Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Absolutely a favorite book of my 2025 Net Galley reads. This is a richly drawn dual timeline story that completely captured me to conclusion. A story of helping veterans, of human connection and mysterious history of dollhouse miniatures. I love it and highly recommend this book for your reading enjoyment.
Thank you to Net Galley, the publishers and the author. My review opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

I am convinced that this historical fiction is so niche it may only attract specific readers. However, it is definitely a book for everyone. My grandfather was a dollhouse builder. When I saw this title, I was immediately sent back in time. Time spent with him.

Don’t let this one site on your TBR. Elsie Hooper has triumphed with this beautifully written story about human connection, loss, passion, and history observed through non-traditional sources. Readers of Kate Quinn should take A shot on Elsie Hooper.

Was this review helpful?

I'm attempting to try to read more historical fiction because a lot of our patrons love it. Unfortunately, this wasn't something I was able to get into. I think it would make a fabulous movie or TV series, though.

Was this review helpful?

I received an ARC of this book from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.

I took a few chapters for me to get into this book, but then I ended up really enjoying it!

Was this review helpful?

I appreciate the opportunity to read this title, but unfortunately it didn’t quite capture my interest. While the premise was promising, I found it difficult to stay engaged. That said, I’m sure it will find its audience with readers who connect more strongly with the writing style or pacing.

Was this review helpful?

I always love any story with a strong and supportive cast of female characters, with a dash of history and a fun premise. This fit the bill. I thought of more authors I've read that would be close matches for anyone who enjoyed this book. This well written historical fiction novel was amazing, and it was interesting to learn about the history of miniatures, how they were constructed and also how they came to be in the world of Disney.

Was this review helpful?

A lovely book filled with mystery and intrigue. I would love to see these dollhouses in real life! My favorite part is how creating the dollhouses became a form of therapy for the wounded soldiers. Loved them!

Was this review helpful?

With a riveting, dual timeline plot and deeply imagined characters, The Library of Lost Dollhouses kept me turning pages to uncover its secrets and mysteries.

When archivist and curator Tildy Barrows discovers two intricately detailed dollhouses in a hidden room inside the memorial library where she works, the discovery sends her on a fascinating quest--one that might save her beloved, nearly bankrupt library in the process. But who created these remarkably constructed dollhouses? And how did they come to belong to Belva Curtis LeFarge, the influential heiress who established the library a century ago?

With impeccable pacing that never rushes or lags, Hooper draws readers along with Tildy as she investigates this historical mystery that spans a timeline stretching from Belle Époque Paris, to World War I, to Hollywood in the 1950s. The prose is effortless and evocative, painting a rich backdrop to the connections the author draws between her characters. The dual timelines are seamless and equally compelling.

The Library of Lost Dollhouses is an absorbing comfort read--it's quietly suspenseful in a way that will hook readers immediately, while including all the atmospheric details that readers of the historical fiction genre enjoy. Themes of female friendship/mentorship, art as a form of rebellion and independence, and positive LGBTQ+ representation give this book high marks. Easily one of my favorites of 2025, thus far!

Was this review helpful?

I was able to read this novel thru NetGalley and glad I got the chance before publication. It’s a mix of historical fiction with mystery within it too. The descriptions of the dollhouses and the importance they played for women in the past was intriguing.

Was this review helpful?

Tildy Barrows is a librarian at an archival library in San Francisco. One day at the library she discovers a secret room upstairs and finds two beautiful antique dollhouses. One of the dollhouses has a miniature portrait of her late mother as a young girl! She begins to investigate the dollhouses and discovers a multi-layered history that spans many years.

I wanted to read this novel because I love historical fiction and I have a lifelong love of dollhouses and miniatures.

The dollhouse descriptions alone in this book made it a delightful read for me! The history behind the dollhouses, and the secrets found there, dating all the way back to the 1910's, were fascinating. Most of the book is told in the present time period but there are also chapters that flash back to Cora Hale, the dollhouse artist, and her complicated life in Paris, London, and the United States.

