Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Thank you to netgalley and Random House for the ARC!

Hannah Bonam-Young is my auto-buy, auto-read, WHATEVER I have to do do read her books, I will do it. I'm absolutely awed that I even got an ARC, but I'm so thankful I did.

I loved Out on a Limb, the book where we first see Sarah and Caleb, who seem exceedingly happily married, but as we find out in this book, its not quite so. There is no questioning their love for each other, but love isn't always enough, and they can't seem to get past a particularly gnarly marital hurdle. Winn (our heroine from OuaL) suggests a hiking trip led by a therapist and her wife called Reignite, meant to do just that in struggling relationships. Caleb hopes it will knock the hurdle out of the way and they can get back to how they were but...Sarah is battling something bigger within herself.

She feels aimless, helpless, like she's been living her life with no purpose. She doesn't see what she brings to the people she loves. She's wrestling with the roles she and Caleb placed on themselves and each other at such a young age. Necessary at first, but feeling like the damsel to Caleb's Knight in Shining Armor isn't working anymore and it's creating a rift. She hopes Reignite can help her with these feelings, and help her be able to express them to Caleb.

Like I said in the beginning of the review, there is absolutely no question how much Sarah and Caleb love each other, and that's one of the things I loved so much about it. The story is about them figuring out how to grow within themselves, finding their own identity that isn't "Caleb's wife" or "Sarah's husband."

The switches in perspective, from present day to when Sarah and Caleb were teenagers were perfection, utter heartbreak, and further explained how they got to this point in their lives. I loved that the "third-act breakup" was at the beginning so all we expected for the rest of the book was the mending. And god was that good. It was so much deeper than I expected. Sarah deals with a lot of her grief from the loss of her mother when she was young, and that helps her in trying to find herself and where she belongs in the world.

Yes, there is a lot of introspection and a lot of hard looks at themselves, but there is also so much humor. The side characters almost really didn't feel like side characters, but as part of the story, and they were so fun!

I can't wait for this book to come out so I can get my paws on a copy!

Was this review helpful?

This was my first marriage in crisis book and it was so freaking good. This story was full of emotion, grief, and depth. You really watched as these characters rediscovered themself while trying to save their marriage. You could tell they were in love and they didn’t want to let each other go.

While it was a little harder to get into at first, the story slowly started to blossom in front of me. Caleb doesn’t have a POV so we are witnessing everything through Sarah. I also do wish there was more tension that we did get in her previous books. I do wish the ending was a wee bit different because I don’t think it was ended or had impact on the story.

Was this review helpful?

BYE EXCUSE ME I NEED 3-5 DAYS TO RECOVER

*takes deep breath and tries not to cry* GOD I LOVED THIS BOOK

I cannot properly put into words how much I loved this book. I laughed, I cried, i swooned.
This one hit every single emotion possible. I saw so much of myself in Sarah and her feelings it felt sometimes like looking in a mirror. As someone who got lucky enough to find their person at 15 this one really struck a cord with me

At the age of thirty-one Sarah Linwood seemingly has the perfect life from an outsiders perspective. Nice house, handsome husband which a cushy job and supportive friends. But recently Sarah has been grappling with the fact that she doesn't really who she is as person without her husband Caleb. Sarah decides she needs a change and she needs it fast.

In an effort to save their marriage, Sarah and Caleb decide to embark on a hiking retreat intended to help couples "reignite" their lives.
What comes to follow is a heartwarming, inspiring and hilarious story full of self discovery, healing. While this story is about a marriage in crisis also depicts living with loss and how that loss can change your entire worldview.

This book contains and then and now timeline in which we get to see Caleb and Sarahs relationship begin from a budding highschool crush. This part of the story also entagles with the story of Sarahs mom who has since passed (not a spoiler- its in the blurb, i promise). Sarahs relationship with her mother made me need to go hug my own mother more than once.

