Skip to main content

Member Reviews

A charming cozy mystery!

There’s something about this genre that’s always a bit hit or miss for me but I’m happy to say this was a such a fun read! I really liked Pom’s character and her growth throughout to book from a spoiled socialite to a crime solving and baking socialite that cares about people.

The mystery itself was intriguing and low stakes which went really well with a cup of tea. I also really enjoyed all the descriptions of Pom’s bakes, which went really well with a brownie lol. I did wish we got to know Gabe a bit more outside the case. He and Pom are very cute but I feel like their getting together happened so quickly.

I really hope this turns into a series because I would love to read more of Pom’s crime solving and baking of course!

Pub date: 3/18

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for this arc in exchange for my honest review

Was this review helpful?

Oh how i loved how silly this book was. I love a good Cozy mystery.
Pomona Afton is an heiress, and a bit aloof, but that all changes when her grandma is murdered! She's cut off from her trust fund and kicked out of her home... what's a girl to do??? Enter Gabe, a charming manager at a coffee shop. He takes a chance on Pom and gives her a job.
I did not want to put this book down! Fantastic read!!!

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to Atria Books for the widget. I love a good cozy murder mystery, and if it gives GG vibes yes please. Pomona is trying to solve the murder of her grandmother and has to go slum it. I really enjoyed this book and seeing Pomona reflect on who she was and who she is becoming. This really made me question if there are people that are that oblivious who have money the way that life works but I guess there is. I hope there are more murders to solve because this was a really cute book

Was this review helpful?

🧁 My review for Pomona Afton Can So Solve a Murder. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

✨A fun story that has murder, mystery, self-discovery, pastries, and a missing furball!

✨Pomona, a hotel heiress, is living her best life until her assets are frozen and forced out of her comfortable lifestyle. Thrown into the real world due to the sudden death of her grandma she connects with her old nanny, who helps her finds a temporary place to call home.

✨Gabe was looking for a roommate and was happy when his mom informed him that she found someone. Pom was the last person he expected, coming into his life and turning it upside down.

✨Forced to become allies to discover clues as to what happened with her grandma. They find themselves bonding over clues, coffee, pastries, and a fur baby.

✨Such a fun ride trying to figure out who done it while watching an unlikely friendship blossom into something so much sweeter while figuring out who you are meant to be.

✨Thank you @Net Galley and Simon and Schuster Publisher for

Was this review helpful?

“The first time grandma called, I ignored her.”
Here are reasons to read the Mystery book:

Hotel Heiress - Pomona is the heiress to family hotel business, so she basically just does galas and spa days
Dead grandma - when her grandmother dies unexpectedly, she finds herself without a place to live
Frozen Inheritance - The details surrounding her death are suspicious, which makes all inheritance frozen for a full year.
Solve it - Pomona finds herself on her own, living with a roommate, and the only thing she can do is solve this case to get her life back.

I have read quite a few books lately where someone in the family dies and there are some hoops to jump through for the inheritance. And believe me when I say, I enjoyed this book so much it was my favorite book for February. The characters are fun, and while Pomona could be very vapid, she quickly realizes her past actions were not humble or giving, without it feeling forced. I really loved her character arc AND the twist was very surprising.

Was this review helpful?

A fun read with a heroine you can appreciate. Pomona Afton, the spoiled daughter of a wealthy New York city couple, finds herself out on the street after her grandmother's death. She picks herself off and determines (so that she can get her inheritance0 to solve her grandmother's murder.

As readers we meet a variety of suspects and come through with an unexpected bad guy. A fun read!

Was this review helpful?

"Pomona Afton Can So Solve a Murder" by Bellamy Rose is a delightful blend of cozy mystery, romance, and self-discovery set in New York City's high society. The story follows Pomona Afton, a spoiled hotel heiress. Her life is completely changed when her grandmother, the matriarch of the Afton family, is murdered. Her trust fund is frozen until the killer is found. Pomona must figure out the real world for the first time, moving in with Gabe, the son of her former nanny, and working at his coffee shop.