I loved everything about this book - the storytelling, the descriptions, the mystery, and the quiet romance that unexpectedly unfolds for Tildy.

The Library of Lost Dollhouses is certain to be a top 10 read for me this year. I recommend it highly for fans of historical fiction and especially for anyone else who loves dollhouses and miniatures. Five enthusiastic stars!

Was this review helpful?

Couldn’t get into this book. I struggled staying interested and connecting with the characters. I loved the cover art for this book.

Was this review helpful?

This was a fun creative story that I enjoyed! The mystery was really enticing and I had fun with this! I would recommend this! Special Thank You to Elise Hooper, William Morrow and NetGalley for allowing me to read a complimentary copy in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

The reader is drawn into a series of amazing twentieth century events and the secret lives of women within them. All this is tied together by a San Francisco private library and some handmade dollhouses. Who created the artifacts and how they are tied together are question at the heart of this gripping novel.

Was this review helpful?

Who doesn’t love a dollhouse, especially one with secrets? This story is dual timelines, with one timeline following Tildy Barrows in the present day who has just discovered two dollhouses hidden in the house museum library she works in in San Francisco. The other is Cora Hale, a woman fleeing her past to Paris right before the start of WWI. We then follow Cora up through closer to Tildy’s timeline as we learn more about the history of the dollhouses.

I loved the historical fiction setting and the tie-in with dollhouses. Hooper mentioned she got inspired to write this book as she was restoring her family’s fifth generation dollhouse. I also have a dollhouse that my grandfather built for me, which has now been passed on to my daughter. There is just something special about miniature houses. I thought Hooper did a great job of researching the history behind why these dollhouses might have been created, and what it was like to live through these times. The slight mystery about Tildy’s mother and her relationship to the museum where Tildy works was also interesting.

Was this review helpful?

The Library of Lost Dollhouses by Elise Hooper was a novel of strong and unconventional women. Interestingly, many of the characters were based on actual historical figures.

Two main characters were featured, Tildy Barrows and Cora Hale. This book mostly follows the story of Cora Hale, who was an art prodigy with tremendous talent and a monumental secret. As a consequence of her past, Cora mostly lives in obscurity, remaining at the edges while the famous women she worked for take the spot light. Cora's story takes us through several historic events like World War I, the Great Depression, and World War II. The book isn't about those events, but they do add context. The historical aspects and the descriptions of building miniatures were the most enjoyable part of this story.

Tildy's role is basically to unfurl Cora's story for us, while Cora reveals the secrets, mysteries, and tragedies of all these nonconformist women. Tildy and Cora both lost their mothers at a young age, which was a defining plot point. By the end of the book, the real connection between Tildy and Cora is revealed.

This story features several romantic relationships, and I feel like they were more of a distraction than an enhancement to the tale of Cora's and Tildy's lives, and I found them more confusing than anything. There were multiple F-F romances, and while it's not something that would detract from my rating, it's also not something I connect with personally.

3/5 stars. While this book had a fast-paced start, and I loved the strong female characters in this book and the historical setting, by the end it was a bit of slog to get through. The pacing felt like it slowed down quite a bit by the last couple hours of reading. I also didn't care for what felt like frequent switching of romantic partners (years may have gone by in the storyline, but only pages went by in the book), too much yo-yo-ing for me. Recommended for those who enjoy stories about unorthodox women in historical contexts.

Was this review helpful?

This was a decent book. Not a bad length and the story was cool. Would recommend to anyone looking for their next read

Was this review helpful?

This novel struck a familiar chord by reminding me of Death in the Details by Katie Tietjen. Both books step into carefully constructed dollhouses and dioramas where every detail holds significance. The connection between these novels deepens when considering their shared inspiration were the masterpieces of Frances Lee Glessner.

