Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Thank you Kathryn Purdie and Net galley for allowing me to read this ARC

I loved this duology. I feel like it was the perfect combination between a Grimm Brothers story and a fairytale of it own originality. This story was more focused on Clara and her growth within herself after her first journey into the forest. She had to learn to trust herself and her magic along with learning her relationship with Axel. There was a lot of twists and turns and some may find it confusing but I loved it. At times I felt like I was a Lost One myself trying to learn what was true and what was fiction through Clara’s point of view. Throughout the whole book there was so many people who I thought would be the murderer but at the end I was shocked at who it was and enjoyed being wrong.

This is a book that will stick with me for a long time. I wish I could go into the Grimm Forest again for the first time and get that feeling. But for now I will highly recommend this duology to anyone who asks.

Was this review helpful?

The Deathly Grimm by Kathryn Purdie seamlessly blends dark fantasy with elements of mystery and eerie fairy tales. The story continues to follow Clara and Axel as they reenter the cursed Forest Grimm, determined to lift the lingering curse threatening their village.

The story is fast-paced and action-packed filled with unexpected twists and turns. The evolving relationship between Clara and Axel adds emotional depth, with their romantic tension enhancing the narrative without overshadowing the central quest.

Purdie’s lyrical prose and vivid descriptions effectively convey the eerie beauty of the Forest Grimm, immersing readers in its haunting ambiance.

The Deathly Grimm is a satisfying and thrilling conclusion to the duology, with its intricate plot, well-developed characters, and evocative setting.

Was this review helpful?

First I would like to thank Netgalley for approving this arc for me to read.

I will be honest I quite enjoyed the first book, but this one was even better than the first and honestly probably should have been the story of the first book. We delve more into lore, the mystery of who the killer is, and the family line of our main character Clara. We meet more famed Grimm fairytale characters, and how the lost became them. I do honestly wish what was led in this book was a bit more in the first as then so much more texture and story building could have been added. I really loved the lore, and the exploration we have of Clara's power in this one. I won't go into more details so not to spoil the book, but I will say I loved this one a lot more than the first.

Was this review helpful?

Epic finale to a dark leaning fairytale retelling
Things I liked
-tarot cards (these are a big focus because her grandma reads tarot)
-a lot of fairytales with a dark twist including Rumplestiltskin, Snow White, Pied Piper, and more
-Some less common fairytale characters are included in the retelling (not many pied piper and Jack and the beanstalk retellings so this is unique)
-cursed village/woods
-rare magic abilities
Things I didn’t enjoy
-some parts were hard to figure out had to keep going back to see if it was present day or a vision

Was this review helpful?

I enjoyed The Deathly Grimm, but like many sequels, it lacked a certain "something". It was a good book, but it never quite got as good as the first one; I'm not sure why. Maybe it was because some of the fairy tale tie-ins seemed a bit more forced in this volume than in the first one - but it was fun looking for the references to fairy tales and seeing how they were modified to fit into this volume. For anyone who enjoyed The Forest Grimm, this volume clears up the plot points left hanging on the the story very well.

Clara and Axel once again enter the forest voluntarily, looking for missing people from their village, and seeking the missing page from the Book of Secrets so they can break the curse and free the village from the menace of its magic. But there's a twist - the page is being sought by others as well. New characters, with reference to different fairy tales, join the story as it progresses. This novel is appropriate for ages middle school to adult.

I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of this book provided by Netgalley. All thoughts and opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

The Deathly Grimm by Kathryn Purdue is exactly why I enjoy fantasy, particularly dark fantasy. This book was filled with many turns and twists and excited from page to page.

Was this review helpful?

The Deathly Grimm by Katheyn Purdie

I absolutely loved being back in this world and seeing these characters again. At times it did feel repetitive to the first story though.

We're back in the woods, meeting creepy fairytales, trying to break a curse.

If you loved the first book and just want more definitely pick this book up. If you're hoping to continue the story, you night be disappointed.

Was this review helpful?

Clara had thought she'd broken the curse on her town and returned a savior, but the curse is only partially broken and the townspeople blame her and her friends. When a large group of girls dances off into the forest and the curse seems to be coming back, Clara and Axel must enter the forest to fulfill the magical book's prophesy and find the murderer who caused the curse to fall upon the town.

