😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
wow. what an incredible book to begin the year with. i haven’t felt this way about a romance book in such a long time. i was completely sucked into the story and felt like i was living through it. i fell in love with Melody and Parker’s characters. Melody loses her husband in a tragic car accident as he’s going to save her purse from a thief. He is an organ donor and his heart is used to save another life. Melody begs the doctor to give her the recipients email to contact them. The book begins with her finally reaching out to this email months after Charlie passed away. You then see Melody visit this support group for grieving individuals which is where she meets Parker. Parker is completely closed off, empty and bordering ignorant. He doesn’t participate with the conversations and doesn’t make eye contact with anyone. Melody being her sweet sunshine self tried to talk to him to no avail. Their ‘relationship’ slowly builds and he ends up fixing a leaky pipe in her house. Melody continues to talk to the recipient of her late husband’s heart who has the user ‘Zephyr79’.
SPOILER WARNING‼️⚠️‼️⚠️
They befriend a girl called Amelia in the support group who struggles with an emotionally abusive mother and self harm. Later on in the story she does commit suicide and it is heartbreaking how Melody and Parker find out through finding her hamster Nutmeg at Melody’s door with a note. The note broke my heart. - ‘We’re storytellers you and me,
my story has come to an end, but yours is just beginning.
i know you’ll take good care of Nutmeg.
She doesn’t like her booties, but she loves the sun
- Amelia
Melody’s nickname was the sun.
Amelia quotes//

‘i’m glad you got your happy ending’

When Parker calls Amelia her name and not Emo Chick 😭

She always says her starting point is her hamster Nutmeg - they always say their starting point at the beginning of each session. Which is what keeps them going.

‘a smile beams to life ‘you remembered.’ ‘it’s nice when your words stick with people. it feels good to be heard. to be seen.’

//

Melody eventually sleeps with Parker after mixed signals and he rushes off and leaves her in the rain outside her house. She doesn’t know what to do so messaged Zephyr asking to video chat. He is apprehensive so she suggested him leaving his camera off and she will just put hers on. This is the moment he realizes she is ‘Magnolia’ (her user) and also Melody. We come to realise Parker lied about being the recipient of her husband’s heart. Parker’s sister Bree was the doctor who worked on Charlie that night. Melody was hysterical and begged Bree for the details of the heart recipient. Bree couldn’t break code and give out anonymous details so gave the email of her brother; she knew he was struggling with his own demons and could use someone to talk to and figured they could both help eachother.
Melody finds this out and needs space. Next minute she gets a call from Leah her best friend and she says Parker is hanging off of a bridge. We later find out he is trying to coax a suicidal guy down - who we find out is the guy who killed Charlie. He was in financial need so his brother convinced him to be his driver as he robbed Melody of her purse, later accidently driving into Charlie. The guy we find out is called Milo falls from the bridge after turning towards Parker and her told Parker he can’t swim. Parker jumps in after him and Melody is wrecked with the feeling that she is reliving her parters death over again. She faints and wakes up in hospital where Bree has some news. They had to do a blood test on her and they found out she is around 8 weeks pregnant. After Parker wakes up and Melody is cleared to see him, they go home but Parker feels like a complete failure as the Guy from the bridge passed away. Melody then tells Parker she is pregnant once they’re home and that she loves him and forgives him. They have a baby girl named August Amelia - August being Melody’s favourite month and Amelia after their late friend from the support group. I love this meaningful name and how they say she is their little story teller as an ode to Amelia. Amelia’s hamster Nutmeg is August’s pet. The epilogue had me so sad but i loved the extra ending with Melody taking over Ms Katherine’s support group and having her own bakery etc. It was lovely to just feel that closure and not be left with questions. I felt like the story was truly finished.


We also learn about Ms Katherine and the significance of the journal she always clutches throughout their sessions. It was a gift from one of her students when she was a primary teacher. A little boy who she cared for who later committed suicide. She holds it every time and Melody asks what is in it and it is a book of her Starting points / which are the groups starting points. Melody reluctantly looks at Parker’s page expecting it to be empty as at that time they were hot and cold and his page was a drawing of Melody😭 She was his starting point…

5/5 stars. Jennifer Hartmann writes deep, emotional, angsty romances like no other! This one is not quite my fave from her (I fear Still Beating cannot be beat) but ranks high up there! Go in blind and enjoy the ride!

Jennifer Hartmann will always have you clutching your heart and gasping for air because you sobbed so much, you’re not sure if you’re ever gonna be okay. Dramatic, much? Yes, I know. But this book is emotional and heartfelt and Hartmann’s writing is truly a punch to the gut because how else can one pull those deep-felt emotions from my soul?! Another beautiful, tragic, and deep romance from the queen of angst!