As someone who also found their person at the age of 15 and knows the struggles that come along, it was moving to watch this couple navigate growing together while also being able to grow as individual people. These two were so flirty and fun and you can tell that they are truely eachothers best friends and isn't that what we all want?

"If you give me the space to grow I'll plant myself next to you, always"

Dont get me wrong, while this book made me cry my eyes out I also laughed my arse off. Sarah is a girl who just gets it. Her and Caleb and not outdoorsy people AT ALL and watching them navigate a 9 mile hike and pooping in the woods along with the amazing cast of side characters was hilarious and filled this book with many light hearted moments.

"Did you just . . . fawn? Isn’t that how they describe it in your books? Or wait, no, it’s— Swoon,”

Although I am a dual POV girl until my dying day I will always make an exception for Hannah, her writing flows easily makes me want to live inside the pages of the story.

A HUGE thank you to Dell Romance and Random House for approving my Netgalley eARC when I had a 0% feedback rate! I love you forever besties 🤍🤍🤍

Tropes
💍marriage in crisis
🪵hiking retreat
🧠mental health rep
🩷highschool sweethearts
⛺️A spicy tent scene

Was this review helpful?

3.5⭐

this story was so sweet! i really enjoyed the self reflection in sarah and how she came to find what she wanted most in life. however, i thought there would be more romance and i had different expectations for this book and super high expectations because i absolutely loved bo and win (and it was so good to see them in this book as well 🤭). i really enjoyed the grief aspect but truly wish there was just more! the ending felt a bit rushed and honestly could've had at least a few more chapters to really make it feel like a solid ending. but i think that's a me thing since this was one of my anticipated releases.

Was this review helpful?

I AM CONVINCED THAT HANNAH BONAM-YOUNG CAN DO NO WRONG! It's always perfect, and this is no different. They are completely adorable and have my whole heart. One of my favorite tropes is win back your spouse and this might be at the top of the list of favorites! All the hearts, all the stars, ALL THE PRAISE!!

Was this review helpful?

Out of the Woods focuses on Sarah and Caleb who were first introduced in Out on a Limb. You COULD read this book without reading the first one, but I don't break the rules and when the author suggests to read in order, I'm going to.

Sarah and Caleb are in a bit of a rut since they have been together more than half of their lives. Rather than having a midlife crisis and someone buying a convertible, they end up going on this nature retreat to focus on their relationship. Honestly, most of the things that they're struggling with are pretty relatable if you've been in a relationship before so there were times when I was just like "come on, communicate already". Overall though, I enjoyed the book, but not as much as Out on a Limb. I'd recommend to check it out if you enjoyed Hannah's first book or want to read something that you can relate to a bit (minus the hiking... I will not be hiking). I've rounded this up from a 3.75.

Thanks to NetGalley and Random House Publishing for the advanced reader's copy!

Was this review helpful?

My Caleb and Sarah <3 What a special read this was. Broke my heart and stitched it back together like 50 times over.
Marriage in crisis is one of my favorite tropes (that isn’t done often enough in my opinion) but! I am very aware how painful it can be and I was fully bracing for impact with this!! However!! I’m really glad that Hannah found a way to write a marriage in crisis book that didn’t make me sick to my stomach the entire time. I will say though… the Sarah x Her mom flashbacks though. That packed a PUNCH!!!!!!

I really loved how once we got over that initial bump, Caleb was so open to trying absolutely anything Sarah wanted to fix what was broken. I also adored that they both mutually wanted to be better for the other. I think a lot of times in a marriage in crisis story there is one character that is (at least seemingly) checked out and ready to GO but I loved seeing two people who love each other, that experienced some challenges together, but don’t want to just throw in the towel. I never for one second questioned if either of them loved the other and I think that’s what made this one so special.
See also: A man that packs your kindle for you so you can keep your reading streak going while in the woods even when you’re going through a rough patch???? I never doubted them!!!

