Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Heart-pumping, kept me guessing, crazy twist, romantasy! For those who love a romantasy, add this to your tbr pile! It's sexy, fast paced and totally sucks you in.

Was this review helpful?

You know what, I really wanted this to give me all the fourth wing hunger games vibe, It didn’t but that’s because it’s its own book & that’s okay! The dystopian & slow burn was done well in the book & I did like the banter between the characters . It was a fun read & I think I will re read on audio! I do recommend this to my fellow dystopian lovers! Training camp galore!

Was this review helpful?

The comparisons to the Fourth Wing series are certainly apt, but after reading through it, I'd say that Silver Elite stands on its own as a new, exciting romantasy in it's own world. I was intrigued by the moral ambiguity of the idea of altered people, and their somewhat unexplained abilities, and the tension between the altered, and the unaltered. I have to say - I did clock the secret identity of Wolf pretty early on, and that definitely did a lot to lessen the inherent tension between Cross and Wren. Overall, a solid, solid read, and I'm intrigued to see where it goes next.

Was this review helpful?

"Spicy budget Divergent”
Rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐
Spice: 🌶️🌶️.5
Audio performance : 🎧🎧🎧🎧

Series: Silver Elite #1
Series Type: Series
Genre: Fantasy
Sub Genre: Dystopian, Fantasy Romance/Romantasy

Tropes:
- Challenge's
- Enemies with benefits
- Forbidden Magic
- Forced Proximity
- Political intrigue
- Jealousy (him)

Other:
- Fantasy Species: Human magic users
- Format: Audible, Digital ARC
- Plot/Character Driven: Both
- Pacing: Medium
- POV: Single POV
- Narration type: 1st person, Audio - single
- Character gender : F/M
- Narrator names : Amanda Dolan
- Comparison titles: Spicy divergent
- Popular boyfriend comparison: FOUR reincarnated

👨‍👧 CHARACTERS
Okay. Let’s talk Cross for a second. The male lead? I wanted to fall in love, but he just didn’t give enough. I needed more tension, more chaos, more oomph. Like sir, where is your backstory? Where is your pain? Where is your depth?? 😩
BUT the female lead Wren!! Kinda iconic. Kinda annoying. She had moments where I wanted to shake her, but ALSO moments where I was like “YES QUEEN DO THAT.” She wasn’t some clueless little bird waiting for a man to save her, she already had the power, the grit, the sass. Was she perfectly written? No. But she was fun, and I respect that.

🌍 WORLD BUILDING & MAGIC
Let’s be real. This book was not here to serve us Throne of Glass vibes or Fourth Wing level worldbuilding. If you squint hard enough, it gave “Divergent’s messy younger cousin.” 💥 Like… it wanted to be dystopian, but it forgot to actually build the dystopia. The vibes were there, the logic? Not so much. Still, I had a good time pretending.

💖 WHAT I LOVED
This book was like a candy-coated fever dream flirty, fun, and just chaotic enough to keep me flipping pages. We NEED more dystopian books back in the rotation and honestly? This could be the beginning of the dystopian girlie renaissance. Did it change my life? No. Did it give me a cute break from high-stakes fantasy politics? YES. And sometimes, that’s the vibe.

💔 WHAT I DIDN’T LOVE
Okay let’s address the TikTok elephant in the room, the hate was LOUD. I tried to block it out, but once I saw the criticisms, I couldn’t unsee them. 😬 And yeah… some of them weren’t wrong. There was a lot of “where is this going?” energy, especially in the romance. I’m worried about the series keeping its spark. I’m hoping the next book proves me wrong, but for now… I’m cautiously curious.

📝 OVERALL THOUGHTS
This isn’t the next big fantasy romance. It’s not going to be studied by the romantasy gods. But it is a fun, good-paced popcorn read. Think: book slump cure, not book soulmate. If you go in expecting vibes over vision, you’ll probably have a good time. Just keep your expectations slightly lowered and you’ll be fine!

Was this review helpful?

4.5/5

This sucked me in from the very start! It definitely gives Fourth Wing and Quicksilver vibes in the best way. Definitely a must read for romantasy lovers who want a bit of dystopia.

Thank you NetGalley and Random House Worlds for sending this book for review consideration. All opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

It's been a hot minute since I picked up a dystopian novel and an even hotter minute since I enjoyed one. This reminded me of the best parts of the Divergent series, but with a more adult theme. Cross was our Four, and Wren was our Tris. Lots of similarities, but lots of differences too. The found family, even when Wren felt like she was betraying her uncle- this may have been my favorite theme throughout the book.

Needless to say, I enjoyed every minute of it and can't wait for the next one.

Was this review helpful?

this one fell flat for me. i was super excited for it, but i just couldn’t keep myself interested enough to actually keep reading the book. I made it about 25% into it

Was this review helpful?

If you liked the war college and romance of Fourth Wing then you will love this. There are no dragons but there is a lot of telepathy and you might meet a secret agent or two.

# Silver Elite
# 5/24/2025 ~ 5/31/2025
# 5.0 / 5.0

Was this review helpful?

This book had me on the edge of my seat with the constant high stakes. The pacing was done well and at no point did I feel like the plot was dragging. It is an enemies to lovers slow burn with plenty of angst.

