Member Reviews

I really loved this book! I knew a book about a wine drinking , beach centered book club would have my heart, but add in the romance and Briar’s Nazi hunting and I could not stop turning the pages. I will definitely be recommending this one. Thank you for the ARC!

Was this review helpful?

I enjoyed reading this fascinating historical fiction that takes place in Martha's Vineyard during WWII. Wonderful storytelling about the Smith sister's family and friends who start a wartime book club. They also try to take care of the farm while their brother is fighting in the war. The U.S. army arrives and the book club provides books for the soldiers. A German U-boat is offshore, a mysterious man washes on the beach and a spy is in their community. This is such a good book! Thanks, NetGalley for the opportunity to read this novel.

Was this review helpful?

The Martha's Vineyard Beach and Book Club, by Martha Hall Kelly, was a wonderful historical women't fiction novel, set in a place I have visited often. My in-laws have a cottage in Oak Bluffs, the next town over from Vineyard Haven, and it's my husband's favorite place in the world. I loved this story of a familiar place, set during an unfamiliar era. Kelly is a beautiful novelist, and I also thoroughly enjoyed her heartfelt Author's Note at the end of the book. Highly recommend!!!

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed this book! I loved the Martha’s Vineyard setting and a good historical fiction. The characters were lovable and interesting, and I loved how the story tied in at the end. Thank you Netgalley for the ARC!

Was this review helpful?

Wonderful read of strong women! Thank you to NetGalley for the ARC! And I love the historical background of this story!

Was this review helpful?

The Martha's Vineyard Beach and Book Club was a breath of fresh air for me! It read like a literal breeze despite it's length. Cadence and Briar (sisters who are local to the Vineyard living with their grandmother) are both well developed and truly unique characters. As is so often the case, the sisters are polar opposites, but their brother Tom along with his girlfriend Bess are uniting characters. While the story was dual timeline, the present timeline was truly "almost" unnecessary and a significantly smaller portion of the book; nevertheless, it kept the plot moving along nicely and kept me wanting to keep reading. I truly enjoyed this being a WWII novel with a completely different and unique perspective compared to what I am accustomed to reading about. German spies and uboats in one of America's most well-known beach towns...who knew? Definitely worth the read.

Was this review helpful?

I have loved everyone of Martha Hall Kelly’s books. However, I can’t say that about this one. I found the first half of the book a real slog. There were so many characters and she kept switching around in time periods and places that it was extremely difficult to keep track of the storyline. I think this really detracted from the novel . I really enjoyed the second half of the book. I thought she brought everything together nicely. I found it interesting in her afterward of who the characters were based on and the history of the area.

Was this review helpful?

4.5 stars.

I loved this book! It starts off in 2016 with Mari, who arrives on Martha's Vineyard to meet the reclusive painter, 'Mrs. D', for a private painting lesson at the artist's home. Mrs. D is not what Mari expects (based on rumors of the painter's life), and she begins telling Mari the story of Martha's Vineyard natives, sisters Cadence & Briar Smith, throughout 1942 and the end of WWII. The sisters live on a farm with their grandmother, brother Tom, and his girlfriend, Bess. Tom is an Army Ranger and ships out, leaving the women on their own to run the farm.

Cadence writes a column in the local paper and loves all things literature related. It is her dream to one day work for a publishing house in New York. Her best friend Bess supports her, but she is also content to live on the farm with Tom. Briar is the younger sister and is unique in spirit and mind. She is highly intelligent and inquisitive, traits that tend to get her made fun of by the local community. She takes all of this in stride and remains true to herself.

Cadence and Bess work at the local club during the summer and come across some of the women in publishing. This motivates them to not only form their own book club (the title) but also to find ways to bring literacy and books to aid the war effort.

The Army begins sending soldiers to train on Martha's Vineyard, and the locals are also under the treat of German U-boats patrolling their coast. The story that unfolds is one of mystery, intrigue, adventure, and drama. There is love, loss, murder, and books. More importantly, there are deep friendships, there is familial loyalty, personal sacrifice, and strong female leads.

