Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Haunting. Atmospheric. Sultry.

Bury Our Bones in the Midnight Soil transports readers into the lives of three vampires as they navigate their respective timelines, societies, circumstances, expectations, and troubles. Echoes of one another's stories reverberate through the narrative of each of our toxic lesbian vampires, and VE Schwab tells their stories with diligent historical context (and just the right amount of spookiness).

The stories of Sabine, Charlotte, and Alice are filled with layers upon layers of grief, rage, fear, femininity, power, betrayal, and nuance. We're gifted their tale in only the way VE Schwab can provide, with a carefully crafted atmosphere, vivid storytelling, and meticulous detail.

Highly recommend for a rainy day, a glass of red, and maybe a trip to the garden at night.

**Thank you to Tor Books and VE Schwab for an early copy of BOBITMS and the opportunity to leave my honest, voluntary review! All thoughts and opinions are my own.**

Was this review helpful?

V.E. Schwab has done it again. I adore everything she writes, but this book? This book wrecked me in the best way. It’s haunting, beautiful, aching with rage, love, and longing — and it’s the kind of story that lingers long after the last page.

You must read this with a glass of wine, a cozy blanket, and someone you love on speed dial. Trust me, you're going to need all three. An instant favorite.

Was this review helpful?

I've been excited about this book since the moment I learned of its conceptualization. I am a huge fan of all of V. E. Schwab's works, including their newsletters.

Let me start by affirming that if you love:

Schwab's writing style
The Invisible Life of Addie LaRue
Slow paced, character driven plot
Vampires
Lesbian Vampires
Toxic lesbian Vampires
The new Interview With a Vampire t.v. show

You will likely also love Bury Our Bones in the Midnight Soil.

This book beautifully weaves three women's life stories together spanning over 500 years. I love the way that Schwab recounts history in these century spanning works. We discover how our characters come to be vampires and how their lives are intertwined. The themes are feminine rage, sapphic love, self discovery, grief, and how far we're willing to go in the name of self preservation.

The vampire lore is unique and iconic. These vampires have elements of gothic romance minus being outwardly grotesque. Without giving too much away I loved how these vampires survive, what powers and weaknesses they have, and what threats they face.

SPOILER FOR THE ENDING DO NOT READ ANY FURTHER IF YOU DO NOT WANT THE ENDING TO BE SPOILED FOR YOU
==================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================

The ending to the book felt out of place for me. We spent the entirety of the book hearing these women's origin stories, and we have a brand new vampire, Alice, who somehow manages to take out two centuries old, cunning, cutthroat, ruthless vampire's with little to no morality left in them. Unless the message was that in the end Charlotte and Sabine's detachment from their humanity was ultimately their downfall, it just seemed rushed and Alice's plot armor enabled her to come out the other side. I'm curious to see what other reader's thoughts are on the ending. For that alone I'm rating it 4.5/5 rounded up to 5 because I just love Schwab, their writing, and who they are as a person. Thank you Netgalley for the ARC.

Was this review helpful?

VE Schwab and vampires?! Yes please, is there anything this gothic author can't do? Fans of VE Schwabs will certainly BITE into this one. (see what I did there?)

Was this review helpful?

This book is incredibly intense and emotional. And even though it falls into the realm of fantasy/ fiction, I do not think that is the over-arcing vibe of the book. Yes, we are dealing with lesbian vampires and we do have some yearning and betrayal, but I think this is far more about the characters and their relationships.

Each woman in this story is seeking for a level of power or control in what is a male-dominated world. We span ages in history to glimpse their lives and each seems to burn with a want or need for more than the world around them wants to give. I feel as though the author is writing each woman in a very raw way to give the scenes a sense of poetry and darkness. They are flawed and more real rather than being cookie-cutter perfect. They obsess and unravel at times.

think It's hard to put into words because I feel as though the overall plot is a bit flimsy. However, the writing is incredibly well done and the reader (if this resonates with them) will feel a ton of emotions as they work through these relationships. I do find the ending to be really good and intense. You may be left with a bit of a book hang over.

