Natalie (Cincinnati) Lee has dreams of following in the footsteps of her explorer and archaeologist great-great-(great?)-grandfather who lives in Cincinnati, Ohio. This upper grade novel heavily borrows from Indiana Jones' adventures, so for fans of those movies and other high-adventure titles, this one will be enjoyed. I feel like the idea for this book is to become a series since Cincinnati's GGG-grandfather stole over 100 items that she has charged herself with repatriating in order to break the perceived family curse. Not a bad debut novel from this author, and with promotion and advertisement, this book has possibilities to catch librarian attention to help make this title more visible.

What an epic book! The daring and adventure of an Indiana Jones movie with a lot more heart and a focus on the importance of museum repatriation. The main trio is awesome. I honestly could have read chapters dedicated to Parsley’s baby goat yoga and thoughts about bees and time.

Going in, I expected the first relic to be the focus on the entire novel…but really that’s just the cold open. This novel expands into a much bigger mystery and quest that constantly has you questioning whether the curses/magic is real or the lore of the intensely devout/faithful.

Though Cincinnati’s overall goals are good, her reasons are something she needs to battle with. Is she doing this because it’s the right thing to do? Is she doing this because she firmly believes in returning these relics to their cultures and will do anything to make it happen? Is she doing it to break her family curse? Is she doing this so that her Pops notices her? This internal conflict adds to the tensions on the novel and makes Cincinnati a much more intriguing protagonist.

This is a wonderful middle grades novel full of adventure, travel, history, and lore. For those trying to decide if their young reader would enjoy it- the main disturbing piece might be that a character is threatened with a gun. The shot happens “off screen,” but the characters are nearby and hear the gunshot. The plot might also get a little complicated for some readers to follow as the characters get themselves in deeper.

That said, I will definitely be adding this book to my middle school classroom library. I greatly enjoyed this novel, and I can think of many students of mine who would love it. It also holds a ton of educational value and conversation starters around the history and future of museums.

Thank you to NetGalley for the ARC!

This book was a delight to read and felt very much like Percy Jackson meets Indiana Jones. I loved Cincinnati's character and voice--I chuckled aloud many times throughout the book. It was great to see her change through the story, although I wish there was a bit more growth, but I'm glad we at least got some considering how action-packed the story was. Parsley was fabulous, the mini-romance was adorable, and the shenanigans were on point for middle grade. And, yes, it was wildly unrealistic and the ending was a little too perfect, but I won't fault a middle grade book for that.

Cincinnati Lee is, at heart, a young Indiana Jones - right down to choosing a nickname; her real name is Natalie. She is the youngest member of a family that has studied archeology for generations, with the exception of her mother, who had a falling-out with her family and became a waitress instead, although she now works for a major museum as a fund-raiser.

This is a fun and fast-paced novel about a girl who doesn't let society - or even her mother - define her, who is loyal to her friends but makes mistakes in dealing with them, but who knows how to apologize. She wants very much to make life better for herself and her mother, by removing a family curse - and by the end of the novel, she just might do it, if in a very different way than she intended.

I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of this book provided by Netgalley. All thoughts and opinions are my own.

Cincinnati is a girl who wants to be Indiana Jones-her mother works in a museum and her great, great, great (great) grandfather stole antiquities and she is determined to get things back to their country of origin. Except that a lot of this involves lying and thievery and a general disregard for the welfare of others. There are references to famous art works and Latin quotes that some readers might find interesting. The story is very mysterious and fast paced, which some readers might enjoy.

This is a great book for your higher level middle grades readers, especially those who love mystery combined with arts and history. Cincinnati spends her time surrounded by historical artifacts via her mother's job at a famous New York Museum. Her estranged grandfather is a famous artifact hunter and Cincinnati longs to follow in his footsteps. This is the story of how Cincinnati and her friends get embroiled in a mystery search, that leads to danger. Fast paced and fun.

I'm waffling between a 2.5 and a 3.

