Skip to main content

Member Reviews

This was an interesting novel of historical fiction set during WWI about three women who have relationships with soldiers serving in the war, and they are each connected by a Liberty of London scarf which was created to inspire hope. Iris Braxton designed the scarf with a poem by Emily Dickenson embedded in the design. Genevieve is a telephone operator working for the allies moving code through the telephone lines and Clara is a Belgian nurse. All three treasure their Liberty scarves and hope that they will bring them luck and hope. Iris's and Genevieve's stories were interesting, but Clara's story got bogged down, confusing and much too long. The end was unfortunately not believable for this reader although I still enjoyed the story. I enjoyed the historical fiction aspect of the novel very much. 3 stars.

Many thanks to Net Galley and HarperCollins Focus | Harper Muse for a chance to read an ARC version of this novel. All opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Harper Collins Focus and NetGalley for an ARC of this audiobook.

This novel takes place during World War I and its aftermath. The story is written by three authors: Aimie K. Runyan, J'nell Ciesielski and Rachel McMillan. I was familiar with Ms. Runyan, but not the other authors. However, they all did a wonderful job bringing this beautiful story together. Each author writes the story of one of the main characters. The stories are tied together by a beautiful scarf. The epilogue does a great job bringing all of the main character's stories together in a very satisfying conclusion. The audiobook was narrated by several narrators and all did a beautiful job conveying each character and keeping the reader engaged. If you love historical fiction and are looking for a unique book that uses a scarf to tie together the lives of three women during wartime, I think that you will enjoy this story.

Was this review helpful?

If you’re looking for your next historical fiction book, pick up The Liberty Scarf. The audiobook was wonderful!

Was this review helpful?

This WWI-era novel is a refreshing take on wartime women's fiction. 'The Liberty Scarf' follows three women from three different countries as they each navigate captivating romance and how they can make a difference in a hurting world.

If you enjoy reading clean historical romance, then I recommend this book to you! The authors do a great job of balancing the POVs for each woman and her love interest.

Special thanks to HarperCollins Focus and Net Galley for a complimentary copy of this audiobook. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.

Was this review helpful?

The scarf is a beautifully woven tapestry of love, war, and the quiet resilience of women during the darkest days of World War I. This audiobook captivates from the very first word, pulling you into a world of stark contrasts — the harshness of war set against the softness of the personal connections that bind us all together.

The story of Iris Braxton, a scarf maker in London, is deeply moving. She’s not only dealing with the monotonous struggles of war, but also chasing a dream of becoming Liberty’s first female pattern designer. Her relationship with Captain Rex Conrad is tender and realistic, with an added layer of longing as she stitches secret messages into the scarves she makes for him, hoping they’ll reach him on the frontlines. The emotional weight of this connection is palpable, and the narrator does a superb job of bringing Iris’s quiet strength and her aching hopes to life.

In Maine, Geneviève Tremblay’s story unfolds with equal depth. As a French-Canadian immigrant serving as a telephone operator, her internal conflict about identity and acceptance speaks to anyone who has ever felt torn between two worlds. Her connection with a French officer adds an unexpected twist to her journey, and her voice, narrated with sensitivity, captures her struggle beautifully.

Meanwhile, in Belgium, Clara Janssens’ and Roman Allaire’s love story adds a poignant layer to the novel, showcasing the impact of war on relationships and the fleeting moments of beauty that emerge from the rubble. The imagery of the scarf as a symbol of hope and connection across continents is powerful and unforgettable.

The audiobook’s pacing is perfect, allowing each character’s journey to unfold at just the right moment. The narrators give each woman a distinct voice, infusing their performances with emotion and authenticity. The intertwining of their lives, bound together by a simple yet meaningful scarf, is a testament to the power of human connection, even in the most turbulent times.

Overall, the scarf is a moving, rich, and atmospheric novel that will stay with you long after the final page. A perfect blend of history, romance, and the enduring spirit of women who carry hope through even the darkest hours. Highly recommended for anyone who loves historical fiction that tugs at the heartstrings.

Was this review helpful?

"The Liberty Scarf" is a touching novel centered around a powerful message woven into a scarf that symbolizes liberty and hope. This message brings comfort and inspiration to several characters who face personal challenges during a tumultuous time, motivating them to keep pushing forward in the aftermath of a devastating war.

