Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Framed by Jim McCloskey and John Grisham is a book full of stories about men and women convicted of murders on basically no evidence and then spending years in prison before getting justice. Imagine stopping to ask a police woman for directions only to be arrested and charged with murder less than an hour later and spending the next 24 years in prison or going to wash the family laundry and stopping to get more quarters and the next day finding out the reason the cashier was nowhere around it was because he was murdered and when you call the police to tell them what you saw you soon find yourself arrested and blamed for his murder. This book is full of egregious examples of why it is okay to believe in the system but never in the people who run it. There were those who got arrested because they were black they have those who were arrested because there were white in those who were arrested just because they were convenient you will want to throw this book across the room it made me so angry and another reason why most people don’t trust the law or policeman. The saddest part of this book was the fact there were so many stories and it in no way got close to being most of them there’s so many innocent people in prison spending years in prison just because they don’t have access to good attorneys, they get lazy detectives or it’s a campaign year. I think John Grisham and Jim McCluskey did an awesome job with the stories in this book I promise you if the stories in this book don’t move you an outrage you, you need to get therapy… I am so serious. #NetGalley,#Double day books, #Jim McCloskey, #John Grisham, #framed,

Was this review helpful?

I found "Framed" ten stories of wrongful convictions, a mind-blowing and absolute gripping read. The author's, John Grisham and Jim McCloskey each chose five meticulously researched and beautifully written stories of real people, locked up, some for decades. We should all be outraged by convictions based on ridiculous police investigations, jail-house snitches, junk science, and interrogations that are more like torturous breakdowns of the suspects ability to think. Writing "Framed" surely took incredible work and I thank the author's for this important book. I hope to see it sitting on the bestseller list for a long time. Thank you Netgalley, publisher and authors for the opportunity to read the ARC of this book.

Was this review helpful?

This is a collection of true stories of wrongful convictions as told by John Grisham and Jim McCloskey. Each story has similarities: someone is accused despite overwhelming evidence to the contrary, regardless of other evidence they are still pursued as the guilty party, appeals are usually denied, and the reader is left wondering how the heck our justice system could so blatantly fail. What is significantly different are the endings. Each wrongly convicted person has a different outcome, some much more heartbreaking than others. Although these stories weren’t easy to get through, reading this seemed to fly by. By the fourth, fifth, even tenth story I was still blown away by the incompetence of those that are supposed to carry out the law and protect its citizens. Sad to say that so many of them took place in the very state I live it, although I’m not at all surprised.
My only complaint of this book was how at times someone was referred to by their first name and then in the next sentence by their last name. Some of these situations had so many people involved it was already difficult to keep track of who was who. Besides that, this was an easy 4 1/2 ⭐️. Highly recommend.
***Thank you NetGalley, Doubleday Books, Jim McCloskey, and John Grisham for an advanced copy in exchange for an honest review.***

Was this review helpful?

Framed is a collection of ten true stories of people that have been wrongfully convicted of a crime. John Grisham writes five of the stories and Jim McCloskey writes the other five stories. Each story tells the story of someone that is wrongfully convicted of a crime. Many times law enforcement is trying to wrap up a case quickly and believes supposed "witnesses" without checking out their stories or the alibis that the convicted person may have. A lot of the stories have DNA to prove the wrongfully convicted person is innocent. You will be amazed as you read the stories and see how convoluted things can be when law enforcement is quick to judgement. Many of the people spent 20 plus years in prison before getting another trial that proved their innocence. Some of the people in these stories are still incarcerated hoping to get another trial. This is a very interesting book that is eye opening. I received a complimentary copy of this book but was not required to leave a review. #netgalley #doubledaybooks

Was this review helpful?

The subtitle is spot on--astonishing! While these true stories were hard to read, what's even harder to take is how often the authors say this happens. Gripping and evocative. For fans of true crime or anyone wanting to learn more about the justice system and wrongful convictions. Truly unbelievable!

Was this review helpful?

I've been a Grisham fan since I was a teenager, but I haven't loved his more recent books. I was really excited to find his second non-fiction book about wrongful convictions was coming out on October 15th. It was hands down the best Grisham book I've read in a long time! Thank you to Netgalley, Doubleday, John Grisham, and Jim McCloskey for the opportunity to read and review an ARC of Framed.

John Grisham partners with Jim McCloskey of Centurion Ministries, a leading organization in exonerating innocent people who've been wrongfully convicted to tell the mind-bending stories of ten different wrongful conviction cases. The mental gymnastics that were required to keep up with the corrupt police and judicial practices, trumped up motives, and outright bias in just the first chapter alone made my brain smoke, and seriously question the way America does justice. I've read several books on this topic, and each and every one of these stories are important because they showcase the dire need for reform in the justice system that never comes. There are certainly people who should be imprisoned, but jailing just one innocent person for years, decades, or taking their life is an unconscionable "travesty of justice."

