Skip to main content

Member Reviews

A Sharp Endless Need is a haunting and evocative tale that delves into obsession and dark desire. The writing is visceral and immersive, pulling you into its intense atmosphere. Some moments feel a bit slow, but the emotional depth keeps you engaged.

Overall, a powerful, thought-provoking read. Perfect for those who enjoy moody, character-driven stories with a touch of darkness.

Was this review helpful?

This was such a beautiful story of coming into queerness in a small town Pennsylvania atmosphere. This manages to mesh the intensity of high school athletics with the uncertainty of sexuality in a small town in a way that was so intense and poignant. The book was really able to make you feel claustrophobic in a way that communicated the experiences of the main character. The relationship between Mack and Liv was so 😭😭😭😭😭. Such a beautiful and heartbreaking story of coming into queerness and navigating the uncertainties of life. I have to know if the author was a basketball player. For anyone who was a high school athlete, it really captures the pressure and intensity perfectly. Simply gorgeous!

Thank you to NetGalley and the Dial press for an advanced reader copy in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

A great insight into the drama and obsessions of teenagers. All the mentions to high school in the 2000s made me remember my high school days, which thankfully were not as intense as the ones in this book :)

Was this review helpful?

Mackenzie Morris is a highschool senior, and is on track to be a D1 basketball player at one of the countless schools trying to recruit her. But her year starts with 2 events that will change her forever, the death of her father, the one who gave her, her love of basketball, and the arrival of a transfer student to the school and team named Liv. Liv and Mack make a killer team on the court, but off the court they wrap themselves in each other and into a very toxic back and forth. A tale of growing up, drugs, sex, grief, ambition and self destruction.

I absolutely love the concept of this book, and the topics it explores. Being a teenager is so tough and I think this book captured that time so well with the added pressure of a college sports scholarship. he writing didn't work for me personally but that does not take away from how good this story was.

Was this review helpful?

A year ago I happened to read a book that intrigued me in its themes from an author I haven’t heard about before. I have absolutely fallen in love with that book and discovered a writer who’s work I’ll keep following and admiring. That was I Keep My Exosceletons To Myself by Marisa Crane. I approached A Sharp Endless Need with big expectations despite being surprised by the theme. Crane’s previous book was a mild sci-fi dystopia, and here we have a coming of age literary fiction revolving around basketball. And here comes the twist; despite tackling quite different themes and genres, Crane’s writing is hypnotizing, propulsive and stunning with truly engaging storytelling and unforgettable characters. A Sharp Endless Need follows Mack, a teenage basketball prodigy who is standing before the biggest decision of her life so far, picking a college, which can make or break her future basketball career. Life suddenly throws some curveballs as her family collapses and her paths cross with a girl who she immediately bonds with in sport and a romantic obsession. This novel is as fast and energetic as a game of basketball. There is no moment that feels too long or out of place. The characters are really vivid with interesting and complex personalities which really shine in dialogue. There is a fair amount of basketball lingo and sports terminology but not knowing it doesn’t take away from enjoyment. It is a book about girlhood and sport, obsession and perfectionism, gender and identity and the chaos of first love. To me A Sharp Endless Need stands right beside recent highly celebrated books with themes of sport like Western Lane by Chetna Maroo or Headshot by Rita Bullwinkel and I really hope it gets the recognition and praise it deserves!

Thank you to Random House, The Dial Press and NetGalley for the eARC!

Was this review helpful?

I don't know shit about basketball, but still I devoured this in one sitting. It's not really written in a stream-of-consciousness style, but that's the vibe I was experiencing while reading — I really felt like I was in Mack's head. I think Crane did a great job evoking teen obsession and drama, how everything is the biggest and most important thing to ever happen to anyone, ya know? And sometimes it is, but sometimes it's not. Still, you'll think about that thing you said at that party for the rest of your life. probably. If you like sports drama, coming-of-age, and grappling with queerness as a teen, put this on your TBR ASAP.

Was this review helpful?

Happy Pub Day to Marisa Crane 🥳

Ok first off though how can u hate the national anthem?! 🧐 I can't agree or like that part .

With that said wow .. I have so many emotions & feelings about this book ... 💔💀🤘❤️🥰😱💩🤯☹️
Just all the emotions really

This novel is about a teenager named Mack who's a highschool basketball star but going through all the teenage things & then some..
There was A LOT of layers to this book :
-Coming of age
-Sexual identity which regardless of your orientation we all go through this to some extent so I think everyone can relate somewhat here
- lots of teen angst which again almost everyone can relate there
- loss of a parent which just adds anger to an already confused teenage girl
-toxic friendships/relationships
- growing up in the early 2000s & omg the nostalgic references. AIM 🙃🤘 yess !!! Bring it back
- Macks obsession with basketball & her future
- drug use . Again Mack's grieving & confusion & also living in a small town with certain beliefs .. turning to drugs to escape is imo relatable. I don't think anyone ever plans to get addicted ..