The Library of Lost Dollhouses captivates with its use of spiral storytelling and its exploration of themes such as overlooked history, the resilience of women, and the search for identity and connection across generations. Centering on Tildy Barrows, a librarian working in San Francisco, whose world shifts when she stumbles upon two beautifully crafted dollhouses hidden within her library. These creations are more than simple miniatures. The houses hold secrets and clues that span over a century, linking ambitious women in Belle Époque Paris, World War I veterans in England, and the world of Walt Disney’s studio in the mid-20th century. As Tildy investigates the origins of the dollhouses, she uncovers women who challenged societal norms and expectations while unraveling surprising truths about her own family.

Art, obsession, and the importance of preserving forgotten stories emerge as key elements. The dollhouses serve as powerful symbols of enduring legacies and the idea of hidden rooms, both literal and metaphorical, which reflect the spaces where secrets, creativity, and untold stories come to life.

The interconnected timelines create a distinct storytelling rhythm, drawing readers into the lives of those who owned the dollhouses. It celebrates the beauty of curiosity and courage, reminding us of the transformative power of uncovering what lies beneath the surface. This novel is a tale of connection, strength, and creativity, offering an unforgettable journey through history and imagination.

Was this review helpful?

Enjoyable read. Though have to question why so many of the secrets were pretty much the same thing. Tildy was a good main character and nice to read about. The Cora bits were overly wordy at times and then in other areas not detailed enough, kind of strange vibe from that.

Overall though a relaxing read with low investment and high payout.

Was this review helpful?

This one starts slowly, setting up all the characters and their timelines, but once it got going about a third of the way in, I was hooked. The main character Tildy, Head Curator of a San Francisco library, discovers a secret room that holds two elaborately constructed dollhouses - what she finds in the dollhouses sends her on a search for answers to her own past, which leads to further mysteries coming to light. The historical timeline takes place during World War I, and features some colorful characters whose connections to Tildy are revealed bit by bit, lending a bit of suspense to the second half of the book. A very unique story, and the details about the dollhouses and the world of miniatures was really interesting, and the dollhouse descriptions very evocative.

Was this review helpful?

Have you ever baked something, followed the directions with fidelity, and it still didn’t turn out as expected? This is what I had with The Library of Lost Dollhouses. It has all the right ingredients, the plot moved at a great pace, but somehow at the end, I was feeling a little meh. I love character driven novels, and I just didn’t connect to the historical character very well and not to the modern character at all.

Tildy Barrows, head curator, at “The Bel” in San Francisco stumbles upon a hidden room in the beaux arts building with two dollhouses inside. These aren’t any ordinary dollhouses. The level of artistry and detail is like nothing she’s ever seen. When she discovers a maker’s mark and a miniature portrait of her own mother, she is determined to figure out the provenance of the two remarkable pieces. Why on earth is her deceased mother in this historical piece of art?

Cora Hale is more than happy to put New York in her hindsight as she heads Paris to pursue her artistic dreams. Here she meets the heiress Belva Curtis LeFarge, who turns her world upside down and changes the trajectory of her life. Determined to make a name for herself, she creates intricate dollhouses commissioned by her wealthy patronesses, all of which hide secrets about their owners. But more than anything, Cora wishes for recognition of perhaps her greatest work made under duress when she was only seventeen years old, but she knows this can never happen.

Alternating between two timelines we learn Cora’s story through the lense of Tildy. These two remarkable women shed light on how women survived in a man’s world through more than one world war. I do believe the vast number of years covering Cora’s life was a little overly ambitious. Focusing on a shorter time period might have done her more justice. Also, what is not mentioned probably to prevent discrimination, is the sapphic relationships in this novel. Though I do not mind, I do know other readers would prefer the publisher to be more forthright.

Thank you to NetGalley, William Morrow, and of course the author Elise Hooper for the advanced copy of the book. The Library of Lost Dollhouses is out on now. All opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?