Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Han Kang does not always make life easy for the reader. This book, like Greek Lessons, can be likened to leaping over a number of barriers; as what the story is is revealed in stages. We Do Not Part opens with writer and journalist Kyngha experiencing a nervous breakdown and withdrawing from the world. An old colleague Inseon, one of the few to keep in touch, sends her an urgent summons to hospital where she is immobilised after a serious accident.

Kyungha is dispatched to Inseon’s family home on Jeju Island, now deserted following the accident, on a mission of mercy to feed Inseon’s caged pet bird. Fighting migraines, stomach pains and sub-zero temperatures, this odyssey feels like it’s the central part of the book - as Kyungha has to battle a raging snowstorm and draw on reserves of determination she didn’t know she had.

These two sections however are only the prelude to the final third of the book, which takes place in the snowbound family home, but also in many other places past and present. Inseon materialises - or is imagined - and the two of them go ever deeper both into the snowy world around them and into Inseon’s horrific family story which centres on their suffering and loss during the massacres of Jeju inhabitants that occurred in the late forties. Kang brings the familial and the national, the past and the present, and the natural and human world together in a dazzling mix of remembrance and investigation. From the genesis of snowflakes to their plans for a wooden sculptural tribute nothing is wasted in this tightly-wound exhumation of Korea’s dark past.

There’s no easy resolution offered - the crimes of the past cannot be reconciled or forgiven, only acknowledged. It’s a devastating read.

Was this review helpful?

Han Kang is an author that since I read Human Acts, is an author I have done my best to read everything she has published, and We Do Not Part is another example of why that is the case.

How Kang writes about pain, memory and grief is unmatched - the way she can write about people so intensely is so difficult for me to compare to anyone else. In this book we see the bond between friends examined and tested and written to perfection but also the acts of humans and how trauma effects generations and can run through families and in contrast.

Kyungha tells the story as it unfolds building us a picture of what is happening to her and what she feels from what surrounds her, from the crispiness of snow to the way trees swish in the breeze creating an atmosphere in this book that draws you in. The ominous tone threads its way through the book and builds to an intensity that I feel only this author does so well - it makes for such a haunting read.

Much like Human Acts this tells the story of people and remembering what people are capable of in the worst ways, she communicates this beautifully here once again creating connections between the past and present in the text that allows you to reach a new level of understanding of the text.

We are so lucky to be living at the same time this author is writing, and writing like this has never been more pertinent.

Was this review helpful?

This novel had a certain dream like quality, and I found myself completely gripped. It was fascinating, and often felt quite heavy at times, to learn about a period of South Korea's history that I knew little about. Written wonderfully with striking metaphors and haunting imagery, this is well worth a read.

Many thanks to the author, publisher and Netgalley for providing an ARC of this book in exchange for an unbiased review.

Was this review helpful?

We Do Not Part is recent Nobel Prize winner Han Kang's most recent work. It is a dreamy, wintery and powerful story which shines a light on some tragic parts of South Korea's history.

Kyungha is called to her friend Inseon's hospital bedside after she has been taken to Seoul for an operation following a wood-chopping accident. Inseon asks Kyungha to go to her home on Jeju Island to feed her pet bird who has already been without food and water for several days. As Kyungha arrives a snowstorm hits and her travel to Inseon's home becomes very difficult. Eventually though she arrives and this is where things begin to turn very strange.

As the story flows we begin to understand the history of Inseon's family and their links to massacres on Jeju Island which claimed the lives of more than 30,000 civilians. I confess this had me googling as I knew nothing about this time in history.

We Do Not Part was full of beautiful descriptive language. The landscape and the winter climate were evoked perfectly and you felt immersed in the cold and snow. It was also eerie and very otherworldly once Kyungha makes her way to Inseon's remote home.

While I did enjoy reading this I didn't love it. The second part of the novel does become a bit strange and there is a lot of pondering about whether what is happening is a dream or reality. The historical references also become very explicit and while it is undoubtedly important to highlight the history and massacres it began to read like a history account rather than a novel at times. There was also a lot of symbolism much of which I think went over my head.

