Second in the Blue Moon series but it totally works as a standalone.

As the story progressed the romance got really, really good.

Lucy Score is the queen of small town romances. This book felt like the perfect mix of cozy and spicy which is also one of the biggest trends in romance this season (cozy spice). I recommend this series to anyone who loved the Dream Harbor series or is a fan of Gilmore Girls.

Lucy Score's writing is always so easy and comforting, though this book definitely fell short of her other, more popular books (like Everything We Hide From the Light.) A s a cozy fall read I wouldn't necessarily recommend it over other books but I wouldn't NOT recommend it! Love Lucy Score's writing as always :)

Beckett Pierce’s interest is piqued. The buttoned-up lawyer / town mayor is eager to meet the newest town resident after catching a glimpse of her through the window of her yoga studio. She may not be his usual type, but something about her catches his attention.

But then he finds out that she’s his newest tenant, occupying the guest house in his backyard with her two children.

And her father is dating his mother.

And it looks like things are getting serious there.

The odds may be stacked against them, but will Beckett and Gianna be able to resist temptation and stay away from each other?

At a glance:
- Dual POV
- Small town
- Single parent
- Landlord/tenant
- Neighbors
- A bit of a forbidden romance
- Opposites attract
- No-strings attached
- Matchmaking town
- Second book in a series

Read it for
- The Pierce family
- The matchmaking scheme
- How Beckett interacts with Gianna’s kids
- Gianna's father

I received a copy of the ebook from Bloom Books. All review opinions are my own.

I think I am in love with Beckett Pierce! This slow burn will have you in your feels! Especially if you love the single mom trope- which I do 100%! I am obsessed with the kids calling him Bucket 😂 I need to go back and read book 1 ASAP to see Summer and Carter because they are adorable in this! Can’t wait to see what’s in store for me in book 3!!

The romance was little too quick- instant love with not a ton of connection. The main male character was not sympathetic. The miscommunication that broke them up was very harsh from him and I did not see how the female main character could forgive him and get back together with him so easily. The way they get back together also seemed very manipulative and it did not make sense for them to be together the way the book ended.

Gianna and her kids had to make a hard decision (but what was best for them) to leave their old life behind and start over. Their new community welcomed her and her yoga studio with open arms and the towns mayor swept her off her feet! I absolutely loved this book. Will definitely recommend!

First things first, I love how authentic and genuine the characters in this book felt. In this story, Beckett Pierce, the town’s mayor, and Gia Decker, a yoga instructor and single mom of two, are both wonderfully flawed individuals. Beckett, struggling with his attraction to a woman who is not his usual type, and Gia, juggling motherhood and a new business, are relatable and grounded in a way that makes their journey all the more compelling. It’s a romance that feels real, with characters whose imperfections make them endearing.

One of the highlights of this book is the realistic depiction of family life, especially with Gia’s two kids, Evan and Aurora. Evan, a wise-beyond-his-years pre-teen, and Aurora, a fiercely lovable five-year-old, bring depth and humor to the story. Their presence adds a layer of warmth to Beckett and Gia's relationship, as they navigate the complexities of blending lives and families. As someone who grew up in a blended family, I thought the way that Score handled the situation was realistic and poignant.

Overall, Fall Into Temptation is a charming, fun, and at times frustrating read, but it’s also a story full of heart. Lucy Score has crafted a tale where opposites attract, but it’s the characters' growth and the slow burn of their relationship that make the payoff so satisfying. Beckett and Gia’s journey from tentative attraction to a strong, loving partnership, with a healthy dose of humor and family bonds, and left me smiling. I loved the setting of Blue Moon and its eccentric matchmaking crew - it was so full of charm and whimsy! I can't wait to read more books in this series!

REVIEW: Fall Into Temptation by Lucy Score

Lucy Score's Fall into Temptation shows that the enemies-to-lovers trope is still alive and kicking, especially in the hands of a skilled author. Set in the charming little town of Blue Moon Bend, this book mixes witty banter, genuine emotions, and some serious chemistry.