The Wrong Heart by Jennifer Hartmann, was such an emotional rollercoaster - I loved this book and couldn't put it down after the first few pages. The themes of loss, grief, recovery and healing, and ultimately hope were very thoughtfully crafted and this is certainly a story I won't forget in a hurry. The writing is deeply evocative, with moments that feel raw and visceral, tugging at the reader’s emotions. The heavy themes of grief and self-discovery are balanced with tender moments of love and hope. Thank you to NetGalley and the publishers for this ARC.

Another book, another heartbreak.

When I picked the wrong heart, I did not notice it's the same author as of [book:Catch the Sun|204125964] and being a doc and have already read blurb I was like ," oh come on." Heart is basically muscle, you can not look for a connection through that but I'm emotional wreck. Even now it wouldn't make any sense to me but this brilliant heartbreaking story made me feel much more than just sense.

Melody is infuriating and so is Parker but I loved them even with their flaws and idiocy and whatever they did throughout the book. There are definitely points where I just went ,"are you dumb?" But seriously I just can't breathe. This book was unexpectedly beautiful. And once I realised that the author is same I knew that I wasn't mistaken and it indeed was a brilliant book. I was mesmerized by catch the sun but I'm not sure now which one I liked more.

It left me bereft, I understand why epilogue did not work for many but I do understand author's reasons for the epilogue and I feel that even though it was not really necessary, it was good for me to get a disconnect from the characters. Otherwise I would have brooded about them for few weeks.


Like a friend of mine said, all my thoughts were centred around the book and characters and I wanted to shift my reality into this world. The more I think about it, the more I feel closer to characters and I thought that this really was as close to the emotions I could get without being destroyed myself.

If I don't get HEA, I will probably never recover from this.

If you are into well written, sad tragic romances this book is worth all your time and more.

Anything Jennifer writes is always a HIT right to the heart. Loved this can't say it loud enough! Her writing sucks you in and won't let you put it down. Like did I cry? Of course. Thank you so much for this ARC. Ya'll don't want to miss this one!

Spicy, male female, 1st person dual point of view, contemporary romance. Lots of sadness and lots of love. This book was an emotional roller coaster. The short epilogue seems to have upset a lot of people, but I didnt mind it. It was a quick way to show they lived a long happy life together.

Wow just wow wow wow I’m as already crying page 4 crying midway crying 2/3 way ahh but also I felt such JOY for these characters- the way she intertwined grief with love and pain and joy is amazing. And working through it all unfolding in a very real way, I just loved this book so much (clearly) and I have loved everything by Jennifer. Can’t wait to shout about it (4.5 stars)

3.5/5 I love me a good, complicated romance, but the MMC Parker is just absolutely insufferable at times. The start of this relationship was just way too unhealthy, way too codependent. The ending was enjoyable, however I wish there were more to that part of the story, and I absolutely loved the epilogue, which is set much later in life. Jennifer Hartmann’s writing is well done and fluent; I always enjoy it!

I requested this book because I have loved most of the Jennifer Hartmann books I’ve read. Unfortunately, I could not get into this one. Parker was one giant red flag and I found myself yelling (in my head) at Melody that this guy is treating her like garbage. Did not believe in this love story.

I have been seeing this author all over my For You Page on TikTok and I’m as I haven’t started in her catalog sooner. Such a great story and I can’t wait to read more.

This story brought so many tears to my eyes while reading. I don't know how Jennifer does it, but she just wrecks you in the best ways. It's such an impactful read that will stay with you and one that you'll find yourself wanting to re-read again.

Thank you NetGalley for the eARC in exchange for an honest review!

4.5⭐️

Melody loses her husband in a tragic accident and then finds herself falling for the man who received his heart via transplant.

You know that when you’re reading a story and your jaw literally drops, it’s going to be a good one. Parker’s character was so multi-layered and Melody’s patience and understanding with him was honestly angelic. His character takes a while to grow, but the pacing of it felt very realistic. I love that he was so opposite from her husband, Charlie. She needed both of them in different parts of her life as things changed for her! I also fell in love with the side characters in this story I.E. Amelia, Bree, and Owen.

A real tearjerker - as all Jennifer Hartmann books are!

I first read The Wrong Heart in 2021 as an indie published book. Below is my review that I had posted.
The Wrong Heart has stood the test of time. It is just as emotional and touching as it was the first time I read it. I am so thrilled that it will be traditionally published so that more readers will be able to experience the beautifully written story of Parker and Melody. Happy reading!

