Skip to main content

Member Reviews

I absolutely loved this graphic novel. As someone who grew up Catholic I really connected with the main character Catherine, and I found her story to be intriguing to follow because she was possessed by a demon. The illustrations of this graphic novel are so fun and I loved the demon.

The conflict in this really threw me for a loop because I was not expecting it and it is something I know a lot of people wouldn't be able to get past. The theme throughout the story is forgiveness, both self-forgiveness and grace from others. I loved the side characters in this graphic novel as well, overall I would definitely recommend picking up a physical copy of this issue. I recommend it to all the Catholics and ex-Catholics out there.

Thank you to First Second Books and NetGalley for the opportunity to review a copy of this graphic novel.

Was this review helpful?

This was a phenomenal graphic novel. Our protagonist Catherine—named after the patron saint—struggles to define what it truly means to be good.

In her twenty years of life, she's never skipped mass. She fears that something terrible will happen once she finally does, because every "first" she's ever had has ended terribly.

Despite her crippling guilt, she does miss Sunday mass, instead spending the day with her boyfriend. She's then possessed by what she sees as a demon, who proposes stealing her soul.

I don't know if it's because of how I was raised, but this story packed a punch and I definitely ugly cried towards the end. There was something about it that resonated so deeply with me, and I really saw myself in Catherine.

The art was cute, but also very impressive! I loved how Catherine's demons were portrayed, and all of the religious imagery was beautiful.

Sending a big thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for an ARC in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Saint Catherine is a visual representation of religious guilt and the inner demons we face in all facets of life. Along with pushing against the ideals your parents hold you to. We may not always agree with the way our parents raised us, once we get older it's up to us to decide if it's the way we want to continue with our lives.
I loved the art, the overall story, and the way it brought in the story of Saint Catherine to mirror the story. The cast is loveable, and the characters are loveable. The main character is flawed in a realistic. I sat and read it in a single sitting. Catherine reflects a lot of us and the doubts that we have in life about whether we're good people or on the right path or a path that our parents would be proud of. At the end of the day, it's up to us to get out of our heads and look around at our lives.

Was this review helpful?

Saint Catherine is a very interesting take on catholic guilt, with a literal personification of a demon. The book juxtaposes the whole thing with a very silly, cartoonish art style. A unique book, I wish the art was more detailed but I loved this unique take on a graphic novel.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for my advanced readers copy of Saint Catherine by Anna Meyer.

I know this book has a fantasy element to it, but it was so relatable. From the family dynamics, to relationships, and reader’s own feelings, this book has a five out of five stars for me. Parts of the book were hard to read, because of the intensity of emotions that appears in the reader, however the whole book feels like a big bear hug. What a wonderful and heartwarming read. This book will speak to those who deal with religious guilt and who feel like they aren’t good enough. Saint Catherine is the perfect book for a moment of comfort in dealing with your own personal struggles.

Was this review helpful?

This was a beautiful graphic novel that will engage readers across life experience. The art is well-done and additive, and the story is relatable, empathetic, and relevant.

Was this review helpful?

As someone who was also raised religious and then dropped it, I can relate a lot to this story. It's actually really well done. Dialogue that works almost all the time, with some excellent imagery and a cool "guilt" is the "demon" idea that actually worked well for the story being told. I liked all the characters, as they were all flawed in some way. I also appreciated the realistic ending, and the unsureness of it all, only made it hit more powerful. A little wordy at times, but overall very much enjoyable read.

Was this review helpful?

Saint Catherine is a reflective and dark yet witty and relatable story about religious trauma and guilt and how we view ourselves when we worry too much about if we are good people. The main character was flawed in a believable way, and the cast was charming. Even the demon was darkly endearing.

Was this review helpful?

First off, the artwork in this book is impeccably beautiful. The images that took up entire pages were my favorite. It really added to enhancing the way Catherine was experiencing the world around her, and her facial expressions portrayed the tension and anxiety she was feeling throughout the plot.

As a milennial with some Catholic guilt, many pieces of Catherine's story resonnated with me. She's a kind and gentle person who is struggling to reconcile with growing up and moving past a lot of the parts of her childhood that troubled her. The problem is she can't - and she's confronted with a legitamite demon who follows her around as a manifestation of her anxieties and guilt. Her current life, a boyfriend & living in the city with her new friends whose lives are growing through major changes, is something she deep down struggles to cope with because she can't seperate herself enough of the "Good Catholic Girl" she was "meant" to be. We see her struggle to communicate this with her mother especially.

The demon becomes scarier and scarier, reminding her that there isn't a way out of the guilt or shame she feels and it really affects her to point where her actions become drastic. The reveal was not what I was expecting, but appreciated as a way for her to be able to move on.

A solid story of a young woman who has a hard time dealing with change, guilt, and moving on - beautifully depicted in the images of the pages.

Was this review helpful?