I'm not a fan of Cincinnati. She's really selfish and thinks she's right about everything (which may be accurate to a real 12-year-old, but it is not endearing). There were a few times she felt more like she was 8 instead of 12. She swears in Latin instead of English and that would be unbelievably annoying in real life.

The only thing in the world she cares about is archaeology, and yet she doesn't seem to know what archaeologists actually do. She and her pops were based heavily on Indiana Jones (her name, she has to have that hat, Pops went on a bunch of adventures to loot things, movies were based on his life), who is the world's absolute worst archaeologist and not somebody people should be looking up to. Archaeology is pretty boring and she seems to think it's all grand adventures.

I never understood why she idolized her pops or why she wanted to name herself after the city he was languishing away in, besides the Indiana Jones comparison.

There's a big acknowledgement that relics should be returned to the cultures they came from, but not near enough criticism of Pops for stealing them in the first place. His change of heart didn't seem realistic.

I liked the criticism of the Craft Raft owners (AKA Hobby Lobby) being artifact smugglers. They suck.

The book got much better as it went on and it focused more on the adventure aspects vs Cincinnati's relationship with her bully cousin. Some moments felt cartoony rather than realistic, so don't expect the story to be that rooted in reality.

I might read the next book if this becomes a series. I think a lot of my issues with it will either be dealt with or played down.

I'm sure a lot of middle-grade readers will love following Cincinnati and her friends on her quest.

CW: off-page gun violence

Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for a digital review copy.

What a fun book! I love adventure stories, and this one tackles some of the genres' more problematic aspects in a really unique and nuanced way. Cincinnati is such an interesting, multi-faceted main character--especially for a middle grade novel. I didn't always agree with her choices, but I was always rooting for her and her friends. I love how passionately she cared about her cause, even if her motivations were sometimes a little bit selfish.

A very fun read for anyone who has ever dreamed of being Indian Jones. This story ask a lot of tough questions of the reader like "how did this artifact end up in this museum?" "does it belong here or does it belong with the culture it is from" "who gets to decide who owns these artifacts and who gave them that power?'. The book asks the question of the reader by taking them on an adventure where Cincinnati tries to right the wrongs done by her ancestors, lift a curse, and discover what is really important in the end. These is a fun thought provoking adventure.

Thank you to #NetGalley, Heidi Heilig and the publisher of the book for the eARC copy in exchange for an honest review.

Cincinnati Lee’s great great something grandfather is famous. His ancient artifacts have been made into movies, and his work is respected by museums everywhere. The thing is, in that line of work, you’re bound to get cursed. And that leaves your great something granddaughter to break the curse by returning said artifacts that you had your hands on.

Cincinnati’s own adventure begins at Cosmopolitan Museum in NYC, where her single mom works and Cincinnati has grown up her whole life. Cincinnati learns about the ancient Spear of Destiny and its ability to right all the wrongs in her family’s past or possibly end the world. Cincinnati must beat two other hunters to the spear. Her search takes her to many locations throughout the city and even to London. Along the way, she’ll make a new friend, make some enemies, and learn what things are worth saving.

Cincinnati Lee is an adventerous middle grade read with a laugh out loud character. A group of friends and enemies, continuous action, and the importance of family! This read will keep you on the edge of your seat!

Four-star fun for middle-grade readers/seekers of adventure…and clever kids who care

Characters: 8

Twelve-year-old Natalie Lee—but please call her Cincinnati—is always on the move. She means well in wanting to break her family’s curse by returning ancient relics to their rightful origins, but she often has to learn the hard way what it truly means to put others’ needs before your own desires. Fortunately, her long-suffering and inventive friend Felix and newfound companion Parsley (who appreciates Cincinnati’s aura) keep her accountable…and alive when she places herself in some dangerous spots. The trio bands together to oppose criminal business owner Taylor Calloway as they uncover clues and overcome obstacles from New York to Paris. Other principal characters include Cincinnati’s hard-working but caring mother, her great-great-great grandfather Pops, and mysterious antiquities dealer Christopher Salt.

