I was SO into this book for about the first half! But then the switching POVs started to get confusing and it was hard to remember which sister was which. This concept was so incredibly interesting, and I don’t regret reading this book, but I felt like it would benefit from being shorter to keep people’s attention span more. I did not guess which sister it was, so I liked that, but I found the ending unsatisfying personal

Thank you to NetGalley and Poisoned Pen Press for a complimentary early release copy of Sister, Butcher, Sister by KD Aldyn.

I found Sister, Butcher, Sister to be a decent/okay kind of read. The characters were interesting to follow and I’m happy that we got perspectives from multiple people during the story as it added an extra element of “who am I to trust” or “what happened”. I liked the sisters and I found their life’s to be interesting, I even liked a few of the love interest for the sisters. The plot and characters kept me invested but I wish a few things had played out differently.

This thriller is certainly one of the darkest ones that I have read but I didn’t really like the perspective of “She”. The timeline of the story also tended to jump around mid chapter sometimes making things confusing to follow. While I didn’t guess the ending I’m a little disappointed by how things had played out in the end, I wish we would have gotten just a little bit more between the sisters. If you have any triggers I highly suggest looking up trigger warnings before reading, there are lots of heavy subjects and gore included in this book.

Sister Butcher Sister | ARC review



I wanted to love this one sooooo bad but I just didn’t🥲 It was a bit confusing and just kind of drug on. I felt like I was mostly reading just to finish it, and felt relieved when I did.

2 stars from me⭐️⭐️

Thank you @netgalley for the chance to read and review ahead of time!

This is a serial killer thriller which quickly had my attention. The story focuses on three sisters Kate, Aurora and Peggy Rowling. Each one is carrying their own secrets and then there is ‘She’, but we are clueless as to which sister this represents.

Soon there are a series of murders and the reader is left to try to figure what is actually going on. The book does become a little confusing regarding the timeline but the eerie and creepy setting and plot ensures that you will keep reading.
Eventually it all comes together to provide a decent crime thriller.

This is my first book from this author and I would pick up another to see what else they offer. Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for an advanced copy, all opinions expressed are my own.

I loved this book! I thought I had it all figured out halfway through the book, but the author kept me second guessing myself right up until the very end; I love psychological thrillers and this one did not disappoint. Definitely will be ordering for our bookstore and hand selling this title.

⭐⭐⭐ (3/5)

*Sister, Butcher, Sister* is a psychological thriller that delves into the complexity of family dynamics, trauma, and revenge. The novel focuses on the Rowling sisters—Kate, Aurora, and Peggy—who reunite when Kate purchases their late grandfather's property. As a chain of gruesome murders occurs, the sisters become the chief suspects, forcing them to reflect on their shared past and secrets.

The novel employs several narratives, one of which is about a serial killer named "she," whose identity remains ambiguous until the end. This employment of narrative creates an additional layer of suspense and intrigue, with readers left wondering who the killer might be. The subject of trauma, memory, and revenge provides depth to the narrative, as it presents a multifaceted representation of the psyches of the characters.
But the pacing of the novel is uneven. The early parts of the novel are tightly tensioned, but the middle section is uneven because the same information comes from different directions. This repetition can take away from the overall impact of the novel. The final reveal, while surprising, happens a little bit too quickly, and some of the plot points are underdeveloped.

Despite these flaws, *Sister, Butcher, Sister* is a tense novel that will appeal to fans of psychological suspense novels with complex characters and darker themes. Even though it isn't flawless, it demonstrates the potential of K.D. Aldyn as a genre author.

Thanks to Sourcebooks and NetGalley for this complimentary review copy.

Which one is SHE?

This one was a much slow burn thrillers but still interesting and a great read. I still would HIGHLY recommend it!

It’s definitely a page turner and it’s a book worth reading in the dark/night.

Sister, Butcher, Sister is a twisty thriller told through well thought out multiple POVs and timelines. No narrator is reliable and readers can't be sure of who the killer is until the very end. I enjoyed being in the dark both atmospherically and storyline wise. I appreciated how the ending unfolded and will definitely check out other books by this author.