The story conveys a profound theme about the resilience of the human spirit, showing how courage and the will to survive can arise from something as simple as a piece of fabric or a few encouraging words. These small reminders inspire individuals not to give in to despair.

Divided into three distinct parts, this engaging novel feels like a collection of interconnected stories. The well-developed characters capture the essence of those who endured the hardships of war, highlighting their struggles and triumphs.

Set against the backdrop of World War II, "The Liberty Scarf" combines romantic elements with historical context, offering a heartfelt exploration of love and hope amidst adversity—perfect for the holiday season.

I appreciate NetGalley for providing a free advanced copy of this inspiring novel and Aimie K. Runyan for crafting such a memorable story.

Was this review helpful?

The Liberty Scarf is a collabortion written by three of my favorite authors, Aimie K. Runyan, J’nell Ciesielski, and Rachel McMillan. This book is a collection of three stories that have a connection because of a beautiful scarf.
During World War One, in Europe, we meet different couples who make a connection during the war and there is a unique theme of hope, kindness and service to others among them amidst the horrors of the war.
I loved the clever ending that weaves the stories all together. I absolutely loved all the history included.
The "Hello Girls" as telephone operators was quite fun to read about.
I was so fortunate to get an early audiobook of this story and loved the narration by Anne Marie Gideon, Gary Furlong, Caroline Hewitt and Saskia Maarleveld.
This was such an incredibly beautiful story. This collabortion is excellent.
Thank you to NetGalley and Harper Collins Focus for a early audio copy.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to the author, narrators, publisher and Net Galley for providing a free audio ARC version of this title in exchange for my review.

I was very excited to find a historical fiction set in WWI (as WWII is so much more popular for a time setting). I also liked the idea of a scarf touching the lives of the three women. But this book didn't work for me. I felt like the research for the historical aspects was sloppy, and the arrangement of the three stories seemed more like three novellas put together, with the ending for the first two stories coming at the end, when I had trouble remembering the details of their stories.

Still, it was mostly enjoyable and a clean romance. I might recommend it for older ladies in the family looking for a nice romantic story, but for a history fan, I don't think it would work.

3 stars for "I liked it"

Was this review helpful?

The audiobook of this story makes this story a million times more enjoyable. While the book I rated a 4, the audio for me was a 4.5. The multiple voices really brings it all to life!

This book is such a powerful read, all tied together by a scarf that connects three different stories. It’s full of romance, hope, and so many beautiful love letters. The history woven into the narrative really pulls you in, and I honestly didn’t expect to feel so immersed in these characters’ lives—whether it was hiding in a theater basement or feeling the raw fear of war. Each story brings its own unique love story, but all are deeply affected by the war, and that scarf weaves through it all.

I found myself completely hooked on the letters between the characters. It was like waiting to see how their casual chats would slowly turn into declarations of love, hope, and dreams for the future. If you're a fan of historical romance, this collection is definitely for you! And the way the stories all tie together at the end? So satisfying.

***I received a complimentary copy of this book. All opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

The Liberty Scarf was such a good book, with three unique stories connected by one unique scarf. I really enjoyed it and was so grateful for the epilogue at the end to tie them all together. Each little story leaves the reader wanting more!

The audiobook was very well done. Saskia Maarleveld and Caroline Hewitt are two of my favorite narrators. Ann Marie Gideon and Gary Furlong are two I will look for in the future. Each narrator brought their part of this story to life. I thoroughly enjoyed listening to each story and felt like I was there, thanks to the talent of this amazing cast.

Thank you to Harper Collins for the ALC. all opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

The Liberty Scarf
I love historical fiction, and “The Liberty Scarf” did not disappoint. The idea of three authors writing this story from the perspective of three different women during WWI all interconnected by a scarf that holds so much symbolism was so unique. I listened to the audiobook while following along with the ebook. The narrators did a fantastic job, and I would recommend this book.

Was this review helpful?

I absolutely adored listening to the Liberty Scarf, written by Aimie Runyan, J’Nell Cieseilski, and Rachel McMillan. It is a compelling historical fiction novel that links three women to one scarf during WWI. Each author was responsible for one woman’s story, and together, they were entwined superbly! The story begins with a scarf maker who weaves messages into her scarves. We then have a bilingual telephone operator. And finally a Flemish nurse who helps wounded soldiers. Each woman finds peace, friendship, hope, and love.

