Tell Me What You Did" by Carter Wilson is a 5-star suspenseful read! Poe Webb, the host of a true crime podcast called “Tell Me What You Did,” gives criminals the chance to confess their crimes—a fresh and intriguing twist on the typical crime podcast narrative. The story unfolds in two timelines: the present and a live podcast set in the future, where Poe interviews a mysterious guest.

While I wouldn’t classify this book as a traditional thriller with shocking twists and a big reveal, Carter Wilson masterfully builds suspense, compelling readers to keep turning the pages. The writing is sharp, and we’re given a vivid glimpse into Poe’s psyche, allowing us to experience her pain and anguish as the story unfolds.

The novel also raises thought-provoking questions: Is committing a crime always wrong, or are there circumstances that might justify it?

This was a gripping read, and I’m eager to explore more of Carter Wilson’s work!

Thanks to Poisoned Pen Press, Carter Wilson, and NetGalley for providing me with the opportunity to read this ARC and share my honest review.

This was shocking, twisting and kept me gasping for more. I never saw it coming, even when I thought I knew what was happening I was proved wrong.

Poe is the host of a popular true crime podcast where she gets people to call in and confess their crimes anonymously. There is no guarantee that the guests won't be found out by the police but the confession gets them instant fame and notoriety. But then a strange man appears on her show and claims to be her mothers murderer. Poe is shocked, not because of the confession, but for the fact that she already knows who killed her mother—-because she killed him.

Wow— this book was truly thrilling and gave me some major creepy stalker vibes. Suspenseful and carefully crafted with just the right amount of thrill. Don’t read this one before bed! Like a typical thriller, I was screaming at Poe to just go to the police or just check this or that or just leave the house. You didn't know who to trust and was a rollercoaster that left me with bated breath and gripped me with anxiety!

The reveal at the end was satisfying and had you teeter tottering the entire book to determine if she really did kill the correct man.

Huge thanks to NetGalley and Poisoned Pen Press for sharing this book’s digital advanced review copy with me in exchange for an honest review.

I read this book through a digital ARC from NetGalley
Author: Carter Wilson
Genre: Thriller, Mystery

Wilson drafts a well written book written from the perspective of a podcaster. I feel this is written for a certain audience, which some love.
It is paced well, but gets dark quickly. Once the main character “solves” her case, things process and take a quick turn.

4.5 stars. This is one of those books you just can’t put down! The story was absolutely gripping right from the beginning. I couldn’t really tell where the story was going and that kept my reading experience really interesting. I also found Wilson’s writing style beautiful and easy to follow. The only reason this didn’t receive 5 stars from me was the ending which I found a bit disappointing, but other than that I loved everything about this.

Thank you NetGalley and the publisher for this ARC in exchange of an honest review!

Wow oh wow. What did I just read? What a perfect read to start 2025 with.

Tell me what you did by Cater Wilson is one of those books I could not put down. It was one insanely wild ride. Poe Webb runs a true crime podcast "Tell me what you did". She invites guests to come on and you guessed it confess to crimes. One night a man comes on called Hindley confessing he killed Poe's mother. But the man who killed her Mum is dead.. Poe knows this but this Hindley guy. He won't stop. He requests a live podcast and this is when everything becomes a rollercoaster.

This book had so much to love and my oh my it was a cracker. I loved Poe's morally grey character. The short chapters had me turning the pages on my kindle until late in the night. My heart was racing many times in this book and is one I would definitely recommend of if you enjoy a fast pace read with a cat and mouse chase.

Thank you Poisoned Pen Press and Amazon for sending me a gifted copy for my honest book review.

In all honesty it was an engaging story , with a good concept ,however pretty predictable.

I thought it’s gonna give “a good girl’s guide to murder” vibes with the whole podcast thing. It didn’t really , so here are some thoughts :


The fact that Poe wasn’t sure if she had ended the right person and kept questioning herself led me to believe the guys are either twins or brothers.

I didn’t enjoy her responses during the whole podcast with him tbh. She sounded very immature. A response to every question being “fuck off, fuck you” is just childish. Ok , you’re angry we get it but you actually want information from the guy so think before you speak.

Her keeping the murder a secret for obvious reasons and then telling her dad ( ok), her bf ( questionable since the relationship doesn’t seem that strong but ok), a random stranger just because she’d survived trauma( wtf).


And then the ending … she recognised the particular orange from the light? Ok 👌🏼

That’s why overall 3.5 stars 🌟

“Happiness is a choice,” Alice says. “You decide what makes you happy and pursue it, rather than waiting for it to announce itself.”


