I think I need to give up and accept that Lynn Painter's adult romances are not for me. Her YA is fun, but her adult characters feel juvenile and childish in a way that's very off-putting. I couldn't finish this one, I barely made it through a few chapters before I had to call it quits.

Isabella is running late on her first day of her new job, so of course she stops to order a coffee to go. The line is long and she places her order and waits. The barista calls out “Amy” three times and no one claims the drink, which happens to be*exactly* what Isabella ordered, so she takes it. Karma instantly catches up to her because once she grabs the drink, she turns around to run into a big, muscular chest that she spills the drink all over. And now the guy who this chest belongs to is calling Isabella “Amy” but then is totally confused because she's later introduced to him as Isabella because he's the VP of her department at her new job.

This book read a little too YA for my liking, but it did have it's cute moments. I don't know about you, but I'd also be tempted to take a drink no one claimed if it was my exact order. I wouldn't though because I'm a huge believer in karma, but I'd sure give it some thought first! My favorite parts probably included all the back and forth with the texting and facetiming. There's some third act drama, but nothing super crazy. Overall it's a cute, fluffy story with a reminder for Star Wars fans that there's actual Renlo fanfic out in the world.

A big thank you to Berkeley Romance and the author for an advanced copy of this book's re-release. Opinions are my own.

THIS BOOK IS FOR YOU IF: You're in the mood for a fast paced story that's cute if you're looking for a light romcom to pass the time with.

Accidentally Amy was a pleasant read. It had some good moments and I did enjoy the story. The meet cute between Izzy and Blake was amusing. But when they discover how they are connected it becomes a game of high tension and will they, won't they. It was great seeing how Izzy and Blake built up their friendship. They couldn't help but gravitate towards the other and it was fascinating to see how it would all play out. It was very insta-love which I don't mind but this was real quick. Izzy and Blake balanced each other and they were somehow the perfect match. Overall a cute story.

I normally love a Lynn Painter book. But this one left a little to be desired. I felt like the cover looked so romantic and cute and intriguing! It all started with the cringey meet cute. The concept was cute enough but I felt like Izzy did a bad job and was immature about admitting blame when Blake finds out. I also just felt like they were not on the same maturity level the whole time which made it hard to buy into them pursuing a relationship. I do love a dual POV and I love Painter's writing. These just weren't my favorite characters and I wished Izzy had more growth or just wasn't as ditzy? So many of her other female leads are strong and independent and I much prefer that.
I will always look forward to her next book!

Thank you, @berkleypub and @berkleyromance, for an advanced digital copy of this book!

Accidentally Amy is a delightful, fun read. The chemistry between Izzy and Blake is infectious, and while they have their cringy moments, their banter makes them so lovable. I especially enjoyed how Blake tried to resist Izzy—he was annoyed by her coffee theft, yet couldn’t stop thinking about her and wanting to see her again.

Lynn Painter has a talent for making readers fall in love with both the characters and their developing romance. The witty dialogue is top-tier, and watching their friendship evolve into something more was heartwarming. Izzy, a lovable hot mess (Painter’s specialty), brings humor, spice, and chaos in equal measure. Blake’s genuine admiration for Izzy’s unpredictable mind is also a great touch.

The only downside was the ending, which felt a bit rushed, leaving me wanting more. Also, despite the cover’s spicy vibe, the book didn’t deliver on that front as much as I’d hoped. Still, the story’s charm, humor, and instant chemistry between the characters made it a very enjoyable read.

Overall, it’s a light, funny, and heartwarming romance perfect for fans of witty banter and feel-good love stories.

I was intending for this to be a 4-star read, but the third act just didn't do it for me. Other than that I really did enjoy this one, I thought it was so funny and clever! I love that we got 2 povs, and I definitely enjoyed reading about both. I can still recommend it!

✨”I was too drunk on her, too lost in every crinkle of her freckled nose, to give up the chance to finish the perfect day with a long, perfect night.”✨

I loved this fun, whimsical work romance! Izzy and Blake are so perfectly adorable together. Their quirky expressions and witty banter was so entertaining and endearing. I will absolutely be reading this one again and recommending it to those who enjoy:
💖an adorable meet cute
💖dual pov
💖he falls first
💖nicknames
💖comical supportive side characters
💖forbidden workplace romance
💖top tier romantic tension (and swoon!)
💖well written open door (low descriptive) romantic scenes

Thank you to NetGalley, Berkley Publishing, and Lynn Painter for the opportunity to read an eARC in exchange for my honest review. This was truly a delightful romance read! 5 stars!!!