I'm giving this one 3.5 stars but rounding it up to 4 because it does some things very well but it's mostly full of unnecessary elements. The spark from the first book that made you need to know what would happen next to the characters is missing, even as the excellent repurposing of Grimm's Fairy Tales continues to be phenomenal. Clara and Axel seem to be going through the motions even as the things that are happening to them are as magical as ever. The introduction of new characters and their motives adds a nice twist to differentiate from their first foray into the forest, but there's so much emphasis on the drama brewing between Clara and Axel that the plot sometimes feels disjointed.

It's still quite an adventure and has some of the most creative use of characters and motifs from Grimm's Fairy Tales, it's just not as impactful as the first book. It's not an excellent conclusion that lives up to what the first volume set up, but still solid.

Thank you to NetGalley and Wednesday Books for the chance to read the conclusion to this series.

Was this review helpful?

A decent conclusion to this duology.
However, I feel like this book is missing something (not sure what 😂), the pacing just felt off, and honestly wasn’t as good as the first one.
Side note: Definitely read, reread or skim through the first book before picking this one (it picks off right where the last book left off).

Was this review helpful?

The Deathly Grimm is the sequel to The Forest Grimm, a young adult fantasy about a cursed village and the girl who vows to break it.

This conclusion to The Forest Grimm duology picks up where the first book left off. Clara, Axel, and their friends have survived the cursed forest, but it’s not done with their village yet. Desperate to break the curse, they re-enter the forest, hoping that solving the murder case that set everything in motion will finally end it. But to uncover the truth, they must outwit the “lost” villagers who are still trapped in twisted fairy tales and have forgotten who they once were.

Although this was an engaging story, and I like Clara and Axel as characters, I found the murder mystery and the origins of the curse convoluted and difficult to follow. It felt overly complicated, with too many players and motives.

Was this review helpful?

An absolutely stunning, memorable and mesmerizing sequel to The Forest Grimm with high stakes, eerie, hauntingly beautiful forest and a dark setting. It’s the perfect gothic fairytale vibe you can ever wish for, adding layers of love, found family and emotions to the mix!

Was this review helpful?

El nuevo capítulo de la historia de Clara y Axel está mucho más desarrollado y pulido que el anterior, con un estilo que encanta desde la primera página. Hay varios detalles que te llaman la atención, cada uno un misterio más pequeño relacionado con la pregunta millonaria de qué pasó realmente en Grimm's Hollow para que cayera la maldición.

The new chapter in Clara and Axel's story is much more developed and polished than the previous one, with a style that captivates from the first page. Several details catch your attention, each a smaller mystery related to the millionaire question of what really happened in Grimm's Hollow to cause the curse.

Full review published in my blog on Monday, March 31: https://tintanocturna.blogspot.com/2025/03/the-deathly-grimm.html

Was this review helpful?

More twisted fairytales! More Scary forest! And more romantic tension! This book delivered all of the things I wanted more of after reading the first one in the duology. One of my favorite things about the first book was the appearance of familiar fairytales twisted into something new and more like a curse rather than a sweet story that promises a happily-ever-after.

The only thing that I struggled with was the miscommunication between Axel and Clara. Like, I understood that his fixation with finding his dad didn’t mesh well with Clara’s mission to undo the curse on the village. I found it frustrating that the divergent goals went on for so much of the story. However, I can see how that tension worked to isolate Clara and make space for some of the story’s other elements.

I also appreciated the disability representation. Clara describes a spine issue that sounds a bit like scoliosis. She wears a lift in one shoe to make it easier to walk, and someone gives her a corset that operates like a back brace. I love Clara as a character, and I appreciate the representation even more after reading Disfigured: On Fairytales, Disability, and Making Space by Amanda LeDuc, which examines how disabled characters appear in classic fairytales.

Even despite the miscommunication between Clara and Axel, I devoured this book. I think I read two-thirds of it in one evening. It’s a wild ride of a story that cleverly weaves together scenes featuring familiar fairytales. The satisfying conclusion made me want to go back and start the duology all over again.

Was this review helpful?

