Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Thank you so much to Annie and @netgalley @avonbooks @harpervoyagerus for an advance reader’s copy of this book! 🫶🏼 it feels so special to be able to read an authors debut novel early and I am so so grateful!

This book follows Piper Adams on her way to her best friend, Allie’s destination wedding. When her flight goes from delayed to canceled, panic sets in. There’s no way for Piper to make it on time for the wedding festivities. Not until she runs into someone at the airport who might be able to save the day….. Wyatt, her beautiful, charming ex-boyfriend and ex-best friend.

Unexpectedly running into Wyatt at the airport was one thing, but him offering to fly them both on his friend’s private plane to Allie’s wedding was another.

For the sake of making it to the wedding on time, Piper says yes and joins Wyatt on the plane. Things take a turn for the worse due a storm and there’s a ✨crash landing✨….

Will Piper survive being stranded on an island with the last person she’d ever want to be with? Or will this be the perfect opportunity for Piper to put on her big girl pants and get the closure she finally needs from her past, in order to move on toward a better future.. with or without Wyatt?

Let me tell you, when I said I loved the cover, I really did. But my eyes failed to register the literal plane crash in the background. My eyes said: wow they’re beautiful, and so is the sunset. *request* So imagine how surprised I was when they literally went crashing down less than 5 chapters in? Even though the book is called CRASH LANDING. My brain was not working lmao. I was caught so off guard and that was literally my bad. Sometimes I like to go into books blindly and pick them based off of their cover. 🤷🏻‍♀️ Anyways!

This book goes back and forth between Piper and Wyatt presently stuck on a remote island, trying to survive and co-exist, and Piper and Wyatt’s friendship, leading to their romantic relationship developing back in high school. Typically these time skips are not my favorite to read, but I feel like Annie wrote them fairly well. Piper and Wyatt’s relationship in both past/present progressed equally in a way that kept me at bay and did not leave me wanting to read one time period more than the other. I enjoyed seeing Piper open up and become vulnerable with the only person she’s ever felt comfortable doing that with. I’m so proud of her for being able to ask questions and get the answers she was looking for in order to understand the past. Not only does this help her understand her past, but it shapes her future and allows her to finally make decisions for herself and not for the happiness of others.

Wyatt felt like a very stereotypical army MMC - and I don’t mean this in a bad way. I mean that, often times they always have that same mentality where they break the girls heart before they leave to “protect” the girl without giving her the option lol like dude?? c’mon. Granted this situation was very different and there were a lot of other elements which contributed to their initial break up (which I think was absolutely perfect, and SUPER super relatable). It literally hurt lol. I felt like I was being broken up with and it made me so so sad. Not just for Piper. Honestly, maybe even more so for Wyatt. This man spent his entire adulthood loving someone he had to push away, because he truly thought it would be better for her. This hurts lol I really loved his gentle and sweet personality, but I hated how he never viewed himself as valuable or worth it due to his upbringing and what other people had to say about him. 😞

There was one technical aspect, where in the past chapters it flopped between senior year, 9th grade, and then back to senior year. I think that should have been linear. And it did feel a bit slow at the start for me.. (granted they were deserted on an island and Piper had major trust issues) but I was waiting for it to pick up and it did eventually! Other than that this was a fun read and a lovely debut novel. You should check it out! I’m looking forward to reading more of Annie’s books and seeing her growth as an author.

𝙧𝙚𝙖𝙙 𝙞𝙛 𝙮𝙤𝙪 𝙡𝙞𝙠𝙚: second-chance romance, forced proximity, minimal spice 🌶️

Was this review helpful?

Annie’s debut is incredible! I shipped this couple so much! Such an escapist romance that sent me to a desert island with them!

Was this review helpful?

This was a quick and sweet second chance romance with a unique premise. I loved the dual timeline and getting to read how Piper and Wyatt's relationship progressed in both timelines.. Definitely would make for a great beach read... just maybe not a trip you take on an airplane! ;-) Thank you NetGalley and Avon for the ARC.

Was this review helpful?

✈️🏝️💔💥

This entertaining debut romance takes readers on a hilarious and heartfelt journey as exes Piper and Wyatt are stranded together on a deserted island after an unexpected plane crash. Piper, who has meticulously rebuilt her life after heartbreak, is forced to confront old wounds and her lingering feelings for Wyatt. The chemistry between them is electric, their banter sharp, and the forced proximity pushes them to rediscover both each other and themselves. As Piper wrestles with letting go of her perfectly controlled life, Wyatt proves he's more than just a past love—he's a shot at a future she never expected. This story is a magnetic blend of second chances, survival, and sizzling romance that will leave you rooting for their happily-ever-after. Congrats on the debut, Annie!

Was this review helpful?

