Skip to main content

Member Reviews

I was SO excited to read this book when I found out it was about the Tudors! Add in some fantasy and sapphic elements, and I was DEVOURING this book at every chance I got! I thought that the magic system in this book was well-thought out, and it was incorporated well into the lore of the wives. I also thought that Race did a good job in creating relationships between the wives that weren't solely based off of competition, which was very refreshing to read about. This book definitely takes creative liberties with Henry VIII and his wives, but I personally enjoyed this reworking of history, and felt that it worked well in creating a more feminist, sapphic retelling of the Tudor wives. Overall, this book delivers on intrigue, magic systems, and sapphic longing.

Was this review helpful?

Six Wild Crowns caught my attention right away with its promise of dragons, dangerous queens, and a magical twist on the wives of Henry VIII. I went in expecting something more tightly bound to its historical inspiration, but the connection is looser than I anticipated—more of a thematic echo than a direct reimagining. Once I adjusted those expectations, I was fully pulled into the world of Elben.

Boleyn and Seymour were standout characters, opposites in personality but equally compelling. Their rivalry-turned-reluctant alliance gave the book its emotional core, and their dynamic was layered with tension, vulnerability, and slow-burning trust. The court politics, magical bonds, and shifting power plays all made for a page-turner, even when the pacing occasionally stumbled or the worldbuilding leaned more decorative than immersive.

There’s a lot packed into this first book, and while not every element felt fully fleshed out, I appreciated how ambitious it was. The ending sets the stage for a much larger conflict, and I’m definitely interested in seeing where the story goes next.

Thank you to NetGalley for the ARC.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Netfalley, and Orbit for this Arc! I received this through Book Huddle for an honest review. I thought this was an interesting take on the story of the wives of Henry the Eight. But it was not for me. The story was not the problem, my issue was with the way it was written, almost like a screenplay instead of a novel. Instead of “Mary placed the crown on her head” it was say “Mary places the crown on her head.” I know this seems knit-picky but I was struggling getting through this book, which sounds made for me since I love all things Tudor. But I couldn’t deal with the way scenes were set.

Was this review helpful?

This was a lot more fantasy and less historical than I expected--for instance, I thought it would be set in Tudor England instead of in a fictional secondary world--but once I adjusted my expectations I had a good time with this one. If a historical-ish fantasy with gorgeous writing and a sapphic subplot sounds like your thing, definitely check this one out!

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the arc! Opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

3.5 stars

The concept of six queens vying for the king’s favor in a court full of dragons and backstabbing is exciting, but the story feels much slower and less action-packed than promised. The historical inspiration of Henry VIII and his six wives initially drew me in, but the characters didn’t have the depth or the personalities of their real-life counterparts. It often felt like the historical tie-ins were more of a marketing tool than a meaningful part of the story, and the connection to the historical figures was largely superficial.

The writing has potential, but there were moments when the emotional arcs felt rushed or unclear. Characters’ feelings seemed to change abruptly, and love was often mentioned but not backed up by strong development. While fear was effectively conveyed, the other emotions and relationships lacked depth.

Additionally, the depiction of Henry VIII as a handsome figure was oddly jarring and made me chuckle. It’s hard to imagine the infamous portly king as a heartthrob based on historical portraits, which created a disconnect in my mind.

Thank you to NetGalley and Little, Brown/Orbit for the ARC.

Was this review helpful?

A blend of Tudor England with hint of a fantasy realm that was interesting to read. Firstly, I think the blurb of this novel is very misleading as the assassins and dragons are very much lacking in this story. Any semblance of a fantasy realm was heavily cast to the wayside more so than I had anticipated.
This book reads more as political intrigue of woman in a male dominated court, whilst also navigating a sapphic yearning from the sidelines. Seymour is an assassin sent by Argon to kill Boleyn, but halts her attack when she notices that she is pregnant. After this, her “assassin” storyline is basically scrapped. She doesn’t act like an assassin whatsoever, and her allegiances flip flop so fast, making her a fickle and flat character.
The yearning is okay, but a bit rushed for my taste, and feels extremely unbelievable from Boleyn’s side. The character of Boleyn that represents Anne Boleyn was fine, and I could see her reacting to things the way that she does in this book—at least with what we know of her. So, I think that the author does an okay job of making me think of the historical figures in their actions and reactions with her. But Henry and the other wives are pretty flat for me, and really lacked the nuance that each of them held.
I didn’t really care for the use of historical figures as the characters in this book. With the fantasy realm, and this book not focusing on Henry and the historical events of his court, it was a strange decision in my eyes that the characters were named and modeled after these historical characters.
I would have liked more if this book was entirely, its own, with its own characters. To me, it felt that the use of the Queens and Henry were shortcuts that the author used so they wouldn’t have to describe the attributes and quirks of these characters. When you say “Boleyn” with the implication of Anne Boleyn, the audience automatically fills in the pieces of her character being cunning, smart, sexual, and jealous—so now the author doesn’t have to introduce the character like this, because we already know her like this. The thing is, Holly Race does a good job describing the characters and their personalities, so I don’t know why she used this shortcut over creating her own world fully. It comes off as a cheap marketing tactic to tack on the name of this historical figures.
I wish we saw more of the fantasy realm and war that Henry is off fighting. I feel as though we were given such a small representation of this world, and for anyone coming in looking for a heavy fantasy world, this book doesn’t hit very well. I would recommend this for someone who is looking more for a sapphic tale of women navigating their way in a court where their husband would kill them for such feelings.
Thank you NetGalley, Orbit Publishing, and Holly Race for the Arc!

