Skip to main content

Member Reviews

McKinney's book brings the thoughtfulness, insight, and humor of the Normal Gossip podcast and her journalism to a new format in a nonfiction book. She's able to provide both a historic perspective and contemporary examples through a lens that's maybe not unique but feels personable and identifiable. I think if you have enjoyed the podcast, her writing on Defector dot com, microhistories, and/or social commentary, this would be a solid read.

Was this review helpful?

Kelsey McKinney explores different aspects of gossip through "You Didn't Hear This From Me".

I have enjoyed Kelsey's podcast for several years. I was excited to pick up this book. It is well written and explores different topics surrounding gossip. I enjoyed the essays while I was reading them. A lot of the essays I felt were more trying to get people to understand why we gossip and almost trying to persuade the reader that gossip wasn't bad. As someone who knows the importance of gossip, that didn't really work for me. I must not be the target audience. I also finished this book over a month ago and I couldn't tell you anything that I took away. So overall, enjoyable, but not one that has stuck with me.

Was this review helpful?

Who knew there was so much to be said about gossip? Kelsey McKinney does, and she takes a deep dive into it. I learned quite a few new things about gossip. Primarily who does it, and why. Each chapter is further exploration through generations and how this ancient means of communicating has evolved.

I especially liked the chapter on Mean Girls. The rise of that culture and the references. I associate gossip with negativity and harm; there is plenty of that, but in following chapters a new spin unfolds to give alternate ideas on this backdoor way of relaying information.

This is a fun book if gossip awakens your senses and perhaps fuel for thinking compassionately, too.

Thanks to NetGalley and Grand Central Publishing for early access,

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Grand Central Publishing and NetGalley for this ARC! If you’re a fan of this podcast you’ll love the book, and if you’re not a fan of the podcast/haven’t listened I still really think you’ll love this book! It’s elevated, well-researched, and give an informational overview of the spreading of information we do as a society. This book is approachable while tackling higher level concepts such as linguistics. Highly recommend!

Was this review helpful?

Happy publication day, and thanks to NetGalley for the ARC!

This was a delight. If you know me, I like to YAP. But not just yap. I like to be yapped to. I like to hear the yappery of others. I like a story. Basically, I enjoy gossip. This collection of essays is a celebration of all things gossip, and a lot of them gave me a new perspective on the cultural value of it, and the role it plays in connecting us to each other. It's very accessible, and I'd recommend it to anyone wanting to try nonfiction for the first time, and anyone who loves the podcast! (And if you aren't listening to the podcast, you should be!) I had a digital ARC, but I know Kelsey narrates the audiobook, and I think her delivery would be even more enjoyable.

The only thing keeping it from being a 5 is that I would have liked to have more of a connecting thread between the essays - sometimes it feels a little disjointed, rather than a journey - and some essays (notable the ones leaning more personal) are stronger than others. Overall, a really fun one!

Was this review helpful?

If you've listened to McKinney's podcast Normal Gossip and are interested in conducting an academic study of gossip, then I highly recommend you check out this book! If you haven't listened to Normal Gossip, what are you doing? Please, go binge all of it and come back when you're done.

You Didn't Hear This From Me looks at gossip in our popular culture (Mean Girls, why we love to gossip about celebrities) as well as how important gossip is in our constant search for truth. This collection of essays was very well researched and entertaining to read, and I love how McKinney blended in moments of memoir throughout the book. Gossip is great, and I love that this essay collection was a celebration of why it feels so good to gossip!

I wish I had the audiobook because I would have loved to listen to Kelsey read this, so if you have the opportunity I'd recommend reading via that route!

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for providing an ARC in exchange for an honest review!

Was this review helpful?

What a wonderful history and story about the importance of gossip through the ages! Perfect for students of gossip, and fans of the podcast, of course.

Was this review helpful?

Whether or not you're a listener of the podcast Normal Gossip, if you're interested in the concept of gossip, you're going to love this book! Kelsey McKinney isn't just a highly entertaining storyteller; she's a journalist who breaks down gossip from a social science/pop culture/history/philosophy/feminist standpoint. I can't stop thinking about this book as I move through the world encountering gossip, and I already know I'll be recommending it for years to come!

Was this review helpful?

I can't resist: You didn't hear this from me, but Kelsey McKinney's new book, You Didn't Hear This From Me, is a fascinating look at the role of gossip in culture and community. It isn't a manual for gossip, or full of gossipy stories, but it really does a nice job justifying the reasons why we gossip, what gossip really is and what it means. I learned some things, and I've got a new appreciation for the whisper networks and side conversations that occur.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Grand Central Publishing and the author for a free advanced reader copy of this book.

This was researched and presented very well in a way that was engaging and educating at the same time. Reading the first portion of the book, I came to the conclusion that the author was actually just trying to justify that they was talking about people behind their back. But as the book went on, the author brought up many different view points and ideas that I have never thought. The sharing of information is vital for human connection and growth. I enjoyed this, but I think it will take a little more dissecting for me to really understand gossip and its role in our lives.

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to Netgalley and Grand Central Publishing for this advanced copy!