Was this review helpful?

My thanks to Net Galley and Doubleday for allowing me this arc.

Framed is a college of previous wrongly convicted cases that were re tried with current technology and information. Very well written and information.

Was this review helpful?

As a loyal John Grisham fan I was delighted to be able to read this book prior to publication. I found it not to be a typical John Grisham book. This is more true crime in nature as it focuses on multiple cases where innocent people were found guilty of crimes they did not commit. It certainly highlights the fact that this country must do more in the judicial field to be sure innocent people are not placed in such situations. I found the book interesting, sad, and way too lengthy in certain situations. I hope reading this book may enlighten others.

I wish to thank Net Galley and Doubleday Books for allowing me to read an advanced copy f this book. I have voluntarily read and reviewed this advanced copy. All thoughts and opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

Very good.

In discussing with a friend, it was suggested to google "Don't Talk to the Police" (corner of YouTube has Regent University / School of Law in bottom right corner). The Fifth Amendment provides "No person ... shall be compelled in any criminal case to be a witness against himself.. The second part of this 46 min video provides some insight from Officer George Bruch of the Virginia Beach PD. People are inherently honest and/or they want to tell their story ... and people hate silence. In an interrogation room, the interviewee wants out of the room ... the detective has the opportunity for overtime. You are going to be interviewed by someone who is experienced, you are not. It's an unlevel playing field. (real world ... defendant next to defense attorney - strike 1; detective who is a professional witness - strike 2; confession - strike 3 ... this is a jury of your peers. You need to prove your innocence.) Keep your mouth shut.

Police can lie in interview/interrogation. This came up over and over in FRAMED (and also at the end of the YouTube). Don't write a confession, don't admit that they deceased was gorgeous, just take the fifth.

Framed reviews 10 cases where police wanted to close cases and people were framed. Snitches, sweetheart deals, profiling, "experts" who aren't experts or paid for their testimony. People who went to prison for decades and some who executed. Framed is eye-opening.

Dr. James Grigson (was a forensic psychiatrist ... and career witness) in two of the 10 cases. The press dubbed him Dr. Death and the American Psychiatric Assoc expelled him in 1995 for unethical conduct. He testified in 167 capital trials.

4 - 5 stars ... because there were so many characters and the chapters/individual stories now feel like they have all rather run together. Just so horrifying how interrogators and the "justice" system was able to frame these men.

Many thanks to Doubleday Publishing and NetGalley for the opportunity to review the advance read copy of Framed by John Grisham and Jim McCloskey in exchange for an honest review. 368 pages. Publication date is Oct 15, 2024. Based on the acknowledgements, the actual book will have photos ... but they were not included in the advance read copy.

Was this review helpful?

Has a wealthy white male ever been wrongfully convicted of a violent crime?

I would honestly like to know.

A 2022 report found that Black people are 7 times more likely than white people to be wrongly convicted of murder.

All wrongful convictions that I’m aware of, regardless of race, have been people from marginalized communities.

FRAMED brings us 10 cases of wrongful convictions. These men spent decades of their lives incarcerated for crimes they had nothing to do with.

Perhaps the worst part, the most appalling aspect, is that in all of these cases, the facts were right there for anyone interested in finding the truth.

The overlap in the shoddy investigations and persecutions (these were not legal prosecutions) blew my mind. Different cities, different cases, same old, tired excuse for a justice system.

I personally prefer longer, in-depth books over the kind of short case summaries presented here. Still, this is an important read that I recommend.

Was this review helpful?

This book was jointly written by two authors. Each innocence case was told by one author. Some of the cases were very wild and in some cases the story followed tangents that made the story difficult to follow. I work in corrections and frankly, criminal cases are very much like that, lots of rabbit holes. That said, some stories challenged my interest to connect the dots. Overall, I am always curious and sad about people that are found guilty and later proven innocent. The evidence in several of the cases involved was bizarre at best, it concerns me that this happens among the professionals we are to trust in the system. I think it is a good reminder to be a critical and objective thinker, and the human condition, how beliefs and emotions can impact the outcomes of matters of liberty.

Was this review helpful?

I am drawn to stories about wrongful convictions. I work in a field that is within the criminal justice area so that isn't unexpected. Our judicial system is highly flawed and sadly once someone in incarcerated, if they are innocent it's so hard for the wrong to be righted. John Grisham and Jim McCloskey each present cases that showcase wrongful convictions. The cases that Jim McCloskey showcases are ones he's worked on with his non-profit, Centurion Ministries. Because of Jim's first hand knowledge of the cases, I found his storytelling more compelling than those provided by John Grisham. It's obvious from both that a lot of research went into all the stories due to the amount of detail provided.

