - similar but not the same. Our two main characters are ones that I will remember!

I do think audio would maybe make this more difficult to follow versus reading a physical book. The in between chapters of where we flash back could be confusing. But reading the physical book, I had no issues and followed along just fine.

I didn't particularly guess the main twist, but I wasn't surprised either. I thought this was added layers of their previously lives really gave the reader a full picture of their connection.

Loved this and definitely would recommend :)