Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Much thanks to NetGalley, the publisher, and author for providing me a copy of VICTORIAN PSYCHO. It was a blast to read.

The comparisons to AMERICAN PSYCHO with a Gothic twist are accurate; though I’d argue Winifred Notty is far more enjoyable and funny than Patrick Bateman. The story follows Winifred, as she becomes the governess to the Pounds children. From there, through flashbacks and hilariously bizarre interactions, we get to see Winifred as she truly is. At times, it did feel like the author forced the gothic language, but this seems to taper off as the novel hits the second and third act. I also would have loved more bizarre interactions with the other characters, as this was its strength.

All in all, a very unique, creepy but funny tale for anyone who appreciates Gothic literature.

Was this review helpful?

Victorian Psycho by Virginia Feito
#eighthbookof2025 #arc #victorianpsycho #novella #gothichorror

CW: death, murder, bodily torture, cruelty to animals and children, miscarriage, extreme violence

From NetGalley: Winifred Notty arrives at Ensor House prepared to play the perfect Victorian governess—she’ll dutifully tutor her charges, Drusilla and Andrew, tell them bedtime stories, and only joke about eating children. But the longer Winifred spends within the estate’s dreary confines, and the more she learns of the perversions and pathetic preoccupations of the Pounds family, the more trouble she has sticking to her plan. Whether creeping across the moonlit lawns in her undergarments or gently tormenting the house staff, Winifred struggles at every turn to stifle the horrid compulsions of her past. When her chillingly dark imagination breaches the feeble boundary of reality on Christmas morning, Winifred is finally ready to deliver on her generous gifts. Wielding her signature sardonic wit and a penchant for the gorgeously macabre, Virginia Feito returns with a vengeance in Victorian Psycho.

My thoughts: Holy shit. I loved this book so much. It was hilarious and gross and creepy and I wish it were a full length novel. I want more of this. Miss Notty is perhaps insane and doesn’t give a shit. She has a purpose and although you don’t know what it is right away, she is funny and dry and a little delusional, everything I want in a main character. I laughed out loud at her throwaway lines that are pretty incongruous for a novel about a governess during this time frame. I will be seeking out the author’s previous work Mrs. March since I enjoyed this one so much. I can’t wait to see what they do with the upcoming adaptation.

Thank you to @liverightbooks and @netgalley for the advance copy. (Pub date is 2/4/25)

Was this review helpful?

It’s so interesting, because I found this to be a really fun book, if not ultimately satisfying. It held my interest and I constantly wanted to know what was going to happen next. It’s kind of a bummer that the book almost feels like it rushes to and through its climax and doesn’t allow the reader to really wallow in the carnage. I truly appreciate the prose of this book; we’re reading through something akin to Jane Austin, but the story being told is a grisly fantasy. To read such gory ideas in this high class English prose made me smile so hard it hurt. I loved the imagery that Feito was creating; every sarcastic line uttered by our featured governess felt as if it was said with a sneer that leapt off the page. I feel like this book could definitely have afforded to be a little longer, giving more room for the closing acts of violence to breathe (or more room to really describe the gore and terrible happenings that caused them). A fun book that I certainly would recommend, but just wish I would have felt as joyful about the ending as I did reading to see what would happen next.

Was this review helpful?

Oh what an insane ride this one was! From the first chapter I was hooked, pleasantly surprised by the authors sarcasm while maintaining the lingo of the time period, I actually giggled on many occasions, it never felt forced or out of place. Winifred Notty was a terrible pleasure to travel alongside, with her charges to boot. Her voice had me rooting for her despite her… tendencies, to say the least and it felt like I was reading a character acting on all the intrusive thoughts I’m sure I’m not alone in; like ‘what if I gave that a bite?’. It was dark and eerie and gross and it had me feverishly turning through the pages, consumed by my own mania. The author’s descriptions were so perfect and original, I still think of “swinging gently in the crystal fist”, what an image was the entire chapters that unfolded in the ended, but beware this is not for the weak stomached. I can’t wait to see this adapted to screen in 2026 and loved visualizing exactly how it would all go. I thoroughly enjoyed and did not predict any of the plot twists. If you are looking for a quick horrific read that transports you back in time, keeping you entertained with wit and clever writing, you’ll love Victorian Psycho (an accurate title, on conclusion). I will be picking up the authors debut, Mrs. March next! 4.5 stars rounded up.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the advanced copy in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Patrick Bateman meet Fred Notty. Gothic tale of a sociopathic narcissist nanny which, right there you know will not end well for those in her care. Crazy, crazy story that made me laugh guiltly as she worked through the situations as they occurred. So much to unpack but don’t know even where to start or end.

Was this review helpful?

"It is early fall, the cold is beginning to descend, and in three months everyone in this house will be dead."