The more we talk about stories of wrongful convictions, the more I hope it'll help to change things in the judicial system. Unless we are willing to deal with racism in the US; however, I find that unlikely. If you think racism doesn't play a role in incarcerate, please read this book along with other stories dealing with false incarceration, such as Just Mercy and The Sing Sing Files.

Thank you to Doubleday and Netgalley for a copy in exchange for review consideration.

Was this review helpful?

Framed is a powerful and deeply moving collection of real-life stories that shine a light on the devastating impact of wrongful convictions. John Grisham and Jim McCloskey expertly present these cases with compassion, shedding light on the human toll of injustice. Each story is a reminder of the flaws within the justice system and the incredible strength of those who fought for their freedom.

The writing is sharp, engaging, and emotionally resonant, making it impossible to put down. This book is not only an engrossing read but also an important call for reform. Highly recommended for anyone interested in true crime, justice, and human resilience!

Was this review helpful?

I adore everything John Grisham writes so requesting to read this was a no-brainer. I remember reading “The Innocent Man” several years ago, and “Framed” stays with the same theme of innocent men being found guilty without a fair chance to prove otherwise.

I’m an attorney and the first to acknowledge our criminal justice system has many flaws. Co-written with Jim McCloskey, “Framed” focuses on 21 different defendants, all of whom faced egregious miscarriages of justice.

I am proud that I teach at a law school that focuses on overturning wrongful convictions. This book emphasizes the importance of pointing out that justice can be blind in particular when it comes to flaws within our criminal law system

My thanks to the author, the publisher, and NetGalley for this great read.

Was this review helpful?

There’s no one else that I would trust to write stories of wrongly convicted people more than John Grisham. I found myself going down the rabbit holes with alot of the cases in this book and it’s really an eye opener to different parts of country and the justice system. Highly recommend this book. 📖

Was this review helpful?

If there ever was required reading on true crime, this would top the list. In alternating chapters, Grisham and McCloskey present cases of justice miscarried resulting in the unwarranted incarceration of ten innocent people, many of which were railroaded into confessions after being beaten down in "interrogation" nightmares. Anyone who thinks that tv and literature depictions of police procedure is an accurate depiction should read this. What enraged me the most was the blind eye cast by authorities who would overlook exonerating material, sure that they "had their man." It took me a while to read since I had to put it down occasionally since it was so strong and disturbing, but don't let that stop anyone from what is a well written, involving page turner.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you for this book in exchange for my honest review.
This book has several interesting cases that I found myself going down the rabbit hole with. Most of the cases were unknown to me before this book, which is always exciting. The topic of real people who were wrongly convicted is something that the True Crime literature world has yet to see...until now. Also, the authors, John Grisham, and Jim McCloskey, do a fabulous job of providing detailed evidence and making the case for innocence of the men and women highlighted in the pages of this book.
One of my letdowns was when Grisham calls someone “mentally retarded” — that is not an appropriate label for someone with a mental disability or lower IQ. The new and more appropriate label would be “intellectually disabled.” In my opinion, this piece of the book needs to be altered to reflect a more kind verbiage.
Another thing that was disappointing was that towards a the end of the book, I did feel like there was too much evidence and the book could have been a lot shorter if paragraphs were cut down.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you NetGalley and the publisher for the ARC. Well This book was about the wrongful convictions of people arrested and found guilty for crimes that they didn't commit. There are still people in prison who were found guilty but they are innocent. This was horrifying to realize this really does happen. Hopefully now with DNA they can limit the number of wrongful convictions. This was so eye opening.

Was this review helpful?

John and Jim's book introduces the significant concept that justice is not always administered swiftly, fairly, or equally, a notion that has been relevant for decades and continues to be pertinent today. By incorporating real stories from across the United States, the authors provide a comprehensive view into the experiences of the accused, as well as the professionals responsible for prosecuting and defending them. The narrative also explores the effects of crime on the families of the accused, the victims, the wider community, and the nation as a whole. The research supporting these insights is thorough and presented in a manner that is both clear and accessible, allowing readers unfamiliar with legal jargon to understand the recounting of court proceedings and legal events related to each case. This examination underscores the ongoing necessity for attention to the imperfections that still plague the justice system, highlighting the critical role of storytelling in the pursuit of its reform.

Was this review helpful?

Framed is an eye opening, heart breaking read about men who were framed for crimes they did not commit. The lengths that some of these police officers, DAs and judges went to convict innocent men is disturbing. I always thought I was ok with capital punishment, but not after reading these 10 stories.

Due to the heavy content, it took me longer than usual to get through this book. I could not read more that one story at a time, it was just too much.

Thank you to Doubleday Books and NetGalley for this ARC in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?