Was this review helpful?

This is my first adult book by V.E Schwab and I am in love with her writing here!
Is it life, if there is never death to balance it? Or is its brevity what makes it beautiful?" Ugh, yes.

found it so atmospheric and the yearning was what really sold it for me. I'm a sucker for anything vampire (yes, still) so this really hit all the plot points for me.

I would definitely recommend this!

Was this review helpful?

𝘽𝙪𝙧𝙮 𝙊𝙪𝙧 𝘽𝙤𝙣𝙚𝙨 𝙞𝙣 𝙩𝙝𝙚 𝙈𝙞𝙙𝙣𝙞𝙜𝙝𝙩 𝙎𝙤𝙞𝙡 𝙗𝙮 𝙑.𝙀. 𝙎𝙘𝙝𝙬𝙖𝙗 is a slow, elegant unraveling of hunger, grief, power and freedom across centuries. V. E. Schwab weaves the lives of three women into a haunting tapestry of longing and transformation. There’s María in 1532 Spain, Charlotte in 1827 London, and Alice in modern-day Boston. Each woman’s story feels grounded in her own time, yet they echo one another. The threads between them are delicate but powerful.

The author’s writing here is lyrical and deliberate. The novel isn’t concerned with action for the sake of momentum. Schwab doesn’t give us vampires that seduce or terrorize in the usual way. Instead, she offers something more intimate.

I must admit that halfway in I started to find the book a bit long. Some parts meandered, and I found myself wishing it had tightened its focus just a little. But then I settled into it realising this was probably a deliberate choice by the author because she excels in world-building and atmosphere.

This is not your typical vampire novel. So, if you like character-driven gothic horror, this one’s worth your time. Solid 4.5 stars!!

Thanks to Netgalley and the publishers for sending a digital ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

This is the story of Lottie, which is intertwined with the story of Alice, which began because of Sabine who was once Maria. We only get one life…or so the saying goes. Some of us get many lives for hundreds of years. However, that can also be unsatisfying and sometimes very lonely. So how do we choose to live these lives, particularly if the person living has been buried in the midnight soil and could perhaps live for hundreds of years?

Reading a book about vampire lesbians was not on my BINGO card this year, but now I have done it. Schwab’s writing continues to be all absorbing. Even though this is not a book topic I would normally choose, it was a fantastic read.

Was this review helpful?

Was the writing pretty? Yes.
Was the writing repetitive AF? Also yes.

It kills me to give this book two stars -- I wanted to love it SO MUCH and was so bored by the end. I really hoped for (and expected!) Schwab to switch up the vampire lore/tropes and come up with something spectacular and unique, but these ladies did all the same dumb stuff as every other vampire. It all felt very Anne Rice meets Twilight with the sexy vampires in period costumes running amok and having Big Feelings… but everybody’s a lesbian so I guess that’s different?

I will still read whatever Schwab writes next - she’s written too many things I absolutely love (Vicious, Darker Shade of Magic, Cassidy Blake) to ever stop reading her books, but this one is definitely not being added to my faves. (And pleeeeease let the next thing published be the third Vicious book...!!! please?)

Was this review helpful?

🥀 Goodness, I was certainly intrigued by this. It’s a story that, while nearly 600 pages, keeps moving. I was always interested and looked forward to picking it up, but by the end, it felt a bit like… nothing happened?

🥀 What I DID love:
- the travel through centuries
- the three distinct MC’s and their different approaches to life
- the changing attitudes toward LGBTQ people as time went on (though it was made clear the fight is not over)

🥀 I was hoping to feel the magic of Addie LaRue again and this just wasn’t it for me. I’ve seen others say it’s their favorite book of the year and they were completely swept up so PLEASE remember I’m just one person. Also, I read this during a stressful time so maybe I couldn’t get wrapped up for my own reasons.

