Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Holy smokes. I didn't think anything could emotionally ruin me like Out on a Limb, but then Out of the Woods came along. Hannah has a great eye for taking unique relationships and making them so authentic for the reader. Every single one of her characters, whether main or supporting, is fully formed and never a charicature. I loved how she found ways to explain grief that weren't so black and white and how grief can push us to make decisions that we will sometimes question in the future. Also -- THANK YOU for writing soft men! It's so refreshing.

Was this review helpful?

What a beautiful, beautiful story. You will not want to skip this one!

Fans of Out on a Limb are transported back into that world with Caleb and Sarah as stars of the show. Bo and Win are back as the special guests who made every scene they're in even better. This book not only had me in my feels but had me laughing and full of awe of the whole time.

Sarah and Caleb have been married for 17 years. They are each other's first loves and high school sweethearts. And lately, Sarah is starting to feel like she doesn't know who she is anymore without her husband. When Win tells Sarah about this couples camping retreat, Sarah decides this is what she and Caleb are meant to do to fix their problems.

I absolutely loved the plot. A marriage in crisis takes on the outdoors. I loved the outdoorsy nature vibes. I loved the complications and playfulness this brought to the story. Caleb and Sarah are absolutely adorable and I was genuinely rooting for their success. You can feel how much these two truly love each other and it broke my heart to see them so lost.

Sarah is a spitfire. She's had to grow up quick. She's tenacious and strong; sarcastic and funny; caring and nurturing; loving and fun. I really loved her character. At times she was a little over the top or whiny BUT Hannah wrote her so well that it's just a tiny part of who Sarah is (through the good and bad). I loved how normal she felt and how realistic her fears were. I loved seeing her growth and I loved watching her learn more about herself throughout this. She had such great character development and I loved watching her stand on her own two feet.

Caleb is so damn adorable and I wanted to just eat him up! He's such a gentle, sweet, loving man. He loves Sarah so much that he's willing to do anything for her. He wants her happy - that is his happiness. Nothing about this man was a turn off to me. He's a glasses wearing, nerdy beautiful man. I mean...can I get one?! He is putting in the work and I commend him for it. I also loved seeing his growth over time. Also, him being "wild" was SO MUCH FUN IYKYK *WINK WINK*

This was a beautiful story about a beautiful marriage. I envy these two so much for having made such a beautiful life. Yes, there are downfalls and tribulations but there is so much love here.

I loved how much Bo and Win we get in this. They are forever and always just a superior couple.

I really loved the side characters we get in this as well. They made the hiking so much more enjoyable. I just loved all the little roles each of them played in this.

I enjoyed the flashbacks but with how good this story was, I was always looking forward to the present day!

Every second of this book was adorable and entertaining. It had me in my feels and the last paragraph in the "10 years later" really got me.

This book was just hit out of the park! I really can't describe this whole thing other than: beautiful.
Highly, highly, highly recommend this book (and Out on a Limb)!!

Thank you so much to Hannah Bonam-Young, Random House, Dell, and NetGalley for the arc copy!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley and publishers for letting my read this E-arc

I can’t express how much I loved this story. As someone who did not read “Out on a Limb”, I was absolutely surprised and in love with the universe. I will be backtracking to read the first story.

Sarah and Caleb’s story was just wonderful. The dialogue and scenery of the story made it like a movie in my head. I felt like the story was just easy to relate to and the characterization was so realistic. There were many moments I felt like crying but in the next minute I am running around and screaming because of how cute they are.

This was a great story full of dealing with grief, finding independence while also keeping those close to you in your heart.

“Darkness before the Dawn”

Was this review helpful?

This book felt like I was reading a story of my very own. As someone who’s been with my high school sweetheart and went through nearly losing my only parent. It gave me every single feeling and it was the most beautiful book. I felt so enthralled by HBY writing and he ability to really make you feel something similar to the characters and to watch their growth as a couple and as individuals was amazing.

Was this review helpful?

I adored Out on a Limb and was ecstatic to get a chance to read Out of the Woods early. It did not disappoint! I laughed, I cried while reading this wholesome and heartwarming story. Bonam-Young takes the readers through an inspiring and heartfelt journey of rediscovery as Sarah and Caleb begin to confront their unresolved concerns and address the foundation of their marriage. The author does a wonderful job of showing how true intimacy and understanding require both partners to be vulnerable and willing to face difficult truths. With moments of tension and tenderness, you can feel the immense respect and love that they have for each other. Even though I felt the third act and some of the flashbacks didn’t really add much to the story, Sarah and Caleb’s relationship was an absolute joy to read and the epilogue was perfection.