I always want to love a romance, especially one with such a great premise, but unfortunately CRASH LANDING kinda....crashed. If you're after a paint-by-numbers romance, Crash Landing would probably do, but don't expect what it offers on the label...there was nothing funny, or humourous about this book, and it definitely read more like a contemporary romance than a rom-com. The characters were extremely 2D, and you'd always find out information about them three chapters too late. Wyatt spent 5 years in the army and couldn't get an emergency radio to work. No stress though, our heroine, Piper, had a random obsession with 1940s wirelesses back in college and is able to connect to the coast guard first try. Honestly, it felt like this book was originally written as a YA book and the author got told they'd only be able to sell it as an adult fiction romance. The time jumping meant the character voices were the same regardless of age, which when you've got two characters four years off from thirty acting as if they've never made an adult decision in their life....yeah.

Two stars for the premise and cute cover, wish I had loved this more than I did.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley for providing an eARC of this book, this is my objective review. Piper, a med student and people pleaser, is dating a blandly appropriate man. She's on her way to a destination wedding in the Bahamas for her best friend. Her childhood friend and high school ex-boyfriend Wyatt is also trying to get to the wedding. Their flight is canceled but Wyatt's friend lends him a plane so he can fly them both to the wedding. These two young and attractive people with a fraught romantic history crash-land on a tropical island and are forced to get reacquainted. Can they revive their romantic feelings for one another and renew their friendship at the same time?

The story is told via 3rd-person POV from Piper's perspective, with the high school events told via flashback. The premise is fine but predictably executed, there's nothing all that new here. Childhood-friends-to-lovers is usually my kryptonite, so I'm a bit disappointed I didn't enjoy this book more. Piper on the island was getting on my nerves, she's kind of spoiled and dramatic. They both seemed very young and immature, but that could be my own age talking. This is a quick read, great if you're looking for a light, new adult open-door romance book with an HEA.

Was this review helpful?

This is like a delicious mash-up of Jo Segura and Carley Fortune, which is to say, a fast-paced adventure romance with dual timeline, high-tension goodness! What I loved is that there’s tension coming from multiple angles--there’s a ton of past baggage Wyatt and Piper have to unpack together but also in the current timeline, they have to go against Nature and somehow survive, with only each other, on an island, with no end in sight and limited resources. It’s so compelling and page-turning, and Annie’s writing particularly shines when it comes to describing setting - you can see the island, feel the island, taste it, hear it. I was stressed out in the best way. Only one bed? Nah man, I’m taking ONLY ONE ISLAND from now on! Can't wait to see what Annie writes next.

Thank you to Avon and NetGalley for the ARC in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

the way i shipped wyatt and piper from the gecko. the plane crash story line is slightly wild but it works

Was this review helpful?

Loved this book! This was definitely a page turner! The story was well written. I was able to sink into the story and experience the emotions of the characters. Main character and supporting characters were interesting and felt to be fully developed. I will absolutely recommend this book!

Was this review helpful?

This book is a treasure that deserves to be known by all lovers of pink romances. Not only the cover is cute, but the whole story.

A while ago I read a book that was written in two different timelines and traveled from their childhood love to the current adult time, however, I didn't like it, and since then I avoided reading books written in two tenses, but I loved this book. It was cute to me, at times a little slow, but nothing that was hopeless or not tolerable.

I loved the trope from childhood friends to enemies to lovers, and second chances.

I totally recommend this book, and please Annie continue to work with the person who designed your cover because it turned out amazing.

Was this review helpful?

Childhood lovers-to-enemies-to-lovers, stranded on a deserted island, and a sizzling second chance at romance? This book was everything I wanted! Piper and Wyatt’s chemistry is absolutely electric—their connection leaps off the page with every lingering look, sharp retort, and unspoken memory. Their banter is perfectly snarky, adding a delicious edge to their unresolved feelings and undeniable attraction. If you love this trope, you’re in for a treat because it’s executed here on nearly every level.

The alternating timeline takes us from Piper and Wyatt’s childhood friendship to the messy teenage breakup that pulled them apart, and it’s heart-wrenchingly believable. Their initial split may have been rooted in something silly—teen boys can be such idiots!—but it feels real, and it adds to the depth and maturity of their reconnection as adults. They’re both still a little immature in some ways, especially Piper, who can be a bit much at times (hence the half-star deduction), but that’s part of what makes this journey feel authentic and messy in the best way.

The island scenes are pure magic. Stranded in the Caribbean, they’re forced to drop their defenses, and the chemistry simmering between them quickly boils over. Wyatt is a perfect book boyfriend—adventurous, caring, and just cocky enough. Watching Piper slowly realize he’s grown into a man she could fall for again was so satisfying, and the way they rediscover each other is sweet, raw, and full of perfect tension. By the end, I was grinning like crazy.

If childhood lovers-to-enemies-to-lovers is your thing, this book nails it. The angst, the chemistry, the beautifully drawn-out reunion—all of it kept me glued to the page. The ending was worth every page of build-up, leaving me with a full heart and a big smile. Highly recommend!

4.5/5

Thanks to NetGalley, the author, and the publisher for a an e-book for review!

Was this review helpful?

I can't resist a cute pink book with second-chance romance and forced proximity. It always means that the story is gonna be fantastic.

This story did not take long at all to hook you in with what makes this book have the forced proximity trope. With the two characters stranded on the island, they have no choice but to suffer through each other's company in order to survive, and it's a constant reminder to both characters about their complicated past with each other.