Was this review helpful?

Enthralling from start to finish, it was hard to out the book down, and I cannot recommend a better way to read this than staying up until 3am every night, in the quiet darkness, reading about the lives and unlives of three women rotting and tangled, twisted together and making each other bleed with their thorns. I adored Sabine, and grew to like Alice over the book, and ah, so much to say about Charlotte—that I won’t to avoid spoilery things. This is a slow burn book—not in the romantic sense, but in the sense you walk down a winding path and through every turn you know something will happen, but you can’t quite see what it is—until you’re right at the end and you know, you know what’s coming, and it’s so incredibly satisfying to be vindicated. I heavily recommend this book, I received this arc but trust me, the hardcover is already sitting on my shelf, and what an amazing addition it is. Truly, I will be telling everyone I can to read this for a proper, dark and seductive read.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you TOR Publishing Group, V.E Schwab and Netgalley for this ARC in exchange for my review.

Bury Our Bones in the Midnight Soil is one of the most unique vampire stories I have ever read. The writing is eerie and atmospheric, but also deeply emotional and full of grief. The story spans hundreds of years and the lives of three different women and how they become entangled in each others story. You can really feel the weight of time as these women live through multiple lives and watch countless others pass them by. The slow erosion of identity, connection and meaning is written so beautifully and painfully and adds a unique take on immortality. The writing is absolutely stunning and reimagines the vampire mythos without leaning into the usual oversexualized tropes.

“Bury my bones in the midnight soil, plant them shallow but water them deep, and in my place will grow a feral rose, soft red petals hiding sharp white teeth.”

I feel like I lived through 400 years and countless lives along with these characters and this story is going to stick with me for a very long time. Beautifully haunting - must read.

Was this review helpful?

Absolutely stunning, following 3 generations of vampires (new and old) from Sabine nee Maria, Charlotte aka Lottie, and Alice, one wants freedom, one wants love, one wants revenge and in the soil their seeds are intertwined till they bloom and flow. I was so enamored by the worldbuilding and the intertwining stories as well as the changes to lore.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to TOR Books and V.E. Schwab for this #gifted copy of Bury Our Bones in the Midnight Soil.

V.E. Schwab has an unmatched ability to craft stories that are both lyrically dark and emotionally devastating. Bury Our Bones in the Midnight Soil is a sweeping, savage, and stunning vampire tale that pulled me in and never let go.

🩸 What did I love the most?
Now this is how you write a vampire novel. We’re talking:
🧛‍♀️ Gruesome origin stories
🩸 Vivid, brutal turning scenes
🥀 Emotional, bloody feeding moments
🪞 Deep reflections on mortality, queerness, and rage

It’s horror, yes, but it’s also coming-of-age, feminist, and achingly queer. Schwab weaves themes of identity, desire, and transformation into something both tender and terrifying.

🩸 What to expect:
👭 Sapphic vampires
🧠 Psychological horror
⏳ Fluctuating timelines + multiple POVs
💀 Feminine rage
🌕 Gothic horror meets dark fantasy

⏳ How was the pace?
Despite the 500+ page count, I never felt the urge to skim or put it down. Schwab balances introspective character work with visceral action and emotional tension. I genuinely wanted to call in sick to finish this.

🩸 Do I recommend it?
Absolutely. One of my favorite things? A beloved character slowly becoming irredeemable, while a quiet side figure unexpectedly stole the entire story. Schwab’s morally complex characters are unforgettable, and this might just be one of her best.

🩸 Perfect for fans of:
📚 Leigh Bardugo (The Familiar)
📚 T. Kingfisher (What Feasts at Night)
📚 Silvia Moreno-Garcia (Certain Dark Things)

🩸 Mood: 🕯️ Gothic | 🖤 Morally gray | 🌒 Haunting | 💋 Sensual horror

🩸 Read if you like:
🧛‍♀️ Queer vampire fiction
🎭 Dark, character-driven fantasy
🌲 Gothic horror with blood and bite
📚 Literary horror that lingers
🔥 Slow burn tension + identity shifts

Was this review helpful?