The novel balances humor and suspense, making it a great read from beginning to end. Pomona's transformation from a sheltered socialite to a determined detective is fun to read about. Her journey is filled with unexpected twists and turns, keeping the reader engaged and guessing until the end. The chemistry between Pomona and Gabe creates a romantic element to the story without taking from the mystery.

This book is a fun must-read for anyone looking for a light-hearted mystery with romance.

Was this review helpful?

I ADORED this book and I am Pomona Afton's biggest fan. This book charmed me instantly with its blend of romance, humor, and light mystery, plus the touch of satire was just delightful.

Pomona Afton, initially a spoiled socialite, evolves into a lovable character through hilarious misadventures and genuine self-discovery following the mysterious death of her grandmother. Pomona's transformation from privileged and clueless to grounded and self-aware is the heart of the story, a journey of finding purpose beyond comfort and forming meaningful relationships.

Gabe, the gentle and supportive foil to Pom's chaos, plays a key role in her growth and I loved that their sweet romance, while filled with chemistry, was built on a foundation of genuine friendship and feels like a classic rom-com. While the murder mystery is fun and cozy, it provides an entertaining backdrop for character development. The focus is less on the "whodunit" and more on Pomona's growth and her evolving connections.

Ultimately, this delightful read prioritizes character growth, laughter, and love. The author has earned a spot on my must-read list, and I will be recommending to EVERYONE. 4.5⭐ rounded up!

Was this review helpful?

Pomona Afton has never had to work too hard for anything in her life. As a spoiled heiress to a hotel line, everything she needs has always been provided for her. But when she accidentally comes across the murder scene of her grandmother, her life gets completely flipped upside down. Her grandmother was not a nice person and it turns out she suspected that she might die by murder. The entire Afton fortune has been frozen until the murder gets solved and Pomona has to move in with her old nanny's son, Gabe. Will she and Gabe actually be able to solve the murder on their own and get Pom's old life back?

This was the perfect cozy mystery with a little bit of romance and I found myself rooting for Pom throughout the story! I loved her character development and how she realized what was really important in life. Her and Gabe's murder investigation was fun to follow and kept me invested the whole time. I also loved their relationship and how they grew together through some pretty crazy circumstances. The writing made me laugh several times and I thought Pom's character and dialogue was written perfectly. If you're looking for an easy read with a lot of heart and some mystery, definitely add this one to your list!

Thank you to NetGalley and Atria Books for the ARC!

Was this review helpful?

Think Paris Hilton solving her grandmother’s murder….this one was a hoot! A spoiled rich girl loses everything when her grandmother dies from unnatural causes due to a clause in her will. The family will only get what is rightfully theirs when the murderer is caught!

I love a good cozy mystery in between my thrillers. With a little romcom sprinkled within, this will suit people who enjoy multiple genres. I really grew attached to Pom as she changed throughout the story, the new person she became. I was rooting for her til the end, and was ecstatic to see what she decided to do with her fortune. It goes to show, people can change for the better!💕

Was this review helpful?

Review: Pomona Afton, a spoiled heiress, must solve her grandmother's murder to avoid losing her inheritance, as the will freezes her assets if death is suspicious. She teams up with Gabe, the son of her former nanny, to investigate. As they uncover twists, a romance complicates the situation.

Narrative Structure and Style: The story is light and cliché, with fast pacing but minimal suspense or depth. The writing feels rushed, especially towards the end, with the resolution too neat and lacking tension. Some filler moments disrupt the flow.

Themes and Impact: While exploring privilege and self-discovery, the themes aren't fully realized. Pomona's growth feels superficial, and the romance lacks emotional depth.

Character Development: Pomona is hard to connect with, starting as spoiled and self-centered, with a forced character arc. Gabe’s character is underdeveloped, and their dynamic lacks charm.

Final Thoughts: Pomona Afton Can So Solve a Murder is a light, easy read with a low-stakes mystery and romance, but the execution falls short. Predictable plot and shallow characters make it more suitable for readers who enjoy formulaic mysteries than those seeking depth. It's a cute story, but not one I'd revisit.