3⭐️

Accidentally Amy was cute, fun, and exactly what I expected... a lighthearted, low-stakes rom-com with an adorable grumpy x sunshine dynamic. The meet-cute was genuinely adorable, and I loved all the little details, like their mutual love for cats (Blake’s cat, Goodyear, was basically a main character). Izzy was sunshiney without being too over-the-top, and the book was cheesy but feel good. That said, the romance felt a little insta-lovey (Blake is convinced he’s in love when he literally just ended his engagement two weeks before meeting her????) I listened to this one on audiobook, and while it was fun and breezy, I think I might have enjoyed it more if I’d read a physical copy.... but the spicy scenes were perfect.

Not my favorite! I think it's hard to escape the weirdness of HR professionals engaging in a relationship that involves a subordinate and her boss' boss. There were cute moments in the middle, but definitely feels like it was written many years ago. To each their own, but not for me.

THIS IS HOW YOU WRITE A ROM COM!!

I enjoyed every single aspect of this book, from the characters, to their quirks, to their amazingly named cats. This was one of those books where you grab a sweet treat, a cozy blanket and you read this book for the whole night. It honestly didn't even feel as though I was reading, this was just a movie in my mind.

From the moment "Amy" crashed into Mr. Chest, I was hooked. The chemistry between them was hilarious and tense, but gradually shifted too adorable as the book progressed. I found myself panicked over how certain things would happen, just to laugh hysterically the next minute. I loved that they couldn't get together right away, and we got to see their relationship gradually grow. Then the conflict that arose was so realistic and troubling, I couldn't find a way that it was going to work!

The characters themselves were an absolute joy, I LOVED THEM SO MUCH!! Izzy is just me at the end of the day. I related to her so much and found so much of myself in her. Then for Blake, his character had a lot of personas through the story, but he is just a sweetie at the end of the day. Their relationship was so heartwarming due to both their humour, banter and the love they had for each other.

I have to end with this. NAMING YOUR CAT THE DARKLING AND HAVING A BEN BARNES REFERENCE. HECK YEAH!!

What a funny premise this one was. she takes a starbucks drink that isn’t hers and then meets a really hot guy who turns out to be her boss. this was a wild ride but i loved it.

On the first day of her new job, Izzy grabs a Starbucks drink meant for someone else and then promptly spills said drink down the front of a hot guy's shirt, only said hot guy ends up being her new boss's boss, Blake. The two find that there is definitely chemistry between them, but their company has strict rules that would forbid them from dating. They agree to be friends and set rules for their friendship to make sure they don't cross any lines. But can things stay that way?

Was this book well-written? Eh. Did it have some cringe-worthy moments? Absolutely (I could NOT stand her calling him Chest). Did I still enjoy the overall reading experience? A resounding yes. It's a great book for those times where you don't want to think but want something to take you out of the real world or it can be a great palate cleanser between books with heavier topics.

Overall: 3.75/5 rounded up
Spice: 1.5/3

Top Pick!

“I’d finally found what seemed like the perfect job, with a company that was considered to be the best place to work in the entire freaking world, and I’d totally blown myself up. I’d somehow managed to lie and insult a vice president on my very first day. As if that weren’t enough of an aww-shit sandwich, I was so profoundly disappointed in AVP Blake’s awful character arc that I could cry. He’d started of the day like some dashing hero in a rom-com, attractive and charming and filled with promise, but then, in an instant, he’d shown himself to be a pompous, arrogant, judgmental jerk. A jerk who would most likely be firing me the following day.”

It’s twelve days into 2025, and I think I’ve just read my favorite book of the year, which is high praise. I have been waiting to read a book like this for so long. I feel like I’ve been starving for some actual chemistry that jumps off the page, and that is what Blake and Izzie have in spades.

Their initial meet-cute is perfect and right out of a romance book, but then it takes a turn for the worst when Blake learns that Izzie may have told a lie, which he has a zero-tolerance policy. Throw in the fact that she is now his direct subordinate, she is totally off limits. Unfortunately, these two are like magnets constantly being pulled into each other’s orbit.

The reader gets to watch their silly antics on how they circumvent the office rules and how they become each other’s person. I adored how they were able to show each other the most authentic versions of themselves and how organically they fell in love. It’s like watching the beginnings of a real relationship.

They would Facetime constantly, stay awake on the phone until they fell asleep, wanted to talk to each other every second of every day. It’s like Lynn Painter went into my brain and found out that I wanted a man who was obsessed with his heroine when she created Blake. He is down bad for Izzie, and that made this book everything. I honestly have nothing negative to say about this book at all. No notes. It’s perfection.

If you’re a fan of authors like Sarah Adams and Christina Lauren, then I would definitely pick this up.