I preferred reading the first part but I appreciated learning more about South Korea's past. It also makes me want to read more of Kang's work as I have only read The Vegetarian to date.

Thank you @netgalley and @vikingbooksuk for my #gifted copy. We Do Not Part is out later this month in Australia.

Was this review helpful?

Han Kang’s writing is always beautiful, Human Acts remains my favourite of hers so far but I love how her books make me think and how they teach me about parts of history I’d never even heard of.

As I’m planning to visit Jeju this year, learning about Jeju 4:3 in this book and then reading testimonies of victims is making me think of the place in a whole new way and I’m glad I got to learn about this before going.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Netgalley and the publishers for this advanced reader's copy and the opportunity to this early. Review has been posted on Waterstones and Amazon.

Was this review helpful?

We Do Not Part is an incredibly powerful novel by Han Kang, one that explores the depths of history, loss, and the unbreakable bond of friendship. It tells the story of the Jeju Massacre, an event I was unfamiliar with before reading, yet Han Kang brings it to life in such a way that it feels impossible to ignore. With tenderness and strength, she captures the personal and collective trauma of this dark moment in Korean history.

What really stands out in We Do Not Part is Han Kang’s signature dreamlike style. The novel is filled with moments where reality and memory blur together, giving it a surreal quality that perfectly mirrors the characters’ internal worlds. This not only deepens the emotional impact of the story, but also lets readers experience the haunting effects of trauma in a very personal, almost physical way.

What immediately stood out upon reading was the recurring motif of snow, which captures how the memories of the massacre are frozen in time, shaping Inseon’s life and her mother’s long after the event. The snow symbolises the generational weight of trauma, covering their lives in a way that prevents them from moving forward.

The beauty of this novel lies in how it intertwines history with the personal, showing how the scars of the past can shape who we are, how we love, and how we survive. We Do Not Part isn’t just about remembering a tragic event, but about the healing power of human connection and the way that friendship can offer hope, even in the darkest times. Han Kang’s writing is lyrical and profound, making this book a powerful exploration of both the resilience of the human spirit and the complexities of Korea’s history.

Was this review helpful?

I’ve sat on this review for a while because I always find it hard to talk about books that move me in some profound way. We Do Not Part is the latest offering by Nobel prize winner Han Kang and it’s a heavy book, the kind that presses down on your chest as you read it.

I don’t mean this to put you off – sometimes we have to be haunted by a book in order for our senses and perceptions to be shifted. Great literature isn’t always there to make us feel comfortable and this is a book that will push you - both in the topics it’s exploring and through its surreal writing, where the narrative is not always entirely clear.

But grief, trauma…these aren’t straightforward things. They don’t follow a linear path. It feels right that a book going deep into these issues remains a little bit elusive, slippery, like the ghosts it hides in plain sight.

And there ARE ghosts in these pages. If you know anything about Korea’s history, you’ll see straight away that Kang is moving towards uncovering the terrible fact of it.

In deep winter, Kyungha travels from Seoul to Jeju Island to the home of her friend, Inseon. She’s been hospitalised after an accident, and has asked Kyungha to make sure her pet bird is still alive and fed. But snowstorms thwart her journey and she struggles to reach the house.

This sets the tone for what’s to come: the snow buries both the physical and metaphysical. It buries truth. But it also facilitates dreams, memories, secrets passed down from Inseon’s mother to her daughter about the deeply shocking massacre that happened on the island some 70 years before. It turns out that Inseon has been painstakingly piecing together archival papers and reports to back up these stories.

What’s real and what’s not can be hard to discern but the atmosphere is chilling - not just because of the wintery forest the book is largely set in, but because the facts themselves ARE chilling, and delivered almost with a cold remove. The pain is in what is not said, in the emotions not expressed. To look a trauma of this magnitude in the eye sometimes takes restraint, otherwise hopelessness is sure to follow – we see this in part play out not with Inseon but with Kyungha in an earlier part of the book. And there is poetry in Kang’s images – beautiful, brutal poetry.

This is one to take your time with. The prose demands it anyway, but reading a book like this is a gift from a writer at the top of her game. A gift not just in craft, but in what it can teach us about the ugliest side of humanity and morality.

Was this review helpful?