Disclaimer: This review is based on an ARC received from NetGalley and Atria Books

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley and Atria for sharing this ARC with me for an honest review.

4/5 Stars

This book felt very Paris Hilton meets Gossip Girl meets Only Murders in the Building. It was fantastic for the most part. I genuinely could not guess the ending and enjoyed all of the plot twists.

Pomona Afton clearly grew up with a silver spoon in her mouth and drastically unaware of the realities of the real world without a trust fund to fall back on. The most annoying part of the book was the very beginning with her lack of awareness and reluctance to grow. But this probably what made her character arc so satisfying. It was such a joy to go on that journey with her and watch her gain confidence in her own abilities. She truly grew so much as her own person, for lack of a better term, it made me 'mama hen' proud.

Gabe was exactly the reality wake up call she needed. While I was frustrated with how he treated her at first, I understood where he came from. Coming from two polar opposite ends of society, it was fun to watch them both bounce off of each other and grow.

I was so hungry throughout this book because of all the baked goods mentioned.

Bellamy did a great job keeping me on the edge of my seat and engaged in the mystery. I do wish there was a tad more romance.

Trope:
- Forced Proximity
- Opposite Sides of the Tracks
- Who dun it?

Was this review helpful?

Cute, fluffy murder mystery with a romance sub plot. Hotel heiress and party girl Pomona loses everything when her grandmother is murdered, she has to solve the cases to regain her inheritance. A bit predictable but moved along, would read more from this author. Thanks to NetGalley and Atria for an advanced copy for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

DNF @ 10%. The plot was moving too slowly and there wasn't enough dialogue to keep me interested. Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for allowing me to be an early reader. All thoughts are my own.

Was this review helpful?

(3.5, rounded up to 4)

Bellamy Rose's "Pomona Afton Can So Solve a Murder" is an utterly delightful blend of murder mystery and rom-com, served with a sharp sense of humor.

The story follows the glamorous and privileged heiress Pomona "Pom" Afton, who finds herself abruptly stripped of her comforts when her grandmother is murdered and all family assets are frozen until the killer is identified. The book’s high-stakes premise combines with Pom’s personal journey, turning the heiress into an amateur sleuth as she learns to navigate the real world and solve the murder in one fell swoop.

Rose’s narrative strikes the perfect balance between intrigue and hilarity, with Pom’s misadventures offering plenty of hijinks and charm. Pom is a captivating heroine, flawed but endearing, and her evolving dynamic with Gabe, the son of her former nanny, adds a sweet romantic subplot. Gabe’s grounded perspective complements Pom’s larger-than-life personality, and together, they tackle the mystery with humor and unexpected competence. The inclusion of quirky, "Schitt's Creek"–esque humor ensures the tone remains breezy, even amidst the murder investigation.

With its lively pacing, sharp wit, and cast of memorable characters, "Pomona Afton Can So Solve a Murder" is a thoroughly entertaining read. Bellamy Rose delivers a sparkling debut in the mystery genre, complete with her signature flair for romantic chemistry and vivid storytelling. Fans of cozy mysteries and rom-coms alike will relish this tale of a fallen heiress learning to stand on her own, all while solving a murder with charm and determination.

Was this review helpful?

From the very first page, I was utterly enchanted by this delightful gem of a book. A perfect blend of romance, humor, and just the right touch of mystery, it offers a wonderfully light escape that lingers long after you turn the last page. The story centers around Pomona Afton, a privileged young woman who, despite her initial spoiled and clueless demeanor, quickly becomes a character impossible not to love. Her hilarious misadventures and genuine evolution into a more self-aware, grounded individual make her journey of self-discovery both satisfying and heartwarming.

Pomona’s transformation is at the heart of this novel, and it’s beautifully captured. What begins as a tale of a rich girl stumbling through life turns into something much more meaningful—a story about finding one’s purpose beyond the comfort of privilege. Watching Pomona navigate her personal growth, particularly as she begins to form real, heartfelt relationships, is a rewarding experience that left me cheering for her every step of the way.