~ Michelle

A sweet, humorous rom-com where a woman has a “meet cute” with a man in a Starbucks after spilling her coffee on him. It turns out, he’s her new boss at her brand new job. It’s entertaining watching them try to stuff the chemistry they have for each other into a friendship since his ethics for work prevent him from starting something more. Overall, a sweet, quick read of a rom-com.

Thank you Berkley for the ARC!

Lynn Painter is such a delightful author, and I’ve loved every book of hers I’ve read! It all started with Mr. Wrong Number, and now, years later, we’re back with Accidentally Amy! I’m absolutely obsessed with the dual first-person POV in this book, especially after reading third-person narratives from her in the past.

I adored Izzy and Blake, this book is the perfect cozy fall read, and I’m so glad I had the chance to cozy up with it again in winter. I loved the fun little touches like the cats, the billboard games, and how Blake falls for Izzy so quickly. Izzy’s personality is a blast and made the whole story even more enjoyable.

This book is what started my love for workplace romances!

Thank you to NetGalley and Berkley for an advanced reader copy of this book in exchange for an honest review. Accidentally Amy by Lynn Painter is an adorable and humorous book following a meet cute at a Starbucks after the female main character, Izzy takes a pumpkin spice latte that is not hers. When I first read that this was initially written as a serial romcom for the authors newsletter subscribers, I could definitely see what would make readers want to anxiously read the next chapter, and I’m really glad that it was made into a physical book. At times, I did feel like the banter between Blake and Izzy was a bit juvenile. I also didn’t feel like there was much character development between the two main characters, which is why I didn’t rate it higher. But as with any romance book, I loved the dual POVs! I also thought the billboard game that they play in the book reminded me a lot of true American from the show “New Girl” and it made me laugh. This book was not my favorite book by Lynn painter, but I still enjoyed it regardless.

I absolutely loved this one! From the start, I loved Izzy (FMC). She's quirky, fun, awkward and relatable. The meet cute and accidentally Amy bit truly made me giggle throughout the story. Literally LOVED Blake. This truly had me rooting for them the entire time! I loved how the ending played out. Cute, funny and spicy bits! Great all around!!

I love Lynn Painter! She never disappoints! The story made me giggle. It was a fast read for me. Light, easy a perfect winter (I hate winter) read. It just made me happy! Isabella Shay made me smile. I very much enjoyed it!

I love Lynn Painter's writing so much, and as a result I was so incredibly excited to read this beautiful book!

I'm sorry to say though that this was just not the book for me - I kept trying to read it and after 2 1/2 weeks of dread when it came to reading, and just an out and out lack of joy when it came to picking this read up on my kindle, I made the painful choice to DNF this book at 40%. I tried so hard but just couldn't do it anymore.

That being said - what did work for me was Lynn Painter's writing style in general - I love the way that she writes, it's like magic on a page. Blake is a really cute MMC.

But, there was far more that I didn't like - the cringe-worthy dialogue, the FMC in general, the sex scenes, the horrid nickname Mr. Chest - like, ewww.

Thanks to NetGalley for this e-arc in exchange for my honest review.

𝐵𝑜𝑜𝓀 𝑅𝑒𝓋𝒾𝑒𝓌

𝘼𝙘𝙘𝙞𝙙𝙚𝙣𝙩𝙖𝙡𝙡𝙮 𝘼𝙢𝙮
by Lynn Painter
352 pages
published January 14, 2025
(readers saying this is a repub with bonus content)

Isabella Shay is late for her first day, so when the barista calls for Amy 3 times, Isabella takes Amy’s PSL, then runs right into Mr. Chest- who turns out to be her boss, Blake. Blake is not so happy about Izzy’s little white lie, and soon, sparks fly. Isabella is determined to win Blake over, and Blake finds himself realizing his new coworker is not as deceitful as he first thought. Their chemistry brings them together and they decide to be friends. When Blake is suddenly not Izzy’s boss, will he take a chance and allow their relationship to be more?

This was a fast read on a cold day. Sometimes the banter was mildly annoying, but it improved as their relationship grew. Read this - it is a sweet, light and fun romance. It has some spice, but it is not detailed, just enough steam to be a great romance. Perfect romance to warm me up on a winter’s day.

Thank you @berkleyromance and @netgalley for the opportunity to read this in exchange for my review.

QOTD: What are your plans this weekend?

I’m trying Zumba Tone today, ice fishing & there’s an important football game tomorrow- Go Bills!

#romancebooks #romance #accidentallyamy #recommendedreading #currentlyreading #bookstagram #amreading #newreads #arcread #arcreading