Skip to main content

Member Reviews

I really enjoyed this book! It’s a super cute mystery (I wouldn’t categorize it under cozy) with fun characters trying to solve a murder in NYC. This book had a few twists and turns that kept you guessing the whole time who the murderer was. I loved Pom, the main character, even though she slightly drove me crazy in the beginning but I grew to love her. I do love a flawed main character. Highly recommend if you need an entertaining, silly, and well written mystery!

Was this review helpful?

This rom-com-meets-murder-mystery offers an entertaining premise with Pomona Afton—a spoiled heiress forced to step out of her comfort zone to solve her grandmother’s murder and reclaim her trust fund. Pom’s journey from privileged socialite to amateur detective has its share of humorous and heartfelt moments, especially as she navigates life without luxury and grows closer to Gabe, her grumpy yet endearing roommate. While the quirky premise is fun, the plot occasionally feels predictable, and the mystery's resolution lacks the punch needed for a stronger impact. Still, Pom’s character growth and her budding romance with Gabe make it an enjoyable, if not groundbreaking, read. A light, breezy story for fans of comedic whodunits.

Was this review helpful?

OMG, this book is so fun! I literally loved everything about it. A little Clueless, a little Gossip Girl, a smidge of Legally Blonde, and a whole lot of heart. I want to read more about Pom and Gabe, baking treats and solving crimes. Thanks to Emily Bestler Books/Atria for the ARC.

Was this review helpful?

We love a murder mystery - rom com combo! While I like a rom com, I prefer a little more intrigue than will they or won’t they (or more, when will they). The main character has a sweet growth arc and who can resist the drama of the uber-rich set in NYC? I hope the author writes more like this one!

Was this review helpful?

Pomona Afton CAN So Solve A Murder!!
This was short and so much fun! After a fall from grace due to her grandmothers death, Pomona takes on the task of solving her murder to gain her inheritance back.
I had so much fun with this book!
- Pomonas effort to get her life back on track, and even improve in her life
- Her journey to being a better person and finding things she loved in baking
- Watching her grow as a better person as she learned to be a good roommate, friend, and cousin
- I loved their detective skills, how they pieced things together through out, and how they eventually solved the murder

I really had no complaints about Pomona! I am looking forward to her next shenanigans.

Was this review helpful?

Pomona Afton Can So Solve a Murder by Bellamy Rose
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
🚫

Two books in one week with no spice? I'm clearly losing my edge. Going to have find something with Carolina Reaper level spice for my next read- any recommendations???


This was a cozy mystery that @netgalley and @atriabooks were nice enough to let me have a digital ARC of.

Pom is the wealthy socialite with no idea how good she has it until her grandmother is suddenly murdered and her trust fund is frozen until the murderer is caught. Turns out grandma suspected someone close to her might do her in and changed her will. When it seems like no one else is going to step up, Pom decides that she is going to solve the murder along with the help of Gabe- her former nanny's son and now roommate.

The mystery side of this novel was fun, but nothing in depth or sophisticated. I did like how there were several legitimate suspects, and that the final reveal wasn't super obvious from the beginning. The romance was PG, but sweet. The thing I really enjoyed was Pom's character development and her sense of humor. Even when she was just making fun of herself, it was entertaining and made the book fly by.

Was this review helpful?

I absolutely loved Pomona Afton Can So Solve A Murder! From the start Pom is giving all of the Alexis Rose vibes you can imagine. We see a once absurdly wealthy NYC socialite fall from grace when she loses her inheritance after her grandmother’s untimely death and are privy to her at times infuriating, almost always hilarious, inner monologue as she starts to learn how to make it in the real world, all while attempting to solve the mystery of the murder. Pom and Gabe make a fantastic duo and it was great to see their relationship and really all of Pom’s relationships grow and develop as she comes to realize her rich and famous lifestyle may not have been all it was cracked up to be. If you’re looking for a lighthearted and minimally gruesome murder-mystery this is the book for you!

Was this review helpful?

My first 2025 book! Imagine Only Murders in the Building, but with Paris Hilton as its lead detective. The first novel by Bellamy Rose (a pen name for a romance writer) does indeed blend the Rom Com and Cozy Mystery genres for a fully enjoyable, wholly engrossing read. Pomona is a heroine you want to root for, as she leaves the clouds of her privilege and takes to the (she thinks) mean streets (they're fine) of Manhattan (and, much to her dismay, Queens). This mystery is fun to watch unfold, is breezy, and will make you never want to leave a pair of high heels in your home ever again. Add into the mix an enemies-to-lovers romance, plenty of hilarious hi-jinxes, and dysfunctional family dynamics, and you have the great start to what could be a rather exciting new series.

Was this review helpful?