This story was both expected and unexpected. I think there should be more stories that relate back to a person's religious upbringing and potential trauma associated with it. Living in the "Bible belt," this seems very appropriate! The take on the story was neat, and Anna Meyer did not disappoint. I am thankful for the ARC and plan to purchase a copy for my library's collection.

Was this review helpful?

I selected this book from the catalog because I was drawn in by the artstyle and color palette. Saint Catherine follows the story of a young woman wracked with religious guilt, primarily from her mother. She forces herself to Catholic mass every week, despite not feeling a sense of enjoyment from it. I am a Protestant and have no understanding of the ins and outs of Catholicism. My dad was a former Head Deacon and has been Associate Pastor for the last 15 years. I'm not guilted into attending church and I enjoy it for the most part. I like my Sunday School and learning more about the Bible each week. I'm secure in my faith and haven't experienced Catherine's doubts about her belief. The insidious presence that magnified the heroine's guilt was an interesting touch, even if the denouement was a joke. Despite not relating to the protagonist's plight and judging her past decisions, it was a unique graphic novel. I loved the illustrations, even if I can't say the same for the plot. Saint Catherine may resonate for other people, but I'm not in that particular audience. I'm not perfect myself and I'm certainly no saint!

Was this review helpful?

As a former Catholic who loves graphic novels, this felt like it was written especially for me. The illustrations and color palette are fantastic, the feelings of guilt and fear that Catherine navigates are relatable, and all of the characters are charming. Highly recommend this!

Was this review helpful?

Netgalley graciously provided me with an advanced copy of this title in exchange for an honest review.

Aaaah. good old Catholic guilt. Even when you grow up, move away from your parents and embark on your own life, it never quite leaves you. At least, it definitely has not left Catherine who feels like she HAS to keep going to mass (even though she doesn't believe in it) just to make her SUPER Catholic mom happy. When she ditches ONE TIME, she not only starts seeing a demon, but her entire life starts to implode.
The author does some interesting things here. From changing from grayscale in flashbacks to muted oranges in the present to really trippy dream and demon sequences it works well to demonstrate Catherine's confusion and self-hatred. A good case study on breaking free of indoctrination.

Was this review helpful?

The art was so cool and the plot was intriguing. I was disappointed by the ending, though. I wish the demons had been real and not all in her head. That was kind of a let down.

Was this review helpful?

Saint Catherine had such an interesting premise that I'm not sure became fully fleshed out. To think of a graphic novel that discusses a possession of a person sounded so intriguing, but as Meyer moves through the novel, it becomes clear this isn't really a possession. I liked the idea that Catherine was possessed by her guilt and if it had been kept at that, I would've liked it. Unfortunately, Meyer goes on to share that it was a health issue that caused the hallucinations which I felt undid the work done to build up Catherine's depth throughout the book.

Was this review helpful?

I found this to be relatable in so many uncomfortable but important ways. I loved the art style and the way things were represented and the overall composition of the book. The story kind of makes me ache for a different outcome, and also for this shared trauma I have with the author. Another great graphic novel for the collection. I can’t wait to pick this up again.

Was this review helpful?

Beautiful art, a compelling story about dealing with religious guilt, personal trauma, past mistakes, and the very relatable difficulty of keeping one's **** together when things are going off the rails come together to make this a great read.

Was this review helpful?

Saint Catherine is a solid graphic novel. I’m sure the nuances of it went over my head as I’ve never had to deal with catholic guilt or organized religion, but I still found it entertaining and emotionally thoughtful. The characters are easy to love, and I found that was what kept me hooked throughout the story, more so than the plot. The art style compliments the theme of the story well, particularly the emotional scenes.

I was able to read Saint Catherine in one sitting, and I would recommend it to someone who likes light horror and is looking for a short book with themes of forgiving yourself, self-realization, and relationships.

Was this review helpful?

All opinions below are my own. Saint Catherine was immediately hooking for me as we share a name and I love a good story based around overcoming guilt.

Catherine is a Catholic who has never missed mass her entire life, until one day she decides to skip. Everything should be fine, excpet now she's being followed by a demon. Could she really be possessed after missing only one mass? She spends the day traveling around doing her best to exercise this demon from her and learning to let go of guilt.

This story was special to me because I love a good 'burdened-by-guilt' story. The art was fantastic and illustrated the literal and metaphorical demons wonderfully. Anna Meyer did a wonderful job portraying Catherine's past and her future. This story is perfect for anyone who likes a good catholic guilt story, or even just a good stand alone graphic novel.

Thank you to NetGalley for this ARC. Thank you to First Second Books for the chance to read this ARC.

Was this review helpful?

An interesting look into Catherine's life, who has skipped Sunday Mass for the first time and is now being haunted. This is very heavy with religious guilt and trauma. I'm someone who never grew up religious, but I could still really feel and understand what Catherine was going through. The art was really well done, and the story was captivating from beginning to end (even though I never would have guessed that ending)

Was this review helpful?