Member Reviews

Thank you to NetGalley and Page Street Publishing for the e-ARC of Liar’s Kingdom!
4 / 5 ⭐

TWs: abuse, death, animal death

A truly enjoyable Cinderella retelling with a few significant twists. I did figure out most of the surprises before their reveals, but I’m not in a competition against authors, racing to see if I can unravel their work before they can complete it; surprised or not, I found the story to be engaging, approachable, and witty.

Was this review helpful?

Christine Calella’s Liar’s Kingdom breathes fresh air into the well-trodden Cinderella trope with a clever twist, compelling characters, and a world brimming with intrigue. This retelling flips the narrative we all know, placing a sharp-witted, morally ambiguous heroine at its heart.

Ell is a protagonist you can’t help but root for—not because she’s perfect, but because she’s relatable in her imperfections. Her decision to deceive Prince Bayard is both desperate and pragmatic, setting the tone for a story steeped in high-stakes deception. The fact that Bayard struggles with facial recognition is a unique and fascinating twist, not only serving as a clever plot device but also adding depth to his character. His naivety contrasts sharply with Maxim, whose sharp intellect and suspicion make him a tantalizing foil to Ell.

The setting of the royal palace—complete with missing princesses, political tension, and impending war with the fae—provides a rich backdrop for the story’s many twists and turns. Calella does an excellent job balancing the personal stakes of Ell’s deception with the larger stakes of the kingdom’s future. The pacing is tight, and the stakes feel ever-present, whether Ell is navigating royal politics, trying to uncover the truth about the missing princess, or outwitting Maxim.

Maxim deserves a special mention. As Bayard’s best friend and a man who’s suspicious of Ell from the start, he’s both an antagonist and a potential romantic interest. Their tense interactions crackle with chemistry, and his role adds an extra layer of tension to the narrative.

That said, there are moments where the world-building, particularly regarding the fae conflict, feels underdeveloped. The book’s focus on Ell’s personal journey sometimes overshadows the larger, kingdom-wide stakes, leaving some questions unanswered. Additionally, while the resolution is satisfying, it’s a little rushed, especially considering the intricacies of the plot leading up to it.

Still, Liar’s Kingdom is a delightful read that combines intrigue, romance, and wit. It’s a story about finding agency, even in a world built on lies, and it’s impossible not to cheer for Ell as she carves out a place for herself in a kingdom of secrets.

Was this review helpful?

I have never been a big fan of Cinderella, that has always been more up my mothers alley. However #LiarsKingdom by #ChristineCalella is an absolutely magnificent retelling of Cinderella.

Ellain has lived with her stepmother and stepsisters for years now being mistreated by them but one day her life takes a sharp turn. She finds herself lying to a sweet Prince named Baynard claiming to be the girl he danced the night away with at the ball, all because the glass slipper fits her absurdely small foot. His best friend however doesn't seem to buy it for a moment that she is the girl from the ball but Maxim finds himself in a position that he can't tell Baynard what he knows.

Elle finds herself at the mercy of her many towering lies with Maxim always lurking trying to find ways to expose the truth about her without getting himself caught as well.

Witth the King rallying troops to fight the fae that he claims are killing his people he sees an advantage in Ellain afterall she has a fairy godmother that she can call upon and set his plan into motion. Fae though are tricky creatures who use word play to their advantage. Soon all of them find themselves in a precarious position as a wronged Fae begins making deals to bring about the downfall of the kingdom that Elle has fallen so in love with.

When a Fae answers your call playing along with your lies its best to be aware, never forget that sometimes a viper waits in the darkness for a chance to strike and sometimes a slipper can make a glorious weapon.

I adored #Liar'sKingdom and plan on adding it to my collection of fairytale retellings as it has quickly become one of my favorites. I want to thank #Netgalley for the chance to read #Liar'sKingdom by #ChristineCalella in return for a fair and honest review.

Was this review helpful?