What made this audiobook extraordinary was the four narrators: Ann Marie Gideon; Gary Furlong; Caroline Hewitt; and Saskia Maarleveld. While listening I could easily imagine the scenery and the surroundings, and what each woman was feeling. This audiobook is well deserving of 5 stars. Bravo!

Was this review helpful?

This story was written by three different authors who bring together the stories of three women during WW1 with one scarf. Each of their stories is heartfelt and unique, I really enjoyed Iris and Rex's story! I loved the theme of hope carrying you through hard times...whether that's in the shape of love, friendship, service, or a scarf.

The only thing I didn't like was how the stories didn't really connect together as much as I was hoping. I might be picky when it comes to dual POVs in a story, but I felt like this one rushed the ending and the chance to connect the stories together in a more endearing way.

Thank you to NetGalley, the publisher, and the authors for the chance to listen to this arc audiobook. All opinions expressed are my own.

Was this review helpful?

This is a heartwarming and poignant tale that will captivate readers who appreciate historical fiction, romance, and stories of female empowerment, resilience, and the transformative power of love and connection in the midst of war and uncertainty.

Was this review helpful?

This was a good story with a different view on women's roles and lives during WWII. I liked that it followed a few friends and we got to see the different ways that the war affected them. It was sad and disappointing at times and also liberating and hopeful. I liked it.

Was this review helpful?

I love a well written and researched historical fiction story that teaches me something new! The Liberty Scarf is set during World War I and connects the lives of three women during that time. Iris, a painter at Liberty Scarf Company, Genevieve, a phone operator, and Claire, a war nurse all have their lives disrupted by the war. Each must endure the hardships, trials, and tribulations of war, but they are all connected by this scarf. I love the reminder how human beings truly are all connected, despite differences.

Was this review helpful?

The Liberty Scarf follows the lives of three women during WWI, each connected by a single scarf. Iris Braxton, a designer at Liberty Co., dreams of breaking boundaries but finds herself drawn to Captain Conrad Jones, who is called back to war after they meet. Geneviève Tremblay, a French-Canadian immigrant and telephone operator, is torn between loyalty to her boyfriend and her budding feelings for Maxime, a French captain. Lastly, Clara Janssens, a nurse, meets Roman, a violinist entertaining soldiers, and their love blooms despite the war’s dangers. Each story reveals the struggles and sacrifices of women who long for more in a time that limits them.

The authors vividly portray the characters’ hopes, heartaches, and resilience, with the scarf symbolizing beauty, hope, and connection through their lives. Together, the stories weave a rich tapestry of romance, friendship, and strength against the backdrop of war. With immersive narration, especially in the audiobook version, *The Liberty Scarf* brings history to life, making it a recommended read for historical fiction fans.

Loved this audiobook, perfect for a cosy Sunday afternoon: thanks to the publisher and the authors for my ARC!

Was this review helpful?

Wow! This one was really different!
And, how lucky am I that I just read another 5++ ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ book??!!!

WWI story that revolved around 3 young women and their part in WWI and the lives they touched along the way!

Genevieve, Clara and Iris lead three very different lives at the time of the setting in this book...1917-1918.

We begin when Iris meets Rex. She works in a scarf factory, but also dreams of 'designing' scarves of her own. When she literally 'walks into' Rex, an ember is ignited that neither of them saw coming...especially in the light of the war that is looming. He is an architect, and as fate would have it, is now working on the Liberty Building...the one where the famous scarves are made and sold.

Then we meet Genevieve. She is a Canadian who's recently moved with her family to Maine and has become a telephone operator...one who is very good at what she does. She's from a family who needs to work hard for any and everything that they have, and her paycheck supplements her Dad's to cover costs for their family. When she is asked to become an operator for the war, she hesitates (due to the cost of the uniform needed), but then goes ahead, as her beau's family offers to cover the cost (they are wealthy, and insist on it)... She is shipped out, and so is Peter, her beloved.
While out in the field, she meets Maxime...who is a handsome and sweet soldier... but she is spoken for already. In any case, they become friends, and keep corresponding via letters when he is shipped out. She knows this can go nowhere, as her heart is promised elsewhere.