I enjoyed the first half, but could not put down the second half! Initially, I did not like the Mari storyline, but that changed as the story developed, and I understood the reason for its presence. I definitely recommend this book to anyone who loves historical fiction with great characters and an excellent story.

I would like to thank Random House Publishing Group/Ballantine Books and NetGalley for this eARC. All opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

Martha Hall Kelly’s *The Martha's Vineyard Beach and Book Club* is a beautifully layered novel that effortlessly weaves together the power of storytelling, the bonds of sisterhood, and the resilience of women during times of profound upheaval. Set against the idyllic yet tension-filled backdrop of Martha’s Vineyard, the book alternates between a gripping wartime tale and a present-day journey of healing and discovery, delivering a story that is both heartwarming and suspenseful.

In 2016, we meet Mari Starwood, a grieving thirty-something who travels from California to the windswept beauty of Martha’s Vineyard. With nothing but a name scribbled on a piece of paper, Mari arrives at the doorstep of the enigmatic Elizabeth Deveraux, a renowned but reclusive painter. What begins as a supposed painting class soon evolves into something much deeper as Elizabeth recounts the extraordinary wartime story of the Smith sisters who once called the Vineyard home. As the tale unfolds, Mari discovers connections to the island that shake her to her core, pulling her into the legacy of this place and its people.

The 1942 narrative is where the novel truly shines. Cadence and Briar Smith are two sisters left to manage their family’s faltering farm as World War II looms large over their quiet island. Nineteen-year-old Cadence dreams of being a writer, and sixteen-year-old Briar is captivated by the war effort, especially when she spots German U-boats lurking offshore. The sisters’ lives are irrevocably changed when the U.S. Army arrives on the island, bringing a mix of danger, romance, and opportunity. Cadence starts a book club with her best friend Bess, offering women an escape and a sense of community during uncertain times. But the arrival of a mysterious man who washes ashore complicates everything, raising questions of loyalty and betrayal in their close-knit community.

Kelly’s writing is immersive and atmospheric, capturing both the beauty and the tension of life on Martha’s Vineyard during the war. The dual timelines are masterfully handled, with the wartime narrative pulsating with intrigue, romance, and suspense, while Mari’s contemporary story offers a quieter but no less compelling exploration of grief and identity. The transitions between past and present are seamless, and the connection between the two timelines unfolds with satisfying revelations that keep readers turning the pages.

The book’s exploration of the power of storytelling is a highlight. The wartime book club becomes a lifeline for the women, a place where they find hope and camaraderie amid the chaos. Kelly skillfully uses the club as a metaphor for the strength that comes from shared stories and collective resilience, both during the war and in Mari’s personal journey decades later.

The characters are richly developed, from the determined Cadence and the passionate Briar to the mysterious and complex Elizabeth. Even secondary characters, like Bess and the women of the book club, are vividly drawn, adding depth and warmth to the story. The romance is tender yet fraught with conflict, perfectly balancing the tension and heart that drives the narrative.

*The Martha's Vineyard Beach and Book Club* is a moving and evocative novel that celebrates the courage of ordinary women in extraordinary times. With its vivid settings, compelling characters, and expertly woven plot, Martha Hall Kelly delivers a story that lingers long after the final page. Fans of historical fiction, dual timelines, and books like *The Nightingale* or *The Guernsey Literary and Potato Peel Pie Society* will find much to love in this five-star gem. It’s a book that reminds us of the enduring power of connection—through community, family, and the stories we tell.

Was this review helpful?

📖 Book Review 📖 From the moment you set foot on Martha’s Vineyard, you are truly pulled into another reality; the scenery is beautiful and the history is rich with a diversity almost unfathomable. And somehow Martha Hall Kelly has managed to add another beautiful layer to the multifaceted chronicles of the island that leaves us all questioning what happens when evil abroad comes to your idyllic happy place. The Martha’s Vineyard Beach and Book Club is a beautifully written tale of family connections and their roots, the sacrifices they make in times of turmoil, and the lasting legacy left for future generations.

Was this review helpful?

