Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Reading the synopsis I was super excited to read it, I was struggling to push through and it was a little bit boring, I did like how the story was going but then it felt like a drag, I just couldn’t really get into it

Was this review helpful?

Thanks NetGalley for the chance! As many reviewers have already adequately covered the plot, my review more
speaks to writing style. The novel’s premise was great, but the execution and pacing felt like it could have been so much stronger. After putting the book down, I was finding it hard to pick back up. Had the plot been sped up a bit, I think I would have rated this at least a 4-star read.

Was this review helpful?

This was a book that I was hesitant to read, because going by the synopsis it seems this book has been done many times before. However, this book was different and so much better than the others before it. The writing was stellar, I loved the characters current development and backstories, and the settings were described perfectly. But… the one problem I did end up having with this book was that it ended up being too lengthy.

This story starts off with Nina Drayton, who goes back to the south of France to her childhood home where her older sister Tamara was killed. Nina was only five years old at the time of the murder, and she decides to go back home to relive that day to see if her memories were right. Nina has struggled her whole life after her sister’s death, relied on several different medications to get through a day- never quite sure of herself. Nina now works as a child psychologist, and her mother and brother are not very happy about her new choice in life.

Josie Jackson is the girl who spent ten years in prison for the death of Nina’s sister, Tamara Drayton. Since being released from prison she has never found any stability in her life, and cannot go back to her hometown since she is shunned there. But was Josie really guilty of Tamara’s murder?

It isn’t until Imogen Faye, a true crime TikTokker reopens the case of Tamara Drayton that new evidence comes to light.
This book goes back and forth between 2004 and 2024, and you get a clear picture of all the characters lives. I was especially fond of Nina’s character, and I would have liked to have read more about her in this book.

This book was divided into Four Parts, and I will say that I really loved the first two parts- and then parts Three and Four seemed to drag on. I do feel that’s when the book started to get a bit too lengthy, and fill with unnecessary drama and details. However, I did mostly enjoy this book and I do plan on reading more from this author in the future.
(3.5 stars)

Many thanks to NetGalley, St. Martin’s Press, and the author for an ARC of this book which I had the pleasure of reading. Publication date: August 12, 2025
Genre~ General Fiction (Adult), Mystery & Thrillers, New Adult

Was this review helpful?

High Season is a gripping story that highlights Nina, who at 5 years old is the youngest witness at a murder trial. When her sister Tamara is murdered, Nina is the only one that saw anything and it ends up putting away the murderer. Now 20 years later, Nina returns to her family's home in France and is immediately thrown back into the past and wonders if she actually remembers things correctly or did she put an innocent woman away. This story is told by different POVs and it is a good build up to see how things happened 20 years ago and now. There are multiple twists and while I did predict the ending, it did not take anything away. There were so many twists that lead up to the ending that you are constantly intrigued.

The author does such a good job developing the characters and evolving the story at a great pace.

Thank you NetGalley and St.Martin Press for an ARC in return for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

This was a really good book that was twisty while also being haunting and sad at times. It centers on the death of 17-year-old Tamara and goes back and forth between the weeks leading up to her death and 20 years later, when all the players are back at the scene of the crime. The earlier story centers heavily on Tamara and also introduces us to her twin, Blake, her younger sister, Nina, Nina's babysitter Josie, and Josie's best friend Hannah. The current timeline has now-adult Nina questioning the version of events she thought she knew as a child, and Josie struggling to rebuild her life after being in prison.

While there are a number of characters in this book, they all have distinct voices and it's easy to keep them straight. I liked the dual timeline, where I got to know Tamara as well as younger versions of the current characters. The story was suspenseful the whole way through, leading me to read late into the night on multiple occasions in order to see what happened. I changed my mind on what I thought really happened multiple times. While there were some truly horrible characters, there were also beautifully real and flawed characters that I was rooting for. The ending was really well done, uncovering surprises while also tying up loose ends, though it did make me sad.

Overall, this was a super engaging book with beautifully drawn characters and a strong mystery. I would recommend to those who enjoy mysteries and domestic suspense. Thanks to Netgalley for providing me with a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Nina’s life is irrevocably altered when she is the only witness to her sister’s death twenty years ago in Katie Bishop’s High Season. Six years old at the time, she was forced by circumstance to testify at her former babysitter’s trial for the murder. As the years have passed, she has begun to doubt her memory, and with the news that a documentary about the case is coming out she is trying her hardest to revisit that night and figure out if she was wrong.