I was given this book by Netgalley in exchange for an honest review. There was a lot going on with this book. It was fast paced and a wild ride. The only issues I really had was the fairy kingdom part. And what was Max owed. I don't know if it was mentioned. I certainly didn't notice. So, there were a few holes for me but I did enjoy the story a lot overall. I loved the building relationships.

Was this review helpful?

A creative and unique Cinderella retelling with some wild twists and some dark feels. Cinderella didn’t make it to the ball, but all the elements of the traditional story show up in different ways. You get a kind, Cinnamon roll Prince with a disapproving and disappointed father.
I love Elle and how protective she is over her Prince and the kingdom. She’s a very determined and brave FMC. I would have liked to have had more time spent with the Prince in the story and more of a romance. The actual romance in this story is unexpected and a quick little side plot at the end.

4⭐️ 🫑 (no spice, some light swoon moments)

Was this review helpful?

💜*Thank you to NetGalley, Page Street Publishing | Page Street YA and @tbrbeyondtours, for including me to the
"Love On Paper", book tour. For the tour schedule go to https://tbrandbeyondtours.com

This was a refreshing retelling. Cinderella meets Ella enchanted in this fabulous YA novel with enemies to lovers and the occasional twist to throw you under the couch-- in the good sense. A freshly prose, with a pinch of sugar this witty retelling will swing you off into a land full of mischief. I HIGHLY suggest you read that book and I can't wait to read more from Christine Calella.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to TBR Beyond Tours and the author for an e-copy of the novel and including me on this tour! Here are my thoughts.

The story begins and we’ve heard it many times before. The prince comes and places the perfect fitting glass-slipper on Ell’s foot, finding his true love. Except there is one little problem, Ell was never at the ball, so she can’t be the prince’s true love. Ell decides to play along anyway to escape her evil family, only to learn the kingdom is in dire danger and the pressures on royalty are much more than she expected.

Retellings are so fun. I love when an author has the crazy “what-if” thoughts and rolls with them. Retelling fairytales in particular hits that nostalgia feel but provides a new story too. Liar’s Kingdom provided a well thought out entertaining read with tons of fantastic characters. As is the usual with me, it was some of the supporting characters that made me excited to get back to reading this one!

The plot was filled with unique magic and some stressful dynamics and situations. And what fairy tale is complete without some sort of love story, in this case, a love triangle, but with a little more unexpected characters thrown in the mix.

Liar’s Kingdom is a great novel to curl up with this winter. It’s cozy, lighthearted and fun with lots of high stakes!

Was this review helpful?

2.5 ⭐️ ARC Review: Wanted to give this one a fair chance, since it was an ARC, but I was ultimately super disappointed. I even read the whole dang thing but should have DNF’d it.

There are a couple positives though. There are funny moments. The twist was so different to the original but it still felt like the original story. I liked the reconciliation between the sisters. Bayard and Trude were such sweet characters. Buuuut that’s about all I liked.

The romance? Non-existent. The love Maxim has for her came out of nowhere and made no sense. Yes he tries to protect her and whatever but like what? I didn’t even like either of the main characters so that didn’t help.

The plot? Also non-existent. I felt like there was no point to this story at all.

Now. The fact of the cheating. Yes the married couple do not love each other, in fact they both love other people, but that’s just it. They are married. Maybe if they waited to kiss their actual true loves till the end. But that didn’t happen sooooo. No.

That ending also wrapped up so quickly and weird. This book was all around bizarre and I didn’t like it.


*Thank you to NetGalley, Christine Calella, and Page Street Publishing, for the complimentary copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

𝙬𝙝𝙖𝙩 𝙩𝙤 𝙚𝙭𝙥𝙚𝙘𝙩:
🧚🏻‍♀️ ya fantasy
🧚🏻‍♀️ mistaken identity (on purpose)
🧚🏻‍♀️ enemies(ish) to lovers
🧚🏻‍♀️ Cinderella retelling w/a twist
🧚🏻‍♀️ HEA

Length: 384p
Source: ARC - TBR & Beyond, NetGalley, Page Street YA
Release Date: January 14, 2025

•••••••
If you’ve ever seen Ella Enchanted and LOVED it, you’re going to LOVE Liar’s Kingdom. A unique retelling of Cinderella, except the girl saves herself.

