Skip to main content

Member Reviews

The author’s debut was one of my favorite books I’ve read this year and am so happy I was able to read this ARC, which I think I somehow love even more than her first novel! 💯🤍🎨 🥹

I LOVED the complicated/toxic friendship between Enka and Mathilde explored through the competitive art world with a tech twist. This felt like a much better written Black Mirror episode. The writing held my interest and had me on the edge of my seat the whole time as it spiraled into madness with each passing chapter.

This book definitely makes you think about how we perceive artists and begs you to question, “what makes a great artist?” and shows you how far one will go to make it. It also explores friendship through the lens both jealously vs support. Enka is such a compelling mc since she makes choices that impact Mathilde's life to extreme levels.

I can’t wait to see what the author writes next! Thank you to the publisher and Netgalley for the E-ARC ❤️

Was this review helpful?

Unsettling, timely, toxic, tense. A fascinating new take on the art world. Will be watching this author!

Was this review helpful?

Imagine the art world, but make it dystopian, pretentious, and so toxic it practically radiates fumes. In Immaculate Conception, Ling Ling Huang drops us into the elite, bio-hacked world of artists Enka and Mathilde, where originality is as rare as a Monet in a dentist’s office. Enka is a struggling artist clinging to her friendship with Mathilde—a woman whose natural talent is so potent, she might as well be channeling art straight from the heavens. But this is no feel-good buddy story; Enka’s friendship with Mathilde is more like a study in jealousy-induced insanity.

Mathilde, blissfully creating her wildly avant-garde art installations, hardly notices Enka’s slow-motion train wreck of envy. Meanwhile, Enka is ready to push every boundary, including questionable tech, to prove that she’s relevant. Cue the darkly humorous descent as Enka leans into biohacking and her obsession for “creative justice.”

Huang brilliantly paints a world where technology and ego collide, mixing social satire with shades of Black Mirror. If you’re up for a dark, tech-dystopian rollercoaster of backstabbing and self-sabotage, this one’s for you. Just remember: the art world is apparently as dangerous as it is glamorous.

Was this review helpful?

The world building this author does is incredible! I felt teleported into this futuristic elite art and technology world were everything felt wild and intense. The way the author conceptualizes all of these artists’ pieces and exhibitions feels very right for the characters and shows an impressive understanding of artists and the art world at large. As a working artist myself, it was hard not to be super invested and impressed with every aspect of this book; from those very real feelings of jealousy and idealizing of other creatives and their achievements- it all felt very real and relatable but dialed to 1,000. It’s was like what would happen if you let all your jealousy and insecurity actually manifest in the worst possible way- seeing it all unfold was wild!! I feel like there’s an interesting theme in there of how often everyone thinks of themselves as the protagonist of their own life; justifying their actions to maintain that image. I already want to read it again.

Read via ARC from NetGalley

Was this review helpful?

The high-end art-world, possibly the most elitist, unobtainable sphere in society today, is ferociously deconstructed and set alight in the techno-dystopian, Black Mirror-esque tale of friendship and toxic insecurity.
Enka and Mathilde are the ultimate toxic duo molded by a patriarchal and classist society to distrust everything innately natural to themselves and yearn solely for what the other has. Enka needs Mathilde’s raw talent and ability to shock the world and profit from her art. Mathilde needs --- well Enka never really knows what Mathilde needs, but she’s going to do whatever it takes to guarantee that Mathilde will always need her.
The world of galleries and exhibits has never appealed to me – as someone who can’t deal in the abstract, literal meanings are worth more than undecipherable emotions splashed on a canvas. Somehow, Huang is able to use Mathilde’s Banksy-style exhibitionism and the monopoly of bio-hacking tech companies to make me feel DEEPLY about the right to make good art, and more importantly, the right to make mediocre art for the sake of nothing but art itself.

Was this review helpful?