Wren, the FMC, must keep her secret abilities under wraps to protect herself from being killed. In addition to learning about her powers I also enjoyed learning about the other characters, with a few unexpected twists throughout. The constant tension between the FMC and MMC as well as fear of discovery kept me on edge throughout. The training program aspect was giving me fourth wing vibes, minus the dragons.

Was this review helpful?

I received an eARC of this book from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.

Honestly I enjoyed this book. I was nervous that it wouldn’t be good based on what I had been hearing on TikTok but I enjoyed it. There were parts that are predictable as they usually are with most romantasy but there was a twist that I didn’t expect. The biggest annoyance I had with this book is that the cursing was just weird. I can see how that might be construed as AI but I feel like it could also just be the author trying to make it seem like a post modern world where god was taken out of everything including cursing. Hellfuck was weird though and distracted me from the story a bit every time I read it. Otherwise I feel like this book is right up there with other popular romantasy books. I don’t understand the hate. I also am looking forward to book two.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Netgalley for the ARC!

This was marketed in the worst possible way unfortunately. To be compared to hunger games, which is built on death, destruction and terrible choices, and this is just kind of surface level dystopia with sex on top of sex, felt out of touch.

Was this review helpful?

There was so much hype around this book that I had to see if it lived up to it! I enjoyed it but I wasn’t blown away or obsessed like some others have been. I predicted one of the twists pretty early on, but it was still an enjoyable story. I’m curious to see where it goes, so I’m planning to read the next one. Read when you want a romantasy book with a character who is trying to infiltrate the elite forces team of her enemies.

Was this review helpful?

Silver elite reminds me of divergent and powerless rolled into one book. The game is survival and not everything is as it seems. There are secrets and lies regarding the past and just who are aberrant.

Was this review helpful?

O ate this up so fast! This was fast paced and exciting from the first chapter, the first page really. I didn’t want to put it down. I loved the romance in this and I love slow burn

Was this review helpful?

3.5. Wren was born with abilities that make her easily identifiable to the enemy. She’s lived her whole life hiding her abilities and pretending not to be “modified” but she’s so powerful that she gets noticed by Cross (he’s noticed her for several reasons) and she’s not supposed to fall in love with him.

I am new to dystopian and while this wasn’t a terrible intro to it, I feel like it could have done a lot more! The most interesting part was the romance which I also felt was lacking but it could have been really fun getting more into the abilities or how they came about. I would have loved more world building since this is going to be a series (I think) I was entertained though!

Thank you so much to Netgalley, Dani Francis, and Del Rey for providing this free ARC. This is my honest review! This published on May 6th.

Was this review helpful?

Not my genre but gave it a go. I liked the premise but the fact romantic character development not so much.

Was this review helpful?

4 ⭐️

Okay as we all know this is not at all similar to how it was marketed but I knew that going in so, I purely read this based off of vibes ✨ and had a blast!

My girl, Wren, is hot mess express and we love her for it! The amount of times I put my kindle down and stared at the imaginary camera with a “are you kidding me?” face every time she pulled a dumb move (especially that dumbass move ifykyk) I think I would be a $100 richer.

And Cross…. Cross gave what needed to be gave. He was everything, we would want in a dark, brooding MMC. But the real star of the book is KAINE oooooweeeee 😮‍💨 girl I would’ve folded that’s all I can tell you. You’re hot AND funny = deadly combo.

Now, I wouldn’t even say this is even dystopian fully, I think the blueprint has been laid out so more world building is definitely possible in the second book. This reminded me of fourth wing (minus the dragons) because of the war/military college aspect, which I loved.

Overall, this was a fun and goofy time. If you haven’t read it yet and want to, go into it blind and forget what you’ve heard, and I promise you’ll at least enjoy yourself reading!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you, NetGalley and Random House Worlds | Del Rey for this ARC for review. This book was highly anticipated and did not disappoint! I really enjoyed the psychic gifts, secrets, world-building, and dystopian not knowing who to trust. I can’t wait for book 2 and where this author plans to go next with these characters and in this series! This is definitely on my list for must read!

Was this review helpful?

This was an interesting romantasy read, but the world building was lacking. I know it’s considered dystopian, but it felt more like a military read that just mentions an ongoing war and didn’t feel like a dystopian book. I liked the FMC, Wren, she was strong and kept moving forward against impossible odds. The MMC, Cross, I don’t feel we ever learned much about, but maybe he will be featured more in book 2. I’m not a fan of the mystery around the author, I wouldn’t mind it if the publisher confirmed that this book wasn’t written by AI, because I don’t want to support AI written works. For now the publisher is remaining silent on the issue and because of that I don’t plan to continue reading the series.

Was this review helpful?

Wren has a secret that could cost her life, and when her uncle is captured and murdered, she is thrown into the middle of the society she has tried so hard to stay away from. Cross is her commanding officer, forbidden from having any relationship with Wren, but from the moment they lay eyes on one another, they can't resist the temptation. Wren wants to trust him, but could he end up being her downfall?

Hunger Games and Divergent meets Fourth Wing (minus the dragons) in this super fast-paced distopian romance. I was hooked from the first page and could not put it down. I've seen many negative reviews for this book, but I absolutely loved it and had a blast!

Thank you, NetGalley and Random House Worlds, for providing me the e-ARC in exchange for an honest review!

Was this review helpful?