Member Reviews

Astounding work from Richard Powers. Relevant and affecting. Highly enjoyed this one, the plot, the characters, the setting. Powerful book.

Was this review helpful?

Richard Powers is one heck of a writer. In his books, he finds a magical way of elucidating big world issues, like the cosmos or the environment, while at the same time capturing the very real, very human experiences of his characters in an evocative way. Playground weaves a fascinating tale of four different characters who eventually all wind up on the Polynesian Island of Makatea. It's an exploration of the possibilities of AI, of the human impact on the environment, of the complexity of relationships, and of the consequences of our actions and desires. Every step of the way, there's something beautiful and something to think about and I guarantee this book will make you feel things! I couldn't put it down and I'm in awe of what Powers has created here. Maybe the best book I've read so far this year!

Was this review helpful?

As I anticipated, Playground by Richard Powers is brilliant. It is a breathtaking meditation on the wonders of the ocean, a devastating consideration of both the wonders of technology and the sometimes evils those technologies have wrought, and interlocking stories that brought me to truly care about the characters Powers introduced me to. The structure of the stories worked well for me, as I followed along in the various timelines and so the intersections of past and future as both the narratives and the characters developed. Powers's descriptions - of life in the ocean, of coding, of racism, of the various time periods - were engrossing. Like Powers's other books, I suspect this one will be an award winner, and I will recommend it strongly for readers interested in complex stories with messages for the endangered world we now inhabit.

Was this review helpful?

This story, told from multiple perspectives over decades, boils down to eco-suspense. A shadowy American group with extreme wealth seeks permission from Pacific island Makatea to build a seasteading project on and off their shores, and the residents are forced to weigh the potential upsides of technology and development over ecological harm and loss of autonomy. The interlacing narratives follow a handful of characters, most of whom are from North America, as their values and divisions develop over time. The full implications of their connection to Makatea's decision is revealed towards the end,
The three (or four) main characters are well developed; their reasoning makes sense and their surprise when handed a bombshell is satisfying to read. The Makateans themselves are given some platform to explain their positions, but not at the same level of depth; their interiority is comparatively surface-level, which is unfortunate, but likely because they don't figure in the personal drama that animates the plot.
[Spoiler alert:] The ending might be the weakest point for me: fantastical, both in its convenient problem solving, as well as the White Savior flavor (it would be nice if the Makateans were given more agency in their choice of colonialism vs deprivation, but maybe that would be the real fantasy?).
Overall, I really enjoyed my first Richard Powers novel. Thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for the ARC.

Was this review helpful?

I love the richness of Richard Powers' descriptions the natural world and the way he creates his ensemble casts with gentleness and a caring eye. I previously enjoyed OVERSTORY and BEWILDERMENT, and this one was not a disappointment. Powers is an author who, it seems to me, continues to experiment with craft and structure with each novel, so it's always exciting to see what he does with his next one.

This is a story about two men who meet as children and grow up together. Both are brilliant in their own ways. It's sort of like MY BRILLIANT FRIEND vibes, but boys in America. Their paths diverge after a significant falling out, and one goes on to be a tech billionaire while the other pursues a love of knowledge and art. Mixed up in all this is AI, and I won't say more about that, but how he uses it is veeerry interesting.

Anyway, this was a great read. Definitely worth checking out.

Full disclosure: I requested this on NetGalley, because I like to read the Booker longlist every year (and also because I always enjoy Richard Powers' books). Thanks to the publisher and Netgalley for the free ARC.

Was this review helpful?

For a novel that bounces through time and across the globe, Playground feels incredibly intimate; at its heart, it is an exploration of the way the lives of four people are shaped by their relationships to nature, technology, and each other. Playground's shifting point of view provides insight into both the complexities of its character's lives and how those complexities are regarded by those that know and love them. And always, thrumming in the background, is the ocean, which Powers portrays with a respect and awe that feels contagious. I loved reading Playground for its deft character studies, nonlinear structure, and gorgeous use of play as a motif, but I loved it just as much for introducing me to coconut crabs, pistol shrimp, and giant manta rays. As in his last novel, Bewilderment, Powers is interested in putting the unknown questions of new technology, and particularly AI, next to the oldest mysteries we know: space, the ocean, the unexplainable distances between the people who know each other best. Playground has been longlisted for the Man Booker Prize, and it is one of my favorite books of the year so far. Deeply nerdy, profoundly relevant, absolutely beautiful.