I will say, I wish I had reread the first book again just so that it was easier to get back into. However, I stil ldid really enjoy it and I like the twists that it took. I think the only thing for me, really, is that the Grimm characters kind of felt a bit forced into the story and didn't feel as natural? It kind of made them feel like they stood out a little too much.

Was this review helpful?

Kathryn Purdie delivers another darkly enchanting tale in The Deathly Grimm, the spellbinding sequel to The Forest Grimm. This book masterfully blends eerie fairy tale elements with heart-pounding adventure, as Clara and Axel are once again forced to face the dangers lurking in the cursed woods.

The novel wastes no time in re-establishing its haunting atmosphere, pulling readers back into the eerie embrace of the forest. Purdie's prose is lush and immersive, painting vivid imagery of the spectral horrors that await Clara and Axel. From riddling woodsmen to ghostly maidens, every new threat adds to the novel’s relentless tension. The stakes feel higher than ever as the forest’s malevolent forces creep closer to their home, making the mission to break the curse all the more urgent.

Clara and Axel's relationship remains a highlight, balancing their deep connection with the dangers that test them at every turn. Their love story is as tangled and perilous as the forest itself, adding emotional weight to their journey. Clara's unsettling visions heighten the suspense, keeping readers on edge as she navigates the fine line between premonition and reality.

While the novel excels in atmosphere and tension, the pacing occasionally falters. Some scenes feel drawn out, and certain riddles or challenges could have been tighter to maintain momentum. However, the eerie world-building and high-stakes adventure more than make up for these lulls.

Overall, The Deathly Grimm is a chilling and mesmerizing sequel that deepens the lore of its dark fairy tale world. Fans of the first book will find plenty to love, while newcomers should prepare for a beautifully twisted journey into the depths of the Forest Grimm.

Would you survive its riddles?

Was this review helpful?

Deathly Grimm is the second book in the Forest Grimm Duology. While I really liked the first book, this second installment was not as fun for me. There were still a lot of things I enjoyed. The world of the forest is still fascinating and the mash up of familiar fairy tale characters is a creative take well worth your time, especially if you enjoy retellings. This is indeed one of the better retellings I have read. However, unlike the first book that keeps the tension and the character growth throughout, I felt this book stretched things out a bit too much at the expense of that growth. Much of the plot depends on both Clara and Axel making the same mistakes over and over again as each doesn't want to believe their relative may be more evil than they want to accept. Overall the mystery and the way in which Purdie adds layers to the story by giving Clara visons through different POV's is done quite well, But for me, by the last act of the story I felt it went on over too many cycles that simply made the story longer. I also felt some of the twists were easy to see from early on, which made Clara and Axel seem to be less perceptive than they should be by this point.

The Deathly Grimm does provide a satisfying ending to the story, but for me, it takes a bit too long to get there.

Was this review helpful?

'The Deathly Grimm' concludes the duology started in 'The Forest Grimm.' Clara and Axel return to the forest in the hopes of getting rid of the curse, once and for all. Another set of darker fairy tales are found within the forest. Once again, love, trust and loyalty battle evil and win. 4 stars.

Was this review helpful?

Rating: 5/5
I received the eARC for my honest opinion.

This book picks up where The Forest Grimm left off, you will see that life has gone back to somewhat normal after Clara, Axel, and Ella. However, when it’s Henni’s turn to make her wish, and she wants to wish the curse away forever, but that is when Clara finds out that she is the key to ending the curse or she might be the one that makes it permanent. Determined to make sure that it’s not permanent Clara and Axel gear up to head into the forest and find the murderer who started the curse, but we all know nothing is ever simple, in this fairytale land.

Wow! Just wow, I loved the way that this author ended this book. I loved all the different mashed-up fairy tales that were written in this book and how they all played a part in ending this curse. You will find a lot of twists and turns throughout the plot but in a great way, I loved that I would start to figure out who it was then boom it changed, and I was like, what is that the murderer or is it this person… or this person. You will find answers to questions that you might have had in the first book answered in this one, and I enjoyed all the new questions that were brought up in this book and I liked the fact that we got pieces of the answers then of course at the end you have it wrapped up nicely. I liked the pace of the book; it would pick up fast and then go right back to steady but for the most part it was fast paced.

