The way this author captures young, intense love is like nothing I've ever read before. She get's the experience so beauitfully into words. I will hold this book near and dear forever.

I wanted to like this book, and gave it a chance, but at 20% I’m going to DNF it. Based on the reviews for this book, I’m in the minority with my feelings (and I’m happy about that). The writing style felt like rambling, run on conversations with little significance, topics that could have developed with more detail didn’t get it, and other parts that didn’t feel significant had more details that seemed necessary. I don’t know if it was the writing style, or the timing, but the storyline nor the characters pulled me in enough to keep trying with this book.
.
.
Thank you NetGalley and Random House for the advanced copy in exchange for my honest review.

3.25 stars

This story was one of queer love and high school basketball. The writing itself was great and the imagery was on point! Unfortunately though this just wasn’t for me. I did not enjoy the high school setting, age of characters, heavy focus on basketball, or drug and alcohol use. I get what the novel was trying to convey but this just did not resonate with me. I think readers who are younger or involved in sports will be more drawn to this book and will greatly enjoy given how engaging the writing itself is!

Thank you to NetGalley and Random House Publishing Group for access to this ARC. All opinions are my own.

one of my most anticipated arcs and it did NOT disappoint -- i absolutely loved this one. this is the kind of book i wish i wrote. there is so much emotion in every single aspect of this, from mack's drive to win all the time to her feelings about liv to the way she lives her life around all of these people that all expect different things from her.

liv and mack never talk about anything but manage to say everything, whether through basketball or obtuse conversation or ice cubes. there's something so different about the space between being friends and being together, mutually understanding that you are the most important people to each other at that moment in time but not knowing what to do about it or how to say it because yeah, you're eighteen and your entire identity is wrapped up in how you love people.

augh. everything i could say is better unsaid and everything unsaid needs to be expressed. five stars.

I DNF'd after about 35%, mostly because I found Mack's voice to be so insufferable. I get she's a teenager going through unimaginable pain with the death of her father, but even before then, she was awful.

Crane's book I Keep My Exoskeletons to Myself has been on my TBR for a long time, and I will want to give that a shot, but I cannot finish this one.

Mack wants to play college D1 basketball one day. She's a senior and the star player on her HS team. Her father suddenly passes away, and while at the funeral, she meets her future teammate, Liv.

As the setting is in a small conservative town, the relationship between Mack and Liv is taboo, but also the crux of this novel. Grief, family secrets and that frustrating year before college when you are ready to be an 'adult' are the topics that are also explored. The game and beauty of basketball is detailed. I do think someone who is unfamiliar might get overwhelmed but as a basketball fan, it helped add to the plot for me.

I think Crane did an excellent job at creating identifiable high school angst. The parties, the stress, the want to get away from your family. That said, I don't know that the ending landed. If you asked me 5 minutes after I finished the book, I wouldn't be able to tell you how it ended.

Is this going to change lives? No. BUT this adds queer basketball coming-of-age to the shelves.

Thanks to NetGalley and the publishers for the opportunity to read and review this book.

This review has been posted to Goodreads and Storygraph on April 28th, 2025. Links provided.

Set in a conservative rural town in the early 2000s, A Sharp Endless Need follows Mack Morris, a high school basketball player trying to hold her life together after losing her father. As the team’s standout point guard, Mack finds unexpected solace in the arrival of Liv Cooper, a transfer student with her own complicated history. Their partnership on the court quickly becomes something deeper and more confusing off of it, blurring the lines between friendship, attraction, and survival. As college scouts begin circling and the pressure to perform builds, Mack struggles to keep her grief, identity, and desires from colliding. At home, her relationship with her emotionally distant mother grows more strained, while her private life becomes increasingly difficult to manage in a place where queerness is rarely acknowledged—let alone accepted. The novel captures a moment in time when everything feels urgent and uncertain, from love to ambition to self-worth, as Mack tries to figure out what kind of future is even possible for someone like her.

