Skip to main content

Member Reviews

This is the first book I've had the pleasure of reading by Laila Lalami, it did not disappoint. The story put me in a dream like state where my imagination flowed throughout.

Was this review helpful?

This “dystopian” book was way too close to American reality for it to be enjoyable for me. The writing was good but I really struggled to be entertained by the story. I feel like the whole dream reading aspect could have been more deeply explored in order to make the book more interesting because as it was this book just felt like everything currently going wrong in the US and it wasn’t fun.

Thank you to Pantheon and NetGalley for the ARC <3

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed this book. It has such an interesting, and entertaining, premise that did not disappoint. This book has been in my mind every day since I finished. It is so good!

Was this review helpful?

I was excited to get this title but it didn’t quite hold my interest as I thought it would. Kind of repetitive and boring in so many spots. Information that didn’t quite add up if you followed the plot. I didn’t even like the main character. Disappointed. Thanks to the publisher and netgalley for this copy for read and review

Was this review helpful?

Sara is a wife, a daughter, and a new mother. She is a historian, working in her dream job at a museum. And then, one day, she becomes a prisoner. In a futuristic world where everything is policed — from the emotions on your face to your social media posts to your dreams — nothing is safe. After attending a conference, Sara is detained at the airport because of her “risk score,” a number that is calculated using hundreds of pieces of data to determine whether she will commit a crime in the future. Because of this score and the altercation resulting from her detention, she is placed in a facility for monitoring. She quickly finds out that these stays are not what they seem to be, and that it will take more from her than time to re-enter the real world.

Lalami expertly develops the building tension of any good dystopian novel, adding to Sara’s story through revelations about the facility and the wider world. Sara is a great protagonist to help us navigate through this world. I was particularly struck by the ways in which her experiences reflect those of both women and immigrants; the description of her reaction to her retention largely consists of thinking about all the things she did “wrong” and blaming herself, which is a common thought pattern for both groups after every altercation.

It was interesting to read this so soon after CHAIN-GANG ALL-STARS, which also heavily criticizes the American criminal justice system. This novel focuses heavily on its privatization, monetization, and red tape. It also explores how the people in this system are at the mercy of the whims of people on power trips. It’s an interesting look at the issues with the system, the ways in which people are exploited, and how technology could quickly bring us to a future with constant surveillance even of our minds, bringing shades of Orwell into the twenty-first century.

I do think that some more time could have been spent developing the minor characters. I also saw some missed opportunities with the ending of the story that would have taken this novel to the next level. But overall, this is a well-done dystopia that reveals many truths about surveillance, the criminal justice system, and technology. Four stars.

Was this review helpful?

Here's the thing- this is really a very good book.
Well written and timely, but terrifying, more than any horror story you could read.
Reminiscent of current library displays which say” this is a warning not an instruction manual” -
Thank you to Netgalley and Penguin Random House.

Was this review helpful?

As more and more of our everyday lives is lived on popular media where it's visible to everyone, the plot line of THE DREAM HOTEL looks more and more like nonfiction than the fiction/fantasy it is today. Just like we are monitored by a credit score, the individuals in Laila Lalami's original story line are monitored by their actions, including their dreams. Sara voluntarily accepts a chip designed to help her sleep, but soon learns the chip has many far reaching applications that will put her in a "temporary" holding facility. From this point, the book takes on an edge that gave me goosebumps. Yes, this is a fantasy. Yes, it's too close to today's fascination with AI for comfort. Recommended to everyone who can get lost in a story that's very close to a Dean Koontz dream.

Was this review helpful?

This is a powerful book about all the ways that women are punished for being people. Provocative and interesting, it held my attention the whole way. My one complaint is that I wished for more clarification of exactly how these women were being used by Safe-X. The ending is amazing, a clarion call for resistance and hope.

Was this review helpful?

They say dreams are a window to the soul. But what if those dreams are used against you to determine your level of culpability in a crime - even one that hasn't happened yet? That's what The Dream Hotel explores in this dystopian piece by author Laila Lalami.

We follow the journey of Sara Hussein, who was detained at the airport by the Risk Assessment Agency (RAA) because her risk score is too high (518, whereas 500 is considered the threshold). Using predictive AI, the RAA has determined that based on her dreams, she is an imminent threat to her husband and is sent to a retention facility with other women who have also been deemed threats to society in one way or another. The initial standard holding period is 21 days, at which time detainees are then re-evaluated and hopefully determined to be cleared and released back into the world. During their time there, detainees are given a strict set of rules and regulations they must adhere to, or their risk assessment score will increase and weaken their chances of being release. We soon see that the conditions in this facility are barely a step up from deplorable, and very few women actually get released after those first 21 days.

This book's relevance to today's world hits almost a little too close to home as it explores themes of AI manipulation, exploitation of women and prisoners, and the issue of what is/isn't considered a fundamental human right. Those basic human rights act as the grim proverbial carrot dangled in front of those in the detention facility in order to coerce them into complacency. Throughout Sara's time in detention, we meet a colorful, albeit complex set of characters that represent various walks of life and get a firsthand view into the disparity experienced by each of these women.