I absolutely loved this. It was one of my top reads of the year by far, but it doesn’t release until 2025. I enjoyed Huang’s other book, “Natural Beauty,” quite a bit and was very interested in this one’s premise. I’m always on board for anything involving artists, especially when the plot gets dark. To say that Huang did not disappoint with “Immaculate Conception” would be an incredible understatement.

There was very little in the book that did not work for me, actually. The story held my interest from start to finish and kept evolving. It focuses on the friendship of two artists named Enka and Mathilde, and is told from Enka’s perspective. Huang knows her characters intimately, and vividly portrays the experiences of struggling, successful and pretentious artists in a believable way. There were times that Enka and her colleagues were discussing their projects and I had trouble following what they were saying, but I think maybe that was the point. I LOVED reading about the wild art installations and performance art that the characters in this world came up with. (Honestly, I wanted even more.)

This was a book that went to very strange and unexpected places, some dark and terribly sad. I could never predict what exactly was going to happen next. There were twists that I did not expect. It was the kind of literary fiction that I can’t get enough of. I loved the strange but subtle magical realism that Huang worked into the story. (People with unnatural abilities, technology combined with the human body to assist with the art process, etc.) There is never really a spotlight shone on this, and I thought that was interesting. Though I will say that there were a few times that I had trouble picturing what she was describing. The chapters are also separated into “Then” and “Now” sections, like a lot of current books seem to be, and I kept forgetting about the changes in time. The story somehow felt linear to me despite the transitions.

I particularly liked how this book handled friendship vs jealousy among artistic peers. Envy has always been something I’ve struggled with on a very personal level. It’s absolutely a part of being insecure, and there’s a terrible guilt that comes along with it. The author understood all of that. It’s the worst when it happens with people you really care about, because those dynamics are so complicated. You do want them to succeed, but you want yourself to succeed, also. They say “Comparison is the thief of joy,” and they aren’t kidding. But it’s a compulsion.

I don’t want to give too much away about the plot itself, but bodily autonomy becomes a theme, as Mathilde is subjected to a situation in which her mental capacity is questioned and Enka is tempted by her inclination towards whether or not to take advantage. Their friendship evolves throughout their careers as success, failure and manipulation brings them closer and tears them apart repeatedly. The novel also questions whether or not trauma really contributes to an artist’s creativity, and if that artist would be the same person without it. (A fascinating concept!) There are multiple complex stories and concepts being explored in this book and I loved all of them.

You should know that this is definitely not a light or easy read. Things get very dark and unsettling. You are reading from the perspective of a character who can most likely never be truly happy, no matter what happens. Enka is potentially irredeemable, and very difficult to root for. However, there were still parts of her that I could relate to, as much as I hate to admit it. I wanted something a bit different from the ending, though I’m not entirely sure what that would be. And I still consider this to be a solid 5-star read and a new favorite in general. Highly recommend if you like dark stories about artists!

Thank you so much to Netgalley and to the Publisher for this ARC in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own, and it was an honor to read this early.

Biggest TW: Self-harm, Child death, Racism, Depression, Mention of Sexual Assault

Was this review helpful?

Loved the premise of this novel but the pacing of the plot just didn't gel for me. Willing to give it another try.

Was this review helpful?

This author is a new favorite. Satire and social horror can skew heavy handed and like the reader needs huge clues about the themes. This author has a great balance. Will be adding to my personal library.

Was this review helpful?

Wow a brilliant read set in the art world a book that left me amazed.The authors writing from her first book to her latest is thoughtful captivating and I was sad to read the last pages #netgalley#duttonbooks

Was this review helpful?

This novel stirred deep emotions in me. Having studied art in university, I connected strongly with the theme of competition. In this story, the protagonists meet at an art school set in a dystopian world where two castes live side by side, though this backdrop is only lightly explored. The real focus is the intense, tumultuous relationship between Enka and Mathilde, set within a cutthroat world where creative ideation is tightly controlled and monitored. An obsessive friendship drives one character to twisted extremes to stay close to Mathilde and stay ahead in this high-stakes, prestigious milieu.