Ell is stuck under the roof of her cruel stepfamily. So when a prince shows up with a glass slipper that happens to fit her foot perfectly, she goes along with the ruse that she’s the young woman he danced with at a recent ball so he whisks her away to his castle.

But when she arrives, it’s anything but a happily ever after. Maxim, the prince’s best friend, knows something is off with her and he’s doing everything he can to uncover the truth. Between some ridiculous but fun developments, Maxim and Ell fall hard for each other.

Seriously such a FUN retelling! I love Ella Enchanted because it’s unhinged at parts. SAME VIBES, y’all. I’m obsessed because the entire story made me happy and nostalgic!

{I received a complimentary copy of this book. All reviews are my own.}

Was this review helpful?

Actual Rating: 3.5⭐

An incredibly clever twist brings a refreshing take to a classic fairy tale!

This tale has a lot more darker elements like The Brothers Grimm's version, which might be sensitive to some readers. I highly suggest checking out the content warnings below before diving in.

I thoroughly enjoyed following Ell’s journey from the beginning to the end.
Watching her character grow after enduring so much grief, hatred and cruelty was truly inspiring. She emerged as the bigger person, learning an important lesson in forgiveness.

The friendships she forms with her maid and two other unexpected characters were one of my favorite parts from the story. Initially suspicious, these characters ultimately prove to be allies, adding depth to the story.

However, the romance element left much to be desired. It felt forced and rushed, appearing abruptly in the last few pages.
The story would have been just as strong without this last-minute addition.

Overall, this was fun and fast-paced read that concluded with a satisfying ending for both the human kingdom and the Fae kingdom.
The twists and turns kept me on the edge of my seat, and each unexpected event throughout the story took me by surprise until the final battle!
I would keep an eye out for more books by this author in the future.

Thank you to TBR and Beyond Tour, Netgalley, author and publisher for giving me an e-ARC of the book and for having me on this book tour. I’m leaving this review voluntarily!

⚠️ 𝐓𝐖: death, animal death, animal cruelty, physical abuse

Was this review helpful?

All I knew about this book was that it was a retelling of Cinderella. Most of the time, it’s hard to surprise with a retelling, but this one surprised me! This story took me down a different path, and I had so much fun figuring out where it was going. Just a heads up: there are some dark parts to the story.

Ell is still an orphan and under her stepmother/sister’s thumb. She hates her life and would love to get away. One day, a prince shows up with a glass slipper. There’s no way it would fit anyone, but it fits Ell. She is now living a life of luxury as the next princess. The only problem is that it was not her slipper. She has never met the prince before and is living a lie. It sets her down a path of trying to keep her lie under cover and agonizing over what the right thing to do is.

It was fun seeing how the parts of Cinderella’s original story are in this retelling. I enjoyed how it was so different than the original story. I adored many of the characters. There are times that I think we could have delved into character development. I wanted to know much more about Bayard and Maxim’s past. The relationship between Ell and Bayard was so sweet and caring. I wish we could have had more time with Maxim to get to know him better. The women were the stand-out characters in this story. I don’t want to say too much, but she’s got quite the girl gang.

There are a lot of things that I would have loved to know more about. This could easily have been a couple more books. I do appreciate the standalone story. With that being said, I would have loved to know what happened to certain characters and more about the magical creatures. There’s potential for some great novellas to come out of this story.

Overall, I thought this was a great book! I read through it rather quickly because I had to know what happened next. Some things could have been expanded on, but it didn’t take from my enjoyment. I enjoyed this one and look forward to what Calella writes next!

Many thanks to TBR and Beyond Tours, the publisher and Netgalley for the e-arc. All thoughts and opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

🌈 Rainbow Ratings:
Representation: 7
Atmosphere: 8
Intrigue: 8
Narrative: 8
Build-up: 7
Originality: 8
Wow Factor: 8

This was such a fun retelling- absolutely not what I'd typically expect from a Cinderella story. It was a great experience beginning to end!

