Member Reviews
Anthologies are always so hard to review and rate because they’re all short stories. So lately I’ve been rating each individual story and then taking the average. For the most part it turns out to be accurate enough for me. As for reviewing, I just tell you a bit about those that I liked and those that I didn’t. That way you get an accurate look at the whole book.
This one starts off with a bang! And no I don’t mean the first story, I mean the message board that brings the anthology together. I’ve told y’all time and time again that I’m a sucker for books with text messages or social media, so this was no different. Add on to the fact that we see every genre of horror depicted in this, I was too excited! I was ready for this to wow me. And some of the stories definitely did! (Fair warning, they do get more gruesome and more gorey as the anthology goes on!)
The stories I liked were so damn good I had to sit with them for a minute. Like the one by Tiffany D. Jackson. (Of course I loved that one lol) I was a bit confused on where it was going, but when I got to the end, I was staring at the wall. In true TDJ fashion I was shook. I also loved the one by H.E. Edgmon. Yo, I stayed up a little longer to read the next story after that because that one kinda freaked me out. I am not scared of a lot of horror, but the subject of that one always freaks me out lol And of course I loved the one by Chloe Gong. I’ve never read anything by her, but this was my favorite sub-genre of horror and I LOVED it. It is gorey tho so tread carefully. But I mean, when isn’t a book/movie in one of those? And the one by Karen Strong and T.J. Benton-Walker were also good af. And I don’t usually like those sub-genres. I also really liked Alexis Henderson’s. I’ve never read anything by her before, so this was my wake-up call to do so! But my favorite of ALL of them? Definitely Kendare Blake’s. I called it and everything, but it was so good!
But as usual, there were also some I wasn’t a fan of. The one by Abida Jaigirdar was just weird. I wanted so much more from that one. I thought maybe it was just me because I’m not a huge fan of that sub-genre, but someone else who read it said they didn’t care for it either. The one by Lamar Giles and Mark Oshiro and Naseem Jamnia were all good, but not necessarily memorable. And in an anthology with all these big names, you gotta be more than just good. Because the others didn’t come to play! Kalynn Bayron and Faridah’s wasn’t bad, but I just didn’t feel like they were scary.
This was an interesting book and I really loved the way they pulled everything together. Definitely hoping there’s another one in the future because this one was fun. Some of them were weird, but some of them were really good! I hope y’all pick this up!
Astonishing! Breathtaking! Downright scary! These stories are everything you could ask for in a horror anthology. Each one is unique in its own way—not only because of their topics but also their perspectives and writing styles. I found myself not wanting to put these stories down, and the audiobook only added to the spookiness of it all. I loved so many of these authors before I began this collection and will definitely be checking out the novels of the authors I did not know. I cannot recommend this book enough. If you are looking for liberating yet terrifying stories, look no further. Know that yes, the White Guy Dies First, but it does not mean he also dies last.
My favorites in the book were "All Eyes on Me," "The Protege," and "Everything's Coming Up Roses."
Just as the title states, The White Guy Dies First: 13 Scary Stories of Fear and Power features thirteen horror stories written by a diverse set of authors and each story contains a common element: the white guy is the first victim. I really enjoyed this anthology! It was a lot of fun and featured various horror subgenres and tropes such as clowns, cannibalism, slashers, post-apocalyptic, and haunted houses to name a few. I enjoyed some stories more than others, but the standouts for me were: All Eyes On Me by Faridah Àbíké-Íyímídé, Docile Girls by Chloe Gong, Everything’s Coming Up Roses by Tiffany D. Jackson (probably my favorite), and Break Through Our Skin by Naseem Jamnia. Some of the stories I wish could’ve been longer (Coming Up Roses by Tiffany D. Jackson) while others I think would have benefited if it were a longer story (Heaven by Adiba Jaigirdar). All of the stories were entertaining though, in my opinion, and the narrators for each were really great! The only audio feature that I did not like at all was during Hell Is Other Demons by Karen Strong, and it wasn’t the writer or narrator but rather the choice to creepily bleep out the name every time it was said, it almost had me wanting to dnf that story entirely.
Factoring all of the stories together, 4 stars out of 5!