The book opens up with a chapter about a writer who is struggling with her own writing. Writing a novel about a massacre she is feeling secluded and absorbed by the research she's doing while also wanting to protect her family from it all. I loved this metanarrative, since Han Kang has previously written the novel "Human Acts" and are currently writing this particular one. This chapter is my absolute favourite part of the whole novel. It feels heart-breaking and real and like reading Kang's thoughts.

But this is not just a novel about a writer, this is also a story about her friendship to Inseon, Inseon's strained relationship to her mother, and that mother's struggles with her memories from the terrible massacre on Jeju Island in 1948.

The first chapter, as well as most of the media circling this novel, makes it seem like this novel will be centered around this massacre (similar to how "Human Acts" is constructed, weaving magical realism elements with history) but "We Do Not Part" is not structured in the same way.

The story takes a detour following the main character visiting her friend at the hospital and then trying to reach her friend's home on Jeju Island through a terrible snowstorm. Some might say that this detour is symbolic or that it is all connected but the detour is so long I almost forgot where we were going. Constantly expecting the story to arrive at it's "main" plot point made less appreciative of the journey, and the journey was so long filled with questions and musings, that when we arrived I had almost lost my interest.

I'm not a reader of poetry or magical realism so a lot of the symbolism and meaning around the journey so this structure makes it seem like two different novels to me.

I think the English translation would have benefited from a introduction or note from the author/translator explaining the context of the Jeju Island uprisings. This very much reads as a novel for someone already familiar with the history. I was lucky I had recently read another novel set on Jeju during these events.

For a reader of magical realism, poetry, and who enjoyed her earlier work this will be a wonderful tribute to Korean history.

Was this review helpful?

The book opens up with a chapter about a writer who is struggling with her own writing. Writing a novel about a massacre she is feeling secluded and absorbed by the research she's doing while also wanting to protect her family from it all. I loved this metanarrative, since Han Kang has previously written the novel "Human Acts" and are currently writing this particular one. This chapter is my absolute favourite part of the whole novel. It feels heart-breaking and real and like reading Kang's thoughts.

But this is not just a novel about a writer, this is also a story about her friendship to Inseon, Inseon's strained relationship to her mother, and that mother's struggles with her memories from the terrible massacre on Jeju Island in 1948.

The first chapter, as well as most of the media circling this novel, makes it seem like this novel will be centered around this massacre (similar to how "Human Acts" is constructed, weaving magical realism elements with history) but "We Do Not Part" is not structured in the same way.

The story takes a detour following the main character visiting her friend at the hospital and then trying to reach her friend's home on Jeju Island through a terrible snowstorm. Some might say that this detour is symbolic or that it is all connected but the detour is so long I almost forgot where we were going. Constantly expecting the story to arrive at it's "main" plot point made less appreciative of the journey, and the journey was so long filled with questions and musings, that when we arrived I had almost lost my interest.

I'm not a reader of poetry or magical realism so a lot of the symbolism and meaning around the journey so this structure makes it seem like two different novels to me.

For a reader of magical realism, poetry, and who enjoyed her earlier work this will be a wonderful tribute to Korean history.

Was this review helpful?

Like freshly fallen snow that becomes an avalanche

In spare and precise prose, the novel is a mosaic of stories, dreams and impressions, nothing ever quite what it is and nothing ever fully in sight. Set in a winter snowstorm on the southern island of Jeju, Kyungha is far from her own comforts, and her comfort zone itself a distant memory. In an unfamiliar place, her friend Inseon’s house, where Kyungha has pledged to look after Inseon’s budgie, Kyungha is met with ghosts of her own trauma and of a historical trauma, the massacre of 30,000 civilians as part of the lead up to the Korean War.

Like snowflakes settling, each piece of the novel lands to build a eulogy and a reckoning with history, and for Kyungha, breakdown and catharsis. Always wary of her incipient migraines, Kyungha is a classic Han narrator, unreliable even when narrating to herself, and threatened from all sides, but making her way regardless, her human spirit unconsciously undaunted in direct contradiction to her spoken desires.

This is, in short, a masterpiece, and evidence of why Han is a Nobel laureate. If I could, I would give this six stars.

