Wow! This was probably the best book I have read in 2025. I could not put it down and when I put it down - I couldn’t stop thinking about it. I do fear describing it could spoil it for others,. But I loved how the story was told — effortlessly woven from the past to the present. I also found all of the characters super likable and I was rooting for them all.

This was an odd book. It took me several false starts to actually get into it because it's so dang sad. I mean, the main character, a thirty-three-year-old mom and her four-year-old daughter are blown to smithereens in a terrorist attack in Paris in the first chapter, so it's all downhill from there.

As it turns out, the woman, Honor Wharton, who oddly narrates the story from the afterlife, wanted a second baby and ended up using a donor egg and a surrogate. The embryo is viable and grows into a baby, Henry, who's born after her death. Honor's grieving husband, Tom, raises their son by himself.

Then, through a strange mistake, he meets Grace, the egg donor. They start dating and he doesn't tell her that she's Henry's egg donor. When his and Honor's jealous friend Lauren exposes it, their engagement implodes. They do get back together, though, and Grace is pregnant with a girl, just in time for a happy ending.

I just... don't know about this one. The characters frustrated me. Honor obsessed over a second baby so much that she barely paid attention to the great kid she did have. Tom worked a hundred hours a week at his hedge fund, despite having enough money to retire comfortably. I wanted to slap them both!

And I'm not sure the medical aspects were accurate. Would doctors really remove the ovaries of a thirty three year old just because of uterine fibroids? That doesn't seem realistic to me. Overall, this was a less well-done, British version of The Lovely Bones.

Thanks to NetGalley for the free review copy.

4.5 Stars rounded up

I really liked this book that, to me, was more of a story about living with grief and moving on from a tragedy—with a touch of romance. Finding Grace follows Honor, who seems to have it all until a devastating event changes everything. Years later, one decision sets off a ripple effect that intertwines two women’s lives in unexpected ways.

Blending emotional depth with a gripping moral dilemma, this debut novel is both moving and thought-provoking. My only critique is that the ending felt a bit rushed, but overall, it’s a beautiful, compelling story about love, loss, and second chances.

Thank you NetGalley, St. Martin’s Press & Macmillan Audio for the e-arc & ALC in exchange for my honest review.

Thanks to NetGalley, St. Martin’s Press, and MacMillan Audio for the digital copy of this book and audiobook; I am leaving this review voluntarily.

The publisher synopsis was sufficiently vague, because this book was written in such a unique way that to say certain things would give away a major plot point. So, I will try to do the same. The first few chapters of the book reminded me of Alfred Hitchcock’s Psycho, but I won’t tell you what parts–sorry!

I didn’t quite connect with the characters in the book, but I was still compelled to find out the whole story. Red herrings, Maguffins, this book has it all. It definitely will make you react emotionally. What emotions it evokes depends upon how much you like how the story unfolds. I really can’t figure out how to tell you about this book without giving spoilers.

The audiobook was narrated by Fiona Button, who did an excellent job. I would definitely listen to another book narrated by her.

Very impressive debut- such a unique structure and plot device. Had to find out what happens. Interesting characters and journey.

Beautiful. Tragic. Heartwarming. Gut wrenching.

A fresh reminder not to take anything for granted. A reminder that grief isn’t cyclical and no one person’s experience is the same. A reminder that you never know when it’s the last everything with someone.

I read and listened to this book and it was a top read so far of 2025. Bring all the tears and laughter, this will stick with me.

Finding Grace was an unexpected, unique story starring Honor, her husband Tom, and Grace. The book started off with a bang, but I'll avoid a plot summary because it's best to go into this one blind and uncover the surprises for yourself.

I noticed a decent number of reviews commented how they disliked the characters, but I enjoyed them for all of their flaws. The biggest microscope was set on Tom, and yes, he made a lot of impulsive, dumb decisions, but I can more or less see why he took the path that he did. In addition to being a great look at character growth, this book focused a lot on grief and how it settles into your daily life. Even if years go by, the loss never really goes away, and I enjoyed following these characters as they all dealt with this in their own manner.

Such an interesting book & really different from what I expected. The book summary isn't wrong, but it is a little misleading. So, I guess, sliiiiight spoilers ahead?

The book started exactly as I expected, then very much veered away quite suddenly. I won't say how, but, wow, it got me.

The narration style was a touch odd. For the most part, I really liked it, but it could be weird. Really insightful and beautiful, but odd. Same with the plot. It had me low-key stressed, especially the closer to the end we got. Almost manic.

But, despite all that intensity & oddities, it was a reflective book with moments that really gave me pause (in a good way) and made me think about moving on & grief.

Many thanks to NetGally and the publisher for the ARC of this book.

Wow, what a debut novel! The author did such a great job crafting the characters and the story.

It's virtually impossible to say anything about the plot without giving spoilers, but suffice it to say that the POV is quite unique. The narrator, Honor, draws the reader in immediately. I loved all of the relationships, and watching them unfold over the multiple timelines was incredibly touching. The overarching theme of parental love is portrayed incredibly well, and I had to stop, breathe and wipe away tears several times. The romantic relationships played out really well too. And the friendships in the story were incredible - between couples, between women, between son in law and mother in law...phew! Honor, Tom and Grace are the main characters, but I actually loved the characters of Annie and Colette the most. They felt like real people to me. This book really had all the feels.

I have to say that when the "villain" of the story is revealed, I was truly shocked...maybe I am just too naive. Gasp!! And Tom makes some very questionable choices throughout the story, which make it really hard to sympathize with him. But that all contributes to the plot line and it really was done well.

I would definitely recommend this! 4.5 stars!

