Anna's obsession with Willow is just too much to handle after a while. I understand that Anna is supposed to be this wide-eyed, small-town girl who doesn't see the conniving Willow's ways, but it just doesn't work. Also, the connection to 9/11 doesn't seem important at all. It feels like the time setting was chosen just to do something different.

My biggest problem with the book, though, was that the "prank war" that is supposed to take place never actually does. Willow does mean, manipulative things to Anna and their friends, and Anna "fights back" by doing dumb things like stealing Willow's keys or her jacket on a cold day. More than anything, Anna's confusion and her helplessness made me sad for her. As a book, I didn't enjoy this one at all.

3.5/5⭐️
This was a tough read. I was in 8th grade when 9/11 happened and I haven’t read a book that had it be at the center of all the drama. I thought the story was good, but I didn’t like a single character. The toxicity of their friendship was well described. But I just couldn’t like any of them and i was okay with that for the story. I liked how the story dives into how everything unravels, but it was a bit slow in some parts. Over all I did enjoy it, the ending was what I expected but it didn’t disappoint. I did like the narrator though, she did an amazing job conveying all of their emotions. So I recommend the audiobook if you are having trouble with it.

Many thanks to NetGalley and Hyperion Avenue for gifting me a digital ARC of the debut novel by Laura Leffler. All opinions expressed in this review are my own - 4 stars!

Anna and Willow met at art school, and Willow quickly became the most important thing in Anna's world. But 5 years later, both living in NYC, the cracks in their relationship have become too big to ignore. A prank is supposed to send Willow running back to Anna, evening out the power between the two. But that morning is 9/11 and Willow never returns home, leaving Anna to worry whether the prank went badly wrong.

This is a fascinating book, looking at a friendship that becomes fraught with envy and ambition, as well as how the art world views women. Told from alternating timelines between their art school years and their lives in NYC, the story is told in both 1st and 3rd person format, which was interesting and pulled you into the current mystery a little bit deeper. This book explores women's friendships at such a vulnerable time in their lives, when they are pulling away from home, wanting to be more, scared about the future, keeping secrets. Add in the events of 9/11, with cell phones down and Willow missing, and it became a taut thriller with multiple twists. Great debut and can't wait to read more from this author!

This was a tough read. The bases of the storyline was intriguing, but it dragged quite a bit. The characters were just unlikable and it made it difficult to want to read to the end. There was so much potential with this plot, but the execution just wasn’t there. I felt as though the timeline falling on 9/11 could have been played up so much more, but it almost felt like it was irrelevant to the entirety of the plot other than the very beginning.

This was a tough one to rate. When I realized I didn't care enough for the characters to really go back to finish the book, I knew this was going to be tough. But the thing was - I was still so curious of how the author was going to play this out. Most of the meat of the book was weirdly both relatable and unrelatable, which made it quite a chore to finish.

Everything about this book was attractive. The art world, the unsettling tone with both Anna and Willow, and the background of 9/11. But it was like being invited to a group and wishing I never accepted the invitation. But yet I couldn't turn away because for some odd reason, I wanted both good and bad things to happen to them. I never was bought into Anna - she seemed obnoxious enough even though she was supposed to be the timid one. Never cared for Willow. And with that, like I mentioned, it was quite a chore to finish. There were a few moments that the book shone, though, and somewhat redeemed itself.

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for a copy of this book. All opinions are my own.

I had a really hard time getting through this book. Nothing stuck in my mind and I found myself having to go back and re-read chapters.

Friends in art school vie for attention and the limelight for their chosen mediums. Willow is the wealthy, outgoing and persuasive photographer while Anna is a quieter broader who is into mixed media. The current time frame is September 11 in NYC and the chapters are interspersed wirh college years .The art school setting was an interesting backdrop and I enjoyed the artistic and literary references. The missing person aspect which drives the current day narrative is especially intriguing as the disappearance could be from the WTC or something more individually targeted. The characters and action are a bit jumbled but makes a strong finish. Geared more towards a young adult audience. However, I would read this author again!

Copy provided by the publisher and NetGalley

Tell Them You Lied delivers a deliciously sharp take on toxic female friendship, set against the backdrop of the art world and anchored by one of the boldest uses of 9/11 as a plot device in recent memory. Messy, moody, and full of razor-edged observations.

Laura Leffler's "Tell Them You Lied" plunges us into the intoxicating and ultimately destructive world of a friendship forged in the crucible of art school and shattered amidst the chaos of 9/11. This isn't a story about grand gestures of heroism or the sweeping historical narrative of that day, but a deeply personal and unsettling exploration of the lies we tell, the masks we wear, and the devastating consequences when they are ripped away.

Anna, a wide-eyed newcomer to art school, is instantly captivated by Willow – the embodiment of mysterious, moody, and undeniably cool. Willow becomes Anna's muse, collaborator, and guide to the "great secrets" of Art. But as the years pass and they navigate the cutthroat New York art scene, Willow's true nature as a self-serving and cruel artist is laid bare.

The tension escalates dramatically on the morning of September 11, 2001, when Anna stages a mugging for Willow, a desperate attempt to force her friend to confront the "monster she's become" and reclaim her own power. The plan is meant to be a wake-up call, a mirror reflecting Willow's cruelty. But the city is thrown into turmoil, and Willow never returns home. Anna, consumed by panic and guilt, remains silent about her prank, terrified that she is responsible for Willow's disappearance.

Leffler masterfully weaves together the past and present, alternating between Anna and Willow's art school days and their lives in 2001 New York. This dual narrative reveals the evolution of their complex friendship, from intense admiration to bitter resentment. As Anna grapples with the aftermath of her actions and the seismic events of 9/11, she begins to question everything – her own motives, Willow's true character, and whether she was ever truly in control or merely a pawn in a larger, more sinister game.