Overall, Out of the Woods is a deeply emotional exploration of love, loss, and strength needed to rebuild a relationship. It is beautifully written and a must read for those who appreciate stories about second chances, personal growth, and the resilience of love.

Thank you NetGalley & Random House for the ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you so much NetGalley and Hannah Bonam-Young for allowing me the privilege of reading and reviewing the arc for Hannah Bonam-Young’s newest book Out of the Woods. You already know how much I love HBYs work.

Reading a Hannah Bonam-Young book doesn’t feel like reading a book. It feels like getting a window into someone’s real life- all their struggles, deep inner feelings, joys and heart aches.

I loved the support that Sarah gave Win in Out on a Limb and the snippets we got of her and Caleb’s relationship. So when Out of the Woods was announced and it was going to be focusing on their marriage, I was over the moon.

The identity struggle that Sarah goes through in this book, begging the question of “who am I without Caleb,” Felt so real and raw. The phenomenon of meeting your soulmate earlier than most and feeling stuck in routine and being too safe. I could picture it as if she was my own best friend. The challenges they faced were realistic but not in a way that weighed them down but uplifted them.

I could tell Hannah absolutely poured her heart and soul into this book. Being able to read the arc of this was truly life changing. I laughed. I cried. I gasped. Caleb and Sarah have my heart and I’m so excited for their story to be shared!

Was this review helpful?

I really didn’t enjoy this book. I enjoyed it for the first 30 ish percent after that I found it boring. I was unable to connect to the characters and I feel like the main couples issues were solved way too fast. Overall, this book put me into a slump and I was left skimming the last 40 percent in hopes it would get better.

Was this review helpful?

Sarah and Caleb have been together since they were young teens. Now they’re into adulthood and have shouldered more than their fair share of grief. Sarah feels like she no longer knows who she is on her own, and Caleb fears losing the person who makes him feel whole. The two end up on an outdoors couples trip that forces them to get out of their comfort zones and face who they are as individuals and a couple. Can they grow together or will this be the final thing that drives them apart?

This is not the normal romance I would read due to it being second-chance(ish). Despite that, I found it enjoyable. The majority of the book is present day, but there’s also scenes that go back in time and lay groundwork for who the couple is today and how they got there. There’s grief and trauma, but there’s also love and joy. If you’re a fan of Hannah Bonam-Young’s other work, you’ll enjoy this one too.

Thanks to NetGalley and Random House Publishing Group - Ballantine for the ARC. All opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

✩5

I’ve known Caleb for over seventeen years now and loved him for nearly as many.

✦What to Expect✦
•HS sweethearts
•Married couple
•Hiking/couples trip
•Forced proximity
•Found family
•Hot nerdy MMC with glasses
•Loss of a parent/ALS

✦Characters✦
•Sarah Green/Linwood
•Caleb Linwood
 
✦Fav Quotes✦
Life kept going, the Earth kept spinning, everyone moved on, but I stayed still.

“If you give me the space to grow, I’ll plant myself next to you. Always.”

“I think heaven might be real.
I think it’s you.”

✦Thoughts✦
Be still my heart.
Truly all the feels.
I’m fine, it’s fine… I am just going to start crying again.

This is story is so beautiful.
It’s heartbreaking and heartwarming at the same time.

CALEB IS A PGOM!!
*precious gem of man*
Truly the most lovable & caring man.

Sarah my heart hurt for her so much.
She was so relatable and I enjoyed her so dang much. I lover her growth & journey to figuring out what she wanted to do.

You could feel the love between these two so much. I knew it was going to be okay, because you could tell they are truly soulmates.
I loved them finding their way back to one another and figuring out what they want their future to look like.

That ending was so emotional
And that epilogue. PERFECTTTTTT

Was this review helpful?

While this book is heavy subject matter - it hit super close to home for me. I absolutely loved it.
I was lucky enough to receive this ARC - I am an out on the limb Stan and I was soooooo excited to get this one
Sarah and Caleb are high school sweethearts with some heavy backstories that they don’t really deal with when they are young and it come around to start hindering their marriage. Will they come out together in the end?
What you can expect:
- marriage in crisis
- high school sweethearts
- a outdoorsy marriage retreat
- light spice
- heavy subject matter
- reminiscing about parental loss

Was this review helpful?