Santo Domingo de la Calzada, 1532. A woman trapped in a challenging marriage craves the freedom a different life can offer. She's used many names, but Sabine is the one that fits her best. In a world that has taken so much from her, she decides to take back. In 2019 Boston, as a college freshman Alice is trying to make a new life for herself, which is going well until the day she wakes up dead. Her only link seems to be to the mysterious Charlotte who she hooked up with after a party. Alice wants answers, Charlotte wants peace, and Sabine still wants revenge 500 years later. What is eternity without someone to love and possess?

You'll see a lot of comps to Dowry of Blood for this, but with a modern setting for a portion of the book, it also evokes Lucy Undying for me, with the feel of Addie LaRue's walk across centuries and filled with more feminine rage. Vampire lore is about power and sexuality at its core, and VE Schwab uses those familiar themes to drive this sapphic tale. It's hard to write a longer review without revealing spoilers, and in a book like this that unwinds the deeper you read, the joy is in savoring the slowly unfolding and crossing storylines.

Was this review helpful?

I featured Bury Our Bones in the Midnight Soil in my June 2025 new releases video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6q31xhbo1tE, and though I have not read it yet, I am so excited to and expect 5 stars! I will update here when I post a follow up review or vlog.

Was this review helpful?

I finished this book last week and I am still reeling—it might just be my favorite book of the year. Bury Our Bones in the Midnight Soil is most of all a story of hunger and sapphic yearning. Following three women across centuries, V.E. Schwab spins a vampiric tale that explores the lines between love and hate, of life and death, of beginnings and endings. It is hard to pin down exactly what this book is—drawing on magical realism, horror, and romance, it keeps you captivated until the very end. This book is also just very queer in a way that goes far beyond the romantic relationships, something we always need more of. Moreover, I really felt this book. The anger, the passion, the desire, all of it jumps off of the page and buries itself into your chest. I will be raving about this book forever, so of course everyone should read it. More specifically, if you loved Schwab’s other work The Invisible Life of Addie La Rue, I think will devour this one.

Was this review helpful?

This was my first book by this author and while I did love the writing and the depth of the characters… honestly the story fell flat for me.
I found myself wanting to pick up my phone and doom scroll… and it was a chore for me to finish it.

I do however think that others who are fans of her writing will absolutely devour this book!!!

— This story had a haunting gothic vibe to it that made the read eerie and I found myself wishing for rain to add the perfect ambience!
Our story follows 3 different women throughout history who are dealing with the same issues just at different times and then we add on Vampirism!
• Maria ( Sabine ) is from 16th Century Spain, is forced into a loveless marriage, and harboring feelings for her female maid! She meets a widow who later turns her into a vampire.
• Charolette is from 19th century England, she is shipped off to London after being caught with her female friend in a scandalous manner 👀, meets and falls inlove with Sabine and chooses to be turned into a Vampire to be with her.
• Alice is from 2019 Boston, meets a cute girl at a party, takes girl home, wakes up a Vampire! Now she is on the hunt to find her attacker and try to cure her herself.

It’s a story that gives the reader a glimpse into the world of a woman living in a man’s world while also choosing to love another woman!
I loved getting to take a glimpse at that world and I feel like it gave me a different insight and viewpoint to take with me!

Was this review helpful?

Yes, yes, just yes! This is a must read, Schwab is a master storyteller. This book takes you on an unforgettable journey.

Was this review helpful?

* i received this review copy through netgalley*

This captured all of the magic of Addie Larue with a vampiric, sapphic twist, and I couldn't have enjoyed it more. The drama, the way the characters grew over the centuries we spent with them, it was all just perfection.

It way maybe a touch longer than it needed to be, as the middle section did drag a bit, but then it picked back up at the end and I was instantly obsessed again.

Was this review helpful?