Dynamic debut that starts with a bang! I went into this story blind, basically knowing that there was an infertility storyline, and I encourage everyone to do the same. I expected a quite different book after reading the first two chapters. This is a well written, emotional, character driven story that involves heartbreak and grief but also second chances. However, I did not like any of the characters, especially the main male character, Tom, which detracted from my overall enjoyment of the book. Tom makes a series of blunders and many of his choices had me covering my eyes, imagining the train wreck ahead. I also disliked Honor so that made me less invested in the story overall. Despite that, I still very much enjoyed the writing, the emotions this story brought out, and the different ways people handle grief. This book has been getting a lot of early positive buzz and I look forward to reading more from this author in the future.

Thank you to NetGalley and St Martin’s Press for an advanced reader copy in exchange for my honest review.

Addictive, memorable, and frustrating in the best way possible — I loved this book!

I was hooked from the very beginning and loved the emotional rollercoaster that this story took me on. I felt every emotion on the spectrum.

The fact that this is a debut is phenomenal. I can’t wait to read more from this author!

One of the best debut novels I have ever read and my top read for 2025 so far. A novel filled with bring you gut wrenching heartbreak and frustration that will make you throw the book across the room only to run and pick it up again to finish it. A truly book you won't be able to put down. Real and raw, with so many twists and turns, the book will have you in a chokehold until the last page. Rothschild's writing style is both sophisticated, honest, and relatable, but the techniques she uses are rare and hard to pull off (but she does it!). Finding Grace is a story that even after reading the synopsis you don't see it coming. You will love some characters to your core and hate others, but they are all so lively and jump off the page. A book that will leave you speechless and want to start all over again from page one. If you enjoy raw and real stories of grief, love, and the life we live in between (as well as plot twists), this is the book for you!.

I was hooked from the beginning. Great read.
Thank you so much NetGalley for letting me read this book

This was an easy to binge book. There was a twist at the start that came out of the blue. After initial wondering what just happened, it set up the rest of the story and sucked me in. I wasn’t expecting the perspective that was shown throughout the book. I was surprised and delighted that I saw this story through different eyes.

I really enjoyed the first half of the book, but by the second half, I was ready for the plot to resolve and to see some maturity. The pace slowed down, and I became bored the more frustrated I got from choices being made. Although, one of the main characters was frustrating, I liked many of the secondary characters. There was an unusual friend group that was a highlight to the story. I love a great friend group, and this one was fully present.

The story revolves around grief, but it felt like a plot device instead of a natural part of the story development. I realize that everyone grieves differently, but for me, this felt like grief was an excuse for poor choices.

This book will be very emotional for some people, and they’ll love the messiness of it. Mixing grief with romance can be a draw. I usually love these types of books, but the last half of this story was a miss for me.

This book contains scattered strong profanity and has some descriptive intimate scenes.

While it started out intriguing and with a horrible twist, what follows just sort of drags. I will admit general fiction is not my favorite genre but I DNF’d at 10%

This was such a brilliant book, the characters were deep and complex and hold secrets that change everything for them. It goes deep into many emotional themes that are increadibly realistic. I will say though, that I enjoyed reading the first half of the book more than the second half.

This was not the book for me. I DNF’d at 15%. I was not able to connect with the characters. I will likely give this book another try in the future.

When his first wife and child die unexpectedly, Tom is left to raise the son they had conceived with a surrogate. And then there's a doppelganger and some ghost-perspective narration. The plot was giving Liftetime movie, but the execution was pretty good—it's obvious why Tom is interested his object of desire, but I was sort of wondering what the attraction is re: Tom. Reminded me of Big Little Lies and associated media—fun read, and it'll be a good movie or TV show too.

4.5-5⭐️ I am purposefully omitting a synopsis here as there is virtually no way to share one without spoiling this book. If you notice the publisher’s synopsis - there is next to nothing about the overall plot. I am therefore going to keep my review short, sweet, and to the point.

I really had to parse out my feelings towards this book versus my feelings towards the MMC. I struggled very hard to connect with him and his decisions throughout the entirety of the book. I think the narration itself really amped up my dislike of him, and I would be so curious as to why the author used the narrator she did.

And yet, and yet, I think the quality of the story, the writing, the character development is outstanding, particularly for a debut novel. Hence my very complicated feelings towards this story, and another reason it is becoming a standout to me - it’s clearly lingering in my psyche even days later.

🎧 I chose to do this as an immersive read, utilizing both the physical/ebook and the audiobook, to fully immerse myself in the story. Fiona Button does an outstanding job of bringing this emotionally wrought story to life.

Read if you like:
▪️unique narrators
▪️complex family dramas
▪️thought-provoking stories
▪️dual timelines
▪️emotional reads

‼️ There are quite a few triggers. Please research or DM me prior to reading if you are sensitive to them.

Thank you St. Martin’s Press and Macmillan Audio for the advanced copies.4.5-5⭐️ I am purposefully omitting a synopsis here as there is virtually no way to share one without spoiling this book. If you notice the publisher’s synopsis - there is next to nothing about the overall plot. I am therefore going to keep my review short, sweet, and to the point.

I really had to parse out my feelings towards this book versus my feelings towards the MMC. I struggled very hard to connect with him and his decisions throughout the entirety of the book. I think the narration itself really amped up my dislike of him, and I would be so curious as to why the author used the narrator she did.

And yet, and yet, I think the quality of the story, the writing, the character development is outstanding, particularly for a debut novel. Hence my very complicated feelings towards this story, and another reason it is becoming a standout to me - it’s clearly lingering in my psyche even days later.

Read if you like:
▪️unique narrators
▪️complex family dramas
▪️thought-provoking stories
▪️dual timelines
▪️emotional reads

‼️ There are quite a few triggers. Please research or DM me prior to reading if you are sensitive to them.

Thank you St. Martin’s Press and Macmillan Audio for the advanced copies.