Lastly we meet Clara, who is a nurse in the field. She meets Roman, a gifted violinist, when he is admitted to her hospital in bad shape. She spends much time with him, telling him stories of home. He is NOT responsive, and she is not sure if he ever will be, or if he even hears her, but she continues day after day, in hopes of bringing him back to life...

Through all three women and these men, there are these ‘Liberty Scarves’ that somehow appear in each of the scenarios...and somehow seem to link them all together. I KNOW it sounds crazy, but it is the most sweet, heartwarming, lovely, beautiful set of stories that you absolutely need to add to your TBR list. There were moments where my heart was soaring and flying, and others where I was outright sobbing...but in the end, it was worth it all!

“HOPE IS A THING WITH FEATHERS” !!🪶 🪶
One of the best quotes I’ve ever heard!!

5++ ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ ✨✨✨💫💫💫 for me!

#TheLibertyScarf by #AimieRunyan, #JnellCiesielski and #RachelMcMilan and narrated beautifully by #AnnMarieGideon, #GaryFurlong, #CarolineHewitt and #SaskiaMaarleveld.

Thanks so much to #NetGalley, #HarperMuse and #HarperCollinsFocus for an ARC of this delightful audiobook! **** RELEASE DATE IS SCHEDULED FOR 11/19/24...SO 👀 LOOK 👀 FOR IT THEN!! ****

Feel free to like, follow and friend me on: Goodreads,
Insta @ #BookReviews_with_emsr and/or
My Facebook Book Club: Book Reviews With Elaine.

Thanks so much for reading! And if you ‘liked’ my review, please share with your friends, & click ‘LIKE’ below… And, let me know YOUR thoughts if you read it!! 📚⭐️

Was this review helpful?

The Liberty Scarf: A Story of Three Women, One War, and a Scarf That Binds Them Together is a rare gem in the world of collaborative storytelling. Unlike many multi-author books, this one beautifully blends its separate narratives into a satisfying whole. The novel is structured like three short stories, each focusing on a different woman, and while the second and third stories initially feel distinct, they come together in a powerful and unexpected way—especially in the epilogue, which ties everything up perfectly.

My favorite story was the first one, where I immediately connected with the two main characters and their engaging banter. I didn't want it to end. The second story took a bit to warm up to, but eventually I was drawn in, despite it being somewhat predictable. The third story, while still well-written, didn’t captivate me as much, mostly because I was still thinking about the first set of characters.

I listened to the audiobook, and the narration definitely added to the experience, though the shift in voices between stories—and especially the dramatic change in tone during the epilogue—was a bit jarring.

Overall, The Liberty Scarf is a beautifully told tale of connection, resilience, and the bonds that carry us through even the toughest of times. Highly recommended!

Was this review helpful?

Gobsmackingly good! Exceptional storytelling. And what a surprise to discover that this is one continuous story written by three authors. I went into this read assuming it was a collection of novellas set in different eras, instead, the authors cover the same timeline from different characters’ perspectives which makes a stunning impact.

Each author’s story flows seamlessly into the next one — but oh the cliffhanger endings in the first two! They have distinctive styles in both plot and characterization but the stories mesh beautifully into a cohesive whole by the end which made ‘The Liberty Scarf‘ such a rich, emotional read.

Love the diverse settings (US, England and Europe) and the historical insights each brings to the story. There’s even a French-Canadian heroine! (says this Canadian reader proudly.) I love learning about history in my fiction and these authors captured elements of WWI that I wasn’t aware of which made the read that much more interesting.

Oh — and there’s a bit of the epistolary novel within these stories as well which I absolutely loved. While mostly told in ‘real time’ there are letter writing components too and those glimpses into the characters’ inner most thoughts were priceless. Such a great way to enhance the story!

I listened to the audio edition of this book and really enjoyed the multi narrator performances. Anne Marie Gideon, Gary Furlong, Caroline Hewitt and Saskia Maarleveld did an incredible job. Such a rich, rewarding listening experience.

My thanks to Harper Muse Audio and Net Galley for providing me with an audio edition of this novel.

Was this review helpful?