Out of the Woods

Sarah and Caleb are high school sweethearts and have been together since they were 16 years old. After years of being together Sarah feels a sense of uncertainty and not exactly sure of who she is without Caleb. Win suggests that she attends an outdoor couple’s retreat. In hopes to save their marriage, Sarah and Caleb agree to go, in attempt to find their way “out of the woods” and back to each other.

This story was relatable in so many ways. I’ve been with my husband for over ten years and have felt those same feelings/emotions as Sarah. I love how this story portrays the hardships of marriage and not just the smooth and pretty sides. I also loved how it gives a sense of hope, showing us that with hard work and effort you can make things work out in the end. This story was so wholesome and real. The addition of Sarah and Caleb’s shared history also add to the emotional impact of the book. The humor and spice included is just a bonus!

Out of the Woods in an interconnected standalone that is meant to be read after Out in a Limb. Although its not necessary, its highly recommended.

Title releases January 28, 2025

Thank you NetGalley and Random House Publishing Group for an ARC of this novel in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

I love a romance about a married couple. They're so different from those about single people and more relatable for me. Here we have a couple who have been together since they were young and the story explores what that means and what it's like to have been together for so long.

This isn't my favorite book by this author (Out on a Limb) but it's solid. It's funny and sweet and sexy, everything I look for in a romance.

Highly recommend.

Was this review helpful?

HBY always knows how to break your heart and put it right back together. I loved getting to know more about Sarah and Caleb, and seeing them build on their relationship. Seeing Sarah's past and watching her grow was stunning. I will never understand how HBY can pull off sweet and heartbreaking and sexy all at the same time. Love her so much!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you Random House and HBY for this ARC!!

This book is utter perfection. There aren’t enough words to describe how much I loved this book.

I am also married to my high school sweetheart, and with that comes unique challenges that are often not represented in the romance genre. But Hannah did such an amazing job with this.

This book made me feel all the feels. I couldn’t put it down, but at the same time I never wanted it to be over. This is one of those books that will stay with me forever and I can’t recommend it enough!! 🩵🩵🩵

Was this review helpful?

I can’t believe I was lucky enough to get an ARC of this. As someone who loved Out on a Limb so much, I was so beyond excited to be able to read this early. I laughed and cried literally the entire time. I have no notes. What a beautiful and interesting take on second chance romance. It’s so important to show people that relationships, while seemingly happy on the outside looking in, can also be lacking. And that it takes work to make them better. Sarah and Caleb are the STANDARD.

Was this review helpful?

Not going to lie, I almost wept when I saw the email approving me for this ARC. This book made me truly appreciate the time I have with my friends and family. Often, we take spending time with loved ones for granted, but as soon as I finished this book, I went and hugged my mom.

I adored Win and Bo's story, so I knew I had to read the second book in the series. Imagine my excitement when I found out it featured the marriage-in-trouble trope! I don’t know why, but I absolutely love that trope.

The story follows Sarah and Caleb, who married at 19. Now, years later, they’re questioning whether that was the right decision. While I would have loved Caleb's POV to better understand his character and thought process, the story focuses on Sarah. She feels like she has lost her sense of self, always being someone's daughter, friend, or wife. Sarah never had the chance to figure out who she was on her own, and her resentment grows as she feels Caleb doesn't understand what she’s going through. Caleb, in turn, begins to wonder who Sarah truly is without him and whether their relationship would have lasted if they'd met later in life.

To save their marriage, they attend a couples' therapy retreat—a seven-day wilderness journey involving trekking, camping, and exercises designed to rebuild their bond. Neither Sarah nor Caleb is particularly outdoorsy, which makes the challenge even more daunting.

I’ve never read anything like this, and it was absolutely beautiful. Watching two people rediscover each other and fall back into a deeper love was so touching. The final chapters were deeply emotional for me, but I absolutely loved Sarah and Caleb's journey of self-discovery and reconciliation.

This is a book I know I’ll reread because I adore the author’s writing and the amazing plots she creates.

Thank you to NetGalley and Random House Publishing - Ballantine for providing me with this ARC in exchange for my honest review.

*Please check the trigger warnings before reading!*

Was this review helpful?