Was this review helpful?

I was intrigued to see Richard Powers back on the Booker list, this time with a novel about technology, AI, and ocean life. A bit of a strange combination when you first think about it, but in Playground, Powers uses his main characters to draw connections between the two subjects.

The novel focuses on Todd, a billionaire, Rafi, a Black man growing up in Chicago, and Evelynne, a French-Canadian deep-sea diver. It follows Rafi and Todd as they grow up together in Chicago and Evie’s path to becoming the first female diver, alternating with Todd's reminiscences from the future as he is diagnosed with dementia.

Where Powers excels is the nature writing, as you might expect if you are familiar with his other books. He truly immerses the reader in the undersea world. I found myself Googling many of the creatures Powers mentions and being awed by their beauty.

All of the characters are stereotypes: the White man billionaire, the girl-boss diver, the Black man trying to break free from his troubled past, island girl stuck on the continent. This becomes partially explained by the ending of the book, but reading these characters was at times frustrating because of how they played into these stereotypes. Other parts of the book, such as the endless discussion of the board game Go, were not interesting to me but I can see how Powers was leveraging it for the larger story. That all said, there were other parts of this book that I flew through, especially as it ramped up toward the end.

The ending is a big twist, which I started to see coming in the last quarter of the book. The twist is ultimately what led me to dislike the book overall. I won’t reveal the twist but it felt a bit gimmicky and was disappointing.

Overall liked the premise but didn’t love the execution.

Was this review helpful?

Playground is my favorite Powers novel to date. This was a remarkable story that weaves through locations and times and narrators much like the movements of the ocean, which is itself arguably the largest character in the book. I never had any trouble following whose story we were in or in what time period, and I fell in love with the ocean through Powers's lyrical writing. This is a book about friendship, about play, about exploration and nature and humanity. I found it completely absorbing and compelling. Thank you to NetGalley and W. W. Norton & Company for a digital review copy.

Was this review helpful?

In Playground, Richard Powers explores themes that will not surprise anyone who has read some of his previous books: artificial intelligence,, climate change, the societal impacts of selfish development projects financed by wealthy investors, and the environment, among others. In this book, his focus is on the ocean, filled with incredibly beautiful and miraculous creatures but also increasingly with plastic detritus. Told through several characters and stories, it is not until the end of the book that they come together powerfully and somewhat unexpectedly. I both read and listened to this book and very much appreciate the narrators of the audio version, whose work greatly enhanced my experience. There is no question that Powers is one of our masters of literature and it is the force and beauty of his writing that elevates the book. He and I interacted occasionally when we both worked at the University of Illinois and it was fun to see some of the book set there, especially in the Main Library. But it is the ocean that is the star of Playground, with artificial intelligence cast in a major role. Playground has earned its place on the current Booker Prize long list.

Was this review helpful?

I’ve had a few opportunities to talk about this book to others, and I flounder every time. There are a few main storylines: Todd, telling the story of he and Rafi’s friendship, Ina (and Rafi, her husband) and the rest of her island community in Polynesia, and Evie’s life as a diver. The stories all intersect and overlap through the way they talk about the act of play, as well as AI. Multiple times as I was reading this, I thought to myself, When did Powers write this? It feels like it was written yesterday, in response to ChatGPT. But this is a 400 page book, with stories so intricately webbed that you think you know where the story is going, only to be thrown a curveball (or, maybe a Move 37) in the last 10% of the book, so it had to be a work in progress for a while. It made me think a lot about what we consider “play” and how important play is for humanity. This was nominated for the Booker longlist, and Booker says “The winning book is a work that not only speaks to our current times, but also one that will endure and join the pantheon of great literature.” I wouldn’t be surprised if this ends up winning. In terms of other books, at times, with all its talk of games, I was reminded of Tomorrow and Tomorrow and Tomorrow, but with all the oceanography and lovely language about the seas, it almost felt (and I write this at the risk of sounding reductive) like an ocean version of The Overstory. But again — it’s so much more than the ocean in here. There is so much we don’t know about the ocean, and so much we don’t understand about AI, and the questions Powers makes you ask yourself have been nagging at me for days. I very much look forward to the release of this, so I can read others’ thoughts and reviews.

Was this review helpful?