I am a HUGE fan of Normal Gossip and really enjoyed Kelsey McKinney's first novel, God Spare the Girls. Basically, if she wants to talk about gossip, I want to listen. But I wasn't sure what to expect from an entire book about gossip. This book does a great job of talking about what gossip is, what it does, and how we feel about it, all from the lens of someone who clearly LOVES a good story and loves gossip. I particularly loved how she started the book talking about the shame she felt as a kid when she wanted to gossip and how that shame comes from patriarchal structures meant to keep women from talking to women. YES. I also appreciated her discussion of how gossip helps keep people safe from predators and shifty situations.

Unlike other similar books, I never got the sense that McKinney was stretching to fill pages with this book. Each chapter is a slight variation on a theme but doesn't feel repetitive or overdone. She looks at gossip in culture both clearly as a fan but also clearly as someone taking a step back to consider and analyze today's culture. Even though McKinney isn't hosting Normal Gossip (it's fine, we are all fine), she is clearly sticking around to tell stories and I am definitely here to listen.

Was this review helpful?

I’ll remember this book whenever I watch mean girls now.
The writing is clear, conversational, and covers some very interesting stuff. This reminded me of Jon Ronson’s books, which were some of my favorite nonfiction books for a long while.
A parasocial fandom chapter! A deuxmoi chapter! A viral content as surveillance chapter! A reality tv chapter! Like what a treat!

Was this review helpful?

Note: I ended up reading this book mostly on audio.

I was psyched to read You Didn't Hear This From Me as a Normal Gossip and Kelsey McKinney fan. Kelsey narrating the audiobook was definitely a highlight.

In terms of content, I liked some chapters much more than others. The sections that focused on Kesley's personal experiences were particularly strong. I appreciated the messaging that gossip can be positive, though I similar sentiments came through clearly in Normal Gossip.

I struggled a bit with Kelsey's storytelling advice to make gossip more interesting. It's a fair point that gossip often goes through various people and details shift, but I feel weird endorsing the idea that we should make those changes on purpose. For Normal Gossip and piece of this book, Kelsey edited gossip submissions to anonymize them, but I've also read that Normal Gossip has sometimes taken the anonymization so far that it's not even recognizable to the submitter. Still trying to figure out how I feel about this.

Was this review helpful?

Such a delightful nonfiction read! I was hooked by the AI generated gossip lesson, but there were several other points that would've gotten my strewn, too. Kelsey McKinney proves to be a talented writer with this one. You Didn't Hear This From Me is well-written and poignant. I am amazed at the research that went into this publication.

From the history of oral legends to Ephesians 4:29, from Mean Girls to Britney Spears, from politics to the #Metoo movement-- gossip is much more than just snickering teenagers. It is about how we process information about the world around us. Ways we communicate what we see, hear, and think about others. We choose how we disseminate that information, but it is a crucial part of our society.

Thank you Netgalley and pub for this ARC!

Was this review helpful?

You Didn't Hear This From Me is a really fun exploration of gossip, from every angle, from someone who knows the subject all too intimately. It's great to see Kelsey McKinney's voice translate so well to the page.

Was this review helpful?

I love love LOVE gossip. In reality who doesn't? Dont grab this book if you think this is a book giving you the juicy scoop on something, because it isn't that. However, if you're into the history of it then its for you and it is quite interesting.

Was this review helpful?

Loved this blend of memoir and history-of-gossip. McKinney's narrative felt well-researched and also personal. Great for fans of memoir and also fans of popular history!

Was this review helpful?

3.5 Stars

I am a big fan of the podcast Normal Gossip so when I heard Kelsey was writing a book I knew I had to read it!

The book began with a quote from a 90’s Reba McEntire song so I was endeared and excited from the jump. Reba is my queen.

Going into this book I wasn’t sure if it would be super research-heavy or just straight focused on various pieces of anonymized gossip or personal run-ins with gossip for the author. It was somewhere in the middle? I would have liked it better one way or the other.

However, Kelsey’s comedic voice did shine through which carried this through for me.

I do love that through the pod and this book Kelsey is proclaiming that gossip is not inherently bad, and can be used to protect people and that whisper networks have been here and doing good for ages.

Was this review helpful?

I am a long time listener of Kelsey's podcsast, Normal Gossip! Her work has legitimacy changed my life and also made it so much better. I am a bit older than her typical demographic, but I have been a fan from day one.

Beyond that, this work was an UNDERTAKING. The research alone is amazing.

Know, this concept and framework around gossip has completely changed my life. I went from feeling ashamed--to realizing that gossip is a thinly vailed rubric to protect those with the upmost power.

I said what I said. I will say it again. Gossip protects those with limited power. It limits the playing field.

Read this book.

Was this review helpful?

Any negative I have towards this book is quite simply MY OWN FAULT and not a flaw in the book. This book is a really unique deep dive into gossip: its history, its cultural importance, its characteristics. It is a sociological exploration about the human need for gossip and once I realized that's what it was about, I did really enjoy it!!

My problem is that as a superfan of the author's podcast, Normal Gossip, I expected the book to be filled with salacious gossip stories that would make me laugh out loud, just like on the podcast. I am not the biggest nonfiction reader, so I found some parts to be a little boring, but I'm really glad I stuck with it. So if you're a Normal Gossip fan hoping for something in the same vein, just be prepared...BUT I do encourage you to pick it up anyway because it's so interesting and provides a contextual framework for gossip. And of course the voice of the author comes through in a hilarious way the whole time. I'll continue to follow Kelsey McKinney anywhere!

Thank you to NetGalley and Grand Central Publishing for an early copy of this book in exchange for an honest review!!

Was this review helpful?