So excited to receive an ARC of this book. I discovered Hannah Bonam-Young this year and fell in love with her stories. Hannah knows how to write refreshing romance books. I LOVED that this book was about an established couple, who while still very much in love, found that they weren't the best at communicating their needs. But also that it was about a woman, who experienced loss, was still grieving and kind of lost who she was along the way. I think that's something a lot of people can relate to, myself included. I appreciated that it wasn't just about a couple constantly fighting throughout the book over ridiculous things. Their problems and the way they dealt with it felt relatable and realistic.
I loved that it felt like reading two stories with the flashbacks to younger Sarah and Caleb, and how their relationship bloomed. But also seeing everything that they (Sarah, Caleb AND Win) had to experience when Sarah's mom got sick. Ugh, that broke my heart and the more into the story we got, the more I felt for Sarah. Sarah's journey throughout the book was so precious.
And lastly, lets not forget about how amazing both present day and past Caleb are. That man is a giant green flag and I love how he was all in from the beginning.
I cried, I laughed, I swooned. My only complaint is that, Hannah knows how to write some really good spicy scenes, and I would have been inclined to read at least one more 😉

Was this review helpful?

Out in the Woods

I really enjoyed this latest book I read an advanced copy of thanks to #netgalley, Random House Publishing and Hana Bonham-Young, in exchange for my honest review! I really enjoyed all aspects of this book. After leaning on her teenage love during her mother’s ailing health and untimely death due to ALS, once in her thirties, Sarah began to get restless and wondered if she made the wrong choice marrying young. They decide to go on a week long couples retreat and I absolutely loved watching them relearn and remember how to love each other and most importantly why they chose each other in the first place. With the support of her best friend (and non-biological sister) Win, Sarah and Caleb remember who they were together, as well as individuals and show it’s never too late to work on your relationship. Most of all I LOVED that Sarah and Caleb had no interest in having children and that never wavered. It’s not something people use in a book often and I think it was a great little detail that was important to their story and insight to their relationship. This book hits shelves in January and you want to be sure to snag it. It’s a rather easy, 260 something page read. I look forward to looking up Hannah’s other books and reading those as well!

Was this review helpful?

Getting married at the very young age of 19 seems crazy, but sometimes when you know you know. And sometimes, your mom is about to die and you were probably going to get married anyways, so best to do it while she’s alive to see it, right? Which, also crazy, but Sarah and Caleb might just be the lucky ones.

High School sweethearts Caleb and Sarah Linwood have been each other’s other half for a startling seventeen years. They’ve been with each other through it all—awkward phases, heartbreaking losses, and everything in between. Now they’re well into their marriage and financially comfortable thanks to Caleb’s incredibly successful business.

Sarah, in her thirties and feeling a bit stuck, is grasping for something in her life to be proud of, something that’s all her own. So she pulls together a fundraiser gala in her mother’s honor, and tragically, it fails. That is, until Caleb steps in with a fat check at the last minute to save the day. This uninvited and mostly well-intentioned gesture throws a stake into their relationship. To save it they decide to go… hiking?!? As two people who don’t like the outdoors?!? Crazy! But they’ll do anything to save their marriage.

From there they go on an incredible journey, albeit a bit of a roller coaster, of healing and self discovery via the great outdoors, all while supported by some truly strange, wonderful characters.

The only other of HBY’s novels I’ve read (tragically, and trust me I’m about to fix that) is Out on a Limb which is the prequel to Out of the Woods. You don’t need to read the first in order to understand this one, but trust me when I say you should and you won’t regret it. Anyways, despite the pregnancy trope of the first, HBY made me fall head over heels for Win & Bo, and she did the same for me with Sarah & Caleb. HBY has this incredible talent for painting the most beautiful pictures of humans and their complicated lives without making the whole thing feel like something cliché you’ve read before in any other romance.

Out of the Woods took me on a journey. In starting it I didn’t think it would hold any relevance to my life, and boy was I wrong. I learned with these characters, laughed with them, and cried with them. This book will fall into one of my favorites this year along with Out on a Limb.

Hannah Bonam-Young is an amazing and incredibly underrated writer. Don’t let the theme of the book scare you away, because I swear you’ll love it anyways.

Thank you infinitely to the author & publisher via NetGalley for this ARC!

Was this review helpful?

I ATE this book up! Like oh my goodness, this may have been the best Hannah book I've ever read??

Literally dived headfirst into this book and it was utter perfection. The romance, the plot, the spice, everything was top tier. Hannah has a way of writing books and characters that you absolutely fall in love with, and this book was no exception. It was everything and I love it so much.

The way I need to read this book over and over again because I cannot get enough of it.

Thank you NetGalley for the eARC!

Was this review helpful?