And then there’s Gabe. He is the perfect foil to Pomona’s whirlwind of chaos—gentle, kind, and quietly encouraging in a way that makes him impossible not to adore. His quiet strength and support are a beautiful contrast to Pomona’s initial naivety, and I absolutely loved how he introduced her to the joys of baking. What begins as a simple shared activity between them transforms into a passion that helps reshape Pomona’s world and her sense of self. Their romance felt like a classic romcom dream—sweet, tender, and crackling with chemistry. Each scene between them made me smile, and their connection felt both inevitable and incredibly special.

The relationships in this book are truly enchanting. Not just the romance, but also the way Pomona forges meaningful bonds with those around her. Watching her evolve from a self-centered young woman into someone who embraces her own flaws and strengths is beautifully rendered. It’s a journey of self-discovery that feels genuine, and one I was privileged to follow.

While the murder mystery at the core of the plot may not be the most intricate, it provides an entertaining backdrop to the characters’ development. The unconventional detective work adds a charming layer of humor to the narrative, and while the focus is less on the whodunit, the journey itself is thoroughly engaging. The killer's reveal wasn't much of a shock—it was pretty easy to guess halfway through—but I still had a fantastic time watching it all unfold.

Was this review helpful?

TY to Atria Books and Simon & Schuster Audio for the gifted early copies!

Pomona Afton Can So Solve A Murder is Schitt’s Creek meets Only Murders in the Building and the best way to describe it is just FUN! It’s got a real mystery, plenty of amateur sleuthing, and none of the usual cheesiness that you often find in cozy mysteries. The characters are real CHARACTERS (you know what I mean) and I couldn’t get enough of them. I’m desperately hoping for a follow up with Pomona and Gabe!

The only thing “missing” from this book is the romance — it definitely takes a backseat. This was totally fine for me, but if you’re expecting more of a mystery/romance combo, you might be a little disappointed.

Audio: Jennifer Jill Araya does a great job bringing Pomona’s saga to life. While I don’t think it would make my list of *best* audiobooks, it’s a solid and steady performance that I’d easily recommend to anyone interested in this story!

Was this review helpful?

Think: If Alexis Rose tried to solve a murder to get her family fortune back, what would have happened?! Pomona Afton CAN solve a murder, and I really enjoyed watching her grow as a character.

Was this review helpful?

A debut novel and the first in a new mystery series. Pomona Afton, a hotel heiress who is used to her Upper East Side life. She discovers the body of her dead grandmother after leaving a gala. It turns out the grandmother was beloved and was a little paranoid. She left a clause in her will freezing all her assets if her death comes from foul play.

Pomona is a clueless rich girl who doesn’t know how to survive in the city without her trust fund. But this death gives her a purpose. If she can solve the mystery she will get her assets and inheritance back. Locked out of her penthouse apartment she turns to Gabe, the son of her former nanny. He allows her to move into his small space. And he agrees to help her as his mothers retirement is also locked up by the freeze. He is a cinnamon roll sweetie. He is kind and earnest and attractive too.

The mystery isn’t difficult to solve. But a lot of the fun of this story is Pomona undergoing personal growth from the spoiled rich girl to someone who cares about others. Gabe is there as a partner in mystery solving and potential romance. Even though they are living together they don’t get beyond kissing and agreeing to a date in this book.

I enjoy cozy mysteries but I have a hard time committing to a new series until I’ve read more than one book. But this has good bones to build on and I look forward to the next book.

Was this review helpful?

Pomona Afton Can So Solve a Murder is a new cozy mystery by Bellamy Rose. This book a a great pick for those who love:
* Fish out of water stories
* New York City
* Murder Mysteries
* Clean romance
Pomona Afton’s world is flipped upside down when her grandmother is murdered. Without access to her trust fund and apartment, Pomona is forced to make it in the real world. Pomona teams up with Gabe, her former nanny’s son, to solve the mystery and regain her social status. This was an easy read with a few laugh out loud moments and some pretty good twists. It also appears that this book is the first of a series. I give it a 3.5 for being a solid mystery with a satisfying ending. Thank you NetGalley and Atria Books for allowing me to read an advanced reader's copy of the book for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?