All characters are distinctly and effectively developed, though readers might hope for more direct interaction between 130-something-year-old Pops and Cincinnati. Additionally, villainous Calloway may come across as a caricature if no backstory is provided for motivation other than religious fanaticism.

Atmosphere/Settings: 9

Author Heilig’s knowledge of New York City shines, including details known only to those who have been there and/or done their research. From the Cosmopolitan Museum (representing the MoMA) to the famous Dakota Building, and from the City Hall Loop to St. Patrick’s Cathedral, the descriptions allow even young readers to become part of the scenes. Even the quick trip to Paris provides engaging imagery along the Seine. Only London felt a bit underserved, but it did make me want to attend an all-night gala at the British Museum.

Writing Style: 8

Cincinnati’s first-person point of view reflects her thoughts, feelings, and character growth. She frequently uses cultural metaphors related to her passion for archeology that may be unfamiliar to some middle-grade readers. The author also employs vocabulary extending beyond the target age. That said, I did not find it off-putting because the words fit the context, hopefully providing an appropriate challenge. Lighthearted, humorous dialogue binds the friends and boosts the enjoyment.

Plot: 9

The pace remains active and well-balanced with moments of introspection. It is fitting for the protagonist, the nature of the storyline, and for readers of all ages. There are moments of convenience when characters unexpectedly appear to resolve a conflict, but at least reasons are provided.

Intrigue: 8

More than enough “I wonder what will happen next” moments to keep the pages turning, enhanced by the variety of well-selected settings.

Logic: 7

The author ensures purpose and resolution for most events. For example, Cincinnati’s motivation for breaking the curse is explained well, and the history of the Spear of Destiny is helpful, but other concepts may be less plausible.

—The sudden appearances of Felix and Parsley may be welcome yet also strain credulity in a world of adults.

—Christopher Salt’s intercontinental travel in his physical state goes undiscovered?

—Context is minimal for the “water of eternal life” obtained by Pops when it could/should be of significant importance.

Enjoyment, Meaning, and Miscellaneous: 8

The relatable personalities of the primary trio make it easy for middle-aged readers to engage with the story and to root for them to overcome any flaws. The clues are not easily obtained, requiring mental and physical effort.

Meaningful messages:

—True family and friends choose to help at all times.

—Honesty isn’t easy in the short run, but it works best in the long run.

Content awareness/concerns:

—Death does occur, though bloodshed and violence are not graphic. Swearing is implied but not spoken, at least not in English.

—Cincinnati’s dismissive views of others’ beliefs expressed early in the story concerned me, especially with the potential to stereotype people of faith. Fortunately, by the end, she recognized that first impressions and labels may be easily applied, but better understanding is gained when you truly listen and get to know someone. She began to appreciate other perspectives without sacrificing her ability to discern right from wrong.

—Miscellaneous: Inclusion of a map to indicate NYC settings might enhance the reading experience.

Thank you to NetGalley and the author/publisher for the ARC. Opinions expressed are my own.

Total: 57, average of 8.14 = 4 stars

This is EXACTLY the book I needed when I was an eleven-year-old reluctant reader. This hit all the notes for me. I was immediately charmed by Cincinnati’s gruff narration and persevering spirit. I’m definitely not above the nostalgia bait with a twist! I want to put this book in every kid’s hand. I desperately want this to be a series. This novel is perfect for kids who love James Ponti, or anyone who likes a great adventure.

Cincinnati (or, Natalie, to her mother), is an exciting, if unrealistic, character who studies archeology and knows more about artifacts and the ethical considerations of collections as a pre-teen than most adults. She has a passion for learning, a strong belief in curses and desire to break them, and struggles to find the best way to do the right thing. This book is one long ride of edge of your seat adventure as Nat sets out to break the curse - or curses - that she believes has a hold over her great, great, great grandfather. While mostly grounded in realism, a bit of fantasy makes the story just right.

Thank you to HarperCollins Children's Books, Greenwillow Books, Netgalley, and the author for early access to this fun adventure novel.

This was a great action-packed adventure! I am certain it will be a popular book in my classroom library. If you're a fan of Indian Jones, this book is for you (or your students)!