The only thing I didn’t particularly love about this was the little situation during the last 20% of the book. It definitely served as a catalyst for a lot of growing and learning but it just felt a tad unnecessary after all they’d been through. BUT! Boy did I love seeing my Bo and Win (and Gus!!) show up when they were needed!! That’s my fictional family!!!!

I also, of course, have to touch on the Taylor Swift of it all briefly as a full time career swiftie. I really really love that in the age of authors using Taylor references whenever they possibly can (which most times just comes across as cringey, gimmicky, and a ploy to get more reads) I love that Hannah did NOT! go overboard!! even though the title would suggest otherwise!! The only references in here are ones that you’d have to be true swiftie tm to pick up on and I loved that!! Yayyy!!

Was this review helpful?

4.5 stars!

I absolutely loved this story! Hannah's writing is so beautiful and she really gets you in the feels!
I loved out on a limb and knew I would love this one too!

This story follows Sarah and Caleb. After being together for so long, something feels off in their marriage. Each of them holding things in and not communicating as much as they should... Win sends them on a couples camping retreat and ... youll have to read and see!

I loved these characters! You can truly see how much they love each other and how much they want to better themselves for the relationship! Add in the scenes with Bo, Win and Gus and the AMAZING side characters, this was an emotional, swoony read!

Highly recommend!

Some of my favorites of my highlights below!
“Do you want your e-reader?” “I didn’t pack it. It would’ve only lasted a few days before the battery gave out anyways.” Caleb smiles knowingly, his face still tilted up to the ceiling. “I brought it and a solar charger. I didn’t want you to lose your reading streak. Downloaded a couple of extra books too.”

“I swooned,” I add excitedly, then shut my mouth tight before another giggle has the chance to fall out. It’s not my fault, dammit! There is a shirtless, hairy lumberjack carrying me through the woods who distinctly resembles my husband. It’s like seven of my favorite horny book scenes all rolled into one. I am wetter than the bottom of a canoe right now."

"You make everyone around you feel that way. Me, Win, Bo, August. You love so deeply, it’s hard for me to understand. It seems exhausting, but you do it anyways. You leave yourself open for anyone who needs a safe place to land, even near perfect strangers. That is all, uniquely, individually, perfectly you. Something to be proud of that is all yours.”

“You deserve good things.” Win lifts her chin on an exhale. “And I think you were right. I think we do. I think we have them. I think Marcie would be very, very proud of us.”

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the ARC in exchange for an honest review!

18 - one direction

being together since high school, it’s understandable sarah and caleb has reach a sort of standstill in their marriage so off to the woods they go, to not just figure what is going on with their marriage but to also figure out what is going on with themselves

a touching, emotional story about a marriage with realistic problems between high school sweethearts that have been together for so long as well as grieving the loss of a parent. this story felt so real and raw especially with the emotional flashbacks with sarah’s mom and the glimpses of young love between sarah and caleb. so emotionally vulnerable

I especially love the narrative writing! lively and you can hear sarah’s personality

sarah’s inner conflict where she felt like she hasn’t achieved much in life was very relatable. very giving this is me trying - "So I got wasted like all my potential” // “I was so ahead of the curve, the curve became a sphere”

I love caleb my acts of service king !!! And his love for sarah reminds me of those soft, calming types of love that sarah truly needed especially in high school.

taylor swift songs
soon you’ll get better
marjorie
cardigan
right where you left me
this is me trying
begin again

[ with that being said, this book is very slow pacing where it felt dragging and boring at times. Also, in terms of a marriage in crisis book, this felt very bland. Idk how to explain it like this felt lacking for me. 3.5 🌟

Was this review helpful?

This story felt so close to home. High school sweethearts? Together for more than half their lives? I could totally relate.

In Out of the Limb, we see Sarah and Caleb's fun, loving side. But in this book, we get to see their vulnerabilities and struggles.