Thank you to Macmillan Audio and NetGalley for the opportunity to read and review an ARC of The White Guy Dies First: 13 Scary Stories of Fear and Power by Faridah Àbíké-Íyímídé; Kalynn Bayron; Kendare Blake; H.E. Edgmon; Lamar Giles; Chloe Gong; Alexis Henderson; Tiffany D. Jackson; Adiba Jaigirdar; Naseem Jamnia; Karen Strong; Mark Oshiro; Terry J. Benton-Walker. My comments are an independent, honest review.
Overall I am giving this book 4 Stars. I feel like it is a good average of each story individually. There were some GREAT stories, some good stories and some okay stories. Each story was very different from each other where the only thing they had in common was that a white person dies first. Sometimes no one is safe and sometimes the BIPOC people are the only safe one's and sometimes you get a white final girl AND a POC final girl. Each story being so different keeps you on your toes. The audio book was great having each story narrated by a different person as well which really lends a hand to the overall feel of each one. I think the narrators did great!
A huge thank you to McMillan Audio and NetGalley for allowing me to listen to the audio book.
My break down of ratings for each story are as follows:
1. All Eyes On Me: Fariday Abike-Iyimide - 4.5
2. Hench: Kalynn Bayron - 5
3. The Golden Dragon: Kendare Blake - 3.5
4. Best Served Cold: H.E. Edgmon - 3
5. The Protégé: Lamar Giles - 3
6. Dossal Girls: Chloe Gong - 5
7. Grey Grove: Alexis Henderson - 4
8. Everything's Coming Up Roses: Tiffany D Jackson - 4.5
9. Heaven: Adiba Jaigirdar - 3.5
10. Break Through Our Skin: Naseem Jamnia - 4
11. Wasps: Mark Oshiro - 4
12. Hell Has Other Demons: Karen Strong - 3.5
13. The Road to Hell: Terry J Benton-Walker - 4
Thanks to NetGalley and Macmillan Audio for the advanced copy.
I love a themed collection of short stories, am basically a sucker for them, and I tend to be a little biased towards them, which may be the case for this collection. I had to contemplate my rating because I read similarly themed collections recently that were absolutely fantastic (Never Whistle at Night and All These Sunken Souls), and I felt like this collection didn't quite reach my expectations for it.
My favorites from The White Guy Dies First:
The Golden Dragon by Kendare Blake - feels so much like a 90s teen horror movie, but with a j-horror spin. I'm a fan of Blake though, especially when she goes horror. I think this could be a fun novel by her.
Best Served Cold by H.E. Edgmon - my favorite of all of them, this one packs a real punch. I actually read it twice, so good and creepy.
Gray Grove by Alexis Henderson - found footage and cosmic horror are always my vibes, and I loved this take on both
Everything's Coming Up Roses by Tiffany D. Jackson - Jackson is a home-run hitter when it comes to writing. Like she's becoming one of my favorites. Her character work is just fantastic, and this is an excellent example of what she's best at. Plus it's the most fun of all the stories, imo I did this one twice too haha
The rest of the stories are good still, if maybe predictable or forgettable, but the standouts are sure to stick with you. As always I'm impressed overall and always excited to have found more new writers to explore! I loved the mix of newer talent and established writers.
I did get the audiobook galley as well, and each story is read by a different narrator, with proper representation - LOVED this. I don't think there were any bad narrators in the bunch either. As I said, I even "re-read" a few!
Plot- or character-driven? A mix Strong character development? It's complicated
Loveable characters? It's complicated
Diverse cast of characters? Yes Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.5
The White Guy Dies First: A missing Film Director, never before seen films and the new Final Girl doesn't have to be a girl!
Finally an anthology that examines Hollywood's lack of gender diversity and cultural representation of both actors, and narratives in Horror films.
How hegemonic cisheteropatriarchy and capitalism have created a
Hollywood whitewashed standard in horror films in which racial and gender diversity can only exist within the confines of stereotypical tropes in a genre that is often characterized as progressive in representation. These authors are here to show us the stories we want to see where the 'black guy'doesn't die first - it's the white guys turn, the final girl can be any gender, and the villians aren't just queer, disabled or white men.. I love the audiobook, it was very welll narrated by a range of different people representative of the pov and narrator of each short story.
