Dear Rebel Witch,
I absolutely adored you. You are such a fun twist on the rules of magic and your world is a fascinating place for me. Getting to dive deeper into Rune's intrigues and plots as she fights to save her fellow witches and the world she wants to go back to. Gideon and Rune have such an amazing push and pull that defines their relationship and I just lost myself in how they played with each other. I truly loved everything about this duology, and will totally read anything else that Ciccarelli writes!

You know a book is amazing when you finish it and stare off for 30 minutes still transfixed and not ready to leave the world just yet. This duology was a fantastic read and I am absolutely recommending it to all my fellow readers!

I’m sad this duology is over! Heartless Hunter was one of my favorite books of last year and Rebel Witch wrapped up Rune and Gideon’s story nicely. I loved seeing the romance between them develop and also see the characters develop individually as well. I would have actually loved for there to have been a third book so that more storylines could have been fleshed out more. Overall I love this duology so much and will continue recommending to everyone I know!

This absolutely stunning conclusion to the Crimson Moth duology truly took my breath away. It kicked off with everyone’s favorite romance tropes, and concluded in an epic exploration of war, humanity, and self discovery. The characters and locations crafted by Ciccarelli are extremely rich and unique in their nature, making this story the perfect playground for the young adult audience it’s aimed at, who are still growing and learning themselves. Everything from the magic system to the relationships, that completely tug on your heart strings, are ripe for discussion and further exploration through fandom, fanfiction, potential spin off series’, adaptations and more! This duology is the gift that keeps on giving and will stay with you forever! As a teen librarian, this is going to be an auto recommend for many years to come. While being sexy and action packed, it ultimately teaches lessons of compassion and equality. It explores these themes and more in such an exciting fashion that is sure to captivate any reader willing to give it a shot. It was tough to put down, and I’m SO looking forward to diving into more from the author to come!

Rune and Gideon are back in this Heartless Hunter Sequel! After Gideon leaves Rune for dead and Run escapes with Cressienda, we are thrown into Rune being engaged to a new man. Gideon is determined to find Rune and bring her back for execution, but come on, we know Gideon cannot do that to Rune. Rune and Gideon find their way back to each other in a "platonic" way. Each has something the other wants, so they work together to return to the mainland. While pretending to be a married couple on a ship back home, these two are playing games behind each other's backs, planning who will kill the other first.

I love Rune and Gideon; I am so happy they are getting to tell the end of their story. I was a bit frustrated with the constant back and forth of "will they won't they". I felt that a lot of the start of the book was Gideon saying he could not be with Rune because she loved Alex, when, as the reader, you know that is not the case. Regardless, these two were able to tell each other the truth and let true love prevail.

Thank you, NetGalley and St Martins, for this arc!!

Fantastic way to end a duology. I loved this story, loved Gideon, loved Rune. The will they wont they, the secrets, the betrayals. It was all fantastic.

I’m literally obsessed with this series. I’m unwell. I just… I’m going to need at least 2 weeks to stare at a wall after reading this book.

this duology has my heart. I’m not sure I can ever love a series more than I love this one.

Rune and Gideon—witch and witch hunter—are back and picked up right where the first book left off. the tension? palpable. the slow burn? excruciating in the best way. the supposed to be enemies, but fate has other plans, forcing them to work together toward a shared goal. expect betrayal, backstabbing, high-stakes action, stowaways, hostages, one bed 🔥, a fake marriage, and, of course, plenty of ✨magic✨.

this book wrecked me. and i’d love to be continued to be wrecked by this author. my heart aches. my eyes are still leaking. i could barely put this book down. I love this world and these characters so much, and I hate that this is likely the end.

i would give this author my entire soul to give me more books.

Thank you to NetGalley and St. Martin's Press for an e-ARC copy of Rebel Witch by Kristen Ciccarelli in exchange for an honest review.

Just a stupid girl with a stupid heart. That is what Rune Winters thinks of herself when she regards the last few months. If she had never trusted Gideon Sharpe, never fallen in love with him, then she would be less devastated about what she already knew. He believed that all witches were monsters and that she was no different. Rune tries to push Gideon from her mind as she slips into her socialite facade to aid Cressida in her plan to return witches to their former glory. Unwilling to let that happen, Gideon steels his heart as he accepts what he must do to stall Cressida's plans... he must kill Rune Winters.