This book was such a cute and quick read and had such an interesting plot as well. Also for any over-achieving eldest daughters who have high-pressure parents, I am sure you'll make some connections. Overall I just had a great time with this book and the ending truly had me hooked to my seat with anticipation.

Thank you to Avon and Harper Voyager for a chance to read and review this book in exchange for my honest opinion.

Was this review helpful?

I enjoyed this book! Ex-lovers crash on an island together. Will they survive alone on the island? I liked how it was written in 2 difference timelines: "now" and "then". I loved reading about their budding romance in high school, but it got a little confusing jumping around the high school timeline. I loved their slow reconnection on the island. I loved their banter, but wanted more of it! There was very little spice, but I wouldn't call this a closed door romance.

I would recommend this for someone getting into romance books! I look forward to more books from this author.

Was this review helpful?

I received this ARC in exchange for my honest review.

I have become more open minded towards second chance romances lately, and this one was a fun one! I like the forced proximity trope where the plane crashed too.

Was this review helpful?

Annie McQuaid's debut is full of high stakes and even higher swooning. Readers will be rooting for both Piper and Wyatt's love story and survival from page one. This dual-timeline adventure romance is tender, suspenseful, and sensual, all at once

Was this review helpful?

I really wanted to like this one but I struggled to get through it and eventually had to DNF @ 30%. I believe this story is for someone else but not me and that’s okay!

Was this review helpful?

3.5⭐/.5 🌶️

First thank you to Netgalley for this arc! :)

I picked this arc after seeing how beautiful the cover was, and im happy to say the book inside was just as sweet! It starts a little slow. Honestly i was a little annoyed at how many brands got name dropped at first lmao. I started to highlight and count. Like ok i get it, our fmc is wealthy!

But i love a good second chance romance, and our mmc was such a cinnamon roll sweetheart. Im so happy he got this opportunity, even if it was at the cost of a whole play crashing 😰 I know this doesnt come out for a while, but i recommend this for a unique romance read! Not often you see the plan crash situation being used.

Was this review helpful?

Annie McQuaid delivers a compelling blend of second chances, forced proximity, and a hint of enemies-to-lovers, all wrapped in a gripping survival adventure. This heartfelt story follows two childhood sweethearts, separated by time and circumstance, who are forced to confront their unresolved feelings and unfinished love.

The novel follows Piper Adams, a young medical student who feels stuck in her life—unsure about her career, disconnected from her boyfriend, and haunted by memories of someone from her past. That someone is Wyatt, the boy who broke her heart and disappeared from her life without a trace, leaving behind lingering pain and unanswered questions.

Piper’s immediate concern, however, is making it to the Bahamas for her best friend Allie’s wedding. What she doesn't see coming are two major obstacles: her flight is suddenly canceled, and she bumps into Wyatt—Allie’s cousin and the very man who left her devastated—at the airport. Wyatt, now a pilot, offers her a ride in his small plane, and although Piper is hesitant, she agrees for Allie’s sake, all while promising herself she’ll keep her emotional distance.

But fate has other plans. A violent storm forces their plane to crash on a deserted island, leaving Piper no choice but to rely on the man she’s spent years resenting. In this unexpected survival scenario, Piper and Wyatt must put aside their old wounds to work together. As they fight for their lives, Piper discovers that Wyatt, now a man hardened by his military service, is not the same boy who once broke her heart. His desire to make amends becomes clear, and the chemistry between them rekindles. While their chances for survival become more dire, their long-buried feelings start to resurface. Could this crisis offer them a shot at the love they never fully had?

What makes this story shine is the way it jumps between the past and present, showing how Piper and Wyatt have both changed, yet their connection remains undeniable. Piper’s overbearing mother adds another layer of tension, with her character often feeling like the antagonist of Piper’s personal journey. The island scenes are gritty and realistic, full of tension, as the two navigate both the physical dangers of their environment and their emotional scars. I found myself rooting for them to overcome their pride and finally communicate the truths they’ve kept buried for years.

In short, I wholeheartedly recommend this book! It’s an emotional second-chance romance that balances survival elements with genuine, heartfelt connection.

Thank you to NetGalley, Avon, and Harper Voyager for providing me with a digital copy in exchange for my honest review!

Was this review helpful?

This was such a fun time. I think it is a good start for new readers of the genre as well . I think it was super sweet and precious.

Was this review helpful?

I absolutely adored this book! I'm a sucker for a rom-com set on the beach, and this one had the twist of a plane crash to shake things up and raise the stakes. The author's choice to switch back and forth between the "then" chapters and the "now" chapters built up a nice slow burn and kept me blazing through the pages to find out what happened next in each timeline. Both Piper and Wyatt's story arcs felt fleshed out and real from start to finish, but I couldn't have loved Wyatt's character development more. Swoon! I couldn't stop smiling after this one, and I'll definitely pick up anything and everything by Annie McQuaid in the future.

Thank you to NetGalley and Avon/ Harper Voyager for the ARC in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?