Absolutely superb writing and imagery, characters, and science....I found myself highlighting passages, looking up Polynesian islands and sea animals, and marveling both at how unique and wondrous the ocean is, and how little I understand. The humans in this book are the least appealing aspect---they are well conceived but fallible, as perhaps all humans are, and their decisions often frustrated me. Powers' imaginative (and surprising!) ending so imaginatively brought together the natural and technological worlds that I found myself silently reflecting for many minutes after I finished the final page. Would highly recommend.

Was this review helpful?

For a work titled Playground, this has sure left me with that empty, post-weeping feeling.

This story moves between characters, geography, and time. With excellent prose, Powers examines curiosity, progress, and human relationships through a Nature vs. AI plot. I loved the vivid descriptions of the ocean, though I appreciated even more the emotional depth in the relationship between Rafi and Todd. Some of the dialogue regarding the colonialist intervention into French Polynesia felt a little obvious/unnecessary, but overall this is a stellar book. I've read 1/3 of the longlist and so far this seems the most Booker-worthy.

Thank you to Norton & NetGalley for the e-arc.

Was this review helpful?

An astounding and astonishing new book by Powers, where he moves from the interconnected forest theme of The Overstory to the vast connectiveness and fragility of the ocean.

First: the backstories of the four main characters which get shared in highly disjointed narrative sprints. Two social awkward teens, Rafi and Todd, bond in high school first in playing Chess and then becoming obsessed with the ancient game of Go. Their competitive play bonds them, though Rafi is an abused kid from inner city Chicago and Todd from a wealthy if dysfunctional family.
They continue their friendship in college, with Rafi obsessed with literature and Todd with computer programming and nascent AI. At college, Rafi falls in love with Aroita, a Hawaiian college student who grew up in the South Pacific as her mother comes from Tahiti and who struggles to relate to Chicago culture.

They boys ultimately have a falling out over their own cultural divide and after Rafi lends some brilliant gamification ideas to Todd about a computer platform he's designing called The Playground. A big part of the narrative is told by Todd, writing to an unknown “you,” decades post college after he’s become a billionaire off The Playground as well as after he’s been diagnosed with a rare form of dementia. The level of unreliability in the tale he shares is unclear.

Separately, Evelyne a young Canadian woman passionate about research diving expeditions has to fight her way into the boy’s club of ocean diving and academia. She writes a book full of stories of wonder of what she has seen while diving that inspires a generation of adolescents to fall in love with oceanography. She’s now in her 80’s and still lives to dive in the ocean.

All four characters converge on a remote French Polynesian island, Makatea, which has been scarred by intense phosphate mining decades earlier and only has 82 current residents. They all face a contentious vote on whether to allow an ocean seeding project of sea-worthy autonomous pod cities to be constructed and launched from their island.

Woven throughout their stories are a look at evolutions: from pristine oceans to plastic garbage and chemicals that are threatening and being to kill all the biodiversity; from the earliest computers to advanced AI and what role technology will play in the future of both humanity and the world; from independent South Pacific islanders to pawns in global politics. What will it take to save the environment, ocean, humanity and ultimately the Earth? Powers implores us with poetic reverences to turn the tides.

Thanks to W.W. Norton & Company and NetGalley for an advanced reader’s copy.

Was this review helpful?

Just before I started to read this book, I learned that it was long listed for the Booker Prize, which only increased my excitement. After finishing it, I confess I have no idea where to start. There are so many layers, so many levels, so many ideas so masterfully intertwined, I can't imagine that my review will be able to do it justice. The title, for one. On the surface, it is the name of a computer software program developed by one of the characters, which evolves into an AI program that has the potential to either save humanity or doom it. Beneath that level, the term "playground" refers to the world in which we live. We learn that play guides much of what we do and the decisions we make. As one of the characters, a life-long ocean diver, discovers, even animals play, and are capable of playing with humans (at one point, Evie watches as a cuttlefish moves through a dazzling display of colors and dance-like gestures after which she concludes, in awe, that the fish was performing a play).

Play also enters the picture when the two main characters, Todd and Rafi, begin playing the ancient game of Go, which has only black and white stones but can encompass a seemingly infinite number of moves based on the creativity of the players. Throughout the book we see the contrast between the black and white of decisions made, relationships starting and ending, life and death - but we also see that there are various ways these stories can go based on the creativity of those involved. Will climate change end the planet? Will humans survive, and at what cost? Is death the end of life? Are earth and ocean two separate worlds?

