Thank you Netgalley and Crooked Lane Books for an e-arc in exchange for an honest review. Our main character Cyra has a sister Mira who is murdered by a serial killer, As such, she joins this support group of......serial killers. We learn of their back stories, what made them begin killing. This book is high stakes and it doesn't take long to get the ball rolling which is what I enjoyed about it. Will Cyra find out who murdered her sister? Let's find out.

Thank you NetGalley for the ARC!

Rating is more like 3.5 stars! This book feels challenging to give a number rating to, honestly. I would not say I enjoyed this book and yet found myself really intrigued to get to the end.

Not a single likeable character in this book but that doesn't usually stop me from enjoying and loving characters. In this case, my dislike was less about how likeable the MC was and more so how disappointing the tired tropes she was given. I read a few reviews saying that this book turned tropes on their head and I just don’t agree. The tropes were there and perhaps made fun of a bit and then nothing done with it!! Maybe I’m missing something but this book did not read subversive to me on the topic of violence or violent character tropes.

I wanted to love this book and I wanted to have fun with this book but it fell kinda flat for me. There were definitely parts I was interested in and felt like it could be scratching the surface to something but ….ugh I don’t know.

I would still read more from this author in the future and really wished I had loved this book!

⭐ 3.75

How far would you go to avenge the death of a loved one? Would you consider putting your life in danger and inserting yourself into a serial killer support group?

That's exactly what Cyra sets out to do in the hopes of solving the murder of her sister.

But soon enough Cyra will learn that you are the company you keep.

It's a really compelling read. You find yourself weirdly captivated by the thought process of the main character and the serial killers she surrounds herself with. And if you enjoy mysteries, you'll also have fun trying to figure out who the killer is.

Be warned that if you are not into descriptions of blood and gore, and getting into the mind of people who kill for basically the heck of it and enjoy the pain and suffering of others, please stay away from this book.


Thank you Net Galley and Crooked Lane Books for the opportunity to read this book in exchange for an honest review.

- review will be posted on Instagram on February 4th.

I thought this book was excellent. The writing was good, the plot was intriguing and engaging, and the characters were all unique and different. I was shocked at the end that Cyra was already a serial killer and that’s why she was able to slip into Mistletoe’s identity so easily. Great read and I would definitely read more from the author.

What a Banger! Cyra's sister has been murdered. The police think it may be the work of a serial killer. Cyra doesn't think the police are doing enough in the search for the killer. Cyra learns that there is possibly a group of serial killers meeting in secret. With the help of a friend who works in IT, she begins to dig in the dark web in search of the group. Cyra does find such a group. How does she handle this information to find the person responsible for her sisters death? 

5 stars

Definitely an interesting premise. It’s what got my attentions and made me want to read it.
The characters were interesting. I wanted more from them. I wanted more development.

The twist was great. I did figure it out but overall, did enjoy the twist.

I thought this was good. The pacing was a little slow and didn’t hold my attention but then at times it was holding my interest.

Thank you for allowing me to read this arc!

I was intrigued by the title of this book and I am a big fan of stories centred around a strong FMC. I loved the development and connection to the protagonist, Cyra, and found the overall plot really enjoyable, especially the plot twist!! I wished I felt more of a connection to the other characters, I did feel that was the only thing missing. But overall, great read!

I really loved the concept of the whole serial killer support group thing—it felt like such a refreshing and unique take. The ending left me with mixed feelings, though. While I wouldn’t say I loved the book, I did genuinely enjoy the experience of reading it.

This was one of those books once you start you cannot put down until you are done. The story you slowly get to know the MC. Her sister was murdered and may have been a victim of a serial killer. She learns that there is this Serial killer support group and ends up joining in revenge of her sister making a different identity.
The novel explores how dark could one go for revenge of a loved one? How that could change a person or is something that was there all along. We all have a dark side.. which one are you feeding?
I read this book in one sitting. I had such a fun time. Even if I guessed few things in the plot didn't take away my enjoyment. If you like dark things gritty stories than this is for you

My favorite part about debut novels is that there are zero expectations -- aside from the title, cover, and description, the reader goes in blind. The title alone was enough to pique my interest, but the second I started reading, I knew I would not be putting the book down until I was done! The premise was a creative spin on the age old murder mystery, and the alternative POVs and timelines really put the reader into the headspace of serial killers. Simply put, Saratoga Schaefer nailed it. Don't sleep on this one!

Serial Killer Support Group - Saratoga Schaefer
Pub Date - 3/18/25
Trigger Warning(s) - death of a sibling
Rating - 2/5 - DNF
Summary - Cyra's sister is murdered by a serial killer and she can't seem to get a straight answer from the NYPD as to what happened. She decides to take matters into her own hands and infiltrates a support group of serial killers to find out what really happened to her sister.
Thoughts - Thank you to Netgalley and Crooked Lane Books for this advanced copy in exchange for my honest opinion. I got through about 30% of this book before stopping. I couldn't get past the actions of the main character. This book had so much potential, but the characters fell flat and the story was so predictable. Unfortunately, not for me.

3.25 Stars
Cyra's sister was murdered while out running, and the police haven't made much progress on finding her killer, it seems. But the lead detective lets it be known that it is thought she was the victim of a serial killer. Cyra learns that there is a local serial killer support group and determines that her sister's killer must be among those in the group. She finds a way to join the group, so she can figure out who is the guilty party, and make sure they never kill again. While pretending to be a serial killer herself, Cyra begins to identify more and more with the killer persona that she adopts, and wonders if she will ever be anything else.