I liked this book a lot—it was well-written, emotionally layered, and had a really strong sense of atmosphere. Mack’s voice felt authentic, and I appreciated how the story didn’t shy away from the tougher parts of growing up, especially when it comes to figuring out who you are in a place that doesn’t make space for that. The relationship between Mack and Liv felt believable in all its confusion and intensity, and the basketball scenes actually added something meaningful to the emotional core of the book, which I wasn’t expecting. That said, it was also kind of a heavy read. There’s a constant weight to everything—grief, shame, repression, pressure—and after a while, it got exhausting. I don’t think that’s necessarily a bad thing, since it’s clearly intentional, but it did make the experience of reading it feel emotionally draining at times. There’s a lot of self-destructive behavior, and while that fits the characters and their circumstances, some of those moments felt repetitive, especially when it came to things like substance use or self-harm. And the ending... I just didn’t love it. It felt a bit rushed and unresolved. After spending so much time building up these relationships and emotional stakes, it didn’t quite stick the landing. I wanted more clarity—or at least more time—for some of those bigger themes to breathe. Still, it captured a very specific feeling of being young and stuck and full of questions, and that definitely made it worth reading.

A Sharp Endless Need would resonate with readers who are into coming-of-age stories that don’t sugarcoat the emotional messiness of adolescence. If you’re drawn to books about queer identity, small-town pressure, intense teen friendships (and the blurry lines between them), or if you just appreciate character-driven stories with a strong emotional undercurrent, this one’s worth picking up. It’s especially for those who don’t mind a little sadness woven into their love stories—and who can appreciate beautiful writing even when the subject matter gets heavy.

Thank you to Random House Publishing Group, The Dial Press, and NetGalley for the opportunity to read to an ARC of A Sharp Endless Need in return for my honest review.

When I saw that Marisa Crane had a new book coming out, I was nervous and excited. Their debut was so powerful and changed my world. I couldn’t imagine a follow up. A Sharp Endless Need more than delivered. I felt so entrenched in their characters’ lives, like I was back in high school. It was both satisfying and overwhelming.

This book is a beautiful exploration of intimacy, heartbreak, and growth, with characters that feel like they could be right beside you, making choices that resonate deep in your bones. It’s the kind of story that will have you reflecting on your own first loves, your own moments of growth, and what it means to fight for the life you want. Absolutely a must-read.

I really truly enjoyed this read, and was sad when it was over. The story was so heartbreaking in so many ways, and I never really wanted to put it down. There were numerous spots that were hard to follow due to a setting/time jump that didn't feel clear to me as a reader that is keeping this from being a 5 ⭐️. However, I think these characters will stay with me, and I know I'll be back to read more from Marisa Crane in the future. I'm new to the Lit Fic genre, and this was just the stepping stone I needed to get into it.

I found “A Sharp Endless Need” to be such a compelling read. The use of basketball to tell this emotional coming of age story immediately had me interested. I really felt for Mack and was truly crying for the final two chapters, seeing what they did and didn’t get after all they’d been through. I really enjoyed Mac’s writing style and the way they built the story. I would definitely recommend to friends!

DNF at about 42%. there are so many basketball analogies/metaphors/references that it's completely taking me out of the book lol. also, i love the yearning and tension between mack and liv but yet they're both flat as characters. they have no real substance to them in my eyes. there's also a lot of alcohol and drug use which is definitely something you'd see with teenagers in high school but they're both such serious athletes??? doesn't make sense.

the writing is also a struggle to get through. dialogue is a bit flat and there are way too many paragraphs of just info dumping and showing rather than telling. i can't endure more of it lol.

Dnf @ 32%

I really wanted to like this but I just couldn’t get past the writing style. Everything felt so info dumpy. For instance something would be brought up and then it would segue into a paragraph long tangent that honestly didn’t even matter. So much of what I read just felt over explained and it was taking away from the flow of the story. Very much a telling versus showing kind of vibe.

I also didn’t find myself connected to the characters. They were all kind of forgettable and didn’t have any strong stand out qualities within the 30% that I managed to read. The basketball aspect was fine but I think it would definitely work better for someone interested in the sport. I did appreciate the explanations in this instance just because I myself am not that familiar with the sport.

Also slightly random bit, I don’t have anything against characters partaking in drugs, but the way it kept getting excessively brought up every three lines at some points was exhausting.

If you're interested in a basketball centric queer coming of age story I'd definitely still say to check it out but, unfortunately this was a huge miss for me.

Thank you NetGalley and Random House for providing me with this ARC.