"Tell Them You Lied" is a gripping and thought-provoking novel that explores the dark side of ambition, the complexities of female friendships, and the devastating impact of a single day on individual lives. Leffler's prose is sharp and evocative, drawing us into the raw and vulnerable minds of her characters. This is a book that will stay with you long after you' turn the final page, leaving you to ponder the difficult search for answers when the truth is the last thing you want to find.

Compulsive reading. This novel is smartly-written, with a compelling plot that’s both mysterious and a bit sinister. It builds and unravels methodically, with effective employment of shifts in time and voice. The present day told in first-person narrative draws you in and amplifies the tension. And setting the events within the chaos of NYC on 9/11 adds layers of confusion and desperation. Alternating those chapters with third-person flashbacks provides distance, with a temporary lessening of the tension, but keeps the underlying foreboding as we learn the history of the complex characters and their complicated group dynamics. The slow build from benign envy and jealousy, through the manipulation and mind games, to the reveal is everything you look for in a suspenseful mystery-thriller.

Thanks Hyperion Press and NetGalley, for the opportunity to read this dark, twisty novel with thoughtful commentary about toxic female friendship, and the role of/portrayal of women in art. This ambitious debut novel accomplishes much of what it sets out to do. In all, it’s a highly exhilarating and entertaining read.

Loved the time frame and general premise of this one, but ALL of the characters were just so unlikeable. They weren't even unlikeable in that charming rogue sort of way - no, they were all just bad people, and I really didn't want anyone to come out on top. Kind of unfortunate, because the premise was really intriguing, and I felt like the author could have done a lot more with this one.

Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for the arc

I wanted to love this book but as someone who has a disability, I do not appreciate the use of the R word -- even in fiction. I am bummed.

Unfortunately, this book didn’t resonate with me. Oddly enough, this isn’t the first mystery/thriller book set in the art world during 9/11 that publishes this year (The Gallery Assistant by Kate Belli). In terms of setup, use of setting/atmosphere, and payoff, the other book is much stronger. This book feels like many elements are there just for the sake of it. For instance, it could have been told without the use of 9/11 or one of our main characters having a sibling with a mental disability (I love disability rep, but this was not that). I also didn’t like that the R-word was included, even though its use was appropriate for the time.

Furthermore, on the topic of the artist's muse, I believe Immaculate Conception by Ling Ling Huang (also published this year) handles this subject much better.

Reading the authors note, I think she thought this book was much deeper than it is.

Overall, this was a huge miss for me, especially as an art historian who almost always loves books set in the world I live and breathe.

This book just sounded interesting from the description. I believe it is a debut novel.

Description:
Anna had never met anyone like Willow. Entering art school with lofty ideas about Art and her role in it, Anna was wholly unprepared for someone as mysterious, moody—and cool—as Willow. Here was Anna’s muse and collaborator all in one, ready to bring her in on Art’s great secrets.

Now, five years later, Anna is weary. Where art school was boundless creativity and collaboration, the New York art scene is all about survival. Worse: Willow’s true nature as a muse only to herself has become nakedly apparent, as has her cruelty.

So the mugging Anna has staged for Willow this morning? It’s supposed to send Willow running back to her true friend. The knife is supposed to be a mirror in which this ‘artist’ can finally see the monster she’s become. It’s supposed to give Anna her power back.

But this morning isn’t just any Tuesday. It’s September 11, 2001. And as the city reels from the seismic events of that day, Willow never returns home. Anna keeps quiet about the prank and her growing panic that she’s to blame for Willow’s disappearance. But as the hours and days tick by, Anna begins to question whether she’s the mastermind she thought she was, or the pawn.

Alternating between the friends' art school tenure and their lives in 2001 New York, Tell Them You Lied reveals how difficult the search for answers is when you'd rather have anything but the truth.

My Thoughts:
Anna and Willow have never come across as equals to me. Anna was always the dependent, needy one and Willow the bold, outrageous type. This ends up breeding resentment, thus the plan to stage the mugging. I was surprised when 9/11 came up as the mugging was suppose to happen on that day. Both girls had flaws in their characters, although very different. I wasn't sure I liked either of them. Well=written and fast-paced which kept me turning pages. I liked the way the story ended, it felt right.

Thanks to Hyperion Avenue through Netgalley for an advance copy.

60/100 or 3.0 stars

There are plenty of things I liked about this: the writing style, the pace, and most of the characters. I do not like how the author used 9/11 as a plot device for this story to even work, as it felt exploitative of a very sad and scary time just for a cheap plot twist. I am also not a huge fan of using SA as a plot device either, and this story does that. The writing itself was easy to read and I'd be interested in what more Leffler has to offer, but I hope that I don't see a pattern in their plots, or they just might not be the author for me.

I had a hard time getting into the e-book so I requested an audiobook which I was approved for and ended up enjoying! Will leave my full review for my audiobook :)

I am not the right audience for this. I really didn't enjoy the characters, the time it was set in, and the art world (in this case) setting. Thank you, NetGalley.

This was such a great read and I was completely hooked and raced through this in only 2 sittings ....I just couldn't stop!

Appropriate for high school and up, the novel features a dark academia vibe, with lush imagery and a just-right pace. The transitions between present and past reinforce the suspense and the overall themes of trust/betrayal, role of women in art, and desire/envy are appealing, especially those who have familiarity with the role of women as muses in art and the allusions to the seven deadly sins.

Tell Them You Lied by Laura Leffler is a dark, twisty thriller about toxic friendship and obsession. Set around 9/11, it explores secrets, manipulation, and the blurred line between truth and lies. Gripping and unsettling.