Thanks to TBR & Beyond Tour, the author, and Page Street YA for the ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Did not finish book. Stopped at 18%.
This book simply wasn’t drawing me in. To me, the characters didn’t feel like they had depth to them. Maybe it was the first person POV that made it feel that way, but even the MC fell a little flat.

I do enjoy books in first person, and it can be hard to build intrigue surrounding the story, since the author is limited to one person. I think this book would have felt more approachable in third person, especially as it starts to get into the political intrigue of the court and of the fae.

While the premise of the story is to throw the reader into the end of another story (Cinderella), it felt a little too much like I was dangling from a branch in the open air. I wish we could have gotten a prologue, or maybe a bit of context BEFORE the story started (a little fairytale about our MCs history perhaps) to get the reader settled in a bit easier.

Knowing this was an enemies-to-lovers book, I could tell easily where the romance was going, and I didn’t see it becoming very fulfilling.

Was this review helpful?

This is such a fun twist on the classic Cinderella story. Though it starts with some similar elements with Ell suffering as an abused servant to her stepmother and step-sisters, the story actually begins after the ball with the Prince searching for the mysterious woman who disappeared when the clock struck twelve. When Ell tries on the glass slipper and it fits, she readily asserts that she's the woman he's looking for. The problem? Ell, desperate to get away from the abusive life she's living, lied. Suddenly she's whisked away to the castle and betrothed to the prince where she finds herself tangled in royal intrigue as she navigates royal life, a brewing war, and the constant threat of being exposed, especially by Maxim, the prince’s suspicious best friend.

Ell is a clever and resourceful protagonist trying to navigate her new royal life while also trying to stay ahead of the king, the prince, and Maxim, the prince’s suspicious best friend. I love Maxim! He’s frustrating and charming in all the best ways, constantly challenging Ell and making her life difficult, but you can tell there’s more going on with him. Their back-and-forth was easily one of my favorite parts of the book.

I liked how the author worked in classic Cinderella elements while also creating elements that made the story feel completely fresh and new. The world-building—especially the tension with the fae—added some darker, more complex layers to the story as does Ell’s growing awareness of the dangers around her. I feel like the more she learns about the king and his decisions, the more intense the story gets. Bayard’s inability to recognize faces adds another intriguing layer, and I really liked how dynamically developed his character was. Usually, the prince is so one-dimensional in fairy tales, so it was great to see a fully-fleshed out character here.

Overall, I thought this was an entertaining read. The characters and story are intriguing, and the mix of classic Cinderella tropes blended well with the new elements. The pacing is quick, and, though it generally worked, I did wish that some parts were slowed down a bit to let a few of the relationships and conflicts breathe more, especially some of the friendships and the love story. If you're looking for a unique Cinderella story, this is definitely worth checking out.

Thanks to TBR and Beyond Tours for providing me with a copy of the book. All thoughts are my own.

Was this review helpful?

Liars Kingdom

If the shoe fits…

What happens when the glass slipper fits Ell but… she was not the girl at the ball…

A closer Grimm’s Fairytale / Fantasy version of Cinderella retelling? Sign me up!… Literally! Thank you NetGalley for the ARC

Imagine what would happen if Cinderella wasn’t really the girl at the ball & the shoe just fit? Add some fae / fantasy & a bunch of lies and you have Liars Kingdom.

I couldn’t put this one down once I started! I needed to know how Ell’s story would unfold. I really enjoyed the characters and the magic of it all.

Was this review helpful?

This was a good one! Such an original spin on the classic tale of Cinderella and it made for a really enjoyable read! The ending to this story was spectacular and made me fall in love with this book even more. Adding this to my collection of new favorite retellings for sure.