Firstly, I thought this would be a satire and was very disappointed that it was not. I think the topic would have made a wonderful satirical horror novel. But once I let that go, I did enjoy the story overall. Cyra is an interesting character and the black hole that pulls on her after her sister's murder was not totally unexpected. The desire for revenge is understandable. Some of the things she got entangled in were a bit of a stretch for me, but didn't ruin it. It did feel like the ending is setting up for a sequel, and if so, I will likely read it.

Thank you to NetGalley, the author and publisher for the advanced copy in exchange for my honest review.

When the investigation into the death of Cyra Griffin's sister hits a standstill, Cyra must take matters into her own hands. Cyra infiltrates a serial killer support group that meets in New York City in an effort to unearth the truth about her sister’s death. But the dangerous men in the group aren't the only obstacle in finding her sister's killer. ☠️ 😍

Serial Killer Support Group is a deceptively simple thriller about a young woman who joins a group of serial killers in search of her dead sister's murderer, but the simplicity of its plot belies a much more complicated examination of how we feel about murder and justice in a broken system that celebrates and excuses monsters. The book does some interesting work, briefly pathologizing its serial killer main characters without making the characters overtly sympathetic. Main character Cyra is not an exception here, a character who might be understandable if she weren't so continuously detached from herself and her grief, so committed to her vengeance.

It's the book's complicated philosophy that I think is most compelling, the space it devotes to exploring issues of grief and anger, how these emotions intertwine and sometimes cannot be distinguished one from the other. There's a lot of righteous anger in the book, but it still begs the question as to what violence is sanctioned in response to how we perceive the world. What injustices will we stand up to and which forms of violence do we find palatable? It's an interesting thought experiment for us to explore through a character like Cyra.

All in all, I think the book aspires to a lot that doesn't always land, but that shouldn't stop anyone from enjoying what feels like an interesting take on a favorite trope in thriller lit.

Disclosure Statement: I received a complimentary ARC from the publisher through NetGalley for review. All thoughts and opinions expressed in this review are entirely my own and uninfluenced by either publisher or author.

Cyra's younger sister has been murdered and it's rumored she may have been the victim of a serial killer. In order to avenge her sister's death, Cyra joins a serial killer support group hoping to find the person responsible. An easy read with a couple of twists along the way which I guessed were coming. This appeared at face value to be an interesting premise for a story but it felt flat, like it's many one-dimensional characters, and the story was a little silly really.

Thanks to Netgalley for allowing me to read and review this book. Publication date for this book is 18 March 2025.

3 stars.

I really enjoyed this book! It's fast paced with an interesting premise. However, the recruitment process for the support group seemed too easy it's unbelievable, even for fiction. The characters also could've been given more depth. Each of them had a lot of potential that could be seen in the serial killer origins chapters.

Thank you to NetGalley and Saratoga Schaefer for an advance reader copy in exchange for an honest review.

Serial Killer Support Group by Saratoga Schaefer was an interesting read with several twists and turns.

From the publisher: “After her sister is murdered, a woman infiltrates a support group for serial killers in this biting queer feminist debut thriller, perfect for fans of The Final Girl Support Group and My Sister, the Serial Killer.”

SKSG plot was not on my radar, but I am glad to have received the ARC and read it. It is a unique take on revenge and justice. There is a lot of murder and death so monitor trigger warnings. The “queer feminist” part of the description is such a minor aspect to the plot. It is barely mentioned at all. I was pleased the focus stayed on track with the main character’s mission throughout instead of having any side quests.

The ending is a definite twist. I recommend SKSG for those looking for a new take on a thriller plot.

This book had a great ending. The build up was a little slower than I had anticipated but the characters were very fleshed out and the story kept me intrigued. I loved the little twist and turns the last 15% of the book!

The author isn’t exactly subtle about what you’re getting into here—this book is about exactly what it claims to be.

Cyra Griffin’s younger sister, Mira, was murdered by a serial killer. Or so the police say. Cyra is less sure (which, frankly, feels like red flag number one). But hold on, because things spiral quickly. The police aren’t making much headway (because apparently, that’s what they do when serial murder is involved), so Cyra—armed with absolutely zero relevant skills—decides to take matters into her own hands. Naturally.

With help from a friend who has access to police files (don’t ask), Cyra manages to worm her way into a *support group for serial killers.* Yes, you read that right. Because, of course, serial killers just *love* to meet up, process their emotions, and share snacks. The way she gets into this group is so absurd that you might want to toss the book across the room. And honestly, I wouldn’t blame you—just maybe don’t do it if you’re reading on your phone or tablet. You’ll need that later to Google the dark web over your morning coffee, because apparently, that’s a thing.

Can Cyra survive this mess and find Mira’s killer? Does the killer just *have* to be in this group? Do you even care? Are you secretly rooting for Cyra to meet a tragic end because, frankly, she’s brought this chaos on herself? And what about these supposed serial killers—are they even remotely competent, or just a bunch of basement-dwelling cosplayers about to get offed themselves?

Here’s the deal: every character in this book is dumber than the last, and I’m pretty sure I could be a better serial killer, detective, and snack coordinator than all of them combined. Save yourself the headache and don’t bother with this one—it’s just not worth your time.