Six stars, rounded down to five.

Was this review helpful?

Trance-like, emotional, tip-toeing the line between dreams and reality. This book was the winner of the Nobel Prize in Literature, and I would say that this is very appropriate given the way Han Kang encourages us to look unflinchingly, document and remember the darkness of our shared experiences, histories and the frailty of human life. Despite the heaviness, I still found this book to be optimistic, exploring themes of friendship and resilience. Admittedly, I was not aware of the Jeju 4.3 incident that the novel draws upon and so found these indirect themes of censorship and obfuscation of truth especially interesting. Having read Human Acts and The Vegetarian, I can see connections between her novels, but I think We Do Not Part is as good a place as any to start - maybe even the best yet! Dreamy, poetic and emotional prose. Expertly crafted, beautifully written, important reading. "Can the present help the past? Can the living save the dead?"

Was this review helpful?

We Do Not Part is another excellent example of how Han Kang's writing reaches to the depths of hidden emotions and traumas and pulls them out for us to look at and reflect on. This is a book that touches on the Jeju Massacre in the middle of the 20th century, but is set decades after. It unflinchingly portrays the impact that violence and trauma has on a community, without ever glamorising violence or trying to get you to feel any particular way about it - it is less about the author trying to tell you how to feel and think than it is a piece of art that finds value in itself. This is something I love about Han Kang's writing in general - she writes things in a way that could be perceived as political, and in a sense IS political, yet she does so in a way that is so quintessentially novelistic, so human-centered, that it tells you the story of human acts rather than the straight-up analysis of those acts. That is not to say that you don't feel moved when reading about the main character's friend and her family's struggles under a violent regime! The empathy you feel reading this feels very authentic, as it's not based on your reaction to the stark facts of a brutal event in history, and it's not based on your preconceived notions of how you SHOULD feel about this event, but a direct reaction to the events you are reading about through the eyes of the fictional characters.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Han Kang and NetGalley for this ARC!!

I’ve been an avid fan of Kang’s work for a few years now, each book I read of hers is both devastating and beautiful in equal measure and this book was no different. It reminded me very much of “DD’s Umbrella” by Hwang Jungeon, a perspective on a national tragedy that manages to encompass the emotions and experience of Korean citizens on both a deeply personal and national level. The prose was gorgeously written and poetic, as Kang’s usually is, but it has left me feeling a bit haunted.

Was this review helpful?

I went into this not knowing what it was about based on how much I enjoyed The Vegetarian. This book was much darker than anything I was expecting and was about a period of history I knew nothing about prior to this book.

It was haunting, and the writing style chosen helped to capture that, especially with the continuous use of snow. It was also interesting to see snow being written this way, when it’s normally used for beauty.

It’s told in a slow, sometimes dreamlike way, to blend past and present and to talk about the way trauma still affects them. It was also about love, and a lot of what was written here will stay with me for a very long time.

Thank you to Netgalley and publishers for the eArc

Was this review helpful?

We Do Not Part is a beautifully haunting exploration of grief, memory, and human connection. Han Kang’s prose is delicate yet deeply affecting, weaving together fragmented narratives that blur the line between reality and dream. Her writing lingers like an echo, soft but impossible to ignore. This is not a story of resolution, but of absence and the ways love and loss become inseparable. Poetic, meditative, and quietly devastating, We Do Not Part is another stunning work from one of the most powerful literary voices of our time.

Was this review helpful?

Han Kang's book showcases her remarkable writing talent and presents a unique voice that sets it apart from her earlier works. Through vivid imagery and delicate metaphors, she captures the sorrow experienced by survivors, their descendants, and those who have passed away. The narratives emerge from the shadows, shedding light on the profound effects of government censorship. In this context, the resistance to forgetting evolves into an act of love and duty towards the living. This book is a brilliant read for anyone who appreciates it Kang's work.

Was this review helpful?