I finished this book in one afternoon because I was so engrossed in the story and invested in the characters. A fun, engaging mystery with satisfying conclusion. The book is a twist, beautifully written mystery with a wealth of well developed characters in a gorgeous setting. A wonderful story that i wholeheartedly recommend. Five out of five stars.

I received this advance copy from the publisher via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review and feedback.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you Netgalley for an early copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
I've really enjoyed both of Katie's books and I was super excited to get a copy of this one. Katie sets the vibes perfectly to where you really feel like you're inside the novel with the characters. This book had an interesting plot (would you believe a 5-year-old that is the only witness of her sister's death??) that had me hooked from start to finish. I love books with dual timelines and different points of view. This would be the perfect escape on a tropical vacation.

Was this review helpful?

5 stars
This was a great read! It really kept me guessing! The elements of rich v. poor, have v. .have nots really added to the story. I also liked the inclusion of a social media influencer in the solving of the crime. Made it feel both very timely and a little icky. I'm pretty new to the mystery genre and this is exactly what I enjoy - nothing too explicit or gory with a puzzle that is hard to solve.

Thank you St. Martin's Press and NetGalley for the digital ARC in return for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

HIgh Season
by Katie Bishop
Pub Date: August 12, 2025
Thanks to the author, St. Martin's Press and NetGalley for the ARC of this book in exchange for my honest opinion.
Set over two unforgettable summers two decades apart, High Season is a dark, tense exploration of the nature of memory, the enduring power of truth, and all the gray areas in between.
What a great book! I flew through this sizzling summer thriller and enjoyed it very much. 20 years ago, Tamara was murdered in her own pool while friends and family were gathered at her house for a party. The only witness was her 6 year old sister Nina. Now, a podcast is delving into the murder to see if there is any new evidence to support or contradict Nina’s account of that evening. When you are looking for that perfect beach read for next summer, remember to pick up High Season as it doesn’t come out until then. I promise it will be worth the wait! Thank you to NetGalley and St.Martin’s Press for the ARC!

Was this review helpful?

“There are kinds of sadness that you can’t even imagine, until they happen to you. And then they happen, and you forget there’s any other way to feel.”... “So no,” she says as she exhales. “I don’t feel any sadder here than I do anywhere else. Because it’s everywhere, that sadness. And you keep on moving because you have to. You survive, because you’re lucky to have been given the chance to do so. Because it’s all that you can do.” - Evelyn Drayton, High Season
An incredibly captivating tale of echoing grief, redemption, and misguided memories. The characters were all so intriguing and intricate. Reading it during the late fall/early winter really makes me wish for summer’s quick return. Everything was great, I just knew from the start what the ending was going to be - hence the four stars instead of five.
Thank you to NetGalley, St. Martin’s Press, Ms. Allison Ziegler for reaching out, and, of course, Ms. Bishop for sending me a copy in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

This book was very hard to get into and I struggled most of the way through. For some reason it just wasn’t clicking for me. High Season tells a story of a then 5-year-old, Nina Drayton, who witnesses the murder of her sister. She claims their babysitter, Josie, did it. Decades later, a podcast/true crime influencer reaches out to Nina looking to resurface the case. The novel switches between past and present. It takes you through many themes such as family drama, friendship, manipulation, toxic relationships, and memory. I think this author has a lot of potential, however I can’t necessarily say that I recommend this book. Maybe it’ll be your cup of tea though.

Thank you to Katie Bishop and NetGalley for the ARC in exchange for a fair and honest review.

Was this review helpful?

An excellent sophomore novel from Katie Bishop!

Nina was just five years old when she testified in her older sister's murder trial. She swears she saw her babysitter/local woman Josie shove her sister in the pool on the night of her mother's birthday party, where she ultimately died from her injuries.

Now twenty years later, Nina begins to doubt herself and her memories. Against the advice of her boyfriend and her family, she agrees to be part of a true crime documentary that is taking another look at the crime.

Josie, meanwhile, has spent the years since she was released from prison trying to form a semblance of a normal life. She is ready to uproot everything at a moment's notice anytime someone learns her true identity. Running from the past has led her right back home, the last place she ever expected to be.

Will these two women be able to use this summer to find out what actually happened the night Tamara died? Taught, suspenseful, full of complex characters -- this one is a winner!

Was this review helpful?

When Nina was six years old, she provided testimony that convicted her older sister’s murder. Now, decades later, a podcast begins investigating and doubts her testimony.

This was a slower paced story but it all came together in the end with a bang. You really get to know all the characters past and present. The dual time lines were both of equal interest. There were also some small parts of a true crime podcast, which added an outsiders perspective. I was not expecting the outcome and what truly happened; it was very upsetting but I loved how the characters came together in the end.