A disturbingly fascinating story. A must-read.

Thank you #netgalley, #dutton, #penguinrandomhouse, #immaculateconception

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley and Penguin Group for the DRC.

Immaculate Conception tackles a lot of interesting concepts and issues. Some are more fleshed out than others and what seems to suffer the most from having a book so jam packed with ideas is characterizations and character interactions that feel real. The world Huang creates feels surreal and heavily manufactured which seems to be the point but to have that extend to the characters themselves and how they interact with each other made this a difficult read for me at times. However, I appreciated and enjoyed the issues this book grapples with including privilege (of all kinds and levels), jealousy in female friendships, ownership of creativity, capitalizing and monetizing someone else's trauma, etc.

All in all, an interesting read but may not be for everyone.

Was this review helpful?

Ohhh, she’s BRILLIANT! Utterly spectacular read that I might like even more than the first book, Natural Beauty. Same vibes - maximalist, femme, unsettling, world shattering… New themes - jealousy in female friendship, art intersecting with technology, the relentless pressure to create, the distinct malaise of not feeling quite yourself. Ling Ling Huang is THAT girl in the domestic horror genre and I will eat up anything she writes in the future. (Thank you soooo much for this ARC!)

Was this review helpful?

I don’t even feel real anymore.

Thank you to Netgalley and Penguin Group Dutton for the advance egalley in exchange for my honest review.

This book put me in a state of fight, flight, freeze. There’s no one to fight because these are fictional characters. I can’t flee because I had to see how it ended. I could only remain frozen in perpetual, enthralled dread, and watch what happened.

Mathilde is a rising star in the art world after thousands of trademarks are placed on artificially generated “artwork.” Anything that could ever have been thought of, created, or combined has been done, and if it’s replicated by another artist, legal action can be brought against them. Mathilde is one of the only “original minds” who is wholly unaffected by this dystopia, because her specialty is in impermanence. Performance.

Enka is a struggling artist affected by this travesty. She struggles with the concept of originality, and never feels as if her creations are good enough or worthy of public scrutiny. She envies Mathilde’s authenticity.

The story follows these women through their youth as art students, their careers in the limelight, and their inevitable downfall brought on by the trust of one and the ambition of the other.

I was screaming. I was crying. If I could look away, I’d throw up.

Was this review helpful?

Ten out of ten no notes. A plus for innovation, timely social commentary, expert weaving of genres, and incredible world
Building!

Was this review helpful?

4.8 stars! I really enjoyed the ingenuity of this book! I've never read anything quite like it and I love how delicately and precisely handled the multiple subject matters were interwoven to make this a believable, beautiful, intriguing and powerful story. Would definitely recommend and I'm so glad I was given the opportunity to read it! Thank you to netgalley and the publisher!

Was this review helpful?

This was SO spectacular, I wish I could give it more than 5 stars. I absolutely loved Natural Beauty and thought I might be disappointed by the new novel because I loved it so much, and I was completely wrong. Everything about it is so masterful, from the carefully selected glimpses at dystopian climate collapse to the structure of the novel's parts, to the way the form and characterization is so masterfully revealed. Enka is such a profoundly, frankly violently, unreliable narrator, but the way the plot points unfold camouflages the extent of it until a brilliant turn at the end. Enka believes so deeply that she loves Mathilde and, to a lesser degree, Logan, that the magnitude of her cruelty and abuse lands like a lead weight. There are so many little betrayals that add up to an avalanche of horror, but the "point of no return" choice Enka ultimately confesses to is thematically brilliant. There are so many lines that rip your heart out, but Mathilde's "Enka, we were equals" is on par with "I wish I could tell my parents I'm a famous pianist now, that I have achieved their American dream. It only took a gimmick and cost me nearly everyone I know" from Natural Beauty. It levels up an element of Natural Beauty that made it such brilliant speculative horror, the science fiction elements actually create the possibility of horrors otherwise unimaginable, kinds of suffering that could only exist to a lesser degree in the present world. You can betray yourself and the people you love without SCAFFOLD, but not like this.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley for the ebook in exchange for an honest review.