Our main characters, Gianna and Beckett, are wonderfully flawed and relatable. Their initial bickering feels natural, not forced. With Gianna trying to save her family's legacy and Beckett wanting to prove himself, some genuine conflict goes deeper than just misunderstandings. Score nails their relationship with clever dialogue that had me laughing and swooning.

The small-town vibe is a big win here. The secondary characters add richness without stealing the spotlight, and the local businesses and traditions make Blue Moon Bend feel like a place you'd want to visit.

What I loved most was the pacing. The journey from enemies to allies to lovers unfolds smoothly, with each step feeling earned through growth and shared experiences. The chemistry between Gianna and Beckett is electric right from their first encounter, and Score does a great job of letting the tension build before everything explodes.

Sure, the plot leans on some familiar romance tropes, but Score's strong writing and character development elevate the story. The only tiny downside is that the resolution in the final act felt a bit rushed compared to how carefully the rest of the story was built up.

You will love this book if you're into contemporary romance with a good mix of heart and heat. Score has crafted a satisfying read that feels both cozy and fresh. It is perfect for fans of small-town romances and enemies-to-lovers stories, especially if you appreciate well-developed characters along with romantic tension.

Thank you, Netgalley and SOURCEBOOKS Bloom Books, for the free advanced copy for my honest review!

This is a real feel good read that makes you laugh, cry and be surprised. Nice and flowy writing and nice characters that are well-depicted. Thank you to NetGalley, the author and the publisher for the eARC in exchange for an honest review.

This is my first book by Lucy Score. I loved her clean romance and how she depicts the characters. I fell in love with Gia myself. What a strong woman to live that life in this hectic and crazy world! I loved the positivity in this book. I will definitely be checking other books by this author, especially the books in this Blue Moon series.

The most perfect book for fall! Cute, quick, and easy read to get you in the fall mood. I have yet to read a Lucy Score book I didn't like. She is my auto-buy author every time because she just doesn't miss.
The banter is top tier and there's a delicate playfulness to it that doesn't seem overdone. I love Gia and Beckett, they might be my favorite characters that she's written!

Every book I read by Lucy Score cements her as one of my favorite, must read authors. She writes characters and communities that are interesting and that I want to know and be part of. The interactions between the main characters, Gia and Beckett, strikes the right balance between sweetness, banter, caring, tension, and heat. The sweet and quirky town of Blue Moon and all of its inhabitants added interest and depth to the story. This was a book that I enjoyed thoroughly and I want to read all of the other books in this series. I highly recommend this book to readers that like their rom-coms with quirky small towns, interesting characters, and a nice balance of sweetness and heat.

This romance novel enchants with a heartfelt story of love that grows in the most unexpected places, drawing readers in with its relatable characters and authentic chemistry. The author’s vivid descriptions bring each setting to life, creating a beautiful backdrop that enhances every heartfelt moment. Both uplifting and tender, this book offers an irresistible escape and a reminder of love's transformative power.

**Review of *Fall into Temptation* by Lucy Score**

Lucy Score's *Fall into Temptation* is a delightful and entertaining romance that captures the charm and chaos of small-town life with a perfect blend of humor and heart. Set in the nosiest town in upstate New York, the story follows the brooding Beckett Pierce and the fiercely independent Gianna Decker, both of whom are navigating the challenges of love, family, and personal growth.

Beckett, the town’s most eligible bachelor, has had his fill of romantic entanglements after a comical disaster with his last girlfriend. His reluctance to get involved is understandable, especially when Gianna, a single mom juggling a new yoga studio and her chaotic life, moves into his orbit. The chemistry between them is undeniable, filled with tension and sizzling moments that keep readers hooked. Their accidental stolen kisses are both playful and electric, showcasing Score's talent for crafting romantic scenes that feel both genuine and exciting.