**Spoilers in below review**

I really liked this duology and I think it definitely fits the enemies to lovers trope. Gideon truly hated witches (and had justifying trauma for why) and Rune truly hated witch hunters (again, justifying trauma). They already had no reason to have feelings for each other and especially not after the heartbreaking betrayal at the end of the first book. I liked that their dynamic went from enemies to lovers to enemies and that, while they hated each other, they involuntarily desperately wanted to other to soothe the pains they had caused. It is a very confusing feeling when the one person you want to comfort you in your pain is the very person who caused it. I do think that the missing heir plot was incredibly predictable and made the plot fall a little flat. I did like the first book better than this one, but I am also content with the ending and glad that it was a duology. I think some authors lean into the cash cow of stretching series out unnecessarily and that was not the case here. Excited to see what Ciccarelli puts out in the future!

Rebel Witch is the second and final book in the Crimson Moth duology. I thought it was a fantastic ending to this story! I enjoyed that we started right off back in the action. In fact, the action truly didn’t let up until the last pages of the book. I enjoyed the further world building that we got. I realize that I haven't read a lot of fantasy books involving witches when I read Heartless Hunter, and I loved learning more about this world. I was very entertained throughout the book. The only downfall, at times, was that it felt a bit repetitive, and sometimes the pacing fell off a bit, but then the reader was sucked right back in when the twists were coming from left and right. I thought the tension between Rune and Gideon was definitely palpable. I left wishing there were maybe a bit more of the spicy scenes, but I realize that wasn’t the point of the book. At the end, I felt like we got a great resolution to the story and all of the important characters throughout the book. I loved my time reading this duology and will look to future books from Ciccarelli in the future.

Many thanks to NetGalley and the publishers for an advanced reading copy of this book. All opinions within this review are my own.

Rebel Witch is the sequel/conclusion to Heartless Hunter, a duology that follows Rune and Gideon — a witch and a witch hunter. It’s a cat-and-mouse, Mr. and Mrs. Smith type story where the two are constantly outwitting each other and, unwittingly, falling in love. If you want a real enemies-to-lovers YA fantasy filled with betrayals and close calls, this is it. I’d also recommend this duology for anyone who loved the fast-paced drama in Caraval.

I am obsessed with this duology. Rebel Witch is so fun and every bit as entertaining as Heartless Hunter. From the very first page, you are thrust right back into the thick of things. The stakes are high, and again I found myself very compelled by Gideon’s story and character arc.

(Side note: this is definitely upper YA, and if you are coming to the series for the first time/buying it for a young person, I would definitely recommend looking up some of the content warnings first, especially as they relate to Gideon.)

As a Scarlet Pimpernel fan, I do believe, in my heart of hearts, that Kristen Ciccarelli wrote this duology for me specifically. (And for that, I say thank you.) It captures the spirit of the original work so well, while also alleviating one of the major problems I have with the source material — Orczy’s uncritical portrayal of the nobility. This is a duology that I will definitely be rereading in the future whenever I need a quick pick-me-up.

his was a overall a great ending to this duology. I loved the intensity that lasted throughout the book but I did feel that the ending seemed a bit rushed. I will miss these characters!

4.5 ⭐️

Thank you Wednesday Books for the gifted physical and digital copies. Thank you PRH for the gifted audio copy.

Rebel Witch
Kristen Ciccarelli
Publishing Date: February 18, 2025
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️💫

🎧 Narrator: Grace Gray 🎧

One of my most anticipated reads of 2025 and it did not disappoint! I absolutely adore this duology.

Rune and Gideon, witch and witch hunter, are back and we start up shortly after the first book’s conclusion. The tension is thick and the burn is slowwwww as these two try to navigate the current state of things. They are enemies, or at least trying to be, when they are forced to work together to accomplish a common goal. There is action, betrayal, backstabbing, hostages, stowaways, one bed 🔥, fake marriage, and of course ✨ magic ✨

I won’t say much else as everyone should experience this duology for themselves. If you were a fan of Heartless Hunter (aka Crimson Moth) you will surely be a fan of its conclusion. Totally binge worthy but I didn’t want it to end!

🎧 I read this one tandem with my eyes and ears. Grace Gray did a fantastic job narrating. You can’t go wrong with either format here!