Winifred Notty is the new governess at Ensor House. The advertisement of her services stated that she knows French and has a great deal of experience. However something isn't right with Fred. She was raised by her mother and pastor step-father as she never knew her real father. But since birth, something has been off. Or has it? Her mother tried to kill her repeatedly because she could sense the evil in her. But is she really evil? Or is it everyone around her?

There is something about the Victorians that seems so romantic, isn't there? The beautiful ornate homes, furniture, and clothing. Things seemed wonderful if you were rich. And male. Winfred is such an interesting character, but it's hard to get a read on her. On the surface prime and proper, then she observes things like "Leaves are strewn across the ground in hues of bile and blood." Or she: "It fascinates me, the fact that humans have the capacity to mortally wound one another at will, but for the most part, choose not to." What is going on with this woman?! We get glimpses into her childhood, and none of it is good. At times it is so outlandish, I had to wonder if this was an unreliable narrator story - could this woman possibly be this awful?! Turns out yes, yes she is.

A short read, I felt like I needed more. The entire book felt like a fever dream.

Was this review helpful?

Victorian Psycho
Virginia Feito

I said a little prayer and danced a little jig in the midst of reading this book. It went a little like this...

"God help the kids for they know not what they do and Devil spare the adults for they know precisely."

As I bobbed up and down.

It was fun, wish you were there.

If this book made a sound it would say "KERSPLAT". If it we're a painting it would look much the way it sounds.

I greatly appreciated the contrast between our main character being in victorian times and her behavior and the things that would come to her mind and come out of her mouth. That contrast was excellent. It's like showing up at the ball buttoned up from head to toe, and everyone can see everything underneath the sheer fabric.

And as always, what's underneath is far more interesting and no one is admiring the buttons. The lie on your tongue is far less interesting than the truth of what you're not saying.

I would say easily that if you liked LAPVONA by Ottessa Moshfegh you'll love the parts of the writing that dare to be a little weirder than it should. Entirely way too short. I am yearning for more.

Thanks to Netgalley and W. W. Norton & Company | Liveright for the advanced copy!

VICTORIAN PSYCHO...⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Was this review helpful?

Wow. This book left me speechless. After reading the last line I sat for several minutes thinking about the narrator and how the story all fit together.

Winifred was a child born out of wedlock, with a tortured mother, a heinous upbringing, and darkness buried within her, seemingly innate. She dreams of tasting blood, stringing instruments with the guts of her charges, and murdering any and all who dare to cross her- even by accident.

Many times in the novella you must determine if the images she sees are imagined or real, and you shift between shock, horror, and surprise as you’re being transported through the spaces of a psychopath’s mind.

I kept coming back to the spaces where Winifred spoke to the reader, and at the end when all was said and done I wondered if she was speaking from her grave, ringing the bell, haunting the reader as she promised she would.

Beautifully written, indescribably intense, and horrific.

Was this review helpful?

File under: I support women’s rights and women’s wrongs!
An Absolute, blood soaked gothic gore fest! No one is safe! Victorian Psycho is nothing short of an unhinged Mary Poppins, slasher-esque fever dream. Its haunting revenge fantasy theme and dark humor lands, providing the tongue in cheek tone to this hilarious and visceral novel. Horror fans, add to your TBR you’re in for a real treat!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you so much to Liverlight for my gifted copy!

I feel bad for giggling.

This book is exactly how it sounds. A Victorian era psycho. And Winifred Notty truly is a psycho. You’re going to hear a lot about how unhinged she is. But “unhinged” doesn’t seem to do her psychopathy justice. She is a Victorian Patrick Bateman. Gleeful and fearless in her demonic behavior. She is diabolical. Gruesome. Deranged.

This book was a gas. It was funny, it was disgusting, it was quaint. It’s literature I can get behind, in all its horror.

And still, somehow, Winifred still wasn’t the worst of the cast of characters. Victorian people were … cruel and disgusting. I never forgot this fact: that the British ate most of the mummies. And, lo and behold, mummies make an appearance in this book. Gleefully unbound by the rich for their Christmas celebrations. Truly evil.

Victorian Psycho is a bingeable short horror story, but I don’t recommend eating while reading it lol.

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to Netgalley for giving me a pre-pub copy in exchange for an honest review. Look, I love books that feature Victorian history, womens' history, social mores, murder, mystery, psychosis, etc. So I hate to admit that I really couldn't get into this one, basically for the same reasons that I dislike American Psycho. (I assume the title - at the very least - is a reference to that book.) However, I know everyone is going to disagree with me and this will likely be made into a movie.

Was this review helpful?

This is an odd story. It is good but very odd. If you are looking for a read that will just confuse yet delight this the story for you. Winifred is a unique character whose disposition just grows throughout the tale. While there is a lot of foreshadowing this book still surprises. I will say I did find it odd to include two pieces of art at unique spots in the book. I would have either liked more art or no art at all.
Thank you so much to W.W. Norton & Company and Netgalley for allowing me to read an advance copy of this title.