Was this review helpful?

Big thanks to netgalley for this eARC!

the blurb for this sounded so up my alley, I love the Tudors usually so I was excited for this magical spin on it and anything with sapphic yearning is a yes for me but it did fall a bit flat for me.

Putting aside my expectations from before starting the book I enjoyed the vibes and the characters despite the pacing being slow to start. the world building is done well and the writing style is easy to follow.
I wanted more action & dragons and the romance fell flat for me.
I'm not 100% invested so I'm not sure I'll continue the series from here.

Was this review helpful?

Huge thank you to Netgalley and Orbit Books for the e-ARC approval!!
I was ecstatic to be approved for a book that instantly went on my TBR when I first saw it up for pre-order on Barnes and Noble's website!

"Six Wild Crowns" by Holly Race

The second I read this synopsis I knew I had to add this to my list. Epic fantasy with dragons, with women dismantling a patriarchy and falling in love in the process? Sign me up! Unfortunately, the actual story fell flat and did not live up to its teaser. The taglines are a stretch and are unfortunately misleading. The first chapter from was so intriguing from Boleyn's point of view drew me in, and then Seymour's immediately gave me the ick (iykyk). The love at first sight element didn't feel organic.

Henry's shift from "the perfect man" to "the villain" was instant and almost comical, I wish it had been hinted at and brought on more gradually. I think the intention was for it to be a plot twist, but it just didn't quite hit.

I also have a hard time getting behind a story that sacrifices any animal, especially one people also keep as pets and "lap dogs".

I think this story had a lot of potential and the author definitely has a unique and pleasing writing style, but the elements and flow of the story just fell a little flat.

I am giving this three stars for creativity, but will not be reviewing this story on any other site. Best of luck to this author in the future!

Was this review helpful?

If you're expecting a story filled with dragons and Seymour as a spy and assassin, based on the synopsis, you might be disappointed. Those elements are barely present. While the premise suggests a lot of action, magic, and scheming, the actual book feels much more subdued.

As this was an advance reader copy, I anticipated some errors. I found four typos within the first six chapters. Hopefully, these will be corrected in the final version, as I didn't notice any more after that.

The concept of drawing inspiration from Henry VIII and his six wives seemed really interesting to me. However, it felt more like a superficial marketing tactic. While the six wives are present, they lack the distinct personalities and characteristics that made their historical counterparts so compelling. As someone who enjoys history, I felt this aspect was underdeveloped. It seems like the Henry VIII connection was primarily used to attract attention, without much depth beyond that.

I also felt that the portrayal of emotions and relationships could be stronger. Characters' feelings often seemed to change abruptly, and I struggled to understand the development of certain close bonds or romantic relationships. The word "love" is used frequently, but without much believable foundation. Fear was the only emotion that felt somewhat well-written, but even that wasn't enough to fully explain the characters' actions.

Finally, the depiction of Henry VIII as handsome was quite jarring. It was hard to reconcile that with the well-known image of him as overweight and wearing tights. It felt like an odd detail to emphasize.

Overall, while the initial idea was promising, the execution fell flat for me. The book didn't deliver on the expectations set by its premise, and I won't be continuing with the series.

Was this review helpful?

An interesting feminist take on Henry VIII and his infamous brides. I appreciate how the author was able to blend fantasy with bits of the known history, while incorporating digestible fiction for smooth storytelling.

Was this review helpful?

One thing I live for is dragons and history reimaginings and this one shot to the top of my list of 'must reads'

This book has been a wild ride and I can't wait for book 2, it really ends in a way that I feel can blossom into a story of Holly's own and the potential is high!

Was this review helpful?

Huge thanks to @netgalley and @orbitbooks_us for the gifted ARC

Six Wild Crowns by Holly Race is the six wives of Henry VIII as you have never seen them before, in a fantasy Tudor era with dragons, intrigue, and yearning.

On the isle of Elben, the king has six queens, each one to live in one of six castles, maintained by the power bestowed upon them by their husband. This is how it has always been, or so the history goes.

Yet, folk tales tell of a different history. A dangerous history.

Six Wild Crowns is one of those books where the first line just sucks you in: “Her wedding dress is the colour of the massacre of Pilvreen.”

I didn't make any annotations other than the first line as I hurtled through this book on pure vibes and a hunger to know more.

I love parts of history, especially the Tudor Era and I love reading about the Six Wives. This was an amazing take on the known history, turning it on its head and placing it in a fantasy setting.

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Five stars! I loved reading this. The intrigue, the relationships, the betrayals, all were fantastic to read and all were written beautifully. Breathtaking ending that left me bereft and had me thinking about it long after I finished.

Was this review helpful?

