
Member Reviews

A twist I didn’t see coming! This one took me a little bit to get into but once you get about half way through, it’s one you can’t put down.

Let me first say, I read this book in one day. Something about the style in writing and suspense just kept me hooked until I finished the book! This book does a great job keeping you guessing about the "whodunit", while also carrying along an entire storyline about the main character. I kept thinking, NO DON'T DO THAT, that's a terrible idea! So, definitely a few of those unrealistic actions that we see in horror movies, but I still didn't guess the ending!
I usually go in blind to most books, and I would recommend you do the same for this one!
Thank you NetGalley for this ARC, all opinions are my own

I selected this book based on the cover and synopsis. Unfortunately the first several chapters did not captivate me and were odd once the initial murder happened. I was not invested in the characters and the progression and the plot was strange. I did not finish the book after chapter 5.

Killer Potential by Hannah Deitch is a thriller featuring Evie Gordon, a flailing multi-degree college graduate. Evie works as an SAT tutor for the wealthy of LA. The novel begins with her being spotted at her clients immediately after their grisly murders. She and the young woman she finds bound at the mansion quickly go from bystanders to fugitives, and go on the run. I became immediately engrossed in the chase and found the novel to be compulsively readable. I could not put it down! It’s a sharp, occasionally funny Thelma and Louise love story. An overall fast paced psychological thriller. A very strong debut novel. 4/5⭐️
Thank you to NetGalley and William Morrow for an advanced copy. All opinions are my own. 3/18/25

Debut mystery thriller that had me cheering for both suspects until the true killer was revealed. Evie found herself in a “wrong place at the wrong time” type of situation on her normally scheduled day to tutor the Victor’s daughter. Upon entering the quiet house she soon finds Mr & Mrs Victor dead so she attempts to flee but not before stumbling across what she thinks to be a kept prisoner. Mishaps occur and various other crimes can’t be avoided in their attempts to remain free until they solve the murder of the Victors. The writer kept me riveted and pensive in comparing true life to some of the narratives. I am looking forward to reading more from this author. I received an advanced copy in exchange for my honest review.

I love the Thelma and Louise + Cat & Mouse vibes that run all through this book. The murder mystery had me thinking I knew what was coming but i totally did not guess the twist. Definitely recommend.

After she shows up to her tutoring gig for a wealthy family and discovers the parents' dead bodies, Evie Gordon goes on the lam with a mysterious young woman she finds hiding in the victims' house. It was a cool premise, but this didn't do much for me. This is a "Bonnie and Bonnie" story; it mostly has pages and pages of Evie and her comrade in arms trying to evade the police, stealing cars and committing petty thievery at every turn. It was all super implausible — Evie and her companion were easily able to steal so many items and break into so many empty houses. I thought the story was repetitive, and the big twists were easily predictable. And though Evie is inevitably book smart and somewhat scrappy, she was also gullible and made many dumb decisions. I wasn't really invested in the story.

The sharp and witty writing pulls you into this Thelma & Louise thriller. The requirement to suspend disbelief becomes almost too much until things take a turn and you realize you're totally invested in the story and these two antiheroes. The big reveal is somewhat predictable so I urge readers to just go along on the wide ride without trying to solve the mystery. This is a really great debut from Hannah Deitch. Many thanks to William Morrow and NetGalley for an advanced digital ARC of this adventurous tale!

Loved this book. Witty, funny, and captivating from the first page. Thelma and Louise but gayer, and with an incredible twist. Cinematic descriptions of the American landscape and sharp, quick inner monologue from a deeply flawed and deeply lovable protagonist. High recommendation for fans of The Girls - Emma Cline, Bright Young Women - Jessica Knoll, and The Maidens - Alex Michaelides.

The premise of Killer Potential had me intrigued from the start, and while the book took me on one heck of a ride, I just don’t think it was for me.

This was a fun cat-and-mouse thriller that had some fun romance thrown in there. Evie, the main narrator, stumbles across a murder and then a person trapped in a wall, and rather than report it to the police - they run.
While I don’t think this book was for me, I did enjoy the writing and the overall flow of the book. I was able to pick up on the twist pretty early on and it felt more like an explanation of what happened rather than a who-done-it.
Fans of Thelma and Louise, Gone Girl and other like novels will find this book entertaining and unique!

#KillerPotential starts with a fascinating premise: SAT Evie Gordon arrives at Serena Victor’s house one day to find Serena’s mother and father brutally murdered. Before she has time to react, she finds a woman tied up in the walls. Convinced that they’ll be accused of the Victors’ murders, Evie and this woman flea. Even more intriguing - the woman refuses to speak.
Hannah Deitch’s debut novel is billed as a thriller, but it’s also an adventure tale, as we follow these two women on road trip, as they try to figure out what to do next and fight against the people who are trying to stop them.
This book is fast-paced, fascinating, and full of surprises. If you’re looking close enough, the biggest surprise might be easy to predict, but it was still a good one. And I really enjoyed the third act of this book, with all of the insight and resolutions it brought.
I’ve heard a lot about this book and I’m thankful to #NetGalley and William Morrow for the chance to read it a little early!