There were things as a straight woman who knows little about basketball that maybe I didn't love or couldn't fully understand but with that said I could relate to so much of this book . In a way most teenagers go through a lot of the same shit .. some more than others.
Grieving & acting out I could totally relate to .. thinking you have your future mapped out & having a wrench thrown in your plans is also something I can 100% relate to.
When I started this book I thought it was a love story & in a sense yes but there's a lot more ..
The ending left me with soooo many questions & tbh I'm a tad salty it ended the way it did but you know what ? That's life. It's not always wrapped up in a pretty bow .
After writing my review I'm bumping this from a 3 ⭐ to a 4 ⭐

I absolutely adore the relationship between Mack & her coach . Coach Puck was an underrated character imo . This author writes incredible characters & managed to suck me in even through again my opinion the boring sports stuff . Congrats to this author .. I think you wrote a banger 🤘

Thank you to #Netgalley , Marisa Crane, & Dial press for this unexpected glorious read. ❤️
#ASharpEndlessNeed

Was this review helpful?

What a ride! This book is gripping and full of emotion. It’s a story of obsession, navigating identity, exploring love, and grappling with life-changing decisions. This is my first book by this author, and all I can say is, well done! As a former basketball player (nowhere close to getting college offers haha) this brought back a wave of nostalgia for the sport itself, the magic of a well-oiled team, and the awe of stepping on the court in front of an infectious crowd. Great read!

Was this review helpful?

This is a hard review for me to write. I was excited for this novel, and I loved certain aspects of it. The grief was raw, the friendship powerful, and the basketball intense. However, I also found it to be super slow moving and was bored at times. I do wish it had been wrapped up a bit differently, too. While it wasn’t a winner for me, I will recommend it to those that I know will appreciate this story.

Was this review helpful?

Queer coming of age about high school athletes in a small town in the early 2000s? Sign me UP.

A Sharp Endless Need feels like a late August night: hot and humid and sticky and heavy with anticipation. Reading it made me think of being 17 on one of those summer nights where I'd sit on the concrete stoop of my childhood home eating endless popsicles, feeling wildly restless and itchy, simultaneously hungry for change and terrified of it.

Mack is the star of her small town Pennsylvania high school basketball team when Liv transfers for their senior season. They're immediately drawn to each other, their magnetic relationship existing both on and off the court as Mack struggles to balance ambition and self-destruction.

It feels like a love letter to sports, to being 17 and hating your hometown and loving it at the same time. It captures that all-encompassing desire to belong to something bigger than yourself, yearning, and the paralyzing fear that comes with coming of age. Crane's prose is precise and evocative, and I deeply enjoyed slowly getting lost in Mack's messy world.

Was this review helpful?

A Sharp Endless Need s a realist queer/lesbian coming-of-age novel. It follows star point guard Mack Morris through senior year, right after the death of her supportive but troubled father. She navigates grief and substance abuse alongside exploring her gender identity and sexuality through a first crush on a new teammate.

Mack is both hard and soft. She’s an elite athlete in a contact sport and she’s lived a life surrounded by addictions and dishonesty and this makes her tough. She endures self harm and substance use and it’s shocking (that is if like me, you’ve never even done *a* drug) but it doesn’t feel out of place in her world. But also, she loves and grieves and yearns honestly (and teenagerly). Although the story’s heart is about grief, first love, and sexuality, my favorite parts were actually the basketball scenes and Mack’s thought process about her future as an athlete. The author clearly KNOWS BALL and their knowledge and passion shine. But also I just really love basketball.

The story is heartfelt and honest and rarely minces words, the prose is frank: precise, humorous, and real, just what you would expect from a teen like Mack. It’s like a gritty realist indie movie, think Andrea Arnold but jock.

Was this review helpful?

A book about basketball and coming of age? As a child who played basketball for years, I was all for this book. I was in high school in the early 2000s, and it was so nostalgic reading this.

There were so many layers to this book and I really enjoyed Mack and Liv. There is loss and grief, and all kinds of love.

Was this review helpful?

I recognized the author’s name from their debut so I requested this book without reading the blurb which sometimes works out well. Mack Morris is a star basketball player for the Hornets, a HS team in a small town in Pennsylvania around 2004. It’s pretty obvious the author was a player and is sure-handed in writing about the mechanics of the game, the running of practices, and the dynamics of a team. This basketball know-how is Mack’s language and how she expresses her thoughts and feelings to the world so it is vital to the story. But no worries to non-sports fans because it’s integrated smoothly.

Mack’s whole life seems disjointed. She drinks and gets high as much as she plays ball. Her late father had a gambling addiction but also was the person who helped her fall under the spell of her sport. Her mother is emotionally distant and seems more worried about how Mack’s decisions might affect her than caring about her daughter. Only Coach Puck and Grayson, Mack’s buddy/drug dealer, seem to be the semi-steadying forces in her life. The town itself is another strong character. Instead of it having a storybook quaintness, the author paints a picture of Mack slowly suffocating in a dead end place, knowing that her talent is her only pathway out, but also terrified of making the wrong decision and being trapped in a small, disappointing life. To discover what makes a life meaningful is a whole journey but when you’re 18, it often feels like you need to know everything right then.