Thanks to the publisher for sending me a copy.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you Page Street for letting me read an ARC of Liar’s Kingdom! The book was utterly enchanting! The story premise is very clever and unique Cinderella Retelling in which Ell (Ellain) did not go to the ball but lies to better her situation. The fairies were a nice twist to the story, adding intrigue and danger where in the traditional story, the fairy godmother was basically angelic. There’s strong demisexual rep that aids the plot along with themes of forgiveness, love, and loss. I thoroughly enjoyed the book and highly recommend it!

Was this review helpful?

If you are a fan of fairytale retellings check out Liar’s Kingdom by Christine Calella.

This novel gives a unique spin on the classic fairytale.

Ell lives with her evil stepmother & stepsisters - acting as their servant after her stepmother murdered her father when she was 11. Thank goodness she has her rat friends. The Prince and his right hand man are going door to door with a glass slipper to find who the runaway maiden was who stole the prince’s heart at the ball…. Funny enough, even though Ell was never at the ball….the shoe fits her petite foot. Now she must come up with an elaborate story to explain how she wound up there!

This book is ridiculous - I mean that in the kindest way possible. It’s a super quick read and it’s fun, but it just keeps getting crazier and crazier. I also wished that the romance was a bit more satisfying, but it sadly was a let down. However, there is a happy ending and some intricate storytelling that will keep you captivated. I think a younger audience would really enjoy this one!

Thank you so much to NetGalley and Page Street Publishing for the ARC in exchange for my honest feedback. Catch this book when it hits shelves 1/14/25!

Was this review helpful?

A new spin on Cinderella except the girl who fits in the shoe isn't actually the prince's beloved but a girl who has lied her way to the throne... and is dealing with the prince's best friend who is as handsome as he is treacherous! Ell's life has been a living nightmare ever since her stepmother killed her father, she is now forced to suffer physical abuse from her stepmother as well as being the house maid. Ell dreams about escaping, she'll do anything to free herself from this house... and when opportunity presents itself in the form of one Prince Bayard ( who has difficulty recognizing faces) showing up at her door with a glass slipper.... that coincidentally fits Ell perfectly, she's happy to pretend that she's the girl he fell in love with and danced with at the ball... even if she wasn't and his best friend Maxim just knows she is a liar. Ell soon finds herself in a complicated mess as Maxim is doing everything in his power to get her out of the palace yet there are evil fairies, revenge schemes, and a mad king to deal with. Ell's lies are bound to catch up to her but who can she rely on and who can she trust when anyone could be lying as well? This was definitely a unique spin on the classic Cinderella story! It really leans into the morally grey protagonist aspect, however for me it just didn't feel all that well fleshed out or developed. The romance just never really feels there, it kind of just appears out of nowhere. You are suppose to believe Maxim and Ell are in love but it doesn't exactly happen until like 70% into the book and I really don't believe it. The romance just doesn't really make that much sense and isn't fleshed out. Ell was a bit annoying at times and honestly I just wish she either leaned into the more morally grey survivor mode or just committed to something at least. I just didn't find myself loving anyone in this retelling and couldn't really care all that much for the overall story. In the end, while this was a unique retelling of Cinderella, it wasn't for me but I would say if you want a morally grey Cinderella retelling, give this a go, maybe you'll have a better time with it than I did!

Release Date: January 14,2025

Publication/Blog: Ash and Books (ash-and-books.tumblr.com)

*Thanks Netgalley and Page Street Publishing | Page Street YA for sending me an arc in exchange for an honest review*

Was this review helpful?

This was one of the best retellings I have read recently. I went into it completely blind other than knowing that it was a Cinderella retelling and I highly recommend that. I love that it was a retelling that truly told the story in its own way. It was not the typical Cinderella story, and yet there were still aspects of it that were kept true and sprinkled into the story throughout the book. I loved the addition of the fae. I think that it was a really cool addition that added another layer to the tale where it was not just the one fairy godmother, but instead an entire race of fae that was in the kingdom. The only thing is I wish that we had gotten more buildup between Ell and Maxim. I feel like there was some of the romance there but I would have wished for some more moments between them to solidify their connection.

Was this review helpful?