“Artists create works of art. Geniuses curate an emotional response.”

“I would always shower with the heat turned all the way up, hoping my skin would melt and reassemble, turning me into someone else.”

“People are wrong about imitation, anyway. It isn’t flattery but an attempt at closeness.”

What a book!!! Ironically, I wish I could spend a few hours in this author’s mind. Unique and beautiful writing style, unique concepts, extremely strange and slightly disturbing.
At some points I hated it, but in a way that makes you realise that’s just how good the writing is.
I will admit I was not a huge fan of the main character, Enka. But my appreciation for Mathilde more than made up for it and kept me interested until the very last page.
The exhibits that are described, that the author has come up with were really fascinating, and extremely creative.
I have so much that I want to say about this book, but I want to keep the mystery for anyone who reads it.
I will definitely be recommending this.

Was this review helpful?

I loved this novel, about a friendship between two artists, tracking their friendship in art school to the present, when one has gone missing. Ling Ling Huang's is a deft writer, and I look forward to whatever she does next.

Thanks to the publisher for the e-galley.

Was this review helpful?

I really loved natural beauty and so I was so excited to get this arc. This book deals with many different themes related to art and trauma and technology. Overall, I would rate this book for stars. I think that the concept of technology and art was very interesting and relevant, considering the rise of artificial intelligence that we are currently experiencing. The relationship between the two main characters was very interesting to read about. I do feel like I enjoyed the first half of the book a lot more than I did the second half. Overall, I would definitely recommend this book to anyone who liked natural beauty, and who is interested in science fiction, trauma and art.

Was this review helpful?

At its core, Immaculate Conception by Ling Ling Huang asks us to consider what is lost in our efforts to preserve what we value. The book is a dark and thought-provoking exploration of celebrity, obsession, friendship, grief and trauma, and the fine line between love and possession. It takes on a lot! Set in a speculative future where technology allows for clones, mind-merge, human genome editing, and more, the novel weaves a disturbing story of Enka and Mathilde’s codependent relationship as they navigate art school and their parallel careers afterwards. While it’s framed as a friendship, it teeters dangerously into a more insidious terrain, one that is obsessive, self-serving, and dishonest in ways that I found deeply unsettling.

There were some underdeveloped elements of the novel that made for a confusing reading experience at times. The ending was frustrating, a series of aphorisms that felt empty. The first third focuses heavily on a seemingly rigid caste system. By the second third, it is never mentioned again and further, characters ascend easily without any barrier (?). Some of the character relationships also felt shallow -- Enka and Logan in particular was a little confusing to me and a lot of Enka's words about their relationship fall flat because there is no exposition about their courtship really at all. Maybe this was the point (i.e. in some ways platonic love can feel more intimate than romantic love). Others have commented that they felt the same with Enka and Mathilde particularly with regard to the speed with which Enka and Mathilde become intense friends as first years in college, and here I disagree: that's girlhood bby.

That being said, this novel made me think. There were times that Mathilde's and Enka's relationship made me want to crawl out of my own skin. There were fleeting moments in Enka and Mathilde's relationship that made me reflect on my own female friendships, and the ways that I wish they could see themselves through my eyes. Enka's realization that every memory shared with Mathilde is only "half remembered" sent me into a momentary trance. There were numerous occasions where Ling Ling Huang leaned into the comedy of it all as well. The descriptions of the exploitative art that caught the media's attention and blew up Mathilde's career were a trite caricature. The snide commentary on art criticism, on 'genius', on wealth, even on the scientific and medical testing of the biotech industry were similarly funny! It was ultimately an immersive and quick read. I enjoyed the reading experience a lot even if it left some open questions.

Content warning: The novel addresses sensitive topics, including the loss of a child, trauma, self-harm, and SA of a child.

Thank you to Ling Ling Huang, Penguin Group Dutton, and NetGalley for an advanced copy in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?