This book, set in 1942 on Martha's Vineyard, follows the lives of the Smith sisters: Briar and Cadence. The effects of war and their brother's enlistment are the main areas of their focus. While their gran is in the hospital, Cadence and Briar, along with Bess, their brother's fiance, must hold down their home. They decide to start a book club and help get books into the hands of soldiers. The book starts from the perspective of Mari, who is visiting the famous painter Elizabeth Devereaux after her mother dies. There is a connection between the two timelines and this lovely story unfolds to make that connection clear. Another winner by Marth Hall Kelly!

Was this review helpful?

I'm a big fan of Martha Hall Kelly's writing style and this book did not disappoint. The Martha's Vineyard Beach and Book Club is a dual timeline story with a mystery. Who is Mrs. Devereaux and how is Mari related to her and to the Smith family who owned the farm where Mrs. D now lives on Martha's Vineyard? In the present day, Mari visits the island after the death of her mother and visits with Mrs. Devereaux, who tells her the story of the former owners of the farm: Gram, Briar, and Cadence Smith, as well as their close friend Bess, during the turbulent WWII years. The story unfolded beautifully and the characters really came to life. I could imagine myself taking part in their book club meetings and living with them in the 1940s! I can't say much more without spoilers - but I highly recommend this book (as well as all other books by Martha Hall Kelly). Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for an ARC of this novel in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

I loved everything about this book, the storyline, the characters, the setting. This story pulled me in from the first page, the characters were well developed, multi leveled and relatable! It took on parts of World War II, that i was not aware of, I learned a lot from this book. It us a dual timeline book, that moves from current day, and
World War II. If you enjoy historical fiction, buy this book.

Was this review helpful?

Martha's Vineyard, 1942 (mostly) to 1945: WWII is on our doorstep and I don't think many modern day East Coasters realized just how close the war was to home.

We follow Cadence and Briar (sisters) and their Gram in their Martha's Vineyard farm house, struggling to survive as older brother Tom goes off to war, leaving behind a pregnant girlfriend named Bess. The women run the farm; Briar is always off, observing the island's inhabitants and trying to convince the military and her family she has seen German submarines off shore.

Through mostly 1942 we see the war through their eyes and their relationships with one another as love is found and lost, dreams are found and lost and found again, and they learn what "home" really is.

Well written, well researched, and with a fabulous Author's Note about the history behind the story (so much is based on Kelly's family!) this is definitely a recommended read.

Was this review helpful?

I fell in love with this book and these characters. The historical timeline paired with the modern day connection was intriguing. I loved a new take on a WWII story that I haven’t heard, especially as it stemmed from real stories from the authors mother.

Was this review helpful?

The relatable eye-catching cover caught my attention, but the beautiful story captured my heart. I began this one with zero expectations as this was my first experience reading Martha Hall Kelly and I am just impressed beyond words by how much I enjoyed this novel. I now want to read her entire backlist. This one is split into a dual timeline between 1942 which is where the bulk of the book takes place and 2016.

In 2016 we meet Mari she travels to Martha's Vineyard on the heels of her mother's funeral. Her finances are tight and her heart is tender. She arrives there to paint as the famed Elizabeth Devereaux"s student. Baffled locals can't figure out why Devereaux takes Mari on. Elizabeth begins to regal Mari with stories of the island's past particularly its involvement in WWII.

That's where the second timeline comes into play. The 1942 timeline is brimming with life and vibrancy! It was amazing to read. I felt as though the sand was between my toes. There are two sisters Briar who is younger and more of a tomboy she has spunk, I took an immediate liking to her and Cadence. Cadence is the older sister with lofty dreams of leaving the island and pursuing a job in publishing.

The two girls struggle to manage the family farm alongside their brother's girlfriend and grandma. Briar is convinced she has spotted a German U-boat off the coast of the island, but no one believes her. Is she mistaken? A mysterious man washes ashore and tells the family there's a spy in there close-knit town. The family must decide if this is the truth or a ploy by an enemy to gain their trust.

The atmosphere won me over with this book. It was one of those that was immersive from the first sentence. Be sure to read the author's note as well it was informative and lovely as this was a personal novel, and it showed. Such rich storytelling!

Thank you to NetGalley and Ballantine Publishing for the Advance Readers Copy

Was this review helpful?

