Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Thank you NetGalley and St. Martin’s Press for sending this book for review consideration. All opinions are my own.

Commissaire Georges Dupin is out for his morning swim, his attention taken by the harbor seal who has been shadowing him every day lately. But today is different – there’s someone on the shore shouting for him. A body has been found in the water just a short distance away. As Dupin investigates the murder, he must travel to a small island off the Breton coast where every resident had a reason to kill the man. Will Dupin uncover the truth or will this one remain a mystery?

Best-selling author Jean-Luc Bannalec is back with the tenth installment in the Commissaire Dupin series – An Island of Suspects. This series has been published in over 14 countries and spent multiple weeks at the top of the best-seller lists worldwide. In this edition, everyone’s favorite detective is celebrating a milestone work anniversary, but must first uncover the truth behind this mysterious murder. Beyond just mystery, this novel delivers witty banter and history of the Breton area, along with a love of coffee!

I give An Island of Suspects 4 out of 5 stars. Knowling little about Breton, I appreciate the history and descriptions Bannalec included about the landscape and customs. As a coffee aficionado myself, I appreciate Dupin’s love for coffee and the inclusion of an old coffee custom as well. This was a great cozy mystery novel, but I felt like I was missing something – perhaps reading earlier novels in this series would have helped with that.

If you’re a fan of Agatha Christie’s Inspector Poirot series, you will love this novel. With light references to violence and murder, this would be best directed to more mature audiences over 13. However, this would make a great book club selection with so many interesting story lines and characters to review. Keep in mind that this novel has already been released in several other languages and is available for holiday gifting for loved ones overseas!

I was excited to see An Island of Suspects available on NetGalley earlier this month. I love the cover image and this is a series I have heard about frequently! The English translation of this novel will hit shelves on February 25th. You can preorder your copy in our Bookshop.org store today!

Was this review helpful?

Commissaire Dupin is out for his morning swim when his colleague Riwal shows up. A body has been found in the nearby harbor caught on a buoy. The man had been strangled, thankfully the Harbor Master could identify him. He was a sheep farmer from a nearby island that Acadian families settled on, Belle Isle, named Patric Provost. Provost was a very difficult man that took pleasure in thwarting the plans of others. He used his money and influence to buy up island properties, he stopped plans to expand the local whisky distillery and museum, and refused to give his wife a divorce even after being separated for almost twenty years. He was a Scrooge so list of possible murderers is long.

Dupin interviews the island residents and checking alibis when another local is kidnapped. Clues point to the kidnapping and murder being linked but it seems no one person could have done it. Can the Parisian Inspector solve this case in time to make it to his ten year anniversary party! But of course, he is Dupin of course.

I love this series so much that I sought out the European television series to watch it. Visiting Brittany is on my Bucket List because of this series.

Was this review helpful?

Jean-Luc Bannelec is one of those authors whi can draw you in from the first words. His books are always well written, complex, and intricate. This one, An Island of Suspects, is the tenth in the Commissaire Dupin series, and another caffeine-fueled winner, for the most part.

When the most hated and wealthiest inhabitant of Belle-Île, Patric Provost, is murdered, found entangled in buoy nets, there is a little sorrow from the islands’s residents who have been pretty much owned by him their entire lives. Commissaire Dupin is called to solve the mystery, battling the heat and mal de mer in the process.

For the most part, I liked this book. As with all of Bannelec books, it is atmospheric, entertaining, and informative — I always learn something new about some of the most obscure areas of France — and it was good to be back with the Concarneau gang, all of whom have become very familiar to me, each character unique in his or her own way. But while the book starts off strong, it waivers a little bit midway, and I found myself setting it aside, something I would never have considered with Bannalec’s previous books that are so engaging I end up reading in one sitting because I cannot not put them down.

Happily the ending is satisfying, and it’s a nice addition to this series, although certainly not the best. It does work as a standalone, but I would suggest a reader unfamiliar with this author would be better served starting with a book other than this one.

Was this review helpful?

Today's entry into the WE LOVE BRITTANY campaign is the island of Belle-Île where Inspector Dupin is called to solve the murder of a most unpleasant man. It's an especially good one because we are actually given a clue, that, if we are clever enough (I wasn't) would have given an idea of the murder's identity, sort-of.

As always the descriptions of the scenery and food will make you want to go there immediately, and the description of the August heat wave that Inspector Dupin is suffering through will cloud your mind from the generally wretched Brittany weather. I loved it.

Was this review helpful?

In the midst of an August heat wave, Commissaire Georges Dupin is called to the scene when a body is found tangled in buoy nets. Someone strangled Patric Provost, and hoped the tide would take the body to sea. Dupin and his team follow Provost's life to Belle-Ile, the largest Breton island. In the little village there, Provost was the largest land owner, disliked by everyone. It's a very insular community, and no one is willing to reveal much unless the team pushes for answers. While Agnes Griffon, the island's electrical technician, lives on the island, no one tells Dupin that she's Provost's ex-wife. In fact, it turns out she's still married to the victim, just separated. Notes show up indicating Provost was blackmailed, and his dog is missing. Then, another islander is kidnapped with a ransom demand left behind. All of the small group of suspects seem to have alibis. Is it the August heat, or the mysticism and legends of the island that leave Dupin dizzy and confused in this bewildering investigation?

A few too many characters, and Dupin drifts off into dizziness too many times making this mystery hard to follow at times.

Was this review helpful?

Interesting and strong start, the most detested person of the island appeared murdered (won't be the only one) and everyone on the island is very open to say they hated him, but everything the clues point towards one suspect sometimes they become the next victim. It's a mild one, good for when I am tired and want to read a mystery but not have to be overwhelmed by it. Good for Poirot fans.

Was this review helpful?

What a cute mystery! Definitely want to read more from this author. Was a quick and easy read and definitely gave me Nancy Drew and Sherlock vibes!

Was this review helpful?