Sarah and Caleb Linwood have been together since high school. For seventeen years, they've been a team, but Sarah is starting to wonder who she is without Caleb. After a conflict at the fundraiser event Sarah organized, she is left feeling frustrated and full of self-doubt, causing them to drift apart. In an effort to save their marriage, they join a couples hiking trip called "Reignite," hoping to reconnect.

This story mainly focuses on rediscovering and rekindling their relationship. I love how the plot was written so maturely. It was so raw, real, and emotional. God! Caleb and Sarah are deeply in love throughout the book.

Caleb is such a sweet and gentle person. He's THE husband material, stable and consistent, always there for Sarah. He takes care of her like she's the most precious thing . Sarah, our girl, is like sunshine, Happy go lucky, yet with so many suppressed feelings beneath the surface. Also, girls! She likes reading just like us 🤭

This book also takes us through Sarah, Win, Sarah's mom, and Win's mom's past, and found it really sad and incredibly emotional to learn about their history. I truly appreciated how the book portrayed grief. Please check trigger warnings

I loved seeing their growth. how they learned to truly understand each other and adapted to the changes they thought were necessary. It was beautiful to watch them evolve, both as individuals and as a couple finding a way to grow together while still holding on to the love that first brought them together.

I also loved seeing Bo, Win, and all the new characters.

Favorite scene: Caleb brings Sarah's Kindle to the camping trip so she doesn’t lose her reading streak 🥹💗🤌

Rating - 4.25 ⭐️

Thank you, Netgalley and Random House for the eARC.

Release date - Jan 28 2025.

Was this review helpful?

I genuinely cannot believe I got an arc of this!!! This book is beautiful, raw, and genuine. No spoilers of course, but a very poignant book for me in particular. Literally about to reread!!

Was this review helpful?

High school sweethearts, marriage in trouble and watching two very non outdoorsy people backpack through the woods for a week, yes please! I listened to this author's earlier novels on audio book and so it was fun to branch out and read this one on kindle instead. (Although i am looking forward to listening to it once released!)

I loved getting to see Sarah and Caleb's story, I loved the new friends they met along the way as well as glimpses of Win and Bo. I would have loved a dual POV since this book felt very sarah focused but that aside, there were sweet moments and intentional moments and a little bit of spice making this, all in all, a great read!



Thank you Netgalley and Random House Publishing Group - Ballantine | Dell for the ARC in exchange for my review!

Was this review helpful?

My excitement for this book was through the roof due to how much I loved Out on a Limb, so it had a hard shoes to fill. I enjoyed this romance, but not as much as the first. However, if Hannah Bonam Young writes it, I will read it.

Was this review helpful?

Where a Marriage in Trouble Embarks on a Journey of Reigniting Love

| contemporary romance | marriage in trouble | man obsessed | finding yourself | couples therapy | couples retreat | spicy | nature | hiking | HEA | love takes work | patience | personal growth | communication | childhood sweethearts | death of a parent | dealing with grief | found family | single POV |

Do I recommend it? YES.
Is it sad? At times, but it does have a happily ever after.

I have become a huge fan of Hannah Bonam-Young. I read this story without first reading Out on a Limb. Although it is not necessary, I highly recommend reading Out on a Limb first because the characters and their personalities overlap. You may miss some of the jokes regarding Win and Bo if you choose to read this without having read the first book.

Something about Hannah Bonam-Youngs writing is that it is plot-driven. Yes, there is some spice and lots of tension, but there are always these deeply emotional elements that drive her stories right into your heart. I cannot tell you the depths at which this story will touch your heart. One moment you're crying because it is a bit sad, and within pages, you are happy again because the sadness turned into something beautiful.

The duality of happiness and sadness I attribute to who the characters are. Sara is dealing with a less-than-savory hand in life. She feels a little lost and very undeserving of her partner. Caleb loves Sara no matter what, and he hates to see her sad or upset. He loves her so wholly and so fully that he would do anything to keep her happy, even if he has to risk upsetting her. He is supportive, dedicated, and loving above all else. Sara is the center of his universe. For Sara, Caleb is always her knight in shining armor. He always comes through for her, and sometimes a girl just wants to be able to stand on her own two feet. She doesn't want to resent Caleb for the ways that he tries to be there for her, but she comes to a point in her life where she realizes that she is unhappy, most of all, with herself.