This is a comedic mystery that will certainly find its audience amongst lovers of cozy mysteries with heartfelt stories and laugh out loud humor at the heart of the story. We follow Pomona as she aims to uncover the mystery behind her grandmother's death, which also triggered her trust fund being frozen as well. In order to access her money, this spoiled heiress must unravel the clues to find her grandmother's killer.

While the humor didn't land with me most of the time, I know this will definitely be a hit with someone that appreciates the Schitt's Creek rich-girl-coping-without-her-money vibes.

Was this review helpful?

A fun read…that feels like a modern cozy…think Finlay Donovan, Dial A For Aunties, & Vera Wong! I need to do some sleuthing myself to see if this is a first in a series and if there is plans for more murders to be solved by Pom & Gabe.

What I loved…
* Hotel heiress
* Trust funds
* The upper East side
* Galas
* Son of the former nanny
* Sleuthing buddy’s
* Delicious baked goods
* Major characters growth for Pom

An amazing debut and I could see many more opportunities for more shenanigans with this socialite💖

Thank you Atria/Emily Bestler Books
Release 3/18

Follow me on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/Lyon.brit.Andthebookshelf/

Was this review helpful?

What a fun premise, who doesn't love a socialite that is taken down and has to live in the real world? Well, if you give your character no personality, is some sort of savant at baking since she's making up recipes despite never cooked once in her life, and continues to rely on others to raiser her, then you've got a bad book.

Thank you to NetGalley for the ARC for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

I LOVED how this book flowed throughout the entirety read. I loved the suspense, the characters and how put together this book was. The development and the book in general kept me reading it as much as I could until it was over. Definitely recommend this read!

Was this review helpful?

I received an ARC from the publisher in exchange for an honest review

Pomona Afton Can So Solve a Murder by Bellamy Rose is a first-POV mystery inspired by Paris Hilton. Pomona Afton is a socialite heiress to the Afton Hotels and has a robust career as an influencer. When her grandmother is murdered and the assets are frozen, Pomona loses her safety net and moves in with Gabe, the son of her former nanny. Her grandmother's will says everything will get returned to Pomona and her family if the murderer is found, but Pomona only has a year to do it.

I recently realized that I strongly prefer mysteries that are character-driven with a strong voice and this was the book that helped me understand that. Pomona's voice reads a lot like Paris Hilton circa her That's So Hot era. Bellamy Rose did more than take the voice and the hotel heiress aspects: she also took the complexity of realizing that you're kind of alone once the party stops and the emotionally distant family that we've started to see now that the layers of Paris’ life are peeling back. It's not a perfect recreation of Paris’ life, but if you're a fan of hers, I think this will be a fun read.

Gabe and Pomona's relationship gets off on the wrong foot, mainly because Pomona doesn't even remember his name or really cares about him at first. She's still quite self-centered and Gabe is, rightfully, cautious about a young woman who has never had to work for a living taking up space in his apartment. They soon find mutual admiration for each other and Gabe supports her newfound love of baking and her investigation, though he also does some stumbling on the way. I love it when a romantic arc is two people trying their best and I really liked this one. If there is a sequel, I want them happily in love and getting through things as a couple because that could be so interesting given their very different POVs as individuals.

Pomona has a lot of growth but never loses what makes her Pomona. She loves fashion, she cares a lot about how things look, she's kind of spoiled and doesn't want to go to Queens without a really good reason. But she also learns how to admit when she's wrong, be more proactive, and to start standing up to her mother's criticism. The last thing I would have wanted was for her to do a complete 180 and start to say that fashion is shallow and that she hates make-up now; it just wouldn't feel like an authentic arc. I really liked how she both could grow and change emotionally and in how she treats people, in how she finds a love of baking, but I still fully believe that the woman who woke-up in chapter one with a hangover after a party and is planning on going to a gala is the same person that we end the book on.

I would recommend this to fans of voicey mysteries and readers who love Paris Hilton-esque characters

Was this review helpful?

If you’re under 30, yes, otherwise read something with a little more substance. The cover is the best thing about the book, the rest of it is sophomoric.

Was this review helpful?

I devoured this book! The humor reminded me of *Schitt’s Creek* and *Only Murders in the Building*—two shows I absolutely love. But what really kept me hooked wasn’t just the laughs, it was the mystery. I couldn’t put the book down until I solved the murder myself!

What I really appreciated in this story was how Pomona and Gabe are both amateurs when it comes to detective work. As Pomona digs into the case with Gabe by her side, it’s clear she doesn’t really need him to crack the case. This not only allows Pomona to prove to herself that she’s more than capable, but it also shows she can solve the problem on her own, without a hero swooping in to save the day.

This is a fantastic story about the power of surrounding yourself with people who truly support you, realizing that money can’t buy kindness or happiness, and showing everyone—including yourself—that you can rise to the occasion when others underestimate you.