“A summer’s day. A story told by a five-year old child. Two decades of a story that has defined all their lives.”

High Season comes out 8/12.

Was this review helpful?

Katie Bishop serves up a juicy slow burn! Set in the south of France (you can almost smell the salt air), rich complex characters tell a story of the haves and have nots. Josie’s mom works for the rich people on the pink house. Hannah’s family runs the local dive shop. The girls get pulled into the lives of the rich kids and what starts out as summer fun, ends in tragedy. Dual timelines and multiple POV keep the reader engaged. Short chapters help build tension that comes to a satisfying ending. I highly recommend High Season!

Was this review helpful?

Katie Bishop’s High Season is a captivating exploration of memory’s fragility, family secrets, and the ripple effects of trauma. Set against the lush, sun-soaked backdrop of the Côte d'Azur, the story alternates between two pivotal summers—2004, when Tamara Drayton’s tragic death shattered her privileged family, and 2024, as a true crime documentary resurfaces unanswered questions about that fateful night.

At the heart of the narrative is Nina Drayton, who, as a five-year-old, became the youngest witness in a French murder trial after claiming she saw their babysitter, Josie, drown her sister. Tamara. Decades later, Nina’s recollections blur, forcing her to confront the ghosts of her past and the layers of deception that enveloped her family. Bishop masterfully intertwines perspectives, painting a rich tapestry of characters, from Josie and her friend Hannah, to Tamara and Blake, whose golden-boy façade conceals a darker side.

The dual timelines are a triumph, building tension as they delve into themes of privilege, manipulation, and the power of perception. The story’s slow-burn pacing in the earlier chapters mirrors the oppressive heat of the French Riviera, while the present-day chapters, with their true-crime podcast vibes, feel refreshingly modern. The twists, though subtly hinted at, pack an emotional punch, especially as the narrative exposes the flawed humanity of its cast.

Bishop’s evocative prose captures both the beauty of the South of France and the stark realities of fractured relationships, creating a hauntingly atmospheric read. High Season is a deeply layered domestic thriller that will linger long after the final page, cementing Katie Bishop as a master of intricate, character-driven mysteries.

I truly enjoyed the balanced pacing and well-developed characterization, as well as how the mystery keeps you hooked until the very end, urging you to make guesses and savor the thrilling ride. Additionally, the city setting is another intriguing aspect that makes this book a must-read.

A huge thanks to NetGalley and St. Martin's Press for sharing this thrilling novel's arc copy with me in exchange for my honest opinions.

Was this review helpful?

Well-written mystery. It throws curves, twists, and turns throughout. With well-developed characters the guessing game for the reader is on.

Was this review helpful?

Wow! This was a really good thriller. It kept me on my toes! I couldn't put it down.

Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for allowing me to read this arc in exchange for an honest review!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for the Kindle ARC in exchange for an honest review. High Season is a slow burn story - set in the South of France over several years. The Draytons live in the Pink House on a cliff overlooking the ocean in the Cote d' Azure. They are considered "new money" and Evelyn, the mother and her son Blake wish to fit in with the old money.. Blake's twin sister, Tamara, isn't so much concerned with money but wishes to be her true self. Their younger sister, Nina, claims that when she was five, she witnessed the horrific death of Tamara. A local, Josie, is implicated in the murder, sending the lives of all involved into a spiral for years to follow. Ms. Bishop's writing builds up suspense. I wasn't sure who committed the crime but I was sure it was not the accused. Finding out the devastating truth in the last chapters was worth the wait.

Was this review helpful?

Honestly, I wasn't that excited about this book. Seemed like the premise was similar to a ton of other books I'd read. But boy was I surprised. (Like a 4.5 for me... I wasn't as jazzed about the true crime through-line, but it grew on me.)

Once I got into this, I found it to be a juicy whodunnit in a glamorous setting, contrasting the lifestyle of the rich and famous vs the locals who make the lives of the rich run seamlessly. In that respect it has kind of a Downton Abbey vibe, parallel timelines but also parallel experiences.

I think what I liked most is that the mystery has been "solved" at the top of the book. A girl (Josie) was tried and convicted for this crime decades ago. The book explores the real story of what unfolded that night. This early reveal allows the reader to sit back and enjoy the ride.

The characters are fascinating and book moves along at a nice clip. Though it's currently snowing outside where I live, I found this to be the ultimate beach read.

Thank you to the author and NetGalley for granting me the opportunity to read this in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

This book was both fast-paced and engaging. Between the setting and the writing, it had me captivated from page one.

Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for this ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?