Tell me What You Did by Carter Wilson

QUICK SUMMARY 🖊️
Poe is a host of a popular true crime podcast that invites people to anonymously confess crimes they’ve committed. But then a straight and oddly familiar man appears on her show, and he’s claiming to be her mother’s killer, except Poe knows … he’s already dead.

FINAL THOUGHTS 💭
What a way to begin the year with this book. I could not put it down. I did nothing with my Sunday but read this book. Although at points the characters made me want to scream I needed to know how it ended and what’s even better is the fact that I enjoyed the ending!
This book comes out at the end of January and it’s one I’d highly recommend for thriller fans !

Someone murdered Poe's mother many years ago. Fewer years ago, Poe killed who she thought was the murderer. So how can the man on her podcast claim to be the murderer? Who is he and what is he up to? I really enjoyed this twist on the newish genre of true crime podcast stories. There were a couple inconsistencies throughout the book, but as I read an advanced copy, I'm assuming they were caught and fixed prior to publication. Thankfully, they did not have a major impact on the storyline, so they were just a bit annoying, not problematic. And, these were totally overshadowed by the wickedly detailed storyline and character development. Nothing in Poe's world is simple and nothing stopped to allow her time to deal with newer problems. I love that reflection of the real world! I also really enjoyed how the whole story came together at the end. This was a well written and thought out story!

Wow! This one was a wild ride! I was on edge 95% of the book! I gasped so many times out loud especially towards the end! The premise of this book was very unique. I’ve read a lot of podcast based thrillers, but this one was like no other. It was so hard figuring out who to trust or how things were connected. This was my second book from this author, but certainly won’t be my last!

4.75⭐️
This was a unique, chilling, suspenseful, high stakes thriller that had me hooked from the very first page and kept me on the edge of my seat. The story centers around Poe, a true crime podcaster, who collects anonymous confessions while at the same time harboring big secrets of her own, blurring the lines between good and evil. If you love edge of your seat thrillers, this is a great one! Will definitely be checking out other tiles by this author. Thank you to Carter Wilson, Poisoned pen press, and NetGalley for the ARC in return for my honest review.

This book has me locked in from the first chapter. I mean true crime podcasts in a fast paced thriller! Everything I love in one spot. This definitely has me guessing, and for sure meets all of my requirements for a true physiological thriller. It definitely had messaged. After I was done reading I had to sleep with my light on! It for sure has creepy vibes, and realistic ones. I loved the way this book was laps out. It goes back and south between days leading up to an event ( but does it well, so it’s not confusing). The climax was definitely worth the wait and read. I do wish some r things were explained more. I for sure had unanswered questions after reading. Which honestly isn’t my favorite thing in a book. Like the question I think about still to this day, is how did he get past her security camera. Or why didn’t Poe just call the police immediately, instead of risking her own life? But overall I am happy with this read!

Thank you, netgalley for the copy.
I loved the premise of this book. Although I don’t listen to true crime podcast, I do watch shows like this on television quite often. I feel that the sense of anonymity such as over the internet allows a person to feel more confident and do and say things they may not do or say in person.
I would rate this one 3/5 stars. I hate when women are dumb and I round Poe dumb. I also didn’t find this thriller really a thriller and the twist wasn’t very twisty.

Carter Wilson's Tell Me What You Did is a gripping and intricately woven psychological thriller that kept me hooked from start to finish. The premise—a true crime podcaster collecting anonymous confessions—is fresh and compelling, blending the allure of modern media with chilling secrets from the past.

Poe Webb is a fascinating protagonist, her career and personal history colliding in a way that ramps up the tension as the story progresses. Wilson does a great job of keeping readers guessing, especially as Poe faces an unexpected visitor whose revelations threaten to unravel everything she thought she knew. The twists are cleverly executed, and the pacing rarely falters.

While the story is undeniably engrossing, there were moments where the plot felt a little over-the-top, and I found myself wishing for more depth in the exploration of certain characters’ motivations. Even so, Wilson's knack for atmosphere and suspense more than makes up for these minor flaws.

If you're a fan of dark, character-driven mysteries with plenty of surprises, Tell Me What You Did is well worth your time. It’s a solid four-star read that delivers intrigue, tension, and a truly unforgettable premise.

Thank you Netgalley and Poisoned Pen Press for the ARC in exchange for an honest review!

“Tell Me What You Did” by Carter Wilson is a chilling and high-stakes psychological thriller that grips you from the first page. With a mix of creeping suspense and relentless pacing, this book explores revenge and the dark corners of the human psyche.