The first chapter of the book tells us the story of Ta'aroa, the supreme god of the French Polynesian islands. Because Ta'aroa was an artist, he created the world, and then summoned the other artists to play on the world and create its inhabitants. He created seven levels and put humans on the lowest level, but whenever humans filled up a level, they climbed to the next level. But, the legend says, even if humans filled all the levels, all still belonged to Ta'aroa. It seems that humans have now filled up the last level, and need to make decisions about what to do next. But it isn't simply black and white. We may need to remember that Ta'aroa is still in charge, and creativity is what started everything in motion so creativity needs to be our way out.

I've written a lot here while not really mentioning the plot or the characters or the book - those are covered adequately in publisher's blurbs and other reviews, and they are yours to discover. My goal with this review is to try and convey some of the life-altering magic I discovered here.

Many thanks to Norton and NetGalley for the opportunity to review this important work.

Was this review helpful?

A moving tale of love between humans and the love the oceans. Beautiful in the scope of language and landscape, this mesmerizing saga will leave you breathless and emotional.

Was this review helpful?

I loved The Overstory and Bewilderment, but I think this is Powers' best book yet. All the intertwined storylines and characters are engaging and the environmental theme isn't at all forced. One surprise for me is that Powers dealt with race in America I think he did an excellent job. I read Playground over 2 days during a 5 day power and cell outage in my community after a severe storm. . There were so many things I wanted to research while I was reading, but I had to wait a few days. That seemed fitting. I highly recommend this beautiful book.

Was this review helpful?

Note: I received a copy of this book in exchange for my honest opinion. Thank you, NetGalley and publishers.

“The fate of continents is written in water.” Beloved author Richard Powers delivers another meditation on the human experience and life on earth, intertwined as it is. Rather than the forests of the (bestseller) Overstory, the focus here is on the ocean, and lives throughout time and place. Read this. It’s beautiful,

Was this review helpful?

What can I say. It may be that you are new to Richard Powers, or, like me, fell in love with The Goldbug Variations and have read everything since. Powers is the master at exploring a scientific or musical topic in the framework of the novel. (Goldbug - DNA sequencing+ Bach.) Playground expands to encompass human survival and technology with a cast of characters and settings that encompass years and miles. Thia may not be the best entry point to Powers but is a superb novel and is on the Booker long list.

Was this review helpful?

This book covers many topics throughout- 21st-century technology, climate change, statements on society, friendship, and activism . The book is written in a few points of view.

I found the plot line a little bit two heavy / deep for me — I really had to sit down and focus solely on this book in a quiet room to grasp everything that was happening -coupling that with the fact that I found it hard to relate to or connect /stay engaged with the characters didn’t work for me.

The writing is excellent for literary fiction and if my state of mind was in the right place for this book , I would likely have been able to enjoy it more, but the topics are important.

Thanks to Netgalley and W. W. Norton & Company for this ARC . This is my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

A Black boy escaping Chicago’s South Side through his brilliance. A white boy from Evanston who is his intellectual equal. An intensely creative young Pacific Islander woman. A French Canadian who discovers her life passion when she slips below the waves to scuba dive. Over decades, these four characters come together in life-changing ways. Inspired by the diver, the boy from Evanston will discover coding and go on to become the billionaire founder of a gamified social platform. The South Side boy will pursue literature and writing–and the Pacific Islander will become a visual artist whose art changes lives. Decades later their paths will cross again on a tiny island in the South Pacific, where the island residents are voting on whether to serve as a launch point for a utopian free-floating island society. And, over the course of the novel, the future of Earth’s oceans–and humankind–will be decided through the crisscrossing stories of these people.

Told through multiple interweaving points of view, PLAYGROUND is filled with Powers’ trademark attention to the natural world–with scientifically detailed, inspiring, and beautiful descriptions of the ocean flora and fauna. It builds in similar ways to Powers’ Pulitzer Prize-winning THE OVERSTORY (across characters and over time), but more slowly. While it doesn’t quite have the dramatic tension and sheer emotional power of THE OVERSTORY, it still tells a beautiful, moving, and urgent story of humanity’s potential to destroy the worlds and ecosystems we need. Lovers of climate fiction and the natural world will get much from this novel.

Was this review helpful?