I’m not really sure what the intention behind this book was. While the pacing was decent (it took about 20% to pick up), the character development is pretty non-existent. The ending was oddly unsatisfying and I found I didn’t root for either character. A bit of a letdown overall.
Thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for an ARC in exchange for an honest review.

This was the ultimate in villain/antihero stories! I loved Evie and Jae, they were brilliantly crafted and their story did them justice (get it? Haha!) I loved reading this book and all of the unexpected twists and turns. This book surprised me when many don’t. I loved every moment of it! Incredible first novel, can’t wait for more from this talented author!

*Thank you to William Morrow and NetGalley for an ARC in exchange for my honest review and to LibroFM for the gifted ALC*
Killer Potential is action-packed from the start. We literally stumble on dead bodies, a woman tied up in a closet, and are forced to flee the scene within the first 15 minutes of the audiobook. HOLY COW. I liked its take on the sensationalism of crime in America, with Evie quickly cast as a murderess a la Charles Manson. It's an interesting take on Bonnie and Clyde, if Bonnie were accused of serial murder and Clyde was their mute accomplice with a knack for hotwiring cars.
Things got a little weird about 3/4ths of the way through and it kinda lost me. But I can respect Hannah Deitch's choice in the plot and the ending. Can't wait to read more from her!

Was this unhinged? Yes. Did I still have a great time? Absolutely. Thank you netgalley for the advanced copy!

The premise is up my alley when I need a pallette cleanser of all the sad, dystopian stuff I've been reading 🤣 I liked it! There's A LOT of disbelief suspending required here and while I wasn't always able to do that, I was curious where the story would go.
Evie is a 29 year old SAT tutor. She tutors rich people's kids in Los Angeles, one of them being Serena Victor. One Sunday, Evie arrives to her scheduled session with Serena to find Serena's parents brutally murdered...and a very skinny, bruised, tied up woman under the stairs. Evie helps this woman escape and they go on the run, evading the police who think they're murderers.
It's very 'Thelma & Louise' - and I love that movie. The two woman are now stuck together, forced to trust each other... but do they really get to know each other at all? What does adrenaline do to our bodies and mind? Is love really blind?
Anything I rate over a 3 I recommend. Again, suspend your disbelief going in and I think you'll have a good time.

This was a ride - and a well written one with a solid pace that only lagged in a few spots. Thanks to the publisher via Netgalley invite for the free advanced copy in exchange for an honest review, book publishes March 18

I was lured here with the promise of morally gray sapphics burning it all down, and I was not disappointed. Evie is an almost perfect proxy for many of the people who will be drawn to this book - a middle class millennial whose potential elevated her to all sorts of positions, where she did everything "right", but fell right back down into the mediocrity muddle when the educational system ran out, leaving her scrambling for something to keep her propped up. What she finds is being an SAT tutor to wealthy families, which pays just enough, but brings her into constant contact with those who build a society that keeps everyone else out.
What I appreciated was that while she didn't actually murder the Victors, the narration and Evie herself never shy away from the fact that the line keeping her away from it is thin. A line that keeps getting thinner the more she and Jae are on the run, becoming more and more desperate to find a way to just <i>live</i>. Because while she is filled with rage, it's mostly at the system and is less personal, though as more of the system gets turned against her, she brings up the point, how long does it take, being labeled and believed something, to believe it of yourself? How much desperation and living on the fringes does it take to lose a sense of self built up over decades?
Jae embodies much more of this, having lived with that desperation for far longer, and as more and more of her story unfolds, it's less of a parallel and more of a converging route.
It's fascinating reading this during the time of Luigi - normally I feel like I wouldn't know a wanted murderer's face, even if it's on tons of news - and thinking of the parallels and how much of a difference knowing /why/ a crime is committed makes in terms of public opinion (there are people who think Evie and Jae were justified, but for most, public opinion is of a brutal, senseless murder out of jealousy) and whose killings make national news.

Here is my review of this book. So if you the blurb Evie is a SAT tutor who arrives at the home of Serena to tutor her only to find her parents are both dead. Before she even can react there is someone locked in a closet crying for help. Evie finds the young girl tied up in the closet. Then Serena shows up and a struggle happens and Evie thinks she might have killed her. Anyway she goes on the run with the girl that was tied up in the closest They evade the police for such a long time. I pretty much figured out who killed Serena’s parents. I liked the book but it was lengthy. I will reveal one thing. Serena landed up in a coma but finally woke up. I received this ARC from NetGalley and the publisher for an honest review. It was a decent read but a little too long. All in all it was a fun book.