If you’re a fan of Indiana Jones then you will most certainly like Cincinnati Lee, Curse Breaker, because this is a kid’s version of that character. Cincinnati plans to break the curse she thinks is put on her grandfather when he worked as an archaeologist collecting finds from different cultures. There is lots of action, some sidekick friends to help her on her quest, and of course an evil adversary. I think kids will really enjoy it even if they are not familiar with Indiana Jones. This looks to be the first adventure in her quest so hopefully there will be many more to come.

Natalie “Cincinnati” Lee has dreamed about following in her great-great-great-grandfather’s footsteps as a explorer, historian, and maybe a little like the famous guy in the movies with the distinctive hat and all the adventures. She also wants to free him from a curse that he may have caused himself and reunite her family (they haven’t been talking for a long while). In an attempt to start correcting his curse, she accidentally stumbles onto her very own adventure that could solve all her problems or make them worse. Cincinnati is charming, headstrong, and determined, not unlike a young Indiana Jones. I really enjoyed how she embodied the spirit of “girls can” with some help from new and old friends. I’m waiting for the next installment.

Thank you NetGalley for the opportunity to read an ARC of this book for review.

Interesting book where the main character has many parallels to Indiana Jones. The author also slips some commentary about “fictional” companies and religion that isn’t normally found in younger grade books. I feel like the sarcasm and snipes at Craft Raft, Hobby Lobby and religion will likely go unnoticed by the intended audience. The author’s note at the end reveals that the author takes issues with museums, and is trying to bring this to light through the story.

Story wise, the main character, Cincinnati is driven, and has a “do whatever it takes” attitude to get what she wants, and only thinks about the consequence afterwards. The story was action packed, but towards the end I felt like things tied up too abruptly. Being that it takes a lot from Indiana Jones, it was hard to believe that a middle schooler would be the lead adventurer in the story. With that in mind, and some of the supernatural occurrences, this book would probably connect well with those who enjoy fantasy/adventure books.

Cincinnati Lee, Curse Breaker (out March 25!) is for middle grade readers wanting a book of mystery, action, and ancient history (lots of fun references for them to go dig into). This book packs the punch. Cincinnati’s great grandfather is known worldwide for his discovery of ancient artifacts and her mom works at the Cosmopolitan Museum. Cincinnati’s interest and knowledge of ancient artifacts comes naturally, which is a huge plus when she goes on the hunt for the Spear of Destiny which could end a generational curse in her family or maybe destroy the word (if it falls into the wrong hands). She and her friends are up against some other relic hunters, but she’s clever and determined to get there first. This is a fun, fast-paced book full of surprises that is sure to delight readers who love #RickRiordan, #BlueBalliet, and #IndianaJones.

Thank you, Netgalley and Harper Collins Childrens Books, Greenwillow Books for the e-galley and a chance to share my review.

Natalie (aka Cincinnati) Lee is attempting to break her family curse by repatriating artifacts back to their rightful owners. As expected, this does not go smoothly and Cincinnati gets into quite a few scrapes.

I enjoyed adventure and especially friendship aspects of the book. Some of the plot was very unrealistic and may be more than my upper elementary students will slog through. The second half seemed to be rushed and I think many of those who stuck with it might be confused. I think older students would enjoy this more as they maybe able to better follow the plot.

Thank you to netgalley for the e-arc! This book was a delight to read and felt very much like Percy Jackson meets Indiana Jones. I loved Cincinnati's character and voice--I chuckled aloud many times throughout the book. It was great to see her change through the story, although I wish there was a bit more growth, but I'm glad we at least got some considering how action-packed the story was. Parsley was fabulous, the mini-romance was adorable, and the shenanigans were on point for middle grade. And, yes, it was wildly unrealistic and the ending was a little too perfect, but I won't fault a middle grade book for that.

My biggest concern is that the book treated the villain's (very problematic) ideology a little glibly. It wasn't presented favorably in any way, but it did touch on heavy topics that should have come with more discourse and/or debriefing in my opinion.