Gianna’s character is refreshing—she’s strong, relatable, and fiercely dedicated to her children and her new business. Her internal struggles about finding love while managing her responsibilities add depth to her character and make her journey all the more engaging. Beckett’s growth as he grapples with his feelings for Gianna is equally satisfying, as he learns to embrace vulnerability and the possibility of love again.

The supporting cast of quirky townsfolk adds an extra layer of charm to the story, bringing plenty of laughter and unexpected moments. The way the community interacts with and complicates Beckett and Gianna's budding romance keeps the plot lively and fun.

Overall, *Fall into Temptation* is a beautifully written romantic comedy that perfectly balances humor, passion, and heartfelt moments. Lucy Score has crafted a story that is not only entertaining but also resonates with themes of family, self-discovery, and the transformative power of love. This book is a must-read for anyone looking for a lighthearted escape filled with relatable characters and unforgettable moments. You’ll find yourself laughing out loud and cheering for Beckett and Gianna every step of the way!

Lucy Score can do no wrong! I love her books, how she gets to the heart of all the family relationships while telling a steamy story at the same time! I can’t wait for The Last Second Chance! Read this one!!

Another win for Lucy Score with this re-release of Book 2 in the Blue Moon Series.

Fall into Temptation tells the story of grumpy Blue Moon mayor Beckett Pierce and his new tenant, the single mom Gianna. Neither one of them are looking for love, but the more time they spend together, the hotter things get. Gianna wants to protect her kids (the younger of which hilariously calls Beckett "Bucket") and her heart, but can "Bucket" be resisted?

I have loved everything I have previously read from Lucy Score, and this was no exception. I really like the way she writes her stories and the characters and how they develop throughout the stories. I love the charming small-town setting of Blue Moon and the comfort it brings when reading. It made me feel as though I was a part of their world. You truly cannot go wrong with a Lucy Score book. I will recommend to others and look forward to future titles.

Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for the ARC to review. All opinions are my own.

Fall into Temptation by Lucy Score is an absolute delight, set in the charming town of Blue Moon—a place so vibrant it feels like a character all on its own. The story follows Beckett, the town’s selfless, rooted mayor, and Gia, a single mom juggling two kids, a yoga studio, and a full plate of responsibilities. When these two go from landlord and tenant to something more, their chemistry lights up every page.

This book gave Beckett and his brothers room to grow and bond. To really dive into some of their backstory and not just focus on the blossoming love. I really enjoyed it and think it sets the reader up to stick with the series. Blue Moon shines in this series, with its quirky, close-knit vibe that makes you wish you could visit. Lucy Score brings humor, warmth, and heart to this small-town romance, and I can’t wait to dive back into Blue Moon for more.

Thank you Bloom & Netgalley for the ebook in exchange for my honest review.

3.75 stars

Second in the Blue Moon series, I found myself liking this one slightly more than the first, as I usually do in series, since I was more familiar with the characters and town setting. However, there were still personalities and situations that rubbed me a little the wrong way, so I wouldn't say I necessarily loved this one either.

Beckett Pierce is the responsible middle Pierce brother, town lawyer and mayor of Blue Moon Bend at just 28 years old, and the one who stuck around when things got hard and his beloved father, John, passed away. When flighty Gianna Decker comes to town to take over the yoga studio, and rents his backyard cottage with her two children, he finds himself uncharacteristically drawn to her. Complicating matters besides the fact that he's her landlord and she has the baggage of a complicated former marriage, she is also the daughter of Franklin Merrill, Beckett's mother's new boyfriend and the man he feels is trying to usurp John's memory. Although I liked Beckett best of the brothers in the first book, his actions in this one were bratty, immature, and insecure. He even said some incredibly misogynistic things to Gia, that as a mother who sometimes questions what would be the best move to make for my children in the long run, left my jaw hanging. It took the manipulation of the town to get both of them to see sense again after Beckett's jump to conclusions in a drawn out third act miscommunication and breakup. Even though Beckett was an idiot, he at least had a personality, which is more than I can say for his older brother Carter.