Throughout the book, Mack explores her Queer identity and her attraction to girls. When the new hot shot ball player, Liv Cooper, joins the team, the pains of first love hit Mack hard, a turbulent tug of war between longing and connection.

Mack is a character I will be thinking about for a while. It’s all or nothing for her just like for a lot of young people and the author grasps those emotions and moments in a way that feels truthful and immediate, with no apologies, and for me, their lyrical telling hits home.

Was this review helpful?

Crane’s first novel, I Keep My Exoskeletons to Myself, was my favorite book I read the year it came out and remains one of my top five of all time, so I had high expectations for their second and they were all met. This one is so different—not sci-fi, about teens instead of adults, has way more sports—but maybe it really isn’t because it’s still full of grief and longing and self-discovery. I finished it this morning and I’ve been thinking all day about the passion and ambition, the so many unsaid things about being a queer teenager, that stretch just at the end of high school when you know you’re on the brink of something and the desire to be there could almost crush you. The black hole of loss at a time like that and the all-encompassing feeling of teenage love. The title explains exactly what you will feel at the end of this book and all the way through it. I hope Crane keeps writing forever.

Was this review helpful?

A little exhausting but also lovely?
I don’t know. I liked the writing but the characters were hard to root for. And I had some anxiety the whole time of some dreadful ending. I definitely wanted them to never see each other again. Toxic love isn’t my jam but the story wasn’t bad.

I think if you like basketball and teen angst with high drama you’ll like it.

Thanks to netgalley and random house pub for an eARC.

Was this review helpful?

Absolutely beautiful.
This story follows high school senior and basketball star Mack Morris through her final year as she picks a college to attend and falls in love with her teammate, Liv.
(Also, as a trans masculine reader Mack is wonderfully trans coded. Though this isn't explored deeply, it is so perfectly done and I am here for it!)

Crane has drafted a book so beautifully written and yet so easy to digest. I basically inhaled it.
What is most impressive is the way Crane writes about Mack's love for basketball. Through Mack's eyes, we can see its beauty. This sport is Mack's entire identity, and though I am not a basketball player (or play any sports that I particularly love), I could truly understand Mack's passion. I think that is the ultimate goal of writing a book like this- you don't have to play a sport to *get* it. Well done!

Was this review helpful?

dnf at 20%. i was not into the sports aspect (although i did know this going into it but i thought id appreciate it more!!!) it being sapphic sadly didn’t save it for me 😔

Was this review helpful?

4

setting: Pennsylvania
Rep: sapphic protagonist

this short book packs many punches - it's not an easy read, charting the struggles of growing up gay in 2000s Pennsylvania and desperately in love with a deeply closeted friend. I loved the writing style and the descriptions of basketball!

Was this review helpful?

I can honestly say I’ve never read a book like this one. I got a little lost in all the basketball talk (my problem not the book’s), but overall this was a quick read. I was very invested in what would happen to Mack and Liv… whether they would own who they really were.. or continue to hide it from their small town world that hated people like them.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for giving me an ARC of this book in exchange for an honest review!

One of my favorite reads of the year!

I cannot even describe the feelings I felt while reading this book. All I can say is the vibes were there and it was perfect. I just felt so deeply for this story and these people. It felt like I was Mack as I was reading. I felt everything she felt, was sad and hurt when she was upset.

It was written so well. It was very descriptive. I could feel and see everything that was being described.

Every page of this book was masterfully done with a gut punch of emotions at every line.

It had a little bit of a slow start, but it didn’t last long. I think it just needed to find its footing. The first couple of chapters I wasn’t super engaged, but after chapter 4 I got hooked and couldn’t put it down!

I was devastated at Liv and Mack’s relationship. I was rooting for them so hard. It was sad to see people rooting against them. Such was the times, but it still hurt that they felt like they couldn’t be out in the open.

Another character I adored was Coach. He was such an important person in Mack’s life, and I was so glad he was always there for her when she needed him.

I wasn’t as passionate as these girls were about basketball, but I did play and enjoy the sport in high school! I liked the sports aspect of this book. It added a lot to the story. I thought the games were written very well and were engaging. I feel like it was easy enough to understand even if you didn’t ever play basketball.

It was a very deep book. It touched on grief and not being comfortable with yourself, and confusing teenage feelings, and so many other things that came together so well. The story blended together and didn’t feel choppy.

As much as I wish it was a happy ending I think it was a sad ending, but I loved the open ended-ness of it all. I thought it was an accurate, if not upsetting way to end the book.

I thought one thing was going to happen and I was so scared, I was biting my nails. It didn’t happen how I thought it would, but it still hurt terribly. I ached for these characters.

It really is hard to explain how much this book spoke to me, so you’ll just have to take my word for it and read it! There is something very special here.

I will be reviewing this book on Goodreads May 10th, 2025 and on Amazon on the release date!

https://www.goodreads.com/review/show/6932831428

Was this review helpful?