Rune Winters has been on the run since Gideon Sharpe, the man she loved, revealed who she was and delivered her to enemy hands. If Rune wants to survive, she must ally herself with Cressida Roseblood, the witch who intends to take back the Republic and reinstate a Reign of Witches. Gideon won’t allow the Republic to fall to witches… and to prevent this from happening, every witch must die. When Rune makes Gideon an offer he can’t refuse, they pair together to accomplish their goals.

REBEL WITCH makes a fantastic sequel to Heartless Hunter, picking up where its predecessor left off. It’s told in dual POV, alternating between Rune’s, a witch, and Gideon’s, a witch hunter, perspectives. Both of the main characters are intriguing and well-written. I couldn’t get enough of either of them. The romance is swoon-worthy and, at times, bittersweet. I loved the push and pull that occurs in this cat-and-mouse relationship.

The plot is fast paced, filled with action, deception, secrets, and lies. There’s ample amounts of political tension and witchy magic. It took me a long while to be convinced that this novel would truly complete this duology but by the end I was satisfied. The ending is well done, although there is one aspect of it that felt a bit too open of a conclusion; nevertheless, it ends nicely with no loose ends.

Needless to say, I’ll be keeping my eye out for whatever Cicarreli writes next!

I would like to thank Netgalley and the publisher, Wednesday Books, of this advanced digital copy for the opportunity to read this novel in exchange for an honest review! All opinions expressed are my own.

3.5 stars!

I didn't enjoy it as much as the first book, but it was still a nice conclusion to the duology. The first two parts of the book had a little too much lusting in my taste (particularly from Gideon), but I did enjoy the third act, as we get to see action from other supporting characters. I would have liked more, but of course, the series is focused on Rune and Gideon. The romance was also better towards the end, in my opinion.

This one started off so strong for me. I was absolutely loving the enemies-to-lovers vibes at the beginning, with Rune and Gideon coming fresh off the betrayals that ended the previous book. It even has a couple other tropes I love in the beginning, too. But then something happened about midway through, and I felt like all of a sudden things were being rushed. I think I actually would have liked this better if it had been split into a trilogy instead of this duology, so some parts of the plot could be explored more. The second half pacing does not slow down, though- only speeds up, so I at least didn’t lose interest. But I wasn’t quite a fan of how everything played together so perfectly towards the end.

If you loved the first book, I think you’ll still love this conclusion to the series. (I feel like I might be an outlier here!) It’s still a fun read that I would recommend to other romantasy fans.

What an exciting conclusion to the Crimson Moth/Heartless Hunter duology!!! I went into this one with very high hopes and it did not disappoint!!

I don’t want to give too much away since this is the second book in the duology and I don’t want to spoil anything for those who haven’t read the first book - but I loved the way the main characters were brought back together after the cliffhanger ending of The Crimson Moth (or Heartless Hunter depending on if you have the American or European versions).

The characters in general were great. I really enjoyed how multifaceted the main characters, Rune and Gideon were. Their relationship is often described as enemies to lovers but they’re not really - maybe rivals would be more accurate? Though I’d describe them as two people who are clearly in love but forced to be enemies due to circumstances out of their control who need to decide whether to put themselves or their lover first.

The world building was also good. It was political without weighing the reader down with a complicated system to try and comprehend- it was a unique world with a unique magic system that was very straightforward and easy to follow. The pacing was also great with a good balance between character development and action to move the plot forward. I couldn’t put it down!

Overall, I couldn’t recommend this duology more. If you’re a romantasy girly and you haven’t picked this up yet - what are you waiting for?!?!

Rebel Witch, the stunning conclusion to Kristen Ciccarelli's latest duology, is an absolute masterpiece that had me spellbound from start to finish. After attending the author's release party signing and spending a magical night buddy reading with friends, I can confidently say this series exemplifies everything I love about reading.

What makes this book particularly special is how Ciccarelli weaves an enchanting narrative that completely immerses you in her imaginative world. The storytelling is both powerful and intimate, creating an experience that reminds me why being a reader is such a precious gift - we get to live countless lives through the creative vision of talented authors.

This duology is, quite simply, pure magic. A stellar 5-star read that I cannot recommend highly enough.

Review to come across my socials!