"All broken things can be fixed. The hard part is deciding that they're worth fixing."

Wow! Just wow! A complicated, beautiful love story.
Jennifer Hartmann is a new-to-me author and I am so glad I took a chance on her! Chapter one starts out emotional, intense and raw. I was consumed! The story flows and flows. There are several twists that had my jaw dropping.

"You don't look like you belong here." "I don't?" "No.
You remind me of sunshine... it's too cold for you here."

I wish I had the words to adequately describe my love for The Wrong Heart. Melody is a force to be reckoned with! Her heart is pure and beautiful. Her smile is everything. Her perception and patience is never-ending. And Parker, my sweet Parker! A bully. So raw. So dark. Their journey will have you turning the pages faster to see where it will end!

"People smile too much. I never understood it. Smiles should be saved for things that bring us real joy, and we give them away so easily, so carelessly. To strangers on the street—to people we don't even like."

I can't wait for more from Jennifer Hartmann!

This was such a great story to end 2024! I know Jennifer Hartmann will always deliver, but wow I was not expecting all of that!

I loved the angst that came with this story. Melody and Parker are meant for each other, even if it didn’t seem like a good fit at first. Each character had so much depth and were actively working to overcome some dark moments of their past but it was also so heartwarming and sweet at times.

I need to give both these main characters hugs.

The Wrong Heart is a deeply moving novel about two broken people, one of them has loved and lost and the other one has never learned to love at all. The beginning of the book is written really well and it was so heartbreaking to read. However, I thought that the book was a bit too long and lost its strong hold over me at times. A beautiful story with beautifully complex characters - and a couple of wonderfully surprising plot twists! - but something was missing.

And then there's the epilogue. I have to say that that was the final straw for a three-star rating, not four. While I can understand the author's reasons for finishing the book like that I personally felt it was unnecessary.

However, the cover is absolutely gorgeous!

✨Book Review✨

@author.jenniferhartmann has become one of my favorite authors! Her books are tragically beautiful and heartfelt. Right off the bat this book had me tearing up. After Melody's husband passes she contacts the recipient of his heart.

I fell in love with all of the characters. Parker's development was 🤌🏻 I really enjoyed the dual POV. I was immersed in this story. Some parts were gut wrenching but so worth it. I absolutely recommend if you're looking for an emotional read!

Thank you Jennifer, @read_bloom , and @netgalley for the gifted ebook.

I swear if Jennifer Hartman writes it, I will read it. She brings romance, drama, tension, banter, amazing plot lines, but she still gets in that spice that everybody wants. This story I think broke my heart a little bit more because my husband has issues that he is not an overly sexual person or touchy-feely kind of person. PDA is not his thing so I related to this book a lot more than I do most of her other ones.

This book was an incredibly heartfelt journey! The ending had me incredibly emotional. These were two incredibly complex characters that Jennifer crafted. Definitely check your trigger warnings before starting this book!

I've had my eye on this author's books for ages, but I confess I'd never come across this one before I found it here, on NetGalley. This book really deserved a new image because in terms of content it's already at the top of its game, now it just has a cover to match it. A very heavy read, but in the best possible sense, emotional and impactful, not easy at times. The author plays so well with emotions that even knowing in advance the moment that opens this story, the death of Melody's (FMC) husband mentioned in the synopsis, I was completely overwhelmed by sadness. I tried to prepare myself, but I wasn't at all ready to feel it so intensely. This event is not just referred to as something from the past, but experienced by the character, making the reader have to experience it too. We feel everything with Melody, which makes it easy to bond with the character; it's impossible to remain indifferent. And how I loved this character and her evolution. I suffered, cried and laughed, healed and overcame with her! With Parker, the process wasn't so "insta-love", so to speak. It ended up being more gradual, I liked him more and more as he revealed himself, as he showed another side beyond the stone barrier, as he connected with Melody and the world. Melody and Parker as a couple make so much sense when all the pieces come together, the evolution of their relationship was so atypical, but also natural and enjoyable even with all the angst involved. This is a true character driven book but one with a perfect touch of something beyond that, with some amazing plot twists that caught me completely off guard and cemented this as one of my favorite reads of 2024!
A perfect ending to a perfect read, the best “happily ever after” and the way its importance is amplified considering how it all began. A story that will always stay with me, complex and well-developed characters, captivating writing that makes you immerse yourself in this read and experience all the emotions in such a vivid way that you feel part of the story of these two!

Plot & World 5⭐
Characters 5⭐
Enjoyment 5⭐
Writting 5⭐

Overall 5⭐