Poe Webb, a popular true-crime podcaster, is thrust into a nightmare when a mysterious and menacing man named Ian Hindley claims to know her darkest secret. Hindley insists on making her the subject of a live podcast on Halloween, forcing Poe to recount not only her past but also the violent act she’s kept hidden for seven years. Hindley’s claim that he killed Poe’s mother—and his knowledge of intimate details that were never made public—sends Poe into a spiral, questioning her memories, her safety, and the truth.

The book alternates between present-day events featuring podcast transcripts and flashbacks, slowly unraveling Poe’s traumatic past, her mother’s murder, and the deadly secret she’s been hiding. The tension builds to a heart-pounding climax as Poe faces off against a truly creepy and monstrous antagonist, testing her wits, resolve, and moral boundaries.

Wilson’s storytelling is gripping and relentless, creating a palpable sense of unease that keeps you on edge. The alternating timelines effectively build suspense, with the flashbacks providing a rich backstory that deepens our understanding of Poe’s character and her trauma while the present timeline keeps you wondering what exactly is going on as the stalker has taken charge of Poe’s podcast. The podcast transcripts scattered throughout the book add a unique and immersive layer to the story, though the premise of Poe’s podcast does make me wonder if it would actually work in real life.

Poe is a flawed yet compelling protagonist—intelligent, resourceful, and deeply human. Her bond with her dog, Bailey, is a touching aspect of the story (no harm comes to the lovable canine). I also really enjoyed Poe’s father as he was very relatable and was also a very interesting character. The antagonist, Ian Hindley, is genuinely terrifying, evoking comparisons to real-life serial killers with his calculated menace and chilling unpredictability. Wilson also excels at crafting a vivid atmosphere. The book’s dark tone is punctuated by moments of humor and warmth, particularly in Poe’s interactions with her steadfast partner Kip and her dependable father, making the stakes feel even more personal.

While the plot is undeniably gripping, it occasionally falters under the weight of some implausibilities. Certain elements, like how Hindley evades recognition despite being widely exposed online, stretch believability. Additionally, Poe’s decisions in key moments—such as not involving the police when it’s clearly the safest option—can feel frustratingly contrived.

Overall, “Tell Me What You Did” is a fast-paced and chilling ride that expertly blends psychological tension with a deeply personal story. Carter Wilson proves himself adept at crafting dark, nail-biting thrillers that linger in the mind long after the final page. If you’re a fan of edge-of-your-seat thrillers that focus on revenge and the blurred lines between good and evil, “Tell Me What You Did” is a must-read.

This was such a unique and fast-paced read. I loved the depth of each character and how nuanced and flawed they were despite still remaining likable and easy to root for. A lot of the twists were more slowly revealed, which isn’t my usual preference, but I ended up enjoying them more than just being out of left field for the sake of shock-factor. Overall, this was such a great thriller and I’ll be recommending it to my audiences!

I received a complimentary copy from Poisoned Pen Press and all opinions expressed are mine.

What a read! I absolutely did not expect to be taken for a ride. I did not fathom what happened in this book. Thrilling,fast-paced ,well written and twisty . I would recommend this book for anyone that loves a good true crime podcast ,family dynamics and secrets.

this is the thriller of 2025! i love how the topics in it were dealt with realistically, because these days the outrageous (ly bad) thrillers aren't doing it for me anymore and now I'm afraid and freaked out about my own online activity and potential creeps! also reading this till 6 am with random noises in the background is an experience in itself!

Tell Me What You Did is a chilling, gripping thriller that had me hooked from the first page. The unique podcast format, combined with alternating perspectives, made this story an absolute page-turner. The suspense was relentless, keeping me on the edge of my seat as Poe Webb, the host of a true crime podcast, is thrown into a terrifying situation involving her past—and the truth that has been buried for years.

What stood out most for me was the eerie tension and the unsettling presence of the villain, whose actions were both sinister and creepy. I could feel the hair on my arms raise as the story intensified. Poe's interactions with this man, coupled with the mystery surrounding her mother's death, create a perfect storm of dread and anticipation.

The book's pacing is perfect, and the unraveling of Poe’s past and her deepest secret had me hooked and I was completely absorbed in the psychological tension between Poe and the mysterious figure from her past.

Overall, Tell Me What You Did was an exceptional start to my reading year. It’s a thrilling, creepy, and satisfying read that delivers on every front—perfect for anyone who loves a dark, twisty psychological mystery.

This is the first time I have read a Carter Wilson book. I enjoyed it but I wish I’d of read Mr Tender’s Girl first.

I found a few bits far fetched but it was a good read. 3.5 stars.