I was honestly not prepared for the perfection of this anthology. Every story in here was SO good. It's so rare I can find a anthology collection where every story was a 4-5 star. So many awesome horror/slasher tropes fill the pages. It's creepy, unsettling and gory as heck and I loved every single second of this book. I will 100% be buying a copy and re-reading it cause I cannot stop thinking about some of the stories. Literally the perfect book to pick up for Halloween!
The audiobook was really great! I loved all the narrators, they all did such a great job and really added to the vibe of the book!
Thank you so much Netgalley and the publishers for a copy of the audiobook in exchange for an honest review!
The title mostly says it all: it's a horror anthology where the white guy dies first (or so it claims...there were a couple stories where I couldn't actually determine who was white and who died first?). It's definitely filled with stories about POC being the "final girl" or at least not the first to be killed off. But as with most anthologies, there were some real duds and some gems, and the duds far outweighed the gems here. The stars were mainly for Mark Oshiro, H.E. Edgmon, and Naseem Jamnia because their stories were by far the best. I think this stellar lineup of authors made my expectations way higher than they should have been, and I think this is a me thing because this happens to me a lot with anthologies. They just don't hit the same as some of these authors' full works do.
I thought this book was a great collection of scary stories where the trope of having the black guy dying first is flipped on its head, where The White Guys First. I thought the premise had hope, and I wasn't disappointed. I recommend this book for any horror film fanatic especially if you have had enough of the black guy dies first trope. I want to thank the author, the publisher, and Netgalley for giving me a copy of the audiobook, in return for an honest review.
[alc review]
Thank you to NetGalley and Macmillan Audio for providing an alc in exchange for an honest review.
The White Guy Dies First releases July 16, 2024
2.5
This anthology is comprised of 13 horror short stories, all written by bipoc authors.
The concept (and title) is brazenly bold, and while I enjoyed the first four stories, the rest that followed fell flat in terms of sticking to a more widespread theme that was cohesive. I found that the depictions of racism and microaggressions were pretty stereotypical, which ended up being underwhelming as a bipoc reader.
All Eyes on Me: queer awakening, circus clowns, mirror fun house.
Hedge: grief, loss of a parent, sibling dynamic, hedge maze.
The Golden Dragon: family restaurant, sibling dynamic, attempted SA, multi-pov, revenge ghost.
Best Served Cold: ancestral trauma, cannibalism.
The Protégé: magic, next door neighbour.
Docile Girls: school dance committee, slasher.
Gray Cove: podcast episode.
Everything’s Coming up Roses: journal entries, restraining order, serial killer.
Heaven: gated community, dystopian, did not feel YA or on theme with any of the other stories.
Break Through Our Skin: transgender/nonbinary, academic, archaeology.
Wasps: residential dispute.
Hell Is Other Demons: demon summoning.
The Road to Hell: ghosts, sentient haunted house.
Short story collections can be a bit of a crapshoot, but I liked if not loved nearly all of the stories in this collection. I also appreciated that there was a bit of a frame narrative that the stories fit into. The White Guy Dies First collects 13 horror stories, some of which span other genres like science fiction and fantasy, by Black, Indigenous, and person of color authors including a number of queer ones. Overall I thought it was a very strong collection and I'll list my favorites...
The Golden Dragon by Kendare Blake follows a Korean girl deserving of revenge.
Best Served Cold by HE Edgemon puts a creepy twist on the Indigenous Skinwalker mythology in a way that is gory and cinematic.
Gray Grove by Alexis Henderson explores the dark side of true crime podcasts.
Wasps by Mark Oshiro has predatory gentrifiers and dark monsters
Definitely worth a read! The audiobook is excellent and has a full cast. I received an audio review copy via NetGalley, all opinions are my own.