The novel opens with a haunting scene that the narrator wonders is a graveyard. It is ambiguous and yet the voice tells us that she is seeing nightmares of a massacre in a place referenced as G ––, which is the topic of the protagonist Kyungha's published book. She recalls "sparse snow" and "black tree trunks jutt[ing] from the earth ... like a crowd of people" which may bring images of WWI trenches to mind, but this is a shoreline with the sea "crashing in". At odds with the snow, what also comes to mind in reading "the thicket of black trees" and "rising water", is the eeriness of places like the Atchafalaya River Basin Swamp between Texas and Louisiana, which does weirdly correspond since flashback scenes are from a subtropical summer in Seoul, when the reader hears stark descriptions of humidity and heat.

Han Kang welcomes the reader with dreamy visions of the forests of Jeju island that surround Kyungha who is called to her old friend Inseon's hospital bedside in Seoul with the message "Can you come right away?" This is only the starting point for her journey.

The relationship between Kyungha-ya and Inseon-ah, is a powerful one. The narrator's conveyal of her connection to Inseon as a fellow artist, in their work together for a magazine, her understanding and the appreciation of Inseon's mother's tragic illness, is smoothly embedded into Kyungha's growing concern about what accident might have befallen her friend and why she is needed to travel to Jeju island for her friend.

Inseon's incident is a gruesome one. The way she explains it to Kyungha from her hospital bed is beautifully explicit and will draw visceral images directly to you. Squeamish readers, watch out!

However, the information conveyed through the story about amputated limbs, the (phantom) pain, the debate about choices, the aftercare, and the intricacies of reconstructive surgery for detached limbs is utterly absorbing. I loved it.

And then there's the snow, which will play with your mind; with its pure whiteness and ability to transpose emotions from one place to another, and one mood to another.

"The strangest thing, snow, Inseon said in a whisper I could barely hear."

And the collaborative photography project the two girls plan and prepare is Han Kang's fascinating tool for bringing together her story threads. In fact the structure and intermittent sections of the narrative that fit with the theme of photography are also brilliant, working to keep the reader right there with Inseon the patient and her friend Kyungha.

Inseon's delicate white bird left at home and in need of Kyungha's care opens up another swathe of thought related to how we think about protecting others, the hidden tragedies that can occur during wars and similar regimes that documented history can forget and have forgotten, as well as the fragility that comes before death.

"You have to keep an eye on them even when they look fine./Birds will pretend like nothing's wrong, no matter how much pain they're in. They instinctively endure and hide pain to avoid being targeted by predators. By the time they fall off their perch, it's too late."

Many thanks to NetGalley and Hogarth.
@francisgilbert_bookclub

#readabitofeverything #hankang #wedonotpart #worksintranslation #workintranslation #southkoreanauthors #nobelprizewinner #eyaewon #paigeaniyahmorris #birdimagery #snowimagery #friendshipinliterature #humanmind #dreamscapes

Was this review helpful?

Having read and been moved by The Vegetarian I couldn't wait to read this book. I was not disappointed.. It is so emotional yet tranquil in its telling. Reading descriptions of snow falling is akin to meditating,Unbelievable. The grit of the story for me was the telling of the Jeju massacre and its profound effect on Inseon and her family Their are so many themes within this story about friendship,loyalty,resilience and above all love. An incredible book

Was this review helpful?

Now don't think that I remembered this term without having to Google it, but We Do Not Part reminded me of some theories that Eastern Asian storytelling follows different structures than Western. Specifically Kishōtenketsu, describes a style of progress that replaces rising tension and eventual resolution with a sort of 'forever tension' stories that don't fall neatly into place but more capture or explore ongoing tensions.

Which is a way to introduce We Do Not Part as a strange (but not in a bad way) sort of story. The narration is really quite different, while our MC does go through some extreme, even borderline comical but deadly situations, Inseon's character is who we really explore. It creates quite a strange effect in reading and I have to confess that I incorrectly guessed that this book was going to have a Sixth Sense type twist because our MC seems so strangely absent and ghostlike in development that I thought they might indeed be a sort of poltergeist.

Other than my own mistakes, the one thing that stands out about this book is the vivid writing. I love snowy wintery settings and the prose on the pages of this book practically dragged me into the scenes, I love writing like this and even though there might not have been a classic plot for this story there is no doubt every scene will sit with you for some time.

Thanks to Netgalley for this advance copy

Was this review helpful?