Was this review helpful?

This book was different form the type of books i usually read, I don't think I've actually read a murder mystery before! But this book was so fun and a good time. Like trying to figure out who killed your grandmother so you can get your families back? Such an intriguing plot and it worked well

Was this review helpful?

In the interest of full disclosure, I received an ARC of this book from Net Galley in exchange for an unbiased review.

This is a very cute, cozy mystery that is exactly what is says on the tin - a temporarily broke hotel heiress tries to solve her grandmother’s murder in order to gain back her trust fund while growing as a person. Props to Bellamy Rose because Pomona Afton could easily have been an annoying, insufferable, poor little rich girl character, but instead she Rose crafted a character that was not only somehow relatable despite her circumstances, but someone you’d actually want to be friends with. The plot was engaging, and while I guessed the murder weapon and its original owner pretty much right away, I only figured out the murderer and motive around the time that Pom did. In my experience, most mysteries are either too clever, making it almost impossible to identify the murderer on your own, or too obvious, making the characters seem stupid and annoying for not figuring it out earlier, but Bellamy Rose did a great job balancing the mystery so it was solvable without giving it away too early.

If I had to nitpick, it might be that the themes of growth, class differences, and income inequality were a little heavy handed and might benefit from a bit more subtlety, but Pom isn’t exactly a subtle character anyway, and for such a short, light novel the heavy-handedness was probably unavoidable. It still gets 5 stars, not because it’s the next great American novel (and let’s be real, those are usually dreary and depressing anyway) but because it is an excellent example of what it is - a cute, cozy mystery, with an engaging plot and sweet romantic side plot. 10/10 would recommend as a beach or vacation read, and I really hope Bellamy Rose keeps the series going.

Things I loved: Gabe, oh Gabe. What a solid, cinnamon roll of a love interest, and a his grounded ness was such a perfect foil for Pom’s everything. I especially liked how we got to skip the whole animosity and “teasing” Pom for having no life skills, because Gabe just doesn’t do that. He supported her from the beginning without giving her grief, which was refreshing to read. I also love Grandma, who was a total bitch but a killer character. And, honestly, Pom. I was prepared to enjoy the book but hate the narrator, and it was refreshing just how likable she was. Also, her disdain for Queens (sorry not sorry).

Things I didn’t: Nah, it all worked for me. The Vienna storyline was again, a little heavy handed and could have used some more development as it didn’t add too much to Pom’s inner growth arc, but again, that’s just a complete nitpick.

Perfect for fans of: Deux Moi (even gets name dropped a couple of times), cozy mysteries, The Simple Life and Cow Belles, family dramas, Starbucks, pastries (I’m craving coffee and brownies right now, at 11pm), and NYC

Was this review helpful?

This was such a lovely mix of genres! I'm a huge fan of Amanda's romances, and this has all the same character development of those books infused with the mystery and humor of ONLY MURDERS IN THE BUILDING!

Was this review helpful?

Hotel heiress Pomona Afton's life is completely turned upside-down when her grandmother is found murdered in her private suite one morning. Her grandmother's death isn't really the heartbreak one would imagine. Pom's never had a great relationship with the woman and she's always been about as cold as they come. But the true heartbreak lies in the legal ramifications of her death. According to a new will, if Pom's grandmother were to die from an "unnatural death," that all Afton assets would be frozen and all members of the Afton family would be escorted from the premises and forced to figure things out on their own. And that is where we find our heroine, stuck working at a coffee shop and living in a cramped apartment with the son of her former nanny. Things are looking rough for our sweet, yet oblivious protagonist when she makes the decision to solve this murder. Partnered with her new roommate Gabe, the duo sift through the messy details of Pom's life and family members to discover who would have wanted this matriarch dead.

For me, this novel was around a 3.75 rating. The first offense for this novel, for me, is that it wasn't compelling. I am a busy working mom, but, if properly hooked in a story, I will make sure I'm getting my reading done. With this book, if I didn't have a boring day at work full of monitoring students taking make-up finals, I'm not sure if I would ever finished it. It was not compelling in the least. Pomona was charming and likable enough for a spoiled hotel heiress, as were the rest of the characters, but there were too many obvious red herrings. In terms of the mystery, I was never really totally mystified. All of the discovered "murderers" I almost immediately wrote off. It was too soon in the novel and just too obvious. And, unfortunately, it didn't take me long to identify who the true killer was.

Overall, good characters, but weak story that didn't have me hooked or mystery that didn't have me puzzled.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you NetGalley and the publisher for the opportunity to read and review this book!

I really enjoyed the character development and how well the story flowed. I related to a lot of the FMC’s difficulty on getting people to really see her and her true colors.

Truly great book and can’t wait to read more from this author.

Was this review helpful?