OH MY GOSH THIS WAS SO GOOD!!!! I love this duology with all my heart 😍 It’s so easy to read and has such beautiful prose. The characters are amazing and the romance oh my gosh is so good! Rune and Gideon will forever have my heart. The rollercoaster of emotions was crazy and I was on the edge of my seat for the entire book! I read this with one of my best friends and we were screaming the whole time! I honestly don’t even know how to articulate how good this series is. I wish it had been longer but I’m very satisfied with the ending as well. I can’t wait to see what Kristen writes next! I also need to read her backlist ASAP.

If I were rating on vibes alone as a regular reader, I would rate this one 4.5 stars. It's entertaining, the story is unique, it's very romantic with lots of slow burn tension. However, as an ARC reader who read this not only for enjoyment, but for critique purposes? I can't honestly rate it above a 3-3.5.

When I reread my review of Heartless Hunter (which I also read as an ARC) I found that many of the execution issues I had with that novel are present in this one. The pacing is all over the place, and it really started to drag before we left the first act, and throughout the second. The chemistry between the two main characters, Gideon and Rune, is able to flourish here, because Alex is no longer in the picture, but I still don't understand why these two fell for each other in the first place. The plot is a mess. Instead of constructing the dam (plot) piece by piece before filling the lake so that the flow of water (narrative) is smooth; the dam was built into an existing lake and constructed of pieces that are different shapes and sizes, so the water leaks like a sieve.

One of my main issues with Heartless Hunter is that there is no explanation at all for the main conflict: bad witches versus innocent humans. The reader isn't told why the witches decided to go full-on evil one day. We still don't know after reading the sequel. We do find out that there were seven goddess witches who created the world (not sure why this is relevant overall, but ok), and that they entrusted magic to witches (for reasons?), and then some of those witches decided to go off script from the goddess's plan. But we still don't know anything about what prompted the witches to do this in the first place. What was the original end game?

Also, and as in the first novel, events would occur and the solutions appeared without any foreshadowing or back story leading the reader up to them. For example, Seraphine and her true nature. Cressida's resurrection scheme. Gideon's curse. The way Cressida's sisters were disappeared off the face of the earth. There was a a lot of world building as the world was being destroyed. So while the climax was awesome, it felt like an island unto itself (pun intended) because there was no groundwork for it in the narrative.

The best part of the novel is Gideon. Rune is fun, but I have to admit she frustrated me by the end. Ultimately, their interpersonal conflict in this novel relies almost entirely on the miscommunication trope. The fact that they don't truly trust each other until the third act, and therefore were constantly second guessing each other's motives and plans, became a truly belabored point. I think that this also contributed to the pacing issue because Gideon and Rune were caught in this never-ending cycle of who's on first.

The thing is, though, I really did enjoy this read. I just had to content myself with plot points all over the place like in a pinball machine. But because I wanted to see how Gideon and Rune got together, and I wanted the good guys to win, it was satisfying by the end, even if the resolutions were too tidy and simple given how high the stakes were supposed to be.

Thank you SMP/Wednesday Books and NetGalley for the opportunity to read and review this novel prior to publication. All opinions are my own.

The Rebel Witch is a high-octane conclusion to The Crimson Moth duology that masterfully blends suspense, near-captures, and a tension-filled romance into a narrative that will leave you breathless.

Rune Winters is on the run and caught between the man she once loved and the ruthless forces who all want something from her. She must navigate a world where loyalties shift as quickly as the wind. The close calls amplify the stakes, creating a pulse-pounding narrative in which survival is never guaranteed and ensuring that every page crackles with tension.

The relationship between Rune and Gideon Sharpe continues but is scarred by past betrayal and regret, but an undeniable connection between them refuses to fade. Gideon struggles between duty and his feelings for Rune. Their complex relationship is complicated by Cressida, whose ambitions to restore the witches to power force decisions for Rune and Gideon that blur the lines and explore the high price of love.

Overall, this book delivers a finale that is full of double-crosses, forbidden romance, and adventure. It was like a race from the beginning to the last page, never letting up. I could not put the book down. The book was a satisfying end to the storyline. With high-stakes romance and suspenseful adventures, this book is a chef's kiss.

Thank you, Netgalley, St. Martin's Press, and Wednesday Books, for the opportunity to review this book honestly.