This couple embarks on a journey to reignite their love and find balance in their marriage. However, the journey also helps them both in personal ways that go beyond their love for each other and embrace their love of self.

Out of the Woods is a beautiful story with a heartbreaking past and a bright future. It's a story that I won't soon forget. I cried, I laughed, and most of all, I loved it. I highly recommend this story and any story written by Hannah Bonam-Young.

Happy Reading, Friends xx

Was this review helpful?

🦇 Out of the Woods Book Review 🦇

Rating: ⭐⭐⭐

❓ #QOTD How did you meet your significant other?

🦇 High school sweethearts Sarah and Caleb Linwood have always been a sure thing. But after 17 years, Sarah has to wonder: who is she without her other half? Caleb always seems to step in to save the day, making her the damsel. In a desperate attempt to fix what they fear is breaking, Sarah and Caleb make the spontaneous decision to get out of their comfort zones and join a grueling hiking trip intended to guide couples through rough patches. Can they navigate their way out of the woods and their messy uncertainty to find their way back to their roots?

💜 First of all, I'd like to reassure readers that no, you don't have to read Out on a Limb to enjoy this book. Out of the Woods focuses on Sarah and Caleb's relationship (friends of the FMC in book one). Let's break it down:
✨ Characters: We're given very little about each character independent of the other. Sarah is deep in grief while Caleb is...well, he seems perfectly supportive and loving, but that's unfortunately stifling Sarah. Once they begin to work through their problems, they're cute together, but there's no major depth. I will say that Sarah is incredibly relatable. She feels stuck and uncertain of who she is outside of her relationship, but it feels like she takes that out on Caleb when he's simply content (and there's nothing wrong with that). It does highlight the importance of recognizing who you are outside of a relationship (a lesson some people haven't learned, which then affects the relationship).
✨ Plot and Pacing: Usually, I love a flashback to show rather than tell. Unfortunately, the CONSTANT flashbacks slow the pace down. They don't show us moments that really define Caleb and Sarah. The plot (Sarah having an identity crisis and feeling like a NPC in her own marriage) had a lot of potential, but ALL the introspection leaves the story dragging. There's just not much going on.
✨ Romance: The absolute best moment for me was Sarah realizing Caleb brought her e-reader so she wouldn't lose her (nearly 2,000-day) reading streak. The little flowers and notes they left for one another were precious. Their relationship is well-established, and they heal with each other, which is sweet. There is smut, so, enjoy that.
✨ Mystery/Suspense: Alluding to a moment that occurred between Sarah and Caleb as young adults without revealing it entirely would have given the story an element of tension and suspense, both of which were lacking.
✨ Tone/Prose: Sarah's narration is relatable, but her constant, page after page of introspection adds nothing to the story. A little more descriptive language while we're in the woods could have placed readers in the moment, but instead, we're stuck in Sarah's head.

✨ The Vibes ✨
🏕 Adult Contemporary Romance
⛺ Camping
🏕 Couples Therapy
⛺ Flashbacks
🏕 High School Sweethearts
⛺ First Person POV
🏕 Loss of a Parent/Grief
⛺ Part of a Duology

🦇 Major thanks to the author and publisher for providing an ARC of this book via Netgalley. 🥰 This does not affect my opinion regarding the book. #OutoftheWoods

💬 Quotes
❝ It’s the cursed roles we’ve been stuck in since the eleventh grade. The gallant knight riding in on his white horse is here to save me once again. And shit, if being the damsel in distress isn’t getting old. ❞
❝ “I brought [your e-reader] and a solar charger. I didn’t want you to lose your reading streak. Downloaded a couple of extra books too.” ❞
❝ I am a simple creature, at my core. Give me books, sunlight, water, and a handsome man looking at me like I’m some rare jewel, and I’m all set. Especially when it feels like a long time since I’ve shined for him. ❞
❝ “If you give me the space to grow, I’ll plant myself next to you. Always.” ❞
❝ “We have the rest of our lives to fuck each other’s brains out. I’m here to get your heart back first.” ❞

Was this review helpful?