Thank you to Poisoned Pen Press and NetGalley for the ARC. All reviews are my own.

Prepare to be devoured. KD Aldyn's Sister, Butcher, Sister is not just a dark thriller; it's a tantalizingly twisted descent into a world where blood is thicker than water... and far more dangerous. This is a story that will sink its teeth into you from the first page and won't let go until you're left breathless and reeling.

Aldyn masterfully crafts a narrative that's both seductive and sinister, luring you in with the promise of twisted sisterhood, only to unleash a storm of suspense and shocking revelations. Imagine a bond forged in darkness, sharpened by betrayal, and stained with secrets that refuse to stay buried.

Sister, Butcher, Sister is a visceral, unforgettable thriller that will leave you craving more. If you're hungry for a story that pushes boundaries, dares to explore the darkest corners of the human psyche, and delivers twists that will make your jaw drop, then this is the book you've been waiting for. Get ready to be consumed.

I gave this book 5 stars. I am not familiar with the author but will be looking for more from her in the near future. It was a great and creepy psychological thriller full of twists and turns!

I loved the way the POVs were set up, each sister and then the killer. The ending was not satisfying for me. It felt rushed and cut short. There were some side plots that felt like they ended up getting dropped and never brought up again.

Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley.

Oh, where to begin? I was so excited to get this book. The book blurb sounded intriguing. The execution not so much.
This book focuses on three estranged sisters:Kate, Aurora, and Peggy. Each sister is deeply flawed in their own way. Kate is the superstar lawyer who runs away at the first sign of trouble. Aurora is the golden girl, favored by the family, and happily married with children. Peggy is the troubled sister who is trying to move past her wild behavior of her youth. One of the sisters is a killer. The local police force is baffled by who is behind a string of grisly murders of men. Who is behind the deaths and why?
That blurb sounded really cool. However, this book was extremely hard to get through. There are flashbacks galore, but the timelines and POV shift so much. It was extremely confusing. A good 30-40% of the book could've been cut out to tighten up the pacing of the book. I nearly quit reading 10 times out of frustration. Towards the middle I didn't really care who was the villain. That being said, I was able to guess the offender by the end. The end was also rather abrupt considering how much the book dragged. I do think this book could be better with
More edits.
Thank you to NetGalley and Poisoned Pen Press for providing this ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Intense is an understatement! Three sisters, three sets of memories, three responses that affect everything, in different ways. The long standing ripple effects of evil - but who is the killer? A killer who is more a victim than than those dead. A strong and suspenseful story on a powerful theme.

This was a good and fast paced book I loved every minute of this read I will recommend for anyone that’s looking for a sister to sister rivalry !!!

This was a bit of a slow burn for me, but once it picked up, I was hooked. The twisted family dynamics, buried trauma, and eerie atmosphere kept me guessing the whole time. I loved the way the story blurred reality and memory, especially with the chilling “SHE” perspective. It didn’t fully blow me away, but it’s a solid, dark debut that fans of psychological thrillers will definitely enjoy.

I really liked the creepy vibes of this book, but sometimes I felt that it was getting a little bit repetitive. I do have to say that that was my only complaint. I really enjoyed the mystery and trying to figure out the murderer. If you enjoy a good family drama with your thrillers, then I definitely recommend this one.

Thanks to Netgalley for the copy of this ARC. This will be out in June of 2025.

Such a page turner that had me clinging on for dear life. I wanted to know all the answer so bad. The atmosphere was creepy and spine tingling. I also loved getting different povs.

I really liked the premise and narrative style of this story! Trying to figure out who is the killer among three sisters? Color me intrigued. I think this is a great psychological thriller, and will be a great beach read for its summer release.

Thank you Poisoned Pen Press for the advanced reader copy.

This book is such an entertaining page turner. I was rushing to find out who the serial killer was. The family drama kept me hooked with all the twists and turns. The vibes are perfectly dark and creepy.

I really enjoyed this one!

This was a good book, but at times very confusing. It has muktiple pov’s and even though it’s a thriller it did often feel like a different genre.. The pacing was also off multiple times. What keot me interested was ofc the mystery of which sister was the killer. It was a good read.