The characters are what really make this book shine. I love Clara and how determined she is to find out the truth and end the curse. I found her strength to carry on no matter what, even with her scoliosis adding pain to her, she overcame the physical pain, but it was also the mental pain that she would endure while trying to have visions to help all the people in the village and of course her loved ones as well. I loved how Clara and Axel's relationship was put to the test when someone else comes around once they get to the forest, and as they try to uncover the truths. I loved seeing how Axel didn’t push Clara but allowed her time to understand everything that she was feeling.

I received the audio for this book as well and let me tell you that the narrator does a fantastic job. I listened to the book as I was reading it and with the mood changing throughout the book Sarah Ovens just knows how to give the readers the right emotions that they should be feeling.

I would like to say more, and I would, but I don’t want to spoil the book for other readers. So, what I will end with is this, the world building is amazing, the author’s style of writing will draw you in, the plot with the twists and turns will keep you on your toes, and the challenges that the characters must overcome will leave you on the edge of your seat.

If you like fairy tales that are mashed up perfectly, suspense, mystery and so much more you need to read these duology books.

I want to thank NetGalley and SMP/Macmillan for the opportunity to review this book.

Was this review helpful?

"I still didn't let you go. All the love you showed a creature, all the vulnerability, you made a mark. Somehow, you became a part of me, Clara. I won't ever let you go. Not unless you want me to, and if you do, I understand.""Don't ever think that. You are my home. You are a part of me too. ...
You're my family, Axel, you're my forever."

The Deathly Grimm by Kathryn Purdie

Wow! This one took me on a ride!
Filled with magic, fortune telling, suspense, mystery, and fairy tales retold, this conclusion to this duology kept me on the edge of my seat.
The author blends a variety of fairy tales together which I loved! This felt like a medieval version of Once Upon a Time, with so many twists and turns that I didn't see coming at all, and I was here for it!
The main character, Clara, can see visions to help her understand the past. This is part of her heritage, since her grandmother is a seer of some kind and can predict people's fates with her cards. I enjoyed seeing Clara's growth throughout both books, as she learned to put aside her debilitating pain for the needs of others. Speaking of, I liked that the author included character with scoliosis in these books.
I loved the closure that the characters receive by the end of this book. The author does a great job wrapping everything up that has gone on throughout the story, including any side stories.
There were some parts that were a bit dark for me-like tasting of blood, character wiping blood into symbols on their face (done by a character who lost his/her mind and is evil). So that part grossed me out and was on the verge of horror. I did appreciate the fact that even though the two love interests talked about having s3x, they decided to respect each other and wait until it was the proper  time.
I liked how the author ends the book. No spoilers here.

Overall, I felt this one was well-written, with the descriptions being beautifully done, painting a vivid picture in my mind of my surroundings within the story. The characters and plot were unique to me.

Favorite Parts:
Fairytale retellings, mystery and suspense, sweet romance, brave female main character, respecting boundaries

Content Guide:
Language: Mild-d*mn and h*ll used a few times
Romance/Sexual Content: Closed-door-passionate kissing, thoughts and discussion of s3x, mild innuendos, sensuality and seduction including a kiss with tongue
Violence/gore: Moderate: Fantasy violence, Quite a lot of blood, including tasting of blood, murder, physical abuse (nondescriptive, happens in the past)
Substance Use: mild-character drinks and is drunk in the past
Prejudices: none
Religious Content: none
Other: poisoning, mention of cannibalism, magic and spells, fortune telling-visions and tarot cards, infidelity (discussed as something that happened), illegitimate children, death, possible hallucinations

Thank you to the author and publisher on Netgalley for the audiobook review copy. All thoughts are my own.

Was this review helpful?

KATHRYN HOW DARE YOU

This book was amazing. Everything was amazing. I loved the depth of exploration between the characters. The new fairytales we got to see twisted and told. THE NEW VILLAIN?

I am so grateful that this is how the series ends, even though I didn't want it to end. I really loved the way Purdie is able to honor the original Grimm fairytales with the creepy horror aspect, but doing so in a fantasy setting. Seriously, I loved all of it.

No notes.

Thanks St. Martins Press and Macmillian Audio for the ARCS!

Was this review helpful?