I really enjoyed this horror anthology. The fact that the authors and narrators are people of color made it even better. This was such a diverse body of work. This book is labeled at YA horror, but I feel as though adults will enjoy this. I know vI enjoy a lot of YA books. I liked all the stories, some more than others. Yet they were all good stories. My favorite was Everything’s Coming Up Roses by Tiffany D. Jackson. I listened to this audiobook in between other books to break the stories up. Typically the black person dies first or early on in horror movies. My favorite part, outside of the people of color being featured, is that the arrogant white guy dies first!
Thank you NetGalley and Macmillan Audio for the ALC in exchange for my honest review.
About a year or so ago I read the book The Black Guy Dies First, which was a really interesting exploration of of Black horror cinema. Now editor Terry J. Benton-Walker bring us a collection of 13 short horror stories that flips the script on that old trope. This is a wild collection of stories, some more disturbing than others, that explore all sorts of horrors. I love that this collection showcases diverse voices in horror, while not using diversity as just some kind of gimmick. Loved many of these stories. I liked the subtle unanswered mystery in ‘Hedge’, and absolutely loved the twisted brutality of ‘Best Served Cold’. No matter what type of horror you prefer, you’re sure to find a number of stories you’ll enjoy. The numerous narrators all delivered excellent performances. This one is definitely worth the time. I’d like to thank Macmillan Audio and NetGalley for the opportunity to listen to an advanced copy of the audio version of The White Guy Dies First.
https://www.amazon.com/review/R5UG4UMIX7JFK/ref=pe_1098610_137716200_SRTC0204BT_cm_rv_eml_rv0_rv
*ARC Review*
I will be the first to admit I am not a horror person because I am a giant baby, however, this was so good and I’m glad I took a chance on it. This anthology covered horror across multiple mediums to provide social critiques which I think is a pillar of excellent horror. Each story had a unique voice and the overall theme of the anthology was so interesting. This has made me more curious about exploring horror in books.
I also would like to state that the multiple narrators is a huge selling point in this anthology, having a diverse narrator cast to read diverse stories is critical.
Thank you Netgalley for the Audio version of this book! I was familiar with several authors before listening to this audiobook. I have also heard a few of the narrators on other audiobooks. This is a great assembly of narrators. Some do an excellent job bringing the story to life!
This is a series of short stories, authored by BIPOC writers. Each story is about someone besides the person of color dying first! Several are stories of power, disillusion, or survival. Several are scary, and the narrator does a great job helping you feel scared and disturbed.
This would be a great book for Summerween or to enjoy in October!
Superb. Simply a Superb collection of 13 stories. While all were good, I did favor two specifically: Everything's Coming Up Roses and Best Served Cold.
I actually wish thar Everything's Coming Up Roses was like a novella, because I could have done with some more to that story.
Best Served Cold. Now that's a terrifying horror story for sure. Even knowing that yellow eyes was going to turn out that way, just the way it was set up gave me chills. If there is another indigenous dark fiction anthology like Never Whistle At Night, this would belong right in it.
Mad respect to all the authors who helped with this collection. They were all so good.
Wonderfully narrated.
I appreciate the diverse storytelling from each author, including some favorites.
Each story was creepy, scary, spooky, some with satire, all around great stories to get lost in.
I think this could make a great movie or mini series, it would mirror AHS!
I really loved this anthology. From the prologue to the last story, I had a great time. Now, I didn't love all the stories as much as the next but overall, this was truly great.
I'm always scared I won't connect to the characters in a short story because it's so short but that really wasn't the case there.
Truly, just a great anthology with a great concept and great execution. I have to give a little mention to Tiffany D. Jackson's story because it was my favorite but I really loved this book as a whole.
I will look into more stories by all of these authors.
Rounding up to 2.5 stars.
I think what's really tough about books with multiple authors is that there are some that are impeccable and there are some that... aren't. I love LOVED the premise of this book and of course the title of it as well. It was incredibly refreshing to see unsurprisingly have the white guy... die first in each story. Some of the short stores shook me more to my core and others... others were just plain weird weird weird.
I'd recommend these from the book if you're going to pick it up:
Everything's Coming Up Roses by Tiffany D. Jackson
Break Through Our Skin by Naseem Jamnia
Hell is Other Demons by Karen Strong
Creepy creepy creepy stories. Had to stop and restart listening a few times because it was so disturbing.