Was this review helpful?

🪓🪓
I wish I liked this more, but I have to admit that I was bored. This is a short one but it was too far on the absurd side for me to be fully invested. It's a shocking tale in description and I love an unhinged FMC, but it fell short for me overall. The ending is good and probably the most exciting part of the book. I didn't like the diary-esque writing, and I mostly wanted to read American Psycho instead. Hopefully the screen adaptation brings it to life in a different and more engaging way!

Thank you to @netgalley and WW Norton & Co. for the arc! Victorian Psycho comes out on Feb. 4th. 🌻

Was this review helpful?

I thoroughly enjoyed this Victorian satire. The writing is compelling and I couldn’t tear myself away from this cheeky and gorey little book.

Was this review helpful?

This is the last book I finished of 2024 and talk about going out with a bang(er). I LOVE THIS BOOK.

Victorian Psycho follows Miss. Winifred Notty as she sets off to Ensor House as the new governess for the Pounds family. If you think the children and their parents are unlikeable, wait until you meet the guests arriving for Christmas.

This book was everything I wanted. It was moody, unapologetic, completely psychotic (very fitting), graphic and yet somehow cozy all at the same time. Maybe that says more about me than the story or our main character, Winifred.

As a reader I enjoy main characters who you aren’t necessarily supposed to root for but can’t help but do so anyway. This was the case for me in Victorian Psycho almost at the onset of the novel. I couldn’t help but be in Winifred’s corner even if I winced and said “oh girl” out loud a few times. I quickly became desensitized to her actions though, so these reactions were mostly in the beginning.

I appreciate how fast paced the story is. It doesn’t take long before the reader is in the thick of the action and it feels like everything is wrapped up at the end even faster. I’m a greedy reader and I wanted more from the ending because I feel like there’s so many questions I wanted answers to. This was probably my only issue with the storyline and once again this is my own problem.

Thank you to @netgalley and @w.w.norton for making the eARC available to me in exchange for an honest review. Victorian Psycho is out February 4th so mark your calendars. You can’t miss this one.

Was this review helpful?

If Jane Eyre and Patrick Bateman had a child, it would be Winifred Notty. Probably psychopaths are not new and, though I’m no expert, they must have existed forever, including Victorian England. This is a historical period that fascinates me, and Feito brings it to life in all its dark glory. The dissonance between the rigidity of such a society and the modernity of Winifred’s thoughts and actions makes for an engrossing, twisted read. Despite being a monster, I found her likeable and immediately connected with her sense of humor. I loved the little details, from unimportant domestic arrangements to the bizarre funerary customs. The author has clearly researched the time period and incorporates it into the story to give it an extra level of atmosphere that makes it feel like you are there, breathing the rarified air and eating the food that is now disgusting to us. The plot is original and truly addictive. It is a very disturbing book and many parts are gross, mainly because it’s written so vividly. The author doesn’t fall into the trap to make Winifred too modern, despite everything, she is a woman of her time. A truly great novel.
I chose to read this book and all opinions in this review are my own and completely unbiased. Thank you, NetGalley/W. W. Norton & Company | Liveright.

Was this review helpful?

As a huge fan of Fieto’s debut, Mrs. March, I was ecstatic to get my hands on her newest book. Victorian Psycho is the casual musings of a female psychopath and charge of two wealthy children. She is cool, calm, and cruel and hasn’t a care in the world, aside from Kill! With hilarious prose and fourth-wall banter, this maiden is delightfully murderous. Darkly humorous and sharply witted.

Was this review helpful?

My first eARC! Thanks #netgalley
#VictorianPsycho was so much fun! Very gory and violent yet funny and, in a very weird way, quite charming. Winne is a governess with many intrusive thoughts, which she often lets win, and I am here for every single one of them! I wished we had a little more time with Winnie, but I thought the ending was wrapped up quite nicely. On sale Feb 4!
#gothichorror
#victorianpyscho
#bookworm
#bookstagram
@netgalley

Was this review helpful?

I was happy to have an advanced copy of this novel from NetGalley & their publisher.

I wanted to love this book. It gave me all the things I liked. A unreliable narrator, violence, a nice little twist, etc. However, It felt too fast. I didn't feel like I could really get into the book and by the time I was sold, it ended. It felt too short for the subject matter that she had wanted to discuss. I felt there could be so much more that could've been expanded on.

With that being said, I did enjoy the story as a whole. There is a wonderful balance of horror and humor that helped me enjoy Feito's writing.

Was this review helpful?

I absolutely loved this book. The characters were written quite well and the plot was entertaining and kept me captivated the entire read

Was this review helpful?