The author does a wonderful job of making each of these characters relatable in some fashion, even if they are not entirely likeable. This is often a hard balance to find, but Lalami does it very well. The pacing starts off slower than anticipated for a story line this gripping, but picks up quickly and hooks the reader in. I would have liked to see the ending play out longer, with a more satisfying resolution than the one given. However, I suppose the ending in and of itself could be considered a portrait of the continued discrimination, manipulation, and control over minority groups we are seeing in the world today. Highly recommend this poignant and thought-provoking novel.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you @pantheonbooks for the complimentary DRC.

“From Laila Lalami—the Pulitzer Prize and National Book Award finalist and a “maestra of literary fiction” (NPR)—comes a riveting and utterly original novel about one woman’s fight for freedom, set in a near future where even dreams are under surveillance.”

The premise of this made me think of Minority Report with anticipating someone’s likelihood of committing a crime in advance. Because of that, I was expecting a level of tension and excitement. While The Dream Hotel didn’t deliver on that, it did provide an increasing sense of unease and dread. It didn’t take much to suspend disbelief, so much of our lives are tracked through the phones we are attached to, if a promise of enough rest without much sleep were offered to us, would we say no? However, after half way through it felt like I was walking uphill to finish this. The story seemed to meander, and while there were a couple minor “events” nothing truly came of them, and the story never gained any momentum. I was hoping for a redeeming ending but sadly that too fell flat

Was this review helpful?

Sara's "risk score," teetering at the low 500s mark, has her flagged and detained at the airport on her way home to a dystopian LAX. From there, she's whisked away to a retention center, where, under 24/7 surveillance, she comes to realize that her labor is being farmed for private security firm Safe-X, in spite of not having committed any of the supposed crimes she's at risk of enacting. Through creative and resilient disruption, she manages to secure her release, but not without enduring incredible psychological, spiritual, and physical duress.

This was really, *really* fantastic! It reminded me a lot of The School for Good Mothers, with its dream logic and frustrating carceral situations. Would definitely recommend this to friends:)

Was this review helpful?

Thank you Net Galley for the ARC; opinions expressed here are my own..

The Dream Hotel is an ambitious story with a strong young woman of Moroccan heritage, Sara, at the center. It opens as she arrives back in the US on a flight from London, where she was attending a work conference. In the airport, Sara is suddenly detained and prevented from getting home to her husband and twin toddlers. The rest of the book describes her struggles to make that journey.

I admired the world building and character development, but these slowed down the plot too much for me. I found the ending oversimplified for such a layered theme. Even with it’s its flaws, I hope someone smart buys the rights and makes it into a suspenseful movie.

Was this review helpful?

Dystopian fiction that feels less and less distant, and more and more like a current events non-fiction commentary the further you read!

Laila Lalami weaves a compelling tale of the dangers posed to every single person who willingly hands over their life to technology, the devices that support it, to the corporations that monetize this practice, and to the algorithms that quantify and qualify our daily existence. There is an insidious, invasive, threatening, and downright dangerous undercurrent to the story of a woman who is flagged by airport technology that in this not so distant future has been calibrated to discern a person's *potential* for crime.

You heard that correctly... immediate arrest and mandatory retention for surpassing an algorithm's predetermination that you (and the content of your DREAMS) might pose a threat to someone, somewhere, sometime in the future.

Let that sink in.
Kafka would have loved this novel!!

"The Dream Hotel" was released on March 4, 2025. I highly recommend this literary novel and thank the author for her craft, the publisher for their recognition of that fact, and NetGalley for offering the galley proof to this reader.

Was this review helpful?

The Dream Hotel is a gripping and thought-provoking dystopian novel that immerses readers in a near-future society governed by predictive AI. In this world, sophisticated algorithms are used to prevent crimes before they happen, offering an illusion of safety while raising questions about fairness, freedom, and the human spirit.

At its core, the novel explores the troubling implications of using technology to control human behavior. The predictive AI, designed to anticipate crimes and prevent them, may not always be accurate, leaving marginalized communities disproportionately affected. Through this chilling concept, the novel critiques a system that, rather than promoting justice, deepens inequality. The narrative highlights the stark divide between the wealthy elite, who seem to exist above the law, and the disenfranchised, whose every move is scrutinized by algorithms that can't fully capture the complexities of human nature.

Equally central to the novel is the exploitation of prisoners, an uncomfortable reflection of a reality where those with the least power often bear the heaviest burdens. The stark portrayal of this systemic abuse serves as a stark reminder of the consequences of unchecked power, and the peril of allowing such technologies to govern human lives.

Despite these grim themes, The Dream Hotel is ultimately a story of resilience. The characters, though trapped in a world that often seeks to strip them of their agency, demonstrate the strength of the human spirit. The novel suggests that while freedom is always at risk of being lost, it can be preserved through solidarity and community, offering hope in the face of overwhelming odds.

The world-building in The Dream Hotel is both haunting and fascinating, and the narrative is rich with philosophical and ethical questions that challenge the reader to reflect on the role of technology, power, and justice in our own world. The writing is sharp and evocative, with each chapter tightening the novel's grip on the reader as the story unfolds.