I so enjoy Martha Hall Kelly books. The story takes place during WWII on Martha’s Vineyard. It’s part historical fiction and part family drama. The story is so well researched. Her author’s notes are filled with so much of her family history of living on Martha’s Vineyard, the shops, the occupation all of which help bring her book to life. Mrs. Kelly has another blockbuster with this book.

Thank you #NetGalley, #RandomHousePublishingGroup-Ballantine,
#MarthaHallKelly and #TheMartha’sVineyardBeachandBookClub for the advance readers copy for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Martha Hall Kelly is among my favourite historical fiction writers. She has yet to disappoint, and this book is another great read. Maybe not as moving as some of the previous books because it takes place a lot more removed from the action, but nevertheless, the characters are well developed and I enjoyed the mystery of figuring out who was the spy. I didn't quite call it, but I certainly suspected. Even then, I totally did not expect how it ended, although I will say that the climax of the Germany U-boat was a bit rushed, almost as though Kelly was running out of pages and had to wrap things up super quick. For all the build up, I wanted there to be more to the final moments and how everyone moved on from it.

I was rooting for all three girls, and I don't want to spoil anything, but my heart felt very heavy with how the story of the three girls wrapped up. It wasn't as though they didn't have great lives after the events of that summer, but I also feel like so much was missed as a result of decisions that were made.

I do find I struggle with alternate POVs when there are many characters, but this book didn't take me long to get into the feel for who was who, even when we threw in a few Bess POVs towards the latter part of the book. The three girls were such strong characters, and those around them were fleshed out well enough to also feel for their stories; and the present day was there just enough to keep things moving without stealing the spotlight.

This is a stand along, although I can't help but think that there were some references to Lilac Girls. Just wasn't 100% sure because I read those books so long ago and my memory isn't always what it once was. Age. Sigh.

I will say that Briar was probably my least favourite character for most of the book, and then she and Cadence kind of flipped for me and I was suddenly all in for Briar.

This is a hard book to review without giving anything away, but suffice to say that there is romance; there is mystery; there is action; and there is family. All wrapped up with a bit of history.

Was this review helpful?

A huge Thank You to Random House Publishing Group - Ballentine and NetGalley for the opportunity to read this ARC. If you are a fan of historical fiction like I am, then you HAVE to read this new one by Martha Hall Kelly. Every time I read one of her books, I am surprised to actually learn historical things that I never knew about before. This book follows the story of a group of young women during WWII on Martha’s Vineyard, as they navigate life on the island while dealing with a US Army presence training on their beloved home, the threat of German U-Boats in their waters off the island, and keeping the home fires burning as their own brother and friend leaves home to be a part of the Army Rangers. Martha Hall Kelly as usual weaves a wonderful story with historical facts that will keep you entranced as you race through the book. For any fans of Anne Quinn or Kristin Hannah, you have to read this book!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Random House Publishing Group for the ARC in exchange for feedback.
The Martha’s Vineyard Beach and Book Club tells the story of a family during the war.. Briar, Cadence and Tom live with their Gram after their parents died.
When Tom goes off to war, the book club comes up with a way to provide “little” books that the men can carry in their backpacks.
Briar is the nosy, rebel sister who often reports seeing a German U-boat from the beach and is searching for clues as to who could be a spy for the Germans in their small town. Because of her supposed sightings, she is nicknamed “Briar the Liar”.
Tom, the only brother, tries to provide for the family as best he can. He plants a new potato variety, that he hopes will provide for the family. His fiancé Bess also lives with the family and stays when Tom ships off to war.
Cadence, wants to work for a publisher, and writes a column in the local newspaper. She impresses a rich frequent visitor to the vineyard, who wants to help her on her publishing dream. She also catches the eye of a British soldier there to command his troops through practice maneuvers.
Gram, the feisty matriarch who provides snacks for the book club meetings, is fighting health problems. She loves unconditionally, worrying about the farm finances and how her grandchildren will fare if something happens to her. She often says “you’re going to miss me when I’m gone.
First book I have read by the author; she transports you to the story as if you are there. The final twist at the end was surprising, wonderful ending.
It is worth reading the author’’s note at the end to find her inspiration. Thanks again!

Was this review helpful?