✨ARC Review✨

Title: Six Wild Crowns
Author: Holly Race
Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️

I’ve always been fascinated with Anne Boleyn and her life. This is why when I saw this ARC on NetGalley, I requested it immediately. Thank goodness I was approved because I enjoyed reading this book! I finished it in two days.

Boleyn, Seymour, Howard, Cleves and the other queens were all damaged in their own ways. I found them relatable in a way especially Seymour - wanting to do your duty as a daughter because that’s what you had been taught to do all your life. Her friendship and love for Boleyn were so heartfelt.

Boleyn, meanwhile, was daring and loved her family. I liked the development of the character throughout the story. From her seemingly naive love for Henry, we see her evolve into someone cunning yet caring. I’m glad Holly Race didn’t stray too far from Anne Boleyn’s destiny.

Some things that I think would have wanted to see:
- I wish there were more dragons in the story and that they actually played a role as teased in the book’s blurb.
- Maybe it’s because it is just the first book but it would have been nice to know the other queens more.
- Henry’s true self should have been given more time to be explored. It just seemed very anticlimactic.
- There were scenes that involved magical creatures that seemed to have been glossed over.

Overall, I enjoyed the book. I will read the sequel to find out what happens to the other queens.

Was this review helpful?

“Six Wild Crowns” is a unique twist on the historical narrative of Henry VIII and his six wives, set in a fantastical world. The premise, which combines dragons, political intrigue, and a medieval setting, initially piqued my interest. However, after finishing the novel, I found the story to be more focused on the struggles of two of Henry’s wives, Boleyn and Seymour, within a male-dominated world, with fantasy elements taking a secondary role. While the novel features fairies, dragons, and magic, these aspects are overshadowed by the feminist storyline of empowering these intelligent women. The main disappointment stems from the book’s summary, which suggests a stronger fantasy presence similar to “Game of Thrones,” but this is not the case.

I recommend approaching this book without reading the summary and coming in with preconceived expectations, as it primarily serves as a retelling of historical figures and events. I think I would have much more enjoyed this novel if I went in without a predetermined mindset, as I did enjoy the two main characters and individualistic struggles against a patriarchal society and domineering husband and king.

Thank you to Orbit Books for the ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Six Wild Crows reimagines Tudor history in a world where dragons exist, magic is real, and Henry VIII is married to all six of his wives—simultaneously. Set on a magical island shielded from invasion, the story explores a realm where the king’s power seems to hold everything together. But what if that power doesn’t come from Henry at all? What if it’s the six queens who are the true source of magic? And what if love is found not with the king, but between two of the queens?

Thank you to NetGalley and Orbit for the opportunity to read and review this unique take on Tudor lore. I’m giving it 3.5 stars.

As an Anne Boleyn fan, I particularly enjoyed her character—watching her navigate complex relationships with the other queens and come into her own power was a highlight for me. However, I did wish we got more depth from the other queens. Only Boleyn and Seymour have POV chapters, and I would have loved to see the story through the eyes of the others as well.

Still, this is a compelling read that I think will resonate with fellow Tudor fans and lovers of historical fantasy alike.

Was this review helpful?

“Her wedding dress was the colour of the massacre of Pilvreen.” Ok, Holly Race, you had me completely roped in with just the first sentence.

This book has strong female lead characters, LGBTQ+ rep, and lap dragons, need I say more?? The world was described beautifully and the magic system is quite unique. The book is a bit slow moving for a while, but about half way through it really starts ramping up and the last 10% is absolutely insane! Everything really comes to an explosion of emotions and rage! I cannot wait to see where the story goes after this book, I need it NOW!

Thank you NetGalley and Orbit Books for giving me the opportunity to read an eARC of this book and provide my honest feedback.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley and Orbit Books for providing an advance copy of *Six Wild Crowns* by Holly Race. I was really excited to dive into this one, as the premise had so much potential, but unfortunately, it just didn’t work for me as I had hoped.


While I appreciate the creativity and effort that went into crafting this world, I ultimately found that it didn’t quite capture my attention the way I expected. *Six Wild Crowns* has a lot of promise, and I think fans of intricate fantasy worlds might still find it enjoyable, but for me, it just didn’t hit the mark.

Was this review helpful?

I thought this was very good and I will have to add this to the shop shelves. Thank you for the chance for us to review.

Was this review helpful?

I've gotten a physical arc of this one, which is my preference, so I'll be reviewing it elsewhere when I finish reading!

Was this review helpful?

I have adored so many of Tessa Gratton's books so when I heard about this new one I leapt on it, and I'm so glad I did! This book is pure magic—lush, immersive, and utterly intoxicating. Iriset is a stunningly complex anti-heroine, torn between ambition and vulnerability, confidence and limitation, making her journey feel all the more real!! The magic system is breathtakingly unique, woven seamlessly into a world rich with intimacy and sensuality. Gratton masterfully crafts relationships that pulse with raw emotion, leaving the reader completely enthralled. While the world-building can feel dense at times, it ultimately clicks into place, rewarding those who push through. With its intricate storytelling, stunning representation, and heart-wrenching love stories, this is a book that lingers—and leaves you desperate for more.

Was this review helpful?