In conclusion, The Dream Hotel is a timely and incisive novel that raises crucial questions about the intersection of technology, power, and human rights. It’s a captivating read for anyone interested in dystopian fiction that tackles both the personal and societal consequences of a future shaped by algorithms, surveillance, and inequality. Highly recommended.

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for this ARC!

Was this review helpful?

In this novel, the United States has taken an extreme step in fighting violence by using an algorithm to detain individuals deemed at risk of committing a violent act. It's no longer about just making threats, either; in this world, implantable devices design to help people sleep better also can read their dreams, and the content of their dreams can be used against them. That is what happens to Sara Hussein, a mother of young twins who sought help for her extreme exhaustion and ends up in a retention facility because the algorithm predicts she is at risk of harming her husband. Once she is in the system, she finds that it is hard to escape it, because not only can her own dreams and data be used against her, but she is also of value to the private company that runs the retention facilities. She is subject to the whims of those who supervise the retainees, who enforce the endless and often changing rules of the facility, and is under constant surveillance by cameras, microphones, and the device that continues to record her dreams, and every infraction lengthens her stay. She is torn between trying to follow the rules in the hopes of being released and fighting against an unjust system. What is so chilling about this book is that it doesn't seem that far-fetched, given how much of our lives we put online and how little attention we pay to the terms and conditions of the apps and sites and devices we use every day. Who is to say that all our data won't be used against us, particularly in the current political climate?

Thank you to NetGalley and Pantheon for providing me with a digital ARC of this book in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

This novel hits horrifyingly close to reality. A combo of Minority Report, 1984, and all those YA dystopian stories from the 2010s that had intense surveillance, (but with more late stage capitalism) this book was so good at establishing its premise that it pissed me off. The overwhelming unfairness of it all made me viscerally angry. Intensely compelling.

The overall message was one of resistance through community which I appreciate immensely and honestly makes me want to do fewer things that give the world data points about me and yet here I am writing a review so what does that say about me.

Was this review helpful?

Sometime in the not-too-distant future, Sara Hussein, mother of two and archivist at the Getty Museum, is traveling home from a conference in London when she is detained at the airport and sent to a retention center for those deemed at risk of committing a crime based on their risk assessment score. Based off of a proprietary algorithm that includes sleep data, Sara does not know exactly what she is at risk of doing or why. When her 21-day observation stretches into months, she must decide whether to remain compliant or attempt to stay true to her own nature.

This is a wonderful dystopian novel in the vein of The School for Good Mothers and The Handmaid’s Tale. The plot is gripping, the writing is lovely, and the themes that the novel grapples with are prescient and timely. I expect this book to be in the top 10 I read this year, and it would be especially good for a book club as there are so many discussion points here. Prison-for-profit, the surveillance state, and gendered expectations are all explored in ways that are always interesting and never pedantic. My one complaint is that Sara’s character’s interior life was a bit subdued; her separation from her children did not have the emotional intensity I would have expected. But all in all this is a solid book that I anticipate being very popular!

Thank you to NetGalley and Pantheon for the electronic advanced readers copy!

Read this if you: liked The Handmaid’s Tale, The Farm, Hum, or The School for Good Mothers

Skip this if: you strongly dislike dystopian fiction or anything touching on sci-fi.

Was this review helpful?

We live in a time of digital overload. Everything we do is tracked, it seems, and the data is shared. So, imagining, in the somewhat near future, our dreams being tracked doesn't seem that far off! Now think about how screwed up dreams can be... The data from our dreams, along with all the other tracked info out there, is analyzed and reviewed by the Risk Assessment Administration and used to determine the risk you pose of committing a crime. Nothing could go wrong with any of this!

The concept of this book is fascinating. Sci-fi, dystopian, authoritarian vibes abound! I wanted a little more out of the ending, but overall, The Dream Hotel will be one I'll keep thinking about.

Was this review helpful?

Sci-fi literary fiction is one of my favorite genres ever. I’m a horror fan but nothing terrifies me more than stories that deal with AI, autonomy, and a reminder that our technological consumption will likely be the ruin of us all. Just a little light reading, amirite?

The Dream Hotel starts off strong and hooked me in immediately. So many incredibly profound lines and the concept was just excellent. It lost a little steam about halfway and I wasn’t crazy about the ending, so it wasn’t the five star read I was predicting early in. I did overall enjoy it though, and it was an important read! l I love the hype it’s getting and can’t wait to see what others take from it.

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to the publisher for the ARC of this book! The Dream Hotel is set in the near-future in a dystopian society where the government has created an agency to assess risk and retain potential criminals before they commit their likely crimes. This premise seemed ambitious to me, but I found myself pretty much immediately sucked in. It does cover a super broad range of societal issues - racism, sexism, the lack of equity in the justice system, commodification of personal data, overreach of both government and tech companies - but it never seems forced or contrived.

Some parts near the middle dragged and there were other areas that I wanted to have more detail for (especially more about the back story both for Sara and for the formation of the RAA), but overall I really enjoyed this book. It's given me a lot to mull over in the hours since I finished reading it and I find myself hoping to revisit these characters in a sequel eventually because I think there's a lot of story left to be told.

Was this review helpful?