(4.5/5) Wow, I’m still recovering from the emotional impact of A Sharp Endless Need. This book took me on a raw and incredibly intense journey through Mack’s coming-of-age story, one filled with love, grief, identity, and the hard choices that come with growing up and figuring out where and how you fit in the world. It’s been days since I finished, and I can’t stop thinking about it

The way the author explores sexuality and the complexities of self-discovery is extraordinary. I was completely hooked from the first chapter, and Mack’s internal tension—the rawness of those quiet moments of connection with Liv—made my heart ache; I was choking on sobs near the end. The chemistry between Mack and Liv, especially when they’re not even touching, is electric. There’s an intimacy in every shared moment, from a simple ride in the backseat to the deep emotional connection that lingers long after their time together on a basketball court.

The title alone, A Sharp Endless Need, is a perfect reflection of how overwhelming and consuming love, especially young love, can be. It's so beautifully portrayed here—devastating and real in a way that resonated with me long after the last page.

That line, "Her dad didn’t have to instruct me to smile for the picture because I was already smiling," hit me like a ton of bricks. It’s just one example of how the author masterfully captures these small yet life-shattering moments.

While I loved so much about this book, I do wish the ending was less inconclusive. I understand ending the book there, but I couldn’t help feeling unsatisfied with the conclusion and wanting more. Maybe that’s part of the beauty of the story—leaving room for reflection and growth—but I do wish for a bit more closure.

Despite this, A Sharp Endless Need is a unique, emotional ride that left a lasting imprint. The characters’ struggles, choices, and growth are so realistic, and the book does an incredible job of capturing the complexity of youth, sexuality, and love. It's a powerful read that will stick with me (and maybe even haunt me at times—in a beautiful and devastating way).

What a poignant and heartfelt read. I was all in with this coming of age story. A reminder of the trials and tribulations of youth and love. Overall a captivating and well written and well developed read. Big thanks to Random House and Net Galley for the opportunity to read this ARC. This book is well worth your time and tears.

Mack is a great High School basketball player. She is constantly practicing basketball and she is a star player. Her Dad passes away and he was her rock. Liv Cooper has just started at the school and she is a good basketball player. When Mack and Liv were on the court they knew each other’s moves. They were a dynamic team together but Mack wanted more. They started exploring their wants but most people weren’t ready for that yet. The ups and downs that Mack goes through is truly heartbreaking.

I received this ARC from Netgalley for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.

The thing I enjoyed most about this book is the author's unapologetic passion for basketball. Crane's intentional use of colloquialism for the basketball dialogue was one of the best parts of the novel. By not trying to explain or dumb down the sport for the reader, Crane is connecting the reader directly to the main character's intensity and need of being the best and how destructive that need can be in a way that is universally relatable.

What the book is:
🔘 A first person, reflective single POV narrative, queer coming of age speculative fiction novel that takes place in a small white working class suburb of PA. The story is told by and details Mac experience as an elite high school basketball player entering the pressure of senior year while also dealing with complex feelings of grief, loss, love, and self discovery.
🔘 An achingly painful (in the best way) ode to unrequited messy teenage queer love.
🔘 A book that I read in one sitting, which means that it was captivating but when I got to the end I felt like I needed more. It wasn't that it felt incomplete, it just felt a bit rushed but I'm going to re-read it and see if I feel differently when it's not 4am.
🔘 Passionate and poetic prose. An essential read for the nostalgic queer millennial looking to relive the early aughts.

What the book is NOT:
🔘 A romance novel. Don't expect it to be, don't hope for it to be and don't get mad at it for not being.

A SHARP ENDLESS NEED is the teenage coming-of-age story that didn't know I needed on the cusp of turning forty. It smoldered, burned, reminded me of what it meant to feel alive & what it means to keep living. Beautifully written, aching and particular. I know nothing about basketball and would read Mac Crane writing about basketball forever. Gorgeous, moving, smart, painful, and hopeful.

The struggle is this book is painful to read. It is unfortunate that we live in a world where this is the reality. Definitely a great story of longing for something that you’re afraid to have.

The tension in this book… wow! This was such a beautiful story about girlhood, identity, and finding your sexuality. I absolutely loved the writing and was so invested in this story.