Hannah has done it again! Out of the Woods was an incredibly beautiful story about self-discovery, rekindling a marriage, and just enjoying what life has to offer. This book made me cry, laugh, and smile. Truly one of the best books I have read so far.

The premise was beautifully written and well-paced. The past and present timelines were nice, as it gave us snippets to Sarah’s relationship with Caleb from the beginning and her mother’s condition and death.

There were some sensitive topics throughout the story such as grief, which I thought were handled and written perfectly. There were definitely moments that made me tear up.

Sarah’s journey was realistic, heartbreaking, beautiful and inspiring. Caleb’s support and understanding of her journey was amazing as well. I will say though, I wished we would have gotten a bit more from Caleb and his journey/struggles. There were also a few subplots that could have been more developed.

The couples therapy retreat in the middle of the woods lead to some amusing, sweet and spicy moments. The rekindling their marriage aspect did have me a bit worried at first but there was truly nothing to fear. Sarah and Caleb’s marriage and love story was one filled with support, care, devotion and love. The understanding, compassion and trust they had in one another was beautiful.

There was no third act breakup/conflict but those last few chapters definitely had me nervous and tearing up. The conclusion and epilogue were perfect though. Overall, just another fantastic story filled with so much heart and love from Hannah.

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for providing me with an ARC in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you so much to NetGalley and PRH Audio for the early access to the digital and audio copies of this new book. This was my first—though I’m going to be going back to read Winnie and Bo’s story. You can still definitely read this one without reading Bonam-Young’s first novel.

This book touched me deep in my soul. As someone who also met their spouse in high school and have been married for 16 years and together for 21 years—over half our lives…there were SO MANY TIMES I felt like the words Caleb and Sarah were saying were taken straight from my mouth, my soul, my journals. I felt seen. I had tears in my eyes so many times because I just resonated so much. A book hasn’t felt like therapy in awhile!

There is definitely some spice. And the trigger warnings at the start of the book for the touchy topics were good. But I laughed. I teared up. I smiled. So freaking much. This was a really beautiful book about relationships and making marriage work through the hard times. I loved it.

Was this review helpful?

After reading and loving Out on a Limb by Hannah Bonam-Young, I was ecstatic when I was approved to read this ARC!!

This book follows Sarah and Caleb through so many hardships as young teens into a marriage at an early age. As many marriage experience up and downs they felt each other slipping away. I loved seeing them reclaim their independence and their love for one another. They had tough conversations that helped them grow closer and see the new and improved spouse. I was also glad we save a glimpse into Bo and Win’s relationship post Out on a Limb.

This book will be in my bookshelf once it’s released! Another must read by Hannah Bonn-Young. Thank you so much for allowing me the chance to experience this read and give my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley, Hannah Bonam-Young and Ballentine for the free ebook in exchange for an honest review.

This was so adorable. I loved every minute with these characters and their personalities. I haven’t read any of the authors other books but they are all a must read for me now. These characters felt like friends and it was so perfect.

Was this review helpful?

I am beyond happy that we got a chance to see the inner workings of Caleb and Sarah’s relationship. Deep, deep in my millennial heart I feel this love. These two characters who were so supportive and loving in the first book just shined in their own story! True love isn’t perfect and it isn’t easy but it can be beautiful. I’m so thankful we got a chance to see the friendships in the family shine once again! There is something so beautiful and true about Hannah Bonham-Young’s writing and I’m just so grateful I got a chance to read this book early. I will literally read anything she writes.

